Skip to main content

Full text of "More wonders of the invisible world, or The wonders of the invisible world displayed. In five parts"

See other formats


"~^ 


(•:\\t:\\\  1 


MORE  WONDERS 

OF    THE 

INVISIBLE  WOELD. 

OR 

THE  WONDERS 

OF 

DISPLAYED. 

7JV  FIVE  PARTS. 

Fart  I. — An  Account  ot  the  Sufferings  of  Margaret  Rule. 

written  by  the  Rev.  Cotton  Mather. 
Part  II. — Several  Letters  to  the  Author,  &c.  and  his  Reply 

relating  to  Witchcraft. 
Part  III. — The   Differences  between  the  Inhabitants  of 
Salem  Village,  and  Mr.  Parris,  their  Minister,  in  New- 
England. 
Part  IV. — Letters  of  a  Gentleman  uninterested,  endea- 
vouring to  prove  the  received  opinions  about  Witchcraft 
to  be  Orthodox.     With  short  Essays  to  their  Answers. 
Part  V.— A  short  Historical  Account  of  Matters  of  Fact 
in  that  Affair. 

to  which  is  added 

A  POSTCIIIPT, 

relating  to  a  book  entitled  "  the  LIFE  OF  SIR  WM.  PIIIPS." 


COLLECTED    BY 

ROBERT  CALEF, 

Merchant,  of  Boston,  in  New-Endand 


TRINTED  LV  LONDON,   A.  D.    1700. 
-PRINTED    IN    SALEM,  BY  JOHN  D.  AND  T.  C.  CUSniNG,  .TPv 
FOR  CISHING  AND  APPLETOff 

1323. 


THE  EPISTLE  TO  THE  READER, 

AND    MORE    ESPECIALLY    TO    THE    NOBLE    BARONS    OF 
THIS    AGE,    WHEREVER    RESIDING. 

GENTLEMEN, 

X  OU,  that  are  freed  from  the  slavery  of  a 
corrupt  education ;  and  that,  in  spite  of  human 
precepts,  example,  and  precedents,  can  hearken 
to  the  dictates  of  scripture  and  reason  ;  for  your 
sakes  I  am  content  that  these  collections  of 
mine,  as  also  my  sentiments,  should  be  exposed 
to  public  view;  in  hopes  that,  having  well  con- 
sidered and  compared  them  with  scripture,  you 
will  see  reason,  as  I  do,  to  question  a  belief  so 
prevalent  as  that  here  treated  of,  as  also  the 
practice  flowing  from  thence ;  they  standing  as 
nearly  connected  as  cause  and  effect ;  it  being 
found  wholly  impracticable  to  extirpate  the  lat- 
ter, without  first  curing  the  former.  And  if  the 
buffoon  or  satirical  will  be  exercising  their  ta- 
lents, or  if  the  bigots  wilfully  and  blindly  reject 
the  testimonies  of  their  own  reason,  and  more 
sure  word,  it  is  no  more  than  what  I  expected 
from  them.  But  you,  gentlemen,  I  doubt  not, 
are  willing  to  distinguish  between  truth  and  er- 
ror;  and  if  this  may  be  any  furtherance  to  you 
herein,  I  shall  not  miss  my  aim.  But  if  you  find 
the  contrary,  and  that  my  belief  herein  is  any 
way  heterodox,  I  shall  be  thankful  for  the  in- 
formation to  any  learned  or  reverend  person,  or 


cy  THE  EPISTLE 

others,  that  shall  take  that  pains  to  inform  me 
better,  by  scripture  or  sound,  reason ;  which  is 
what  1  have  been  long  seeking  for  in  this  coun- 
try in  vain. 

In  a  time  when  not  only  England  in  particu- 
lar, but  almost  all  Europe,  had  been  labouring 
against  the  usurpations  of  tyranny  and  slavery, 
the  English  x4merica  has  not  been  behind  in  a 
share  of  the  common  calamities  ;  more  espe- 
cially, New-England  has  met  not  only  with  such 
calamities  as  are  common  to  the  rest,  but  with 
several  aggravations  enhancing  such  afflictions, 
hj  the  devastations  and  cruelties  of  the  barba- 
rous Indians  in  their  eastern  borders,  &c.  But 
this  is  not  all ;  they  have  been  harast  (on  many 
accounts)  by  a  more  dreadful  enemy,  as  will 
herein  appear  to  the  considerate. 

Were  it,  as  w^e  are  told  in  Wonders  of  the  In^ 
visible  World,  "  that  the  devils  were  walking 
about  our  streets  with  lengthened  chains,  making 
a  dreadful  noise  in  our  ears ;  and  brimstone 
(eve.n  without  a  metaj^hor)  was  making  a  hor- 
rid and  a  hellish  stench  in  our  nostrils  ;"  and, 
"  that  the  devil,  exhibiting  himself  ordinarily  as 
a  black  man,  had  decoyed  a  fearful  knot  of 
proud,  fro  ward,  ignorant,  envious  and  malicious 
creatures,  to  list  themselves  in  his  horrid  ser- 
vice, by  enterin^^  their  names  in  a  book  tendered 
unto  them ;  and  that  they  have  had  their  meet- 
ings and  sacraments,  and  associated  themselves 
to  destroy  the  kingdom  of  our  Lord  Jesus  Christ, 
in  these  parts  of  the  world ;  having  each  of  them 
their  spectres,  or  devils,  commissioned  by  them, 
and  representing  of  them  to  be  the  engines  of 


TO  THE  READER.  v 

their  malice,  by  tlicsc  wicked  spectres  seizing; 
poor  people  about  the  country,  with  various  and 
bloody  torments,  and  oi"  those  evidently  preter- 
natural torments  some  have  died;  and  that  they 
have  bewitched  some  even  so  far  as  to  make  them 
self-destroyers,  and  others  in  many  towns  here 
and  there  languished  under  their  evil  hands — 
the  people,  thus  afflicted,  miserably  scratched 
and  bitten ;  and  that  the  same  invisible  furies 
did  stick  pins  in  them,  and  scald  them,  distort 
and  disjoint  them,  with  a  thousand  other  plagues; 
and  sometimes  drag  them  out  of  their  chambers, 
and  carry  them  over  trees  and  hills,  miles  toge- 
ther, many  of  them  being  tempted  to  sign  the 
devil's  laws" — "those  furies,  whereof  several 
Imve  killed  more  people  perhaps  than  would 
serve  to  make  a  village'' — If  this  be  the  true  state 
of  the  afflictions  of  this  country,  it  is  very  deplora- 
ble, and  beyond  all  other  outward  calamities  mis- 
erable. But  if,  on  the  other  side,  the  matter  be,  as 
others  do  understand  it,  that  the  devil  has  been 
too  hard  for  us  by  his  temptations,  signs,  and 
lying  wonders,  with  the  help  of  pernicious  no- 
tions, formerly  imbibed  and  professed  ;  together 
with  the  accusations  of  a  parcel  of  possessed, 
distracted  or  lying  wenches,  accusing  their  inno- 
cent neighbours,  pretending  they  see  their  spec- 
tres, i.  e.  devils  in  their  likeness,  afflicting  of 
them;  and  that  God  in  righteous  judgment  (af- 
ter men  had  ascribed  his  power  to  witches,  of 
commissioning  d;:':;vils  to  do  these  things)  may 
have  given  them  over  to  strong  delusions  to  be- 
lieve lies,  &c.  and  to  let  loose  the  devils  of  envy, 
hatred,  pride,  cruelty  and  malice  against  each 
1* 


vi  THE  EPISTLE 

other,  jet  still  disguised  under  the  mask  of  zeai 
for  God,  and  left  them  to  the  branding  one  anoth- 
er with  the  odious  name  of  witch  ;  and  upon  the 
accusation  of  those  above  mentioned,  brother  to 
accuse  and  prosecute  brother,  children  their  pa- 
rents,  pastors    and    teachers    their    immediate 
flock,  unto  death;  shepherds  becoming  wolves;, 
wise  men  infatuated  ;  people  hauled  to  prisons ; 
with  a  bloody  noise   pursuing  to,  and  Insulting 
over  the  (true)   sufferers  at,  execution;  while 
seme  are  fleeing  from  that  called  justice,  justice 
itself  fleeing  before  such  accusations,  when  once 
it  did  but  begin  to  refrain  further  proceedings  ; 
and,  to  question  such  practices,   some  making 
their  escape  cut  of  prisons,  rather  than  bv  an 
obstinate  defence  of  their  innocencj  to  run  so 
apparent  hazard  of  their  lives ;   estates  seized, 
families  of  cliUdren  and  others  left  to  the  mercy 
of  the  wilderness  (not  to  mention  here  the  num- 
bers proscribed,  dead  In  prisons  or  executed, 
&:c.)— All  which  tragedies,  though  begun  in  one 
town,  or  rather  by  one  parish,  has  pj ague-like 
spread  more  than  through  that  country,  and  by 
its  echo  giving  a  brand  of  infamy  to  this  whole 
country  throughout  the  world  : — If  this  w^ere 
the  miserable  case  of  this  country  in  the  time 
thereof,  and  that  the  devil  had  so  far  prevailed 
upon  us,    In  our  sentiments  and   actions,   as   to 
draw  us  from  so  much  as  looking  into  the  scrip 
tures  for  our  guidance  in  these  pretended  intrl- 
eacles ;  leading  us  to  a  trusting  In  blind  guides, 
^uch  as  the    corrupt  practices  of  some-   other 
<i;ountries,  or  the  bloody  experiments  of  Bodit), 
'dixl  si.jch  other  authors  : — then,  though  our  ca?f> 


TO  THE  READEU.  vli* 

be  most  miserable,  yd  it  must  be  said  of  New- 
England,  thou  hast  destroyed  thysell',  and  brought 
this  greatest  oC  miseries  upon  thee. 

And  now,  whether  the  witches  (such  as  have 
made  a  compact  by  explicit  covenant  witii  the 
devil,  having  thereby  obtained  a  power  to  com- 
mission him)  have  been  the  cause  of  our  mise- 
ries; or  whether  a  zeal,  governed  by  blindness 
and  passion,  and  led  by  precedent,  has  not  here- 
in precipitated  us  into  far  greater  wickedness 
(if  not  witchcrai'ts)  than  any  have  yjet  been  pro- 
ved against  those  that  suffered: — to  be  able  to 
distinguish  aright  in  this  matter,  to  which  of  these 
two  to  refer  our  miseries,  is  the  design  of  the 
present  work. 

As  to  the  former,  I  know  of  no  sober  man, 
much  less  reverend  christian,  that,  being  asked, 
dares  affirm,  and  abide  by  it,  that  witches  have 
that  power,  viz.  to  commission  devils  to  kill  and 
destroy;  and  as  to  the  latter,  it  were  well  if 
there  were  not  too  much  of  truth  in  it,  which 
remains  to  be  demonstrated. 
,-  But  here  it  will  be  said,  What  need  of  raking 
in  the  coals  that  lay  buried  in  oblivion?  We 
cannot  recal  those  to  life  again,  that  have  suf- 
fered, supposing  it  were  unjustly;  it  tends  but 
t;o  the  exposing  the  actors,  as  if  they  had  pro- 
ceeded irregularly. 

Truly  1  take  tills  to  be  just  as  the  devil 
would  have  it,  so  much  to  fear  disobliging  men, 
as  not  to  endeavour  to  detect  his  wiles,  that  so 
he  may  the  sooner,  and  with  the  greater  advan- 
tages, set  the  same  on  foot  ag^in  (either  here  or 
elsewhere),  so  dragging  us  through  the  pond 
twice  by  the  same  cat.     And,  if  reports  do  not 


viii  THE  EPISTLE 

herein  deceive  us,  much  the  same  has  been  act- 
ing this  present  year  in  Scotland.     And  wliat 
kingdom  or  country  is  it,  that  has  not  had  their 
bloody  tits  and  turns  at  it  ?     And  if  this  is  such 
a  catching  disease,  and  so  universal,    I  presume 
I  need  make  no  apology   for  my  endeavours  to 
prevent,  as  far  as  in  my  power,  any  more  such 
bloody   victims   or  sacrifices ;  though   indeed   I 
had  rather  any  other  would  have  undertaken  so 
offensive,    though    necessary,    a    task;  yet,  all 
things  weighed,  I   had  rather  thus  expose   my- 
self to  censure,  than  that  it  should  be    wholly 
omitted.      Were  the  notions  in  question  innocent 
and  harmless,  respecting  the  glory  of  God,  and 
well-being  of  men,  I  should  not  have  engaged  in 
them;  but  finding  them,  in  my  esteem,   so  into- 
lerably destructive   of  both,  thisy  together  w^ith 
my  being  by  warrant  called  before  the  justices, 
in  my  own  just  vindication  I  took  it  to  be  a  call 
from  God,  to  my  power,  to  vindicate  his  truths, 
against  the  pagan  and  popish  assertions,  which 
are  so  prevalent ;  for  though  christians  in  gene-^ 
ral  do  own  the  scriptures  to  be  their  only  rule 
of  faith  and  doctrine,  yet   these  notions  will  tell 
us,  tliat  the  scriptures  have  not  sufficiently,  nor 
at  all,  described  the  crime  of  witchcraft,  where- 
by the   culpable   might  be  detected,  though  it 
be  positive  in   the   command  to    punish    it    by 
death ;  hence  the  world  has  been  from  time  to 
time  perplexed,  in  the  prosecution  of  the  seve^ 
ral  diabolical    mediums  of  heathenish  and    po- 
pish invention  to  detect  an  imaginary  crime  (not 
but  that  there  are  witches  such  as   the   law  of 
God  describes)  which  has  produced  a  deluge  of 


TO  THE  READER.  ix 

blood;  hereby  rendering  the  commands  of  God 
not  only  void  but  dangerous. 

So  also  they  own  God's  providence  and  go- 
vernment of  the  world ;  and  that  tempests  and 
storms,  adlictlons  and  diseases,  are  of  his  send- 
ing; yet  these  notions  tell  us,  that  the  devil  has 
the  power  of  all  these,  and  can  perform  them 
when  commissioned  by  a  witch  thereto;  and 
that  he  has  a  power,  at  the  witch's  call,  to  act 
and  do,  without  and  against  the  course  of  nature, 
and  all  natural  causes,  in  afflicting  and  killing  of 
innocents;  and  this  It  is  that  so  many  have  died 
for. 

Also  it  is  generally  believed,  that  if  any  pian 
has  strength,  it  is  from  God  the  Almighty  Be- 
ing :  but  these  notions  will  tell  us,  that  the  de- 
vil can  make  one  man  as  strong  as  many;  which 
was  one  of  the  best  proofs,  as  it  was  com^ted, 
against  Mr.  Burroughs  the  minister;  though' 
his  contemporaries  in  the  schools,  during  his  mi- 
nority, could  have  testified,  that  his  strength 
was  then  as  much  superior  to  theirs  as  ever 
(setting  aside  incredible  romances)  it  was  disco- 
vered to  be  since  :  thus  rendering  the  power 
of  God,  and  his  providence,  of  none  elFect. 

These  are  some  of  the  destructive  notions  of 
this  age;  and  however  the  asserters  of  them 
seem  sometimes  to  value  themselves  much  upon 
sheltering  their  neighbours  from  spectral  accu- 
sations, they  may  deserve  as  much  thanks  as 
that  tyrant,  that,  having  industriously  obtained 
an  unintelligible  charge  against  his  subjects,  in 
matters  wherein  it  was  impossible  they  should 
be  guilty,  having  thereby  their  lives  in  his  pow- 


X  THE  EPISTLE 

er,  yet  suffers  them  of  his  mere  grace   to  live, 
and  will  be  called  gracious  lord. 

It  were  too  Icarian  a  task  for  one,  unfurnished 
with  necessary  learning,  and  library,  to  give  any 
just  account  from  whence  so  great  delusions 
have  sprung,  and  so  long  continued.  Yet,  as  an 
essay  from  those  scraps  of  reading  that  1  have 
had  opportunity  of,  it  will  be  no  great  venture 
to  say,  that  signs  and  lying  wonders  have  been 
one  principal  cause. 

It  is  written  of  Justin  Martyr,  who  lived  in 
the  second  century,  that  he  was  before  his  con- 
version a  great  philosopher;  first  in  the  way  of 
th^stoicks,  and  after,  of  the  peripateticks,  after 
that  of  the  pythagorean,  and  after  that  of  the 
platonist,  sects;  and  after  all  proved  of  eminent 
use  in  the  church  of  Christ:  yet  a  certain  au- 
thor, speaking  of  one  Apollonius  Tyaneus,  has 
these  words :  ^'  That  the  most  orthodox  them- 
selves began  to  deem  him  vested  with  power 
sufficient  for  a  deity;  which  occasioned  that  so 
strange  a  doubt  from  Justin  Martyr,  as  cited  bj 
the  learned  Gregory,  fol.  37 :  If  God  be  the 
creator  and  lord  of  the  world,  how  comes  it  to 
pass  that  Apollonius  his  telisms  have  so  much 
over-ruled  the  course  of  things?  for  we  see  that 
they  also  have  stilled  the  waves  of  the  sea,  and 
the  raging  of  the  winds,  and  prevailed  against 
the  noisome  flies,  and  incursions  of  wild  beasts, 
&;c."  If  so  eminent  and  early  a  christian  were 
by  these  false  shews  in  jnich  doubt,  it  is  the  less 
wonder,  in  our  dej)raved  times,  to  meet  with 
what  IS  equivalent  tliereto.  Besides  this,  a  cer- 
tain author  informs  me,  that  Julian  (alter vvards 


TO  THE  READER.  xi 

called  the  apostate)  bcinsc  iustrucfed  in  the  plii- 
losopliy  and  disciplines  of  the  heathen,  by  Liba- 
rius  his  tutor,  by  this  means  lie  came  to  love 
philosophy  better  than  the  gosj^el,  and  so  by  de- 
grees turned  from  Christianity  to  heathenism." 

This  same  Julian  did,  when  apostate,  forbid 
that  christians  should  be  instructed  in  the  disci- 
pline of  the  gentiles;  which,  it  seems,  Socrates, 
a  writer  of  the  ecclesiastical  history,  does  ac- 
knowledge to  be  by  tliC  singular  providence  of 
God  ;  christians  having  then  begun  to  degenerate 
from  the  gospel,  and  to  betake  themselves  to 
heathenish  learning.  And  in  the  Mercury  for 
the  month  of  February,  1695,  there  is  this  ac- 
count, *'  That  the  christian  doctors,  conversing 
much  with  the  writings  of  the  heathen,  for  the 
gaining  of  eloquence,  a  council  was  held  at  Car- 
thage, which  forbad  the  reading  oi'  the  books  of 
the  gentiles." 

From  all  which  it  may  be  easily  perceived, 
that  in  the  primitive  times  of  Christianity,  when 
notj  only  many  heathen  of  the  vulgar,  but  also 
many  learned  men  and  philosophers,  had  em- 
braced the  christian  faith,  they  still  retained  a 
love  to  their  heathen  learning;  which,  as  one 
observes,  being  transplanted  into  a  christian  soil, 
soon  proved  productive  of  pernicious  weeds, 
which  overran  the  face  of  the  church;  hence 
it  was  so  deformed,  as  the  reformation  found  it. 
Among  other  pernicious  weeds  arising  from 
this  root,  the  doctrine  of  the  power  of  devils, 
and  witchcraft,  as  it  is  now  and  long  has  been 
understood,  is  not  the  least :  the  fables  of  Ho- 
mer, Virgil,  Horace  and  Ovid,  &c.  being  for  the 


iLii  THE  EPiSTLE 

elegancy  of  their  language  retained  then  (and  so 
are  to  this  day)  in  the  schools,  have  not  only  in- 
troduced, but  established,  such  doctrines,  to  the 
poisoning  the  christian  world.  A  certain  author 
expresses  it  thus :  "  That  as  the  christian  schools 
at  first  brought  men  from  heathenism  to  the 
gospel,  so  these  schools  carry  men  from  the  gos- 
pel to  heatlienism,  as  to  their  great  perfection." 
And  Mr.  L  JVl.  in  his  Remarkable  Providences^ 
gives  an  account,  that  (as  he  calls  it)  an  old 
council  did  anatiiematize  all  those  that  behoved 
such  power  of  the  devils,  accounting  it  a  damna- 
ble doctrine.  But  as  other  evils  did  afterwards 
increase  in  the  church  (partly  by  such  education) 
so  this  insensibly  grew  up  with  tliem,  though  not 
to  that  degree  as  that  any  council,  I  have  ever 
heard  or  read  of,  has  to. this  day  taken  off  those 
anathemas;  yet  alter  this  the  church  so  far  de- 
clined, that  witchcraft  became  a  principal  eccle- 
siastical engine  (as  also  that  of  heresy  was)  to 
root  up  all  that  stood  in  their  w^ay ;  and  besides 
the  w^ays  of  trial  that  we  have  still  in  practice, 
they  invented  some  which  were  peculiar  to  them- 
selves; which,  whenever  they  w^ere  minded  to 
improve  against  any  orthodox  believer,  they 
could  easily  make  effectual.  That  deluge  of 
blood,  which  that  Scarlet  Whore  has' to  answer 
for,  siied  under  this  notion,  how  amazing  is  it! 

The  first  in  England,  that  I  have  read  of,  of 
any  note,  since  the  reformation,  that  asserts  this 
doctrine,  is  the  famous  Mr.  Perkins:  he,  as  also 
Mr.  Gaul,  Mr.  Bernard,  &c.  seem  all  of  them  to 
have  undertaken  one  task;  taking  notice  of  the 
fnultiplicity  of  irregular  Avays  to  try  them  by. 


TO  THE  READEK.  xiii 

invented  by  heathen  and  papists,  they  made  it 
their  business,  and  main  work,  herein  to  oppose 
such  as  they  saw  to  be  pernicious.     And  it'  they 
did  not  look  more  narrowly  into  it,  but  i'ol lowed 
the  hrst,  viz.  Mi".  Perkins,   whose  education  (as 
theirs  also)  had  forestalled  him  into  such  belief, 
Avhom  they  readily  followed,  it  cannot  be   won- 
dered at.     And   tliat  they  were  men  liable  to 
err,  and  so  not  to  he  trusted  to  as  perfect  guides, 
will  manifestly  appear  to  him  that  shall  see  their 
several  receipts  laid  down  to  detect  them,  by 
their  presumptive  and  positive  ones  ;  and  con- 
sider how  few  of  either  have  any  foundation  in 
scripture,  or  reason;  and  how  vastly  they  differ 
from  each  other  in  both  ;  each  having   his   art 
by  himself,    which   forty  or  an  hundred  more 
may  as  well  imitate,  and  give  theirs,  ad  infinitum, 
being  without  all  manner  of  proof.    But  though 
this    be   their  main  design,  to  take  otf  people 
from  those  evil  and  bloody  ways  of  trial,  which 
they  speak  so   much   against;  yet  this  does  not 
hinder,  to  this  day,  but   the  same  evil  ways,  or 
as  bad,  are  still  used  to  detect  them  by,  and  that 
even  among  protestants;  and  are  so  far  justified, 
that  a  reverend    person  has  said    lately  here, 
How  else  shall  we  detect  witches.'^  And  another, 
being  urged  to  prove  by  scripture  such  a  sort 
of  witch  as   has   power  to  send   devils    to   kill 
men,  replied,  that  he  did  as  firmly  believe  it,  as 
any  article  of  his  faith  ;  and  that  he  (the  inqui- 
rer) did  not  go   to  the  scriptures  to  learn   the 
mysteries  of  his  trade   or   art.     What   can   be 
said  more  to  establish  their  heathenish  notions, 
and  to  vilify  the  scriptures,  our  only  rule  ?  and 


xiv  THE  EPISTLE 

that,  after  we  have  seen  such  dire  effects  there- 
of, as  has  threatened  the  utter  extirpation  of 
this  whole  country. 

And  as  to  most  of  the  actors  in  these  trage- 
dies, though  they  are  so  far  from  defending 
their  actions,  that  they  will  readily  own  that 
undue  steps  have  been  taken,  &;c.  yet  it  seems 
*they  choose  that  the  same  should  be  acted  over 
again,  enforced  by  their  example,  rather  than  it 
should  remain  as  a  warning  to  posterity,  as 
herein  they  have  mist  it.  So  far  are  they  from 
giving  glory  to  God,  and  taking  the  due  shame 
to  themselves. 

And  now',  to  sum  up  all  in  a  few  words,  vre 
have  seen  a  bigoted  zeal  stirring  up  a  blind  and 
most  bloody  rage,  not  against  enemies,  or  irreli- 
gious, profligate  persons ;  but  (in  judgment  of 
charity,  and  to  view)  against  as  virtuous  and  re- 
hgious  as  any  they  have  ]eft  behind  them  in 
this  country,  w^hich  have  suffered  as  evil  doers 
(with  the  utmost  extent  of  rigour,  not  that  so 
high  a  character  is  due  to  all  that  suffered)  and 
this  by  the  testimony  of  vile  varlets,  as  not  only 
were  known  be'fore,  but  have  been  further  ap- 
parent since,  by  their  manifest  lives,  whore- 
doms, incest,  &c.  The  accusations  of  these, 
from  their  spectral  sight,  being  the  chief  evi- 
dence against  those  that  suffered  ;  in  which  ac- 
cusations they  were  upheld  by  both  magistrates 
and  ministers,  so  long  as  they  apprehended 
themselves  in  no  danger. 

And  then,  though  they  could  defend  neither 
the  doctrine  nor  the  practice,  yet  none  of  them 
have,  in  such  a  puublic  manner  as  the  case  re- 


TO  THE  READER.  xy 

quires,  testified  against  either ;  thou<^h  at  the 
same  time  they  could  not  but  be  sensible  what 
a  stain  and  lasting  infamy  they  have  brought 
upon  the  whole  country,  to  the  endangering  the 
future  welfare  not  only  of  this  but  of  other  pla- 
ces, induced  by  their  example;  if  not  to  an  en- 
tailing the  guilt  of  all  the  righteous  blood  that 
has  been  by  the  same  means  shed,  by  heathen 
or  papists,  &c.  upon  themselves,  whose  deeds 
they  have  so  far  justified,  occasioning  the  great 
dishonour  and  blasphemy  of  the  name  of  God, 
scandalizing  the  heathen,  hardening  of  enemies ; 
and,  as  a  natural  effect  thereof,  to  the  great  in- 
crease of  atheism. 

I  shall  conclude,  only  with  acquainting  the 
reader,  that  of  these  collections,  the  first,  con- 
taining More  Wonders  of  the  Invisible  World, 
I  received  of  a  gentleman,  who  had  it  of  the 
author,  and  communicated  it  to  use,  with  his 
express  consent,  of  which  this  is  a  true  copy. 
As  to  the  letters,  they  are,  for  substance,  the 
same  I  sent,  though  with  some  small  variation, 
or  addition.  Touching  the  two  letters  from  a 
gentleman,  at  his  request  1  have  forborn  nam- 
ing him.  It  is  great  pity  that  the  matters  of 
fact,  and  indeed  the  whole,  had  not  been  done 
by  some  abler  hand,  better  accomplished,  and 
with  the  advantages  of  both  natural  and  acquir- 
ed judgment ;  but  others  not  appearing,  1  have 
enforced  myself  to  do  what  is  done;  my  other 
occasions  will  not  admit  any  further  scrutiny/ 
therein.  R.  C. 

Aifgu^t,  11,  1697. 


PART  1. 


ACCOUNT  OF  THE  SUFFERINGS 

OF 

MARGARET  RULE. 

SIR, 

1  NOW  lay  before  you  a  very  entertaining 
story — a  story  which  relates  yet  more  Wonders 
of  the  Invisible  World — a  story  which  tells  the 
remarkable  afflictions  and  deliverance  of  one  that 
had  been  prodigiously  handled  by  the  Evil  An- 
gels. I  was  myself  a  daily  eye-witness  to  a  large 
part  of  these  occurrences,  and  there  may  be  pro- 
duced scores  of  substantial  witnesses  to  the  most 
of  them;  yea,  I  know  not  of  any  one  passage  of 
the  story  but  what  may  be  sufficiently  attested. 
I  do  not  write  it  with  a  design  of  throwing  it 
presently  into  the  press,  but  only  to  preserve 
the  memory  of  such  memorable  things,  the  for- 
getting whereof  would  neither  be  pleasing  to 
God,  nor  useful  to  men;  as  also  to  give  you,  with 


18 

some  others  of  peculiar  and  obliging  friends,  a 
sight  of  some  curiosities.  And  I  hope  this  apo- 
logy will  serve  to  excuse  me,  if  I  mention,  ag 
perhaps  I  may,  when  I  come  to  a  tenth  para- 
graph in  my  writing,  some  things  which  1  would 
have  omitted  in  a  farther  publication. 

COTTON  MATHEEv. 


1^ 


ANOTHER  BRAND 

FLUCKT  OUT  OF  THE  BURMIJ^G, 

OR 

MORE  WONDERS  OF  THE  INVISIBLE  WORLD; 

Sect.  1.  V^ITHIN  these  few  years,  there 
died  in  the  southern  parts,  a  christian  Indian, 
who,  notwithstanding  some  of  his  Indian  weak- 
ness, had  something  of  a  better  character,  of  vir- 
tue and  goodness,  than  many  of  our  people  can 
allow  to  most  of  their  countrymen,  that  profess 
the  christian  religion.  He  had  been  a  zealous 
preacher  of  the  gospel  to  his  neighbourhood, 
and  a  sort  of  overseer  or  officer,  to  whose  con- 
duct was  owing  very  much  of  what  good  order 
was  maintained  among  these  proselyted  savages. 
This  man,  returning  home  from  the  funeral  of 
his  son,  was  complimented  by  an  Englishman, 
expressing  sorrow  for  his  loss.  Now,  though 
the  Indians  used  upon  the  death  of  relations  to 
be  the  most  passionate  and  outrageous  creatures 
in  the  world,  yet  this  converted  Indian  hand- 
somely and  cheerfully  replied.  Truly  I  am  sorry, 
and  I  am  not  sorry:  I  am  sorry  that  I  have 
buried  a  dear  son ;  but  I  am  not  sorry  that  the 
will  of  God  is  done :  I  know  that  without  the 
will  of  God  my  son  could  not  have  died;  and  I 
know  that  the  will  of  God  is  always  just  and 


20  SUFFERINGS  OF 

good,  and  so  I  am  satisfied.     Imaiediately  upon 
this,  even  within   a  few  hours,   he  fell  himself 
sick,  of  a  disease  that  quickly  killed  him  ;  in  the 
time  of  which  disease,  he  called  his  folks  about 
him,  earnestly  persuading  them  to  be  sincere  in 
their  praying  unto  God,   and  to  beware  of  the 
drunkenness,  the  idleness,  the  lying,  v/hereby  so 
many   of  that  nation  disgraced  their  profession 
of  Christianity ;  adding,  that  he  was  ashamed, 
Avhen  he  thought  how  little  service  he  had  hi- 
therto done  for  God ;  and,  that  ii'God  would  pro- 
long his  life,  he  would  labour  to  do  better  ser- 
vice ;  but  that  he  was  fully  sure  he  was  now  go- 
ing to  the  Lord  Jesus  Christ,  who  had   bought 
him   with   his  precious  blood;  and  for  his  part, 
he  longed  to  die,  that  he  might  be  with  his  glo- 
rious Lord ;  and,  in  the  midst  of  such  passages, 
he  gave  up  the  ghost;  but  in  such  repute,  that 
the  English  people,  of  good  fashion,  did  not  think 
much  of  travelling  a  great  way  to  his  interment. 
Lest  my  reader  do  wonder  why  I  have  related 
this  piece  of  a  story,  1  will  now  hasten  to  abate 
that   wonder,   by  telling  that  wliereto  this   was 
intended  but  for  an   introduction.     Know  then, 
that  this  remarkable  Indian  being,  a  little  before 
he  died,  at   work  in  the  wood,   making  of  tar, 
there  appeared  unto  him  a  black  man,  of  a  ter- 
rible aspect,  and  more   than  human  dimensions, 
threatenmg  bitterly  to  kill  him,  if  he  would  not 
promise  to  leave  otf  preaching,  as  he  did,  to  his 
countrymen,  and  promise  particularly,  that  if  he 
preached   any   more,    he  would  say  nothing   of 
Jesus  Christ  unto  them.     The  Indian  was  amaz- 
ed, yet  had  the  courage  to  answer,  I  will,  in  spite 


MARGARET  RULE.  21 

of  you,  ^o  on  to  preach  Christ,  more  than  ever 
I  did;  and  the  God  whom  1  serve  will  keep  me, 
that  you  shall  never  hurt  me.  Hereupon  the 
apparition,  abating  somewhat  of  his  fierceness, 
olfered  to  the  Indian  a  book, of  a  considerable 
thickness,  and  a  pen  and  ink,  and  said,  that  if  he 
woiild  now  set  his  hand  unto  that  book,  he  would 
require  nothing  further  of  him  ;  but  the  man  re- 
fused ibe  motion  with  indignation,  and  fell  down 
upon  his  knees  into  a  fervent  and  pious  prayer 
unto  God,  for  help  against  the  tempter;  where- 
upon the  demon  vanished. 

This  is  a  story  which  I  would  never  have  ten- 
dered unto  my  reader,  if  I  had  not  received  it 
from  an  honest  and  useful  Endishman,  who  is 

IT 

at  this  time  a  preacher  of  the  gospel  to  the  In- 
dians; nor  would  the  probable  truth  of  it  have 
encouraged  me  to  have  tendered  it,  if  this  also 
had  not  been  a  fit  introduction  unto  a  yet  fur- 
ther narrative. 

Sect.  2.  It  was  not  much  above  a  year  or 
two  after  this  accident  (of  which  no  manner  of 
noise  has  been  made)  that  there  was  a  prodi- 
gious descent  of  devils  upon  divers  places  near 
the  centre  of  this  province  ;  wherein  some  scores 
of  miserable  people  were  troubled  by  horrible 
appearances  of  a  black  man,  accompanie"d  with 
spectres,  wearing  these  and  those  human  shapes, 
who  oiFered  them  a  book  to  be  by  them  signed, 
in  token  of  their  being  listed  for  the  service  of 
the  devil ;  and,  upon  tiieir  denying  to  do  it,  they 
were  dragooned  with  a  thousand  preternatural 
torments,  which  gave  no  little  terror  to  the  be- 
holders of  these  unhappy  people.     There  wa- 


^t  SUFFERINGS  OP 

one  in  the  north  part  of  Boston  seized  bj  the 
evil  angels  many  months  alter  the  general  storm 
of  the  late  enchantments  was  over,  and  when 
the  country  had  long  lain  very  quiet,  both  as  to 
molestations  and  accusations  from  the  invisible 
world  :  her  name  was  Margaret  Rule,  a  young 
-woman  :  she  was  born  of  sober  and  honest  pa- 
rents, yet  living ;  but  what  her  own  character 
was  before  her  visitation  I  can  speak  with  the 
less  confidence  of  exactness,  because  1  observe 
that  wherever  the  devils  have  been  let  loose,  to 
worry  any  poor  creature  among  us,  a  great  part 
of  the  neighbourhood  presently  set  themselves 
to  inquire,  and  relate  all  the  little  vanities  of 
their  childhood,  with  such  unequal  exaggerations, 
as  to  make  them  appear  greater  sinners  than  any 
whom  the  pilot  of  hell  has  not  yet  preyed  up- 
on. But  it  is  affirmed,  that,  for  about  half  a  year 
before  her  visitation,  she  was  observably  impro- 
ved in  the  hopeful  symptoms  of  a  new  creature ; 
she  was  become  seriously  concerned  for  the 
everlasting  salvation  of  her  soul,  and  careful  to 
avoid  the  snares  of  evil  company.  This  young 
woman  had  never  seen  the  afflictions  of  Mercy 
Short,  whereof  a  narrative  has  been  already 
given  ;  and  yet,  about  half  a  year  after  the  glo- 
rious and  signal  deliverance  of  that  poor  dam- 
sel, this  Margaret  fell  into  an  affliction,  marvel- 
lous, resembling  hers  in  almost  all  the  circum- 
stances of  it ;  indeed  the  afflictions  were  so  much 
alike,  that  the  relation  i  have  given  of  the  one, 
would  almost  serve  as  the  full  history  of  the 
other;  this  was  to  that  little  more  than  the  se- 
cond part  of  the  same  tune  ;  indeed  Margaret'? 


MARGARET  RULE.  2$ 

oase  was  in  several  points  less  rcraarka!)lc  than 
Mercy's,  and  in  some  other  tnirjgs  tlie  entertain- 
ment did  a  little  vary. 

Sect.  3.  It  was  upon  the  Lord's  day,  the 
10th  ol  September,  in  thi^  year  1603,  that  M-^r- 
garet  Rule,  after  some  hours  of  previots  distur- 
bance in  the  public  assembly,  ieil  into  odd  fits, 
which  caused  her  (riends  to  carry  her  home, 
where  her  fits  in  a  few  hours  i{rew  into  a  figure 
that  satisfied  the  spectators  of  their  bein^;  pre- 
ternatural. Some  cf  the  neighbours  were  for- 
ward enough  to  suspect  the  rise  of  this  mischief 
in  an  house  hard  by,  where  lived  a  miserable 
Avoman,  who  had  been  formerly  imprisoned,  on 
the  suspicion  of  witchcraft,  and  who  had  fre- 
quently cured  very  painful  hurts,  by  muttering 
over  them  certain  charms,  which  I  shall  not  en- 
danger the  poisoning  of  my  reader  by  repeating. 
This  woman  had,  the  evening  before  Margaret 
fell  into  her  calamities,  very  bitterly  treated 
her,  and  threatened  her;  but  f!ie  hazard  of 
hurting  a  poor  Avoman,  that  might  be  innocent, 
notwithstanding  surmises  that  might  have  been 
more  strongly  grounded  than  those,  caused  the 
pious  people  in  the  vicinity  to  try,  rather, 
whether  incessant  supplication  to  God  alone 
might  not  procure  a  quicker  and  snfer  ease  to 
the  afflicted,  than  hasty  prosecution  of  any  sup- 
posed criminal  ;  and  accordingly  that  unexcep- 
tionable course  was  all  that  was  ever  followed: 
yea,  which  1  looked  on  as  a  token  for  good,  the 
afflicted  family  was  as  averse,  as  any  of  us,  to 
entertain  thouglits  of  any  other  course. 

Sect.  4.     The  young  woman  was  assaulted 


24  SUFFERINGS  OF 

bj  eight  cruel  spectres,  whereof  she  imagined 
that  she  knew  three  or  four;  but  the  rest  came 
still  w^ith  their  faces  covered,  so  that  she  could 
never  have  a  distinguished  view  of  the  counte- 
nance of  those  whom  she  thought  she  knew^; 
she  w^as  very  careful  of  my  reiterated  charges, 
to  forbear  blazing  their  names,  lest  any  good 
person  should  come  to  suiTer  any  blast  of  repu- 
tation, through  the  cunning  malice  of  the  great 
accuser;  nevertheless,  having  since  privately 
named  them  to  myself,  I  will  venture  to  say  this 
of  them,  that  they  are  a  sort  of  wretches,  who 
for  these  many  years  have  gone  under  as  vio- 
lent presumptions  of  witchcraft,  as  perhaps  any 
creatures  yet  living  upon  earth;  although  I  ani' 
far  from  thinking  that  the  visions  of  this  young 
w^oman  were  evidence  enough  to  prove  them 
so.  These  cursed  spectres  now  brought  unto 
her  a  book  about  a  cubit  long — a  book  red  and 
thick,  but  not  very  broad ;  and  they  demanded 
of  her,  that  she  would  set  her  hand  to  that 
book,  or  touch  it  at  least  with  her  hand,  as  a 
sign  of  her  becoming  a  servant  of  the  devil. 
Upon  her  peremptory  refusal  to  do  what  they 
asked,  they  did  not  alter  renew  the  proffers  of 
the  book  unto  her,  but  instead  thereof  they  fell 
to  tormenting  of  her  in  a  manner  too  hellish  to 
be  sufficiently  described — in  those  torments  con- 
fining her  to  her  bed  for  just  six  weeks  to- 
gether. 

Sect.  5.  Sometimes,  but  not  always, together 
wnth  the  spectres,  there  looked  in  upon  the 
young  woman  (according  to  her  account)  a  short 
and  a  black  man,  whom  thcv  called  their  mas- 


Margaret  rule.  25 

ter — a  white,  exactly  of  the  same  dimensions 
and  complexion  and  voice,  with  the  devil  that 
has  exhibited  himself  unto  other  infested  peo- 
ple, not  only  in  other  parts  of  this  country,  but 
also  in  other  countries,  even  of  the  European 
world,  as  the  relation  of  the  enchantments  there 
informs  us.  They  all  profest  themselves  vassals 
of  this  devil,  and  in  obedience  unto  him  they  ad- 
dressed themselves  unto  various  ways  of  tortur- 
ing her.  Accordini^ly  she  was  cruelly  pinched 
with  invisible  hands,  very  often  in  a  day,  and 
the  black  and  blue  marks  of  the  pinches  became 
immediately  visible  unto  the  standers  by.  Be- 
sides this,  when  her  attendants  had  left  her 
without  so  much  as  one  pin  about  her,  that  so 
they  might  prevent  some  feared  inconveniences, 
yet  she  would  every  now  and  then  be  miserably 
hurt  with  pins,  which  were  found  stuck  into  her 
neck,  back  and  arms  ;  however,  the  wounds 
made  by  the  pins  would  in  a  few  minutes  ordi- 
narily be  cured ;  she  would  also  be  strangely  dis- 
torted in  her  joints,  and  thrown  into  such  exor- 
bitant convulsions  as  were  astonishing  unto  the 
spectators  in  general.  They  that  could  behold 
the  doleful  condition  of  the  poor  family  without 
sensible  compassions,  might  have  entrails  in- 
deed ;  but  I  am  sure  they  could  have  no  true 
bowels  in  them. 

Sect.  6.  It  were  a  most  unchristian  and  un- 
civil, yea,  a  most  unreasonable  thing,  to  imagine, 
that  the  fits  of  the  young  woman  were  but  mere 
impostures;  and  I  believe  scarce  any  but  peo- 
ple of  a  particular  dirtiness  will  harbour  such 
an  uncharitable  censure.  However,  because  I 
3 


2S  SUFFERINGS  OF 

know  not  how  far  the  devil  may  drive  the  ima- 
gination of  poor  creatures,  when  he  has  pos- 
session of  them,  that  at  another  time,  when  they 
are  themselves,  would  scorn  to  dissemble  any 
thing,  I  shall  now  confine  my  narrative  unto  pas- 
sages wherein  there  could  be  no  room  left  for 
any  dissimulation.  Of  these,  the  first  that  I'll 
mention  shall  be  this:  From  the  time  that 
Margaret  Rule  first  found  herself  to  be  formal- 
ly besieged  by  the  spectres,  until  the  ninth  day 
following,  namely,  from  the  lOth  of  September 
to  the  18th,  she  kept  an  entire  fast,  and  yet  she 
was  unto  all  appearance  as  fresh,  as  lively,  as 
hearty,  at  the  nine  days  end,  as  before  they  be- 
gan; in  all  this  time,  though  she  had  a  very  ea- 
ger hunger  upon  her  stomach,  yet,  if  any  re- 
freshment were  brought  unto  her,  her  teeth 
would  be  set,  and  she  would  be  thrown  into 
many  miseries ;  indeed  once  or  twice  or  so  in 
all  this  time,  her  tormentors  permitted  her  to 
swallow  a  mouthful  of  somewhat  that  might  in- 
crease her  miseries,  whereof  a  spoonful  of  rum 
was  the  most  considerable  ;  but  otherwise,  as  I 
said,  her  fast  unto  the  ninth  day  was  very  ex- 
treme and  rigid:  however,  afterwards  there 
scarce  passed  a  day  wherein  she  had  not  liberty 
to  take  something  or  other  for  her  sustentation. 
And  I  must  add  this,  further,  that  this  business 
of  her  fast  was  carried  so,  that  it  was  impossible 
to  be  dissembled  without  a  combination  of  mul- 
titudes of  people,  unacquainted  with  one  another, 
to  support  the  juggle ;  but  he  that  can  imagine 
such  a  thing  of  a  neighbourhood,  so  filled  with 
virtuous 43eople,  is  a  base  man — I  cannot  call  him 
any  other. 


MARGARET  RULE.  27 

Sect.  7.     But  if  tlie   sufferings  of  this  young 
woman  were  not  imposture,  yet  might  they  not 
be  pure  distemper  ?     1  will  not  here  inquire  of 
our  sadducoes,  what  sort  of  a  distemper  it  is,  that 
shall  stick  the   body  full  of  pins  without    any 
hand   that    could    be    seen   to    stick    them;  or 
whether  all  the  pin-makers  in  the  world  would 
be  willing  to  be  evaporated  into  certain  ill  hab- 
its of  body,  producing  a  distemper ;   but  of  the 
distemper   my  reader  shall  be  judge,   when    I 
have  told  him  something  further  of  those  unu- 
sual suiferings.     1  do  believe  that  the   evil   an- 
gels do  often  take  advantage,  from  natural  dis- 
tempers in  the  children  of  men,  to  annoy  them 
with  such  further  mischiefs,  as  we  call  preter- 
natural.    The  malignant  vapours  and  humours 
of  our  diseased  bodies  maybe  used  by  devils, 
thereinto  insinuating  as  engines  of  the  execution 
of  their  malice  upon  those  bodies;  and  perhaps, 
for  this   reason,  one  sex  may   suffer  more  trou- 
bles of  some  kinds  from  the  invisible  world  than 
the  other;  as  well  as  for  that  reason,  for  which 
the  old  serpent  made,  where  he  did,  his  first  ad- 
dress.    But  I  pray,  what  will  you  say   to  this  ? 
Margaret  Rule  would  sometimes  have  her  jaws 
forcibly  pulled  open,  whereupon  something  in- 
visible would  be   poured  down  her  throat;  we 
all  saw  her  swallow,  and  yet  we  saw  her  try  all 
she  could,  by  spitting,  coughing   and   shrieking, 
that  she  might  not  swallow  ;  but  one  time  the 
atanders-by  plainly  saw  something  of  that  odd  li- 
quor itself  on  the  outside  of  her  neck  :  she  cried 
out  of  it,  as  of  scalding   brimstone  poured  into 
her,  and  the  whole  house  would  immediately 


.28  SUFFERINGS  OF 

soent  so  hot  of  bxiiastone  that  we  were  scarce 
able  to  endure  it — whereof  there  are  scores  of 
witnesses  ;  but  the  young  woman  herself  would 
be  so  monstrously  inflamed,  that  it  would  have 
broke  a  heart  of  stone  to  have  seen  her  agonies. 
This  was  a  thing  that  several  times  happened; 
and  several  times,  when  her  mouth  was  thus 
pulled  open,  the  standers-by  clapping  their 
hands  close  thereupon,  the  distresses  that  other- 
wise followed  would  be  diverted.  Moreover 
there  was  a  whitish  powder,  to  us  invisible, 
sometimes  cast  upon  the  eyes  of  this  young  wo- 
man, whereby  her  eyes  would  be  extremely  in- 
commoded; but  one  time  some  of  this  powder 
was  fallen  actually  visible  upon  her  cheek,  from 
whence  the  people  in  the  room  wiped  it  with 
their  handkerchiefs;  and  sometimes  the  young 
woman  would  also  be  so  bitterly  scorched  with 
the  unseen  sulphur  thrown  upon  her,  that  very 
sensible  blisters  would  be  raised  upon  her  skin, 
whereto  her  friends  found  it  necessary  to  apply 
the  oils  proper  for  common  burnings;  but  the 
most  of  these  hurts  would  be  cured  in  two  or 
three  days  at  farthest.  I  think  I  may  without 
vanity  pretend  to  have  read  not  a  few  of  the 
best  systems  of  physick  that  have  been  yet  seen 
in  these  American  regions,  but  I  must  confess 
that  I  have  never  yet  learned  the  name  of  the 
natural  distemper  whereto  these  odd  symptoms 
do  belong:  however,  I  might  suggest  perhaps 
many  a  natural  medicine  which  would  be  of  sin- 
gular use  against  many  of  them. 

Sect.  8. "  But  there  fell  out  some  other  mat- 
ters far  beyond  the  reach  of  natural  distemper. 


ivfAKGARET  RULE.  29 

This  Margaret  Rule  once  in  the  middle  of  the 
night  laniciiled  sadly  that  the  spectres  threaten- 
ed the  drowning  of  a  young  man  in  the  neigh- 
bourhood, whom  she  named  unto  the  company: 
well,  it  was  afterwards  found  that  at  that  very- 
time  this  young  man,  liaving  been  prest  on  board 
a  man  of  war,  then  in  the  harbour,  was  out  of 
some  dissatisfaction  attempting  to  swim  ashore, 
and  he  had  been  drowned  in  the  attempt,  if  a 
bvMt  had  not  seasonably  taken  him  up;  it  was 
by  computation  a  minute  or  two  after  the  young 
woman's  discourse  of  the  drowning,  that  the 
young  man  took  the  water.  At  another  time 
siie  told  U-,  that  the  spectres  bragged  and  laugh- 
ed in  her  hearing  about  an  exploit  they  had  lately 
dane,  by  stealing  fiom  a  gentleman  his  will  soon 
after  he  had  written  it;  and  within  a  few  hours 
after  she  had  spoken  this,  there  came  to  me  a 
gentleman  with  a  private  complaint,  that  having 
written  his  will,  it  was  unaccountably  gone  out 
of  the  way ;  how,  or  where,  he  could  not  imagine : 
and  besides  all  this,  there  were  wonderful 
noises  every  no w^  and  then  made  about  the  room, 
which  our  people  could  ascribe  to  no  other  au- 
thors but  the  spectres  ;  yea,  the  watchers  affirm, 
that  they  heard  those  fiends  clapping  their  hands 
together  with  an  aucHbleness  wherein Tfi'ey  could 
not  be  imposed  upon;  and  once  her  tormentors 
pulled  her  up  <o  the  cielingoi' the  chamber,  and 
held  her  there,  before  a  very  numerous  company 
of  spectators,  who  found  it  as  much  as  they  could 
all  do  to  pull  her  down  again.  There  was  also 
another  very  surprising  circumstance  about  her. 
agreeable  to  what  we  have  not  only  read  m 
.3^ 


30  SUFFERINGS  OF 

several  histories  concerning  the  imps  that  have 
been  employed  in  witchcraft,  but  also  known  in 
some  of*  our  own  afflicted:  we  once  thought  we 
perceived  something  stir  upon  her  pillow  at  a 
little  distance  from  her;  whereupon  one  present 
laying  his  hand  there,  he  to  his  horror  appre- 
hended that  he  felt,  though  none  could  see  it,  a 
jiving  creature  not  altogether  unlike  a  rat,  which 
nimbly  escaped  from  him ;  and  there  were  di- 
vers other  persons  who  w^ere  thrown  into  a  great 
consternation  by  feeling,  as  they  judged,  at  other 
times,  the  same  invisible  animal. 

Sect.  9.  As  it  has  been  with  a  thousand 
other  enchanted  people,  so  it  was  w'ith  Margaret 
Rule  in  this  particular,  that  there  were  several 
words  which  her  tormentors  would  not  let  her 
hear,  especially  the  words  Pray  or  Prayer,  and 
jet  she  could  so  hear  the  letters  of  those  words 
distinctly  mentioned  as  to  know  what  the*y 
meant.  The  standers  by  were  forced  some- 
times thus  in  discourse  to  spell  a  word  to  her  ; 
but  because  there  were  some  so  ridiculous  as  to 
count  it  a  sort  of  spell  or  a  charm  for  any  thus 
to  accommodate  themselves  to  the  capacity  of 
the  sufferer,  little  of  this  kind  was  done.  But 
that  which  was  more  singular  in  this  matter 
was,  that  she  could  not  use  these  words  in  those 
penetrating  discourses  wherewith  she  would 
sometimes  address  the  spectres  that  were  about 
her.  She  would  sometimes  for  a  long  while  to- 
gether apply  herself  to  the  spectres,  whom  she 
supposedf  the  witches,  with  such  exhortations 
to  repentance  as  w^ould  have  melted  an  heart 
of  adamant  to  have  heard  them  ;  her  strains  of 


MARGARET  RULE.  31 

expression  and  argument  were  truly  extraordi- 
nary ;  persons  perhaps  ol'  the  best  education 
and  experience,  and  of  attainments  much  beyond 
hers,  could  not  have  exceeded  them  ;  neverthe- 
less, when  she  came  to  these  words,  God,  Lord, 
Christ,  Good,  ilepent,  and  some  other  such,  her 
mouth  could  not  utter  them;  whereupon  she 
would  sometimes,  in  an  angry  parenthesis,  com- 
plain of  their  wickedness  in  stopping  that  word, 
but  she  would  then  go  on  with  some  other  terms 
that  would  serve  to  tell  what  she  meant.  And 
I  believe  that  if  the  most  suspicious  person  in 
the  world  had  beheld  all  the  circumstances  of 
this  matter,  he  would  have  said  it  could  not 
have  been  dissembled. 

Sect.  10.  Not  only  in  the  Swedish,  but  also 
in  the  Salem  witchcraft,  the  enchanted  people 
have  talked  much  of  a  white  spirit,  from  whence 
they  received  marvelloxts  assistances  in  their  mi- 
series. What  lately  befel  Mercy  Short,  from 
the  communications  of  such  a  spirit,  hath  been 
the  just  wonder  of  us  all ;  but  by  such  a  spirit 
was  Margaret  Rule  now  also  visited.  She  says 
that  she  could  never  see  his  face  ;  but  that  she 
jiad  a  frequent  view  of  his  bright,  shining  and 
glorious  garments  ;  he  stood  by  her  bed-side 
continually,  heartening  and  comforting  her,  and 
counselling  her  to  maintain  her  faith  and  hope 
in  God,  and  never  comply  with  the  temptations 
of  her  adversaries.  She  says  he  told  her,  that 
God  had  permitted  her  afllictlons  to  befal  her 
for  the  everlasting  and  unspeakable  good  of  her 
own  soul,  and  for  the  good  of  many  others,  and 
for  his  own  hnmortal  glory ;  and  that  she  should 


32  SUFFERINGS  OF 

therefore  be  of  good  cheer,  and  be  assured  of  a 
speedy  deh'verance  ;  and  the  wonderful  resolu- 
tion of  mind  wherewith  she  encountered  her 
afflictions  was  but  agreeable  to  such  expecta- 
tions. Moreover,  a  minister  having  one  day  with 
some  importunity  prayed  for  the  deliverance 
of  this  young  woman,  and  pleaded  that  as  she 
belonged  to  his  flock  and  charge,  he  had  so  far 
a  right  unto  her  as  that  he  was  to  do  the  part 
of  a  minister  of  our  Lord  for  the  bringing  of  her 
home  unto  God,  only  now  the  devil  hindered 
him  in  doing  that  which  he  had  a  right  thus  to 
do;  and  whereas  he  had  a  better  title  unto 
her  to  bring  her  home  to  God,  than  the  devil 
could  have  unto  her  to  carry  her  away  from  the 
Lord,  he  therefore  humbly  apphed  himself  unto 
God,  who  alone  could  right  this  matter,  with  a 
suit  that  she  might  be  rescued  out  of  satan'S 
hands.  Immediately  upon  this,  though  she  heard 
nothing  of  this  transaction,  she  began  to  call 
that  minister  her  father,  and  that  was  the  name 
w^hereby  she  every  day  before  all  sorts  of  peo- 
ple distinguished  him.  The  occasion  of  it  she 
says  was  thjs  :  the  white  spirit  presently  upon 
this  transac'ion  did  after  this  manner  speak  to 
her:  Margaret,  you  now  are  to  take  notice  that 
sucli  a  man  is  your  father ;  God  has  given  you 
to  him;  do  you  from  this  time  look  upon  him 
as  your  father,  obey  him,  regard  him,  as  your 
father;  lollow  his  counsels,  and  you  shall  do 
well.  And  though  theie  was  one  passage  more, 
which  I  do  as  little  know  what  to  make. of  as 
any  of  the  rest,  I  am  now  going  to  relate  it: 
more  than  three  times  have  i  seen  it  fulfilled  in 


MARGARET  RULE.  36 

bleness  of  her  thoughts.  INevcrtheless  her  for- 
;ner  troubles  returned  not;  but  we  are  noAV 
Awaiting  to  see  the  good  eflects  of  those  troubles 
ipon  the  souls  of  all  concerned.  And  now  I 
thv>|)ose  that  some  of  our  learned  witlings  of  the 
tfiFee-house,  for  fear  lest  these  proofs  of  an  in- 
Jislble  world  sliould  spoil  some  of  their  sport, 
fci'ill  endeavour  to  turn  them  all  into  sport;  for 
tvhich  buffoonery  their  only  pretence  will  be, 
*'They  can't  understand  how  such  things  as 
these  could  be  done  ;'*  whereas  indeed  he  that 
is  but  philosopher  enough  to  have  read  but  one 
little  treatise,  published  in  the  year  1656,  by  no 
other  man  than  the  chirurgeon  of  an  army,  or 
but  one  chapter  of^HehnonL  which  I  will  not 
quote  at  this  time  too  particularly,  may  give  a 
far  more  intelligible  account  of  these  appearan- 
ces than  most  of  these  blades  can  give  why  and 
how  their  tobacco  makes  them  spit,  or  which 
way  the  flame  of  their  candle  becomes  illumi- 
nating. As  for  that  cavil,  "The  world  would 
be  uhdone  if  the  devils  could  have  such  power 
as  they  seem  to  have  in  several  of  our  stories," 
it  may  be  answered,  that  as  to  many  things,  the 
lying  devils  have  only  known  them  to  be  done, 
and  then  pretended  unto  the  doing  of  those 
things  ;  but  the  true  and  best  answer  is,  that  by 
these  things  we  only  see  what  the  devils  could 
have  power  to  do,  if  the  great  God  should  give 
them  that  power;  whereas  now  our  histories 
afford  a  glorious  evidence  for  the  being  of  a 
God.  The  world  would  indeed  be  undone,  and 
horribly  undone,  if  these  devils,  who  now  and 
then  get  liberty  to  play  some  very  mischievous 


36  SUFFERINGS  OP 

pranks,  were  not  under  a  daily  restraint  of  some 
Almighty  Suj)erior  from  doing  more  of  such 
mischiefs.  W  herefore,  instead  of  all  apish  shouts 
and  jeers  at  histories  which  have  such  undoubt- 
ed confirmation,  as  that  no  man  that  has  breed- 
ing enough  to  regard  the  common  laws  of  hu- 
man society,  will  offer  to  doubt  of  them,  it  be- 
comes us  rather  to  adore  the  goodness  of  God, 
who  does  not  permit  such  things  every  day  to 
befdl  us  all,  as  he  sometimes  did  permit  to  befal 
some  few  of  our  miserable  neighbours. 

Sect.  12.  And  why,  after  all  my  unwearied 
cares  and  pains  to  rescue  the  miserable  from 
the  lions  and  bears  of  hell,  which  had  seized 
them,  and  after  all  my  studies  to  disappoint  the 
devils  in  their  designs  to  confound  my  neigh- 
bourhood, must  I  be  driven  to  the  necessity  of 
an  apology?  Truly  the  hard  representations 
wherewith  some  ill  men  have  reviled  my  con- 
duct, and  the  countenance  which  other  men 
have  given  to  these  representations,  oblige  me 
to  give  mankind  some  account  of  my  behaviourr 
No  christian  can  (I  say  none  but  evil  workers 
can)  criminate  my  visiting  such  of  my  poor  flock 
as  have  at  any  time  fallen  under  the  terrible 
and  sensible  molestations  of  evil  angels  :  let 
their  afflictions  have  been  what  they  will,  I 
could  not  have  answered  it  unto  my  glorious 
Lord,  if  I  had  withheld  my  just  counsels  and 
comforts  from  them;  and  if  I  have  also  with 
some  exactness  observed  the  methods  of  the 
invisible  world,  when  they  have  thus  become 
observable,  I  have  been  but  a  servant  of  man- 
kind in  doing  so ;  yea^  no  less  a  person  than  the 


MARGARET  RULE.  37 

Venerable  Baxter  has  more  than  once  or  twice 
in  the  most  publick  manner  invited  mankind  to 
thank  me  for  that  service.  I  have  not  beeif  in- 
sensible of  a  greater  danger  attending  me  in  this 
fuliihnent  of  my  ministry,  than  if  I  had  been  to 
take  ten  thousand  steps  over  a  rocky  mountain 
iilled  with  rattle-snakes;  but  I  have  considered, 
he  that  is  wise  will  observe  things;  and  the  sur- 
prising explication  and  conlirmation  of  the  big- 
gest part  of  the  bible,  w^hich  I  have  seen  given 
in  these  things,  has  abundantly  paid  me  for  ob- 
serving them.  JNow,  in  my  visiting  of  the  mi- 
serable, I  v\as  always  of  this  opinion,  that  we 
were  ignorant  of  what  power  the  devils  miglit 
have  to  do  their  mischiefs  in  the  shapes  of  some 
that  had  never  been  explicitly  engaged  in  dia- 
bolical confederacies,  and  that  therefore,  though 
many  witchcrafts  had  been  ianly  detected  on 
inquiries  provoked  and  begun  by  spectral  exhi- 
bitions, yet  we  could  not  easily  be  too  jealous  of 
the  snares  laid  for  us  in  the  devices  of  Satan. 
The  world  knows  hov>^  many  pages  I  have  com- 
posed and  published,  and  particular  gentlemen 
in  the  government  know  how  many  letters  I 
have  written,  to  prevent  the  excessive  credit 
of  spectral  accusations;  wherefore  I  have  still 
charged  the  alHicted  that  they  should  cry  out 
of  nobody  for  afflicting  of  them;  but  that,  if  this 
might  be  any  advantage,  they  might  privately 
tell  their  minds  to  some  one  person  of  discretion 
enough  to  make  no  ill  use  ol  their  communica- 
tions; accordingly  there  has  been  this  elFect  of 
it,  that  the  name  of  no  one  good  person  in  the 
world  ever  came  under  any   blemish  by   mean$ 


as  ^OFFERINGS  OF 

of  an  afflicted  person  that  fell  under  my  particu- 
lar cognizance;  yea,  no  one  man,  woman  or 
child  ever  came  into  any  trouble  for  the  sake  of 
any  that  were  afflicted,  after  I  had  once  begun 
to  look  after  them.  How  often  have  I  had  this 
thrown  into  my  dish,  "that  many  years  ago  I 
had  an  opportunity  to  have  brought  forth  such 
people  as  have  in  the  late  storm  of  witchcraft 
been  complained  of,  but  that  I  smothered  all; 
and  after  that  storm  was  raised  at  Salem,  I  did 
myself  offer  to  provide  meat,  drink  and  lodging 
for  no  less  than  six  of  the  afflicted,  that  so  an 
experiment  might  be  made,  whether  prayer 
with  fasting,  upon  the  removal  of  the  distressed, 
might  not  put  a  period  to  the  trouble  then  ris- 
ing, without  giving  the  civil  authority  the  trou- 
ble of  prosecuting  those  things  which  nothing 
but  a  conscientious  regard  unto  the  cries  of  mi- 
serable families  could  have  overcome  the  reluc- 
tancies  of  the  honourable  judges  to  meddle 
with."  In  short,  I  do  humbly  but  freely  affirm 
it,  that  there  is  not  a  man  living  in  this  world 
who  has  been  more  desirous  than  the  poor  man 
I  to  shelter  my  neighbours  from  the  inconveni- 
ences of  spectral  outcries;  yea,  I  am  very  jea- 
Jous  I  have  done  so  much  that  way,  as  to  sin 
in  what  I  have  done  ;  such  have  been  the  cow- 
ardice and  fearfulness  whereunto  my  regard  un- 
to the  dissatisfaction  of  other  people  has  pre- 
cipitated me.  I  know  a  man  in  the  world, 
Tvho  has  thought  he  has  been  able  to  convict 
some  such  witches  as  ought  to  die;  but  his  re- 
spect unto  the  pubilck  peace  has  caused  him 
rather  to  trv  whether  he  could  not  renew  them 


MARGARET  RULE.  .        39 

by  repentance  ;  and  as  I  have  been  studious  to 
defeat  the  devils  of  their  expectations  to  set 
people  together  by  the  ears  thus,  I  have  also 
checked  and  quelled  those  forbidden  curiosities 
Avhich  would  have  given  the  devil  an  invitation 
to  have  tarried  amongst  us,  when  I  have  seen 
wonderful  snares  laid  ibr  curious  people,  by  the 
secret  and  future  things  discovered  from  the 
mouths  of  damsels  possest  with  a  spirit  of  divi- 
nation. Indeed  I  can  recollect  but  one  thing 
wherein  there  could  be  given  so  much  as  a  sha- 
dow of  reason  for  exceptions,  and  that  is,  my 
allowing  of  so  many  to  come  and  see  those  that 
were  afflicted.  Now  for  that  I  have  this  to  say, 
that  I  have  almost  a  thousand  times  entreated 
the  friends  of  the  miserable,  that  they  would 
not  permit  the  intrusion  of  any  company,  but 
such  as  by  prayers  or  other  ways  might  be  help- 
ful to  them  ;  nevertheless  I  have  not  absolutely 
forbid  all  company  from  coming  to  your  haunted 
chambers ;  partly  because  the  calamities  of  the 
families  were  such  as  required  the  assistance  of 
many  friends ;  partly  because  I  have  been  wil- 
ling that  there  should  be  disinterested  witnesses 
of  all  sorts,  to  confute  the  calumnies  of  such  as 
would  say  all  was  but  imposture ;  and  partly 
because  I  saw  God  had  sanctified  the  spectacle 
of  the  miseries  on  the  afflicted  unto  the  souls  of 
many  that  were  spectators;  and  it  is  a  very  glo- 
rious thing  that  1  have  now  to  mention :  The 
devils  have  with  most  horrid  operations  broke 
in  upon  our  neighbourhood,  and  God  has  at  such 
a  rate  overruled  all  the  fury  and  malice  of  those 
devils,  that  all  the  afflicted  have  not  only  heeu 


4.0  SUFFERINGS  OF 

delivered,  but  1  hope  also  savingly  brought  home 
unto  God,  and  the  reputation  of  no  one  good  per- 
son in  the  world  has  been  damaged;  but  instead 
thereof  the  souls  of  many,  especially  of  the  ris- 
ing generation,  have  been  thereby  awakened  un- 
to some  acquaintance  with  religion;  our  young 
people,  who  belonged  unto  the  praying  meetings, 
of  both  sexes,  apart,  w^ould  ordinarily  spend 
whole  nights  by  whole  weeks  together  in  prayers 
and  psalms  upon  these  occasions,  in  which  de- 
votions the  devils  could  get  nothing,  but,  like 
fools,  a  scourge  for  their  own  backs;  and  some 
scores  of  other  young  people,  who  were  straa- 
gers  to  real  piety,  were  now  struck  with  the 
lively  demonstrations  of  hell  evidently  set  forth 
before  their  eyes,  when  they  saw  persons  cruel- 
ly frighted,  wounded  and  starved  by  devils,  and 
scalded  with  burning  brimstone ;  and  yet  so  pre- 
served in  this  tortured  state,  as  that,  at  the  end 
of  one  month's  wretchedness,  they  were  as  able 
still  to  undergo  another ;  so  that  of  these  also  it 
might  now  be  said,  "  Behold  they  pray."  In  the 
^hole — the  devil  got  just  nothing — but  God  got 
praises,  Christ  got  subjects,  the  Holy  Spirit  got 
temples,  the  church  got  addition,  and  the  souls 
of  men  got  everlasting  benefits.  I  am  not  so 
vain  as  to  say  that  any  wisdom  or  virtue  of  mine 
did  contribute  unto  this  good  order  of  things; 
but  I  am  so  just  as  to  say,  I  did  not  hinder  this 
good.  When  therefore  there  have  been  those 
that  picked  up  little  incoherent  scraps  and  bits 
of  my  discourses  in  this  fruitful  discharge  of  my 
ministry,  and  so  travestied  them  in  their  abusive 
pamphlets  as  to  persuade  the  town  that  I  was 


MARGARET  RULE.  41 

their  common  enemy  in  those  very  points,  where- 
in, if  in  any  one  thing  whatsoever,  I  have  sen- 
sibly approved  myselT  as  true  a  servant  unto 
them  as  possibly  I  could,  though  my  life  and  soul 
had  been  at  stake  for  it — yea  to  do  like  satan 
himself,  by  sly,  base,  unpretending  insinuations, 
as  if  I  wore  not  the  modesty  and  gravity  which 
became  a  minister  of  the  gospel — I  could  not 
but  think  myself  unkindly  dealt  withal,  and  the 
neglect  of  others  to  do  me  justice  in  this  affair 
has  caused  me  to  conclude  this  narrative  with 
complaints  in  another  hearing  of  such  monstroue 
injuries. 

4# 


0:5^  The  dates  of  the  letters  beginning  on  pages  56,  62  and  HI 
should  have  been  printed  1693  (mstead  of  1694)  conformably  to  the 
practice  at  that  time  beginning  the  yeai  on  the  25;h  of  March,  and 
^0  the  dates  of  other  letters  in  the  book. 


PART  n. 
SEVERAL  LETTERS,  &c. 

Boston^  Jan*  11,  1693. 
Mr.  Cotton  Mather, 
Reverend  Sir, 

Finding  it  needful  on  many  accounts,  I 
here  present  you  with  the  copy  of  that  paper 
which  has  been  se  much  misrepresented,  to  the 
end  that  what  shall  be  found  defective  or  not 
fairly  represented  (if  any  such  shall  appear) 
they  may  be  set  right, — which  runs  thus : 

September  the  Vdth,  1693.  In  the  evening, 
when  the  sun  was  withdrawn,  giving  place  to 
darkness  to  succeed,  I  with  some  others  w^ere 
drawn  by  curiosity  to  see  Margaret  Rule,  and 
so  much  the  rather,  because  it  was  reported 

Mr.  M would  be  there  that  night.     Being 

come  to  her  father's  house,  into  the  chamber 
wherein  she  was  in  bed,  I  found  her  of  a  heal- 
thy countenance,  of  about  seventeen  years  old, 
lying  very  still,  and  speaking  very  little ;  what 
she  did  say  seemed  asaf  she  were  light-headed. 

Then  Mr.  M (father  and  son)  came    up, 

and  othere  with  them  5  in  the  w^hole  there  wcrp: 


44  LETTERS  T© 

about  thirty  or  forty  persons;  they  being  set, 
the  father  on  a  stool,  and  the  son  upon  the  bed- 
side by  her,  the  son  began  to  question  her : 

Margaret  Rule,  how  do  you  do  ?  then  a  pause 
without  any  answer. 

Question^  What!  do  there  a  great  many 
witches  sit  upon  you?    Answer,  Yes. 

Question,  Do  you  not  know  that  there  is  a 
hard  master?  Then  she  was  in  a  fit.  He  laid 
his  hand  upon  her  face  and  nose,  but  as  he  said 
without  perceiving  breath;  then  he  brushed 
her  on  the  face  with  his  glove,  and  rubbed  her 
stomach  (her  breast  not  being  covered  with  the 
bed-clothes)  and  bid  others  do  so  too,  and  said 
it  eased  her — then  she  revived. 

Q.  Don't  you  know  there  is  a  hard  master? 
J,  Yes. 

Reply,  Don't  serve  that  hard  master — ^you 
know  who. 

Q.  Do  you  believe  ?  Then  again  she  was 
in  a  fit,  and  he  again  rubbed  her  breast,  &c. 

About  this  time,  Margaret  Perd,  an  attend- 
ant, assisted  him  in  rubbing  her.  The  afflicted 
spake  angrily  to  her,  saying,  Don't  you  meddle 
with  me— and  hastily  put  away  her  hand.  He 
then  wrought  his  fingers  before  her  eyes,  and 
asked  her  if  she  saw  the  witches?     A.  No. 

Q.  Do  you  believe?     J3,  Yes. 

Q.  Do  vou  believe  in  you  know  who  ? — 
J.   Yes. 

Q.  Would  you  have  other  people  do  so  too-— 
to  believe  in  you  know  who?     .y^.     Yes. 

Q.  Who  is  it  that  afflicts  you?  A.  1  know 
not,  there  is  a  great  many  of  them. 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  4& 

'About  this  time  the  father  questioned,  if  she 
knew  the  spectres.  An  attendant  said,  if  she 
did  she  would  not  tell.     The  son  proceeded : 

Q.  You  have  seen  the  black  man,  have  you 
not?     J,  No. 

Reply^  I  hope  you  never  will. 

Q.  You  have  had  a  book  offered  you,  have 
you  not?     Ji,  No. 

Q.  The  brushing  of  you  gives  you  ease, 
don't  it  ?  A.  Yes.  She  turned  herself,  and 
a  little  groaned. 

Q.  Now  the  witches  scratch  you,  and  pinch 
you,  and  bite  you,  don't  they  ?     A.  Yes. 

Then  he  put  his  hand  upon  her  breast  and 
belly,  viz.  on  the  clothes  over  her,  and  felt  a. 
living  thing,  as  he  said ;  which  moved  the  fa- 
ther also  to  feel,  and  some  others. 

Q.  Don't  you  feel  the  live  thing  in  the  bed  ? 
A,  No. 

Reply ^  That  is  only  fancy. 

Q.  The  great  company  of  people  increase 
your  torment,  don't  they  ?     A,  Yes. 

The  people  about  were  desired  to  withdraw. 
One  woman  said,  I  am  sure  1  am  no  witch,  I 
will  not  go;  so  others  ;  so  none  withdrew. 

Q.  Shall  we  go  to  prayers?  Then  she  lay. 
in  a  fit  as  before.  But  this  time,  tg,  revive  her, 
they  waved  a  hat,  and  brushed  her  head  and 
pillow  therewith. 

"   Q.  Shall  we  go  to  prayer,  &c.  spelling  the 
word.     A,  Yes. 

The  father  went  to  prayer  for  perhaps  half 
an  hour,  chiefly  against  the  power  of  the  devil 
aud  witchcraft,  and  that  God  would  bring  out 


46  LETTERS  TO 

the  aSflicters.  Durmg  prayer-time,  the  son 
stood  by,  and  when  they  thought  she  was  in  a 
fit,  rubbed  her  and  brushed  her  as  before,  and 
beckoned  to  otb^ers  to  do  the  hke.  Alter  prayer 
he  proceeded: 

Q.  You  did  not  hear  when  we  were  at  prayer, 
did  you?     Jl.  Yes. 

Q.  You  don't  hear  always — you  did  not  hear 
for  some  time  past,  a  word  or  two,  did  you  ? 
Jl.  No. 

Then   turning   him   about,  said,   this    is   just 
another  Mercy  Short.     Margaret  Perd  rephed, 
she  was  not  hke  her  in  her  fits. 
Q.     What    does  she    eat   or   drink?     Jl,  She 
does  not  eat  at  all,  but  drinks  rum. 

Then  he  admonished  the  young  people  to 
take  warning,  ^Vc.  saying  it  was  a  sad  thing  to 
be  so  tormented  by  the  devil  and  his  instru- 
ments. A  young  man  present,  in  the  habit  of  a 
seaman,  replied,  "  This  is  the  Devil  all  over^ 
Then  the  ministers  withdrew.  Soon  after  they 
were  gone  the  afflicted  desired  ths  women  to  be 
gone,  saying,  that  the  company  of  the  men  wag 
not  offensive  to  her;  and  having  hold  of  the 
hand  of  a  young  man,  said  to  have  been  her 
sweetheart  formerly,  who  was  withdrawing,  she 
pulled  him  again  into  his  seat,  saying,  he  should 
not  go  to  night. 

September  the  \9th,  1693.  This  night  1  renew- 
ed my  visit,  and  found  her  rather  of  a  fresher 
countenance  than  before.  About  eight  personjr 
were  present  with  her.  She  was  in  a  fit,  scream- 
ing and  making  a  noise.  Three  or  four  per- 
sons rubbed  and  brushed  her_with  their  hands  : 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  4  7 

they  said  that  the  brushing  did  put  them  away, 
If  niey  brushed  or  rubbed  in  tlie  right  place; 
therefore  they  brushed  and  rubbed  in  several 
places,  and  said  that  when  they  did  it  in  the 
right  place  she  could  fetch  her  breath,  and  by 
that  they  knew.  She  being  come  to  herself 
was  soon  in  a  merry  talking  fit.  A  young  man 
came  in,  and  asked  her  how  she  did.  She  an- 
swered, very  bad,  but  at  present  a  little  better. 
He  soon  told  her  he  must  be  gone,  and  bid 
her  good  night;  at  which  she  seemed  troubled, 
saying  that  she  liked  his  company,  and  said  she 
would  not  have  him  go  till  she  was  well;  add- 
ing, for  I  shall  die  when  you  are  gone.  Then 
she  complained  they  did  not  put  lier  on  a  clean 
ca[>,  but  let  her  lie  so  like  a  beast,  saying  she 
should  lose  all  her  fellows.  She  said  she  won- 
dered any  people  should  be  so  wicked  as  to 
think  she  was  not  afflicted,  but  to  think  she  dis- 
sembled. A  young  woman  answered,  Yes,  if 
they  were  to  see  you  in  this  merry  fit,  they 
would  say  you  dissembled  indeed.     She  replied, 

Mr.  M said  this  was  her  laus^hingtime,  she 

must  laugh  now.    She  said  Mr.  M had  been 

there  this  evening,  and  she  enquired  how  long 
he  had  been  gone.  She  said  he  stayed  alone 
with  her  in  the  room  hali'  an  hour,  and  said  that 
he  told  her  there  were  some  that  came  for 
spies,  and  to  report  about  town  that  she  was 
not  afflicted ;  that  during  the  said  time  she  had 
no  fit;  that  he  asked  her  it'  she  knew  how  ma- 
ny times  he  had  prayed  for  her  to  day;  and 
tiiat  she  answered,  that  she  could  not  tell ;  and 
tlidt  he  replied,  he  had   prayed  for   her   nine 


48  LETTERS  TG 

times  to  day,  The  attendants  said  that  she 
was  sometimes  in  a  f\t^  that  none  could  open  her 
joints,  and  that  there  came  an  old  iron-jawed 
woman  and  tried,  but  could  not  do  it;  they 
likewise  said,  that  her  head  could  not  be  moved 
from  the  pillow.  I  tried  to  move  her  head,  and 
found  no  more  difficulty  than  another  person 
(and  so  did  others)  but  was  not  willing  to  offend 
by  lifting  it  up,  once  being  reproved  for  endea- 
vouring it ;  they   saying  angrily,  you  will  break 

her   neck.     Tlie  attendants    said    Mr.   M 

would  not  go  to  prayer  with  her  when  people 
were  in  the  room,  as  they  did  one  night — that 
night  he  felt  the  live  creature.  Margaret  Perd 
and  another  said  they  smelt  brimstone.  I  and 
others  said  we  did  not  smell  any  ;  then  they  said 
they  did  not  know  what  it  was.  This  Marga- 
ret said  she   wished  she   had  been  here  when 

Mr.  M was  here.    Another  attendant  said, 

If  you  had  been  here,  you  might  not  have  been 
permitted  in,  for  her  own  mother  was  not  suf- 
fered to  be  present. 

Sir,  alter  the  sorest  affliction  and  greatest 
blemish  to  religion  that  ever  belei  this  country, 
and  after  most  men  began  to  fear  that  some  un- 
due steps  had  been  taken,  and  alter  his  excel- 
lency (with  their  Majesties'  approbation  as  is 
said)  had  put  a  stop  to  executions,  and  men  be- 
gan to  hope  there  would  never  be  a  return  of 
the  like;  finding  these  accounts  to  contain  in 
them  something  extraordinary,  I  writ  them  down 
the  same  nights,  in  order  to  attain  the  certainty 
of  them,  and  soon  found  them  so  confirmed  that 
I  have  (besides  other  demonstrations)  the  whole 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  ..^ 

under  the  hands  of  two  persons  who  arc  ready 
to  attest  the  truth  of  it;  but  not  satisfied  here- 
with, I  shewed  them  to  some  of  your  particular 
friends,  that  so  I  might  have  the  greater  cer- 
tainty; but  was  much  surprised  with  the  mes- 
sage you  sent  me,  that  I  should  be  arrested  for 
slander,  and  at  your  calhng  me  one  of  the  worst 
oi' liars,  making  it  pulpit  news,  with  the  name 
of  pernicious  libels,  &c.  This  occasioned  my 
first  letter:  [as  followeth.] 

September  tJu  29th,  1693. 
Revermd  Sir, 

1  having  written  from  the  mouths  of  several 
persons,  who  affirm  they  were  present  with 
Margaret  Rule  the  13th  instant,  her  answers 
and  behaviour,  &c.  and  having  shewed  it  to 
several  of  my  friends,  as  also  yours,  and  under- 
standing you  are  offended  at  it,  this  is  to  acquaint 
you  that  ilyou  and  any  one  particular  friend  will 
please  to  meet  me  and  some  other  indilierent 
person  with  me  at  M?'.  Wilkins's,  or  at  Benj. 
Harris's,  you  Intimatiiig  the  time,  I  shall  be  rea- 
dy there  to  read  it  to  you,  as  also  a  further  ac- 
count of  j)roccedings  the  J 9th  instant,  which 
may  be  needful  to  j.revent  groundless  prejudi- 
ces, and  let  deserved  blame  be  cast  wliere  it 
ought.     From,  sir,  yuurs,  in  what  I  mav, 

k.  c. 

The  effects  of  which,  sir,  (not  to  mention 
that  long  letter  only  once  rend  to  mc)  uas,  you 
sent  me  word  you  would  meet  me  at  Mr.  Wil- 
Icins's;  but,   before   (hat  answer,  at  yuurs  and 


J  LETTERS  TO 

your  father's  complaint,  1  was  brought  before 
their  majesties'  justice,  by  warrant,  for  scanda- 
lous hbels  against  yourself,  and  was  bound  over 
to  answ^er  at  sessions.  I  do  not  remember  you 
then  objected  against  the  truth  of  what  I  had 
wrote,  but  asserted  it  was  wronged  by  omis- 
sions ;  which,  it"  it  were  so,  was  past  any  power  of 
mine  to  remedy,  having  given  a  faithful  account 
of  all  that  came  to  my  knowledge :  and,  sir,  that 
vou  might  not  be  without  some  cognizance  of 
of  the  reasons  why  I  took  so  much  pains  in  it, 
as  also  for  my  own  information,  (if  it  might  have 
been)  I  wrote  to  you  my  second  letter  to  this 
eifect : 

JVovemher  the  24th,  1693. 
Reverend  Sir, 

Having  expected  some  weeks  your  meeting 
me  at  Mr.  Wilkins's,  according  to  what  you  in- 
timated to  me,  and  the  time  drawing  near  for 
our  meeting  elsewhere,  I  thought  it  not  amiss 
to  give  you  a  summary  of  my  tlioughts  in  the 
great  concern,  which,  as  you  say,  has  been  agi- 
tated with  so  much  heat.  That  there  are 
witches  is  not  the  doubt ;  the  scriptures  else 
were  vain,  which  assign  their  punishment  to 
be  by  death;  but  what  this  witchcraft  is,  or 
wherein  it  does  consist,  seems  to  be  the 
whole  difficulty:  and  as  it  may  be  easily  demon- 
strated, that  all  that  bear  that  name  cannot  be 
justly  so  accounted ;  so  that  some  things  and 
actions,  not  so  esteemed  by  the  most,  yet  upon 
due  examination  w^ill  be  found  to  merit  no  bet- 
ter character. 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  i)l 

In  your  late  book  you  lay  down  a  brief  sy- 
nopsis ol'  what  has  been  written  on  that  subject, 
by  a  triumvirate  of  as  eminent  men  as  ever 
handled  it  (as  you  are  pleased  to  call  them)  viz. 
Mr.  Perkins,  Gaule  and  Bernard,  consisting  of 
about  thirty  tokens  to  know  them  by,  many  of 
them  distinct  from,  if  not  thwarting,  each  other: 
among  all  of  which  I  can  find  but  one  decisive, 
viz.  tliat  of  Mr.  Gaule,  head  iv,  and  runs  thus  : 
''  Among  the  most  unhappy  circumstances  to 
convict  a  witch,  one  is  a  maligning  and  oppugning 
the  word,  work  or  worship  of  God,  and  by  any 
extraordinary  sign  seeking  to  seduce  any  from  it. 
See  Deut.  xiii.  1.  2.  Matt.  xxiv.  24.  Acts  xiii. 
8,  10.  2  Tim.  iii.  8.  Do  but  mark  well  the 
places ;  and  lor  this  very  property,  of  thus  op 
posing  and  perverting,  they  are  all  there  con- 
cluded arrant  and  absolute  witches." 

This  head,  as  here  laid  down  and  inserted  by 
you,  either  is  a  truth  or  not;  if  not,  why  is  it 
here  inserted  from  one  of  the  triumvirate?  If 
it  be  a  truth,  as  the  scriptures  quoted  will  abun- 
dantly testify,  whence  is  it  that  it  is  so  little  re- 
garded, though  it  be  the  only  head  well  proved  by 
scripture,or  that  the  rest  of  the  triumvirate  should 
so  far  forget  their  work  as  not  to  mention  it  ?  It 
were  to  be  unjust  to  the  memory  of  those  other- 
wise wise  men,  to  suppose  them  to  have  any  si- 
nister design;  but  perhaps  the  force  of  a  pre- 
vailing opinion,  together  with  an  education  there- 
to suited,  might  overshadow  their  judgments,  as 
being  wont  to  be  but  too  prevalent  in  many  other 
cases.  But  if  the  above  be  truth,  then  the  scrip- 
ture is  full  and  plain,  what  is  witchcraft.     And 


52  LETTERS  TO 

if  so,  what  need  of  his  next  head  of  hanging  peo- 
ple without  as  full  and  clear  evidence  as  in  oth- 
ler  cases?  Or  what  need  of  the  rest  of  the  re- 
ceipts of  the  triumvirate  ?  What  need  of  pray- 
ing that  the  afflicted  may  be  able  to  discover  who 
it  is  that  afflicts  them  ?  or  what  need  of  search- 
ing for  teats  for  the  devil  to  suck,  in  his  old  age  5 
©r  the  experiment  of  saying  the  Lord's  prayer, 
&:c.  with  a  multitude  more,  practised  in  some 
places  superstitiously  inclined?  Other  actions 
have  been  practised  for  easing  the  afflicted,  less 
justifiable,  if  not  strongly  savouring  of  witch- 
craft itself,  viz.  fondly  imagining  by  the  hand,  &c. 
io  drive  off  spectres,  or  to  knock  off  invisible 
chains,  or  by  striking  in  the  air  to  wound  either 
the  afflicted  or  others,  &c.  I  write  not  this  to 
accuse  any,  but  that  all  may  beware ;  believing 
that  the  devil's  bounds  are  set,  which  he  can- 
not pass;  that  devils  are  so  full  of  malice,  that 
it  cannot  be  added  to  by  mankind ;  that  where 
he  hath  power  he  neither  can  nor  wnll  omit  ex- 
ecuting it;  that  it  is  only  the  Almighty  that  sets 
bounds  to  his  rage,  and  that  only  can  coramis- 
sionate  him  to  hurt  or  destroy  any. 

These  last,  sir,  are  such  foundations  of  truth, 
in  my  esteem,  that  I  cannot  but  own  it  to  be 
my  duty  to  assert  them,  when  called,  though 
with  the  hazard  of  my  all ;  and  consequently  to 
detest  such  as  these,  that  a  witch  can  commis- 
sionate  devils  to  afflict  mortals  ;  that  he  can,  at 
his  or  the  witch's  pleasure,  assume  any  shape  ; 
that  hanging  or  drowning  of  witches  can  lessen 
his  power  of  afflicting,  or  restore  those  that 
were  at  a  distance  tormented,  with  many  others 


MR.  MATHER,  isic.  53 

depending  on  these  ;  all  tending,  in  my  esteem, 
highly  to  the  dishonour  of  God,  and  the  endan- 
gering the  well-being  of  a  people  ;  and  do  fur- 
ther add,  that  as  the  scriptures  are  full  that 
there  is  witchcraft  (ut  sup.)  so  'tis  as  plain  that 
there  are  possessions,  and  that  the  bodies  of  the 
possest  have  hence  been  not  only  afflicted,  but 
strangely  agitated,  if  not  their  tongues  improved 
to  foretel  futurities,  &c.  and  why  not  to  accuse 
the  innocent,  as  bewitciiing  them?  having  pre- 
tence to  divination  to  gain  credence.  This  be- 
ing reasonable  to  be  expected  from  him  who  is 
the  father  of  lies,  to  the  end  he  may  thereby 
involve  a  country  in  blood,  malice  and  evil-sur- 
mising, which  he  greedily  seeks  after,  and  so 
finally  lead  them  from  their  fear  and  depen- 
dence upon  God,  to  fear  him  and  a  supposed 
witch,  thereby  attaining  his  end  upon  mankind; 
and  not  only  so,  but  natural  distempers,  as  has 
been  frequently  observed  by  the  judicious,  have 
so  operated  as  to  deceive  more  than  the  vulgar, 
as  is  testified  by  many  famous  physicians  and 
others.  And  as  for  that  proof  of  multitudes  of 
confessions,  this  country  may  be  by  this  time 
thought  competent  judges  wliat  credence  we 
ouofht  to  orive  them,  having^  had  such  numerous 
instances,  as  also  how  obtained. 

And  now,  sir,  if  herein  be  any  thing  in  your 
esteem  valuable,  let  me  entreat  you  not  to  ac- 
count it  the  worse  for  coming  from  so  mean  a 
hand;  which,  however  you  may  have  received 
prejudice,  &c.  am  ready  to  serve  you  to  my 
power;   but  if  you  judge  otherwise  hereof,  you 


6-4  LETTERS  TO 

may  take  your  own  methods  for  my  better  irn 
formation.  Who  am,  sir,  yours  to  command,  in 
what  I  may,  R.  C. 

In  answer  to  this  last,  sir,  you  replied  to  the 
gentleman  that   presented   it,  that  you  had  no- 
thino-  to  prosecute  against  me  ;  and  said,  as  to 
your  sentiments  in  your  books,  you  did  not  bind 
any  to  believe  them;  and  then  again  renewed 
your   promise  of  meeting  me,  as  before,  though 
not  yet  performed.     Accordingly,  though  I  wait- 
ed at  sessions,  there  was  none  to  object  ought 
against  me,  upon  which  I  was  dismissed.     This 
gave  me  some  reason  to  beheve  that  you  intend- 
ed all  should  have  been  forgotten ;    but,  instead 
of  that,   I  find    the  coals  are  fresh  blown  up,  I 
being  supposed  to  be  represented,  in  a  late  manu- 
script. More  Wonders  of  the,  &c.  as   travestying 
your    discourse    in   your    faithful    discharge    of 
Your  duty,  &c.  and  such  as  see  not  with  the  au- 
thor's eyes,  rendered  sadducees  and  widings,  &c. 
and   the   arguments   that  square   not    with   the 
sentiments  therein  contained,  buffoonery  ;  rarely, 
no  doubt,  agreeing  with  the  spirit  of  Christ,  and 
his  dealings  with  an  unbelieving  Thomas,  yet 
wliose  infidelity  was  without  compare  less  excus- 
able ;  but  the  author  having  resolved  long  since 
to  have  no  more  than  one  single  grain  of  patience 
with  them  that  deny,  &e.  the  wonder  is  the  less. 
It  must  needs  be  that  offences  come,  but  wo  to  him 
by  whom  they  come.  To  vindicate  myself  there- 
fore from  such  false  imputations,  of  satan-likc 
insinuations,  and    misrepresenting  your   action?^ 


MR.  MATilKR,  kc. 

&CC,  and  to  vlnilicate  yourself,  sir,  as  much  as  is 
in  my  power,  t'roiii  those  suo^i»esti()ns,  said  to  be 
insinuated,  as  it"  you  wore  not  the  modesty  and 
gravity  that  becomes  a  minister  of  the  gospel  ; 
which,  it  seems,  some,  that  never  saw  tfie  said 
narratives,  report  tliem  to  contain  ;  I  say,  sir, 
for  these  reasons,  I  here  present  you  with  the 
first  copy  that  ever  was  taken,  &c.  and  purpose 
for  a  week's  time  to  be  ready,  if  you  shall  inti- 
mate your  pleasure  to  wait  upon  me,  either  at 
the  place  formerly  appointed,  or  any  other  that 
is  inditi'ercnt ;  to  the  end  that,  if  there  shall  a|> 
pear  any  defects  in  tiiat  narrative,  they  may  be 
amended. 

Thus,  sir,  I  liave  given  you  a  genuine  account 
of  my  sentiments  and  actions  in  this  affair ;  and 
do  request  and  pray,  that  if  I  err,  I  may.be 
shewed  it  from  scrij>ture,  or  sound  reason,  and 
not  by  quotations  out  of  Virgil,  nor  Spanish  rhe- 
torick.  For  I  find  the  withngs  mentioned  are 
so  far  from  answering  your  profound  questions, 
that  they  cannot  so  much  as  pretend  to  shew  a 
distinction  between  witchcraft  in  the  common 
notion  of  it,  and  possession  ;  nor  so  much  as  to 
demonstrate  that  ever  the  jews  or  primitive 
christians  did  believe  that  a  witch  could  send  a 
devil  to  afflict  her  neighbours.  But  to  all  these, 
sir,  (ye  being  the  salt  of  the  earth,  «kc.)  I  have 
reason  to  hope  for  a  satisfactory  answer  to  him, 
who  is  one  tliat  reverences  your  person  and  of- 
fice ;  and  am,  sir,  yours  to  command,  in  what 
I  may,  R.  C. 


56  LETTERS  TO 

Boston^  Jan,  the  15th,  1694 
Mr,  R  a 

Whereas  you  intimate  your  desires,  that 
what  is  not  fairly  (I  take  it  for  granted  you 
mean  truly  also)  represented  in  a  paper  you 
lately  sent  me,  containing  a  pretended  narrative 
of  a  visit  by  my  father  and  self  to  an  afflicted 
young  woman,  whom  we  apprehended  to  be  un- 
der a  diabohcal  possession,  might  be  rectified  ;  I 
have  this  to  say,  as  I  have  often  ah^eady  said, 
that  1  do  scarcely  find  any  one  thing  in  the 
whole  paper,  whether  respecting  ray  father  or 
self,  either  fairly  or  truly  represented:  Nor  can 
i  think  that  any,  that  know  my  parent's  circum- 
stances, but  must  think  him  deserving  a  better- 
character  by  far,  than  this  narrative  can  be 
thought  to  give  him.  When  the  main  design 
we  managed,  in  visiting  the  poor  afflicted  crea- 
ture, was  to  prevent  the  accusations  of  the 
neighbourhood,  can  it  be  fairly  represented  that 
our  design  was  to  draw  out  such  accusations  ? 
which  is  the  representation  of  the  paper.  We 
have  testimonies  of  the  best  witnesses,  and  in 
number  not  a  few,  that  when  we  asked  Rule 
whether  she  thought  she  knew  who  tormented 
her,  the  question  was  but  an  introductionJo  the 
solemn  charges  which  w^e  then  largely  gave, 
that  she  should  rather  die  than  tell  the  names 
of  any  whom  she  might  imagine  that  she  knew, 
your  informers  have  reported  the  question,  and 
report  nothing  of  what  follows,  as  essential  to 
the  giving  of  that  question.  And  can  this  be 
termed  a  piece  of  fairness  ?  Fair  it  cannot  be, 
that  when  ministers  faithfully  and  carefully  diii- 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  67 

charge  their   duty    to  the  miserable    in    tlieir 
flock,  httle  bits,  scraps  and  shreds  of  their  dis- 
courses should  be  tacked  together  to  make  them 
contemptible,  when  there  shall  be  no  notice  of 
all    the    necessary,    seasonable    and     profitable 
things   that  occurred  in  those  discourses ;  and 
without  which,  the  occasion  of  the  lesser  passa- 
ges cannot  be  understood  :  and  yet  I  am  furnish- 
ed with  abundant  evidences,  ready  to  be  sworn, 
that  will  positively  prove  this  part  of  unfairness, 
by  the  above  mentioned  narrative,  to  be  done 
both  to  my  father  and  self.    Again,  it  seems  not 
fair  or  reasonable  that  I  should  be  exposed  for 
that  which  yourself  (not  to   say  some   others) 
might   have  exposed  me  for  if  I  had  not  done, 
viz.  for  discouraging  so   much  company    from 
flocking  about  the  possest  maid;  and  yet,  as  I 
persuade  myself,  you  cannot  but  think  it  to  be 
good  advice  to  keep  much  company  from  such 
haunted  chambers.    Besides,  the  unfairness  doth 
more  appear,  in  that  I  find  nothing  re])catcd  of 
what    I  said  about  the    advantage    which  the 
devil  takes  from  too  much  observation  and  cu- 
riosity. 

In  that  several  of  the  questions  in  the  paper 
are  so  worded  as  to  carry  in  them  a  presuppo- 
sal  of  the  things  Inquired  after,  to  say  tiic  best 
of  it,  is  very  unfair.  But  this  is  not  all;  the 
narrative  contains  a  number  of  mistakes  and 
falsehoods,  which,  were  they  wilful  and  design- 
ed, might  justly  be  termed  gross  lies.  The  re- 
presentations are  far  from  true,,  when  'tis  af- 
firmed my  father  and  self  beln<i^  come  into  the 
room,  I  began  tiie  discourse  :  I  hope  I  under^ 


58  LETTERS  TO 

«tand  breeaing  a  little  better  than  so.  For 
proof  of  this,  did  occasion  serve,  sundry  can  de- 
pose the  contrary. 

'Tis  no  less  untrue,  that  either  ray  father  or 
self  put  the  question,  How  many  witches  sit  up- 
on you?  We  always  cautiously  avoided  that 
expression,  it  being  contrary  to  our  inward  be- 
lief. All  the  standers-by  will,  I  believe,  swear 
they  did  not  hear  us  use  it,  (your  witnesses  ex- 
cepted) and  I  tremble  to  think  how  hardy  those 
woful  creatures  must  be,  to  call  the  Almighty, 
by  an  oath,  to  so  false  a  thing.  As  false  a  re- 
presentation 'tis,  that  1  rubbed  Rule's  stomach, 
her  breast  not  being  covered.  The  oath  of  the 
nearest  spectators,  giving  a  true  account  of  that 
matter,  will  prove  this  to  be  little  less  than  a 
gross  (if  not  a  doubled)  lie ;  and  to  be  somewhat 
plainer,  it  carries  the  ijace  of  a  lie  contrived  on 
urpose  (by  them  at  least  to  whom  you  arc 
eholden  for  the  narrative)  wickedly  and  basely 
to  expose  me :  for  you  cannot  but  know  hovr 
much  this  representation  hath  contributed  to 
make  people  believe  a  smutty  thing  of  me.  I  am 
far  from  thinking  but  that  in  your  own  conscience 
you  believe,  that  no  indecent  action  of  that  nature 
could  then  be  done  by  me  before  such  observ- 
ers, had  I  been  so  wicked  as  to  have  been  in- 
clined to  wliat  is  base.  It  looks  next  to  impos- 
sible that  a  reparation  should  be  made  me  for 
the  wrong  done  to  (I  hope,  as  to  any  scandal) 
an  unblemished,  though  weak  and  small,  servant 
of  the  church  of  God.  Nor  is  what  follows  a 
less  untruth,  that  it  was  an  attendant  and  not 
myself  who  said,  If  Rule  knows  who  afflicts  her. 


i:, 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  5B 

yet  she  won't  tell.  1  therefore  spoke  it  that  I 
might  encourage  her  to  continue  in  that  conceal- 
ment of  all  names  whatsoever;  to  this  I  am  able 
to  furnish  myself  with  the  attestation  of  sufficient 
oaths.  'Tis  as  far  from  true,  that  my  appre- 
hension of  the  imp,  about  Rule,  was  on  her  bel- 
ly; for  the  oaths  of  the  spectators,  and  even  of 
those  that  thought  they  felt  it,  can  testily  that  it 
was  upon  the  pillow,  at  a  distance  from  her  bo- 
dy. As  untrue  a  representation  is  that  which 
follows,  viz.  that  it  was  said  unto  her,  tnat 
her  not  apprehending  of  that  odd,  palpable, 
though  not  visible,  mover,  was  from  her  fancy; 
for  I  endeavoured  to  persuade  her  that  it  might 
be  but  fancy  in  others,  that  there  was  any  such 
thing  at  all.  Witnesses  eyevy  way  sufficient 
can  be  produced  for  this  also.  It  is  ialsely  re- 
presented, that  my  father  felt  on  the  young  wo- 
man after  the  appearance  mentioned,  i'or  his 
hand  was  never  near  her;  oath  can  sufficiently 
vindicate  him.  'Tis  very  untrue,  that  my  father 
prayed,  for  perhaps  half  an  hour,  against  the 
povver  of  the  devil  and  witclicraft,  and  that  God 
would  bring  out  the  afflicters :  witnesses  of  the 
best  credit  can  depose,  that  his  prayer  was  not 
a  quarter  of  an  hour,  and  that  there  was  no  more 
than  about  one  clause,  towards  the  close  of  the 
prayer,  which  was  of  this  import;  and  this 
clause  also  was  guarded  with  a  singular  wariness 
and  modesty,  viz.  If  there  were  any  evil  in- 
struments m  this  matter,  God  would  please  to 
discover  them:  and  that  tlierc  was  more  than 
common  reason  for  that  petition,  I  can  satisfy 
any  one  that  will  please  to  inquire  of  jne.     And 


60  LETTERS  Td 

strange  it  is,   that  a  ge.uilemm)  that   from  eigh- 
teen to  fifty-four  hath  been  an  exemphirj  mi- 
nister of  the  gospel;   and  tliat,  besides  a  station 
in  the  church   ol  God,  as  considerable  as   any 
that  his. own  country  can  afford,  hath  for  divers 
years  come  off  with  honour,  in  his  apphcation  to 
three  crowned  heads,  and  the  chiefest  nobihty  of 
three   kingdoms;  knows  not  yet   how  to  make 
one  short  prayer  of  a  quarter  of  an  hour,    but 
in   New-England    he    must    be    hbelled    for   it. 
Tliere   are   divers    other  down-right   mistakes, 
which  you  have  permitted   yourself   (I    would 
hope  not  knovvin^ly  and  with  a  malicious  design) 
to  be  receiver  or  compiler  of,  which  I  shall  now 
forbear  to  animadvert  upon.      As  for  the  appen- 
dix of  the  narrative,  I  do  find  myself  therein  in- 
juriously trealed;  i'ov  the  utmost  of  your  proof, 
for  what  you  say  of  me,  amounts  to  little  more 
than  this,  viz.  Some  people  told  you,  that  others 
told  them,  that  such  and  such  things   did   pass; 
but  Yt>^  niay  assure  yourself,  that  I  am  nut  unfur- 
nisl-ed  with  witnesses  that  can  convict  the  same. 
Whereas  you  would  give  me  to  believe  the  bot- 
tom of  these,  your  methods,  to  be   some  dissatis- 
faction about  the  commonly  received  power  of 
devils  and  witches;   I  do  not  only  with  all  free- 
dom ofier  you  the  use  of  any  part  of  my  library, 
which  you  may  see  cause  to  peruse  on  that  sub- 
ject, but  also,  if  yuu  and  any  one  else,  whom  you 
please,   will  visit  me  at   my  study,  yea,  or  meet 
me  at   any  other    place,  less  inconvenient   than 
those  by  you   proposed,  I  will    with  all  the  fair- 
ness and  calmness  in  the  world  dispute  the  point. 
?!  beg  of  God  ihdt  he  would    bestow    as   many 


MR.  MATIIEK,  kc.  Gl 

blessings  on  jou,  as  ever  on  myseli';  and  out  of 
a  sincere  wish  that  you  may  be  made  yet  more 
capable  of  these  blessings,  I  take  this  occasion 
to  lay  before  you  the  faults  (not  few  nor  small 
ones  neither)  which  the  paper  contained,  you 
lately  sent  me,  in  order  to  be  examined  by  me. 
In  case  you  want  a  true  and  full  narrative  of  my 
visit,  whereof  such  an  indecent  travesty  (to  say 
the  best)  hath  been  made,  I  am  not  unwilling  to 
communicate  it;  in  mean  time  must  take  liberty 
to  say,  it  is  scarcely  consistent  with  common  ci- 
vility, much  less  christian  charity,  to  oiler  the 
narrative,  now  with  you,  for  a  true  one,  till  you 
have  a  truer;  or  for  a  full  one,  till  you  have  a 
fuller.  Your  sincere  (though  injured)  friend 
and  servant,  C.   Mather. 

The  copy  of  a  paper  received  ivilh  the  above  letter, 

1  do  testify  that  1  have  seen  Margaret  Rule, 
in  her  afflictions  from  the  invisible  world,  lifted 
up  from  her  bed,  wholly  by  an  invisible  force,  a 
great  way  towards  the  top  of  the  room  where 
she  lay ;  in  her  being  so  lifted,  she  had  no  as- 
sistance from  any  use  of  her  own  arms  or  hands, 
or  any  other  part  of  her  body,  not  so  much  as 
her  heels  touching  her  bed,  or  resting  on  any 
support  whatsoever.  And  1  have  seen  her  thus 
lifted,  when  not  only  a  strong  person  hath  thrown 
his  whole  weight  across  her  to  pull  her  down, 
but  several  other  persons  have  endeavoured, 
with  all  their  might,  to  hinder  her  from  being 
so  raised  up;  which  I  suppose  that  several  oth- 
ers will  testify  as  well  as  myself  when  called  un- 
to  it.     Witness  mv  hand,  Samuel  Ave'- 

6 


62  LETTERS  TO 

We  can  also  testify  to  the  substance  of  what 
is  above  written;  and  have  several  times  seen 
Margaret  Rule  so  hfted  up  from  her  bed.  as 
that  she  had  no  use  of  her  own  Hmbs  to  help  her 
up;  but  it  was  the  declared  apprehension  of  us, 
as  w^ell  as  others,  that  saw  it,  impossible  for  any 
hands,  but  some  of  the  invisible  world,  to  lift  her. 

Robert  Earle, 
John   Wilkins, 
Dan.   Williams. 

We,  whose  names  are  under- written,  do  testi- 
fy, that  one  evening,  when  we  were  in  the  cham- 
ber where  Margaret  Rule  then  lay,  in  her  late 
?iffliction,  we  observed  her  to  be,  by  an  invisible 
force,  lifted  up  from  the  bed  whereon  she  lay, 
so  as  to  touch  the  garret  floor,  while  yet  neither 
her  feet,  nor  any  other  part  of  her  body,  rested 
either  on  the  bed  or  any  other  support,  but  were 
also,  by  the  same  force,  lifted  up  from  all  that 
was  under  her;  and  all  this  for  a  considerable 
while,  we  judged  it  several  minutes;  and  it  was 
as  much  as  several  of  us  could  do,  with  all  our 
strength,  to  pull  her  down.  All  which  happened 
-when  there  was  not  only  we  two  in  the  chamber, 
but  we  suppose  ten  or  a  dozen  more,  whose 
names  we  have  forgotten.  ^.^^^^^^  Thornton 

WiLLL\M  Hudson 
testifies  to  the  substance  of  Thorniorfs  testimony^ 
to  which  he  also  hath  set  his  hand, 

..    ^  .,  Boston.  January  \^^\^M. 

Mr.  Cotton  Mather,  ^ 

Reverend  Sir, 
Yours  of  the  15lh  instant  1  received  yester- 
day, and  soon  found  I  had  promised  myselt  too 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  tid 

much  by  it,  viz.  either  concurrence  with,  or  ei 
denial  ol,  those  fundamentals  mentioned  in  mine, 
of  November  the  24th,  finding  this  waved  by 
an  invitation  to  your  hbrary,  (fee.  I  tliank  God  1 
have  the  bible,  and  do  judge  that  sufficient  to 
demonstrate  that  cited  head  of  Mr.  Gaule  to  be 
a  truth,  as  also  those  other  heads  mentioned  as 
the  foundations  of  rehgion.  And  in  my  appre- 
hension, if  it  be  asked  any  christian,  whether  God 
governs  the  world,  and  whether  it  be  he  only  can 
commissionate  devils,  and  such  other  fundamei> 
tals,  he  ought  to  be  as  ready  as  in  the  question, 
Who  made  him?  (A  little  writing  certainly 
might  be  of  more  use,  to  clear  up  the  contro- 
verted points,  than  either  looking  over  many 
books  in  a  well  furnished  library,  or  than  a  dis- 
pute, if  I  were  qualified  for  it;  the  inconvenien- 
cies  of  passion  being  this  way  best  avoided.)  And 
am  not  without  hopes  that  you  will  yet  oblige 
me  so  far,  as  to  consider  that  letter,  and  if  I  err, 
to  let  me  see  it  by  scripture,  &;c. 

Yours,  almost  the  whole  of  it,  is  concerning 
the  narrative  I  sent  to  you  ;  and  you  seem  to  in- 
timate as  if  I  were  giving  characters,  reflections, 
libels,  &ic.  concerning  yourself  and  relations;  all 
which  were  as  far  from  my  thoughts,  as  ever 
they  w^ere  in  writing  after  either  yourself,  or  any 
other  minister.  In  the  front  you  declare  your 
apprehension  to  be,  that  the  afflicted  was  under 
a  diabolical  possession;  and  if  so,  1  see  not  how 
it  should  be  occasioned  by  any  witchcraft  (unless 
we  ascribe  that  power  to  a  witch,  which  is  only 
the  prerogative  of  the  Almighty,  of  sending  or 
commissionating  the  devils  to  afflict  her.)     But 


64  LETTERS  T(i 

to  your  particular  objections  against  the  narra- 
tive; and  to  the  first.      My  intelligence  not  giv- 
ing me  any  further,  1  could  not  insert  that  I  knew 
not     And  it  seems  improbable  that  a  question 
should  be  put,  whether  she  knew  wdio  they  were 
that   tormented  her,   and  at  the  same  time  to 
charge  her,  and  that  upon  her  life,   not  to  tell; 
and  if  you  had  done  so,  I  see  but  little  good  you 
could  promise  yourself  or  others  by  it,  she  b^ing 
possest,  as    also  having   it  inculcated   so  much 
to  her,  of  witchcraft.     And  as  to  the  next  ob- 
jection,  about  company  flocking,  <kc.  I   profess 
my  ignorance,  not  knowing  what  you  mean  by  it. 
And,  sir,   that  most  of  the  questions  did  carry 
with  them  a  presupposing  the   things  inquired 
after,  is  evident,  if  there  were  such  as  those  re- 
lating to  the  hlach  man  and  a  book,  and  about 
her  hearing  the  prayer,  &c.  (related  in  the  said 
narrative,  which  1  find  no  objection  against.)    As 
to  that  which  is  said  of  mentioning  yourself  first 
discoursing,  and  your  hopes  that  your  breeding 
was  better,  (I  doubt  it  not,  nor  do  I  doubt  your 
father  might  first  apply  himself  to  others)  my 
intelligence  is,  that  you  first  spake  to  the  afflict- 
ed or  possessed,  for  which  you  had  the  advan- 
tage of  a  nearer  approach.     The  next  two  ob- 
jections are  founded  upon  mistakes:  I  find  not 
in  i\\e  narrative  any  such  question,  as  How  ma- 
ny witches  sit  upon  you.^  nor,   that  her  breast 
was  not  covered,  in  which  those  material  words, 
with  the  bed  clothes^  are  wholly  omitted.     I  am 
not  willing  to  retort  here  your  own  language  up- 
on you ;  but  can  tell  you,  that  your  own  discourse 
of  it  publickly,  at  SirW.Ps  table,  has  much  more 


MR.  MATHER,  kc.  66 

contributed  to,  <kc.      As  to  the  reply,  \i  she  could 
she  would  not  tell,  whetlier  either  or  both  spake 
it,  it  matters  not  much.     Neither  does  the  nar- 
rative say,  you  felt  the  live  thing  on  her  belly; 
though  1  omit  now  to  say  what  further  demon- 
strations there  are  of  it.    As  to  that  reply,  That 
is  only   her  fancy,  I  find  the  word  her  added. 
Aad  as  to  your  father's  feeling  for  the  live  crea- 
ture after  you  had  ielt  it,  if  it  were  on  the  bed  it 
was  not  so  very  far  from  her.  And  for  the  length 
of   his    prayer,  possibly    your  witnesses  might 
keep  a  more  exact  account  of  the  time  than 
those  others,  and  I  stand  not  for  a  few  minutes. 
For  the  rest  of  the  objections,  I  suppose  them  of 
less  moment,  if  less  can  be;    however,  shall  be 
ready  to  receive  them.    Those  matters  of  great- 
est concern  1  find  no  objections  against.     These 
being  all   that  yet  appear,  it  may   be  thought 
that  if  the  narrative  be  not  fully  exact,  it  was  as 
near  as  memory  could  bear  away  ;  but  should 
be  glad  to  see  one  more  perfect  (which  yet  is 
nut  to  be  expected,  seeing  none  wrote  at  the 
same   time.)      You    mention  the    appendix,    by 
which  I  understand  the  second  visit  ;  and  if  you 
be  by  the   possessed  belied  (as  being  half  an 
hour  with  her  alone,  excludino^  her  own  mother, 
and  as  telling  her  you  had  prayed  lor  her  nine 
times  that  day,  and  that  now  was  her  lauohino- 
tune,  she  must  laugh  now)  1  can  sec  no  wonder 
in  It:   Wiiat  can  be  expected  less  from  the  fa- 
ther of  lies,  by  wnom,  you  judge,  she  was  pos- 
ses t  ? 

And  besides  the  ab ne  letter,  you  were  pleas- 
ed to  send  me  anoiher  paper,  containing  several 
6* 


66  LETTERS  TO 

testimonies  of  the  possessed  being  lifted  up,  and 
held  a  space  of  several  minutes  to  the  garret 
floor,  (fee.  but  they  omit  giving  the  account, 
^vhether  after  she  was  down  they  bound  her 
down,  or  kept  holding  her ;  and  relate  not  how 
many  were  to  pull  her  down,  which  hinders  the 
knovtledge  what  number  they  must  be,  to  be 
stronger  than  an  invisible  force.  Upon  tPie 
whole,  I  suppose  you  expect  1  should  believe 
it;  and  if  so,  the  only  advantage  gained  is,  that 
what  has  been  so  long  controverted  between 
protestants  and  papists,  whether  miracles  are 
ceast,  will  hereby  seem  to  be  decided  for  the 
latter;  it  being,  for  ought  I  can  see,  if  so,  as 
true  a  miracle  as  for  iron  to  swim;  aiul  the  de* 
vil  can  work  such  miracles. 

But,  sir,  to  leave  these  little  disputable  things, 
I  do  again  pray  that  you  would  let  me  have  the 
happiness  of  your  approbation  or  confutation  of 
that  letter  before  referred  to. 

And  now,  sir,  that  the  God  of  all  grace  may 
enable  us  zealously  to  own  his  truths,  and  to 
follow  those  things  that  tend  to  peace,  and  that 
yourself  may  be  as  an  useful  instrument  in  his 
hand,  effectually  to  ruin  the  remainder  of  hea- 
thenish and  popish  superstitions,  is  the  earnest 
desire  and  prayer  of  yours  to  command  in  what 
I  may,  R.  C. 

Postscript. — Sir,  I  here  send  you  tlio  copy  of  a  paper 
that  lately  came  to  my  hands  ;  which,  though  it  contains 
ao  wonders,  yet  is  remarkable,  and  runs  thus : 
.^71  account  ofza^hat  an  Indian  told  Capt.  Hill  at  Saco  Fort. 

The  Indian  told  him,  that  the  French  ministers  were 
better  than  the  English ;  for  before  the  French  came 
/among  them  there  were  a  great  many  witches  among  the 


Mil.  MATHER,  kt.  (,7 

Indians;  but  now  there  were  none;  and  there  were 
witches  among  the  English  ministers,  as  Burroughs,  who 
was  hang'd  tor  it. 

Were  I  disposed  to  make  reflections  upon  it,  I  suppose 
you  will  ju(!ge  the  tield  large  enough  ;  but  I  Ibrbear. 

As  above,     R,  C. 

Boston,  Feb.  19,  1694. 
Mr.  Cotton  Mather, 
Reverend  Sir^ 
I  have  received  as  yet  no  answer  to  mine  of 
November  the  24th,  except  an  offer  to  peruse 
books,  (fee.  relating  to  the  doctrinal*  therein 
contained;  nor  to  my  last,  of  January  the  18t!i, 
in  which  1  again  prayed  that  if  I  erred  I  mioht 
be  shewed  it  by  scripture,  viz.  in  believing  that 
the  devil's  bounds  are  set,  which  he  cannot  pass 
— that  the  devils  are  so  full  of  malice,  that  it 
can't  be  added  to  by  mankind — that  where  he 
hath  power,  he  neither  can  nor  will  omit  exe- 
cuting it — that  it  is  only  the  Almighty  that  sets 
bounds  to  his  rage,  and  who  only  can  commis- 
sion him  to  hurt  or  destroy  any ;  and  conse- 
quently to  detest,  as  erroneous  and  dangerous, 
the  belief  that  a  witch  can  commission  devils  to 
afflict  mortals — that  he  can  at  his  or  the  witch's 
pleasure  assume  any  shape — that  the  hanging 
or  drowning  of  witches  can  lessen  his  power 
of  afflicting,  and  restore  those  that  were  at  a 
distance  tormented  by  him; — and  whether 
witchcraft  ought  to  be  understood,  now  in  this 
age,  to  be  the  same  that  it  was  when  the  divine 
oracles  were  given  forth,  particularly  those  quo- 
ted by  mr.  Gaule,  in  that  cited  head.  Wonders 
of  the  Invisible  World  (mr.  Gaule's  fourth  head) 
to  discover  witches,  which  do  so  plainly  shew  ^ 


C8  LETTERS  TO 

witch,  in  scripture  sense,  to  be  one  that  maligns^ 
&:c.  and  that  pretends  to  give  a  sign  in  order  to 
seduce,  &c.  For  I  have  never  understood,  in 
my  time,  any  sucli  have  suffered  as  witches, 
though  sufficiently  known;  but  the  only  witch 
now  inquired  after  is  one  that  is  said  to  become 
so  by  making  an  exphcit  covenant  with  the  de- 
vil, i.  e.  the  devil  appearing  to  them,  and  mak- 
ing a  compact,  mutually  promising  each  to  other ; 
testified  by  their  signing  his  book,  a  material 
book,  which  he  is  said  to  keep;  and  that  there- 
by they  are  intituled  to  a  power,  not  only  to  af- 
flict others,  but  such  as  is  truly  exorbitant,  ii'not 
highly  intrenching  upon  the  prerogative  of  hina 
who  is  the  Sovereign  Being  :  For  v*'ho  is  he  that 
saith,  and  it  cometh  to  pass,  when  the  Lord 
commandeth  it  not  ? 

Such  explicit  covenant  being,  as  is  said,  in  this 
age,  reckoned  essential  to  complete  a  witch; 
yet  I  finding  nothing  of  such  covenant  (or  pow- 
er thereby  obtamed)  in  scripture,  and  jet  a 
witch  therein  so  fully  described,  do  pray  that  if 
there  be  any  such  scriptures  I  may  be  directed 
to  them ;  for  as  to  the  many  legends  in  this 
case,  I  make  no  account  of  them:  I  read  indeed 
of  a  covenant  with  de.jth  and  with  hel).  but  sup- 
pose that  to  be  in  the  heart  (or  menhd)  only, 
and  see  not  what  use  such  an  explicit  one  can 
be  of  between  spirits,  any  further  than  as  'tis  a 
copy  of  that  mental  which  is  in  the  heart.  The 
dire  effects  and  consequences  of  such  notion  may 
be  f"  und  written  in  indelible  Roman  characters 
of  blood,  in  all  countries  where  they  have  pre- 
vailed.    And  what  less  can  be  expected,  when 


MR.  MATHER,  L^.  ^9 

men  are  indicted  lor  that,  which  it  is  iinpossiblc 
to  jirove,  so  as  for  any  to  clear  himself  of,  viz. 
such  exphcit  covenant  with  the  devil ;  and  then, 
for  want  of  better  evidence,  must  take  up  with 
such  as  the  nature  of  such  secret  covenant  can 
bear,  as  mr.  Gaule  hath  it,  i.  e.  distracted  sto- 
ries, and  strange  and  foreign  events,  &:c.  thereby 
endeavouring  to  find  it,  though  by  its  but  suppo- 
sed effects.  By  the  same  rule  that  one  is  put 
to  purge  himself  of  such  compact,  by  the  same 
may  all  mankind. 

This  then  being  so  important  a  case,  it  con- 
cerns all  to  know  what  foundations  in  scripture 
are  laid  for  such  a  sti-ucture  ;  for  if  they  are 
deficient  of  tiiat  warrant,  the  more  eminent  the 
architects  are,  the  more  dangerous  are  they 
thereby  rendered^  <fec.  These  are  such  consi- 
derations as  I  think  will  vindicate  me,  in  the 
esteem  of  all  lovers  of  humanity,  in  my  endea- 
vours to  get  them  cleared  ;  and,  to  that  end,  do 
once  more  pray,  that  you  would  so  far  oblige 
me  as  to  give  your  approbation  or  coni'utation 
of  the  above  doctrinals  ;  but  if  you  think  silence 
a  virtue  in  this  case,  I  shall  (I  suppose)  so  far 
comply  with  it  as  not  to  lose  you  any  more  time 
to  look  over  my  papers.  And  if  any  others  will 
so  far  oblige  me,  t  shall  not  be  ungrateful  to 
them.  Praying  God  to  guide  and  prosj^er  you, 
I  am,  sir,  yours  to  my  power,  R.  C. 

(He  that  doth  truth  cometh  to  the  lii(ht,) 


70  LETTERS  T0> 

Boston,  April  the  IQth,  1694 
Mr.  Cotton  Mather, 
Reverend  Sir, 
Having  as  yet  received  no  answer  to  my  last, 
touching  the  doctrinals  therein  referred  to, 
though  at  the  dehvery  of  it  you  were  pleased 
to  promise  the  gentleman  that  presented  it  that 
I  should  have  it,  and  after  that  you  acquainted 
the  same  gentleman  you  were  about  it;  the 
length  of  time  since  those  promises  makes  me 
suppose  you  are  preparing  something  for  the 
press  (for  I  w^ould  not  question  your  veracity ;) 
and  I  think  it  may  not  be  amiss,  when  you  do 
any  thing  of  that  nature  for  the  public  view,  that 
you  also  explain  some  passages  of  some  late 
books  of  yours  and  your  relations,  which  are 
hard  to  be  understood ;  to  instance  in  a  few  of 
many;  Wonders  of  the  Invisible  World,  page  17, 
"  Plagues  are  some  of  those  woes  with  which 
the  devil  causes  our  trouble."  Page  18,  "  Hence 
come  such  plagues  as  that  besom  of  destruction 
which  within  our  memory  swept  away  such  a 
throng  of  people  from  one  English  city,  in  one 
visitation.  Wars  are  some  of  those  woes  with 
which  the  devil  causes  our  trouble."  Page  16, 
*' Hence  'tis  that  the  devil,  like  a  dragon  keep- 
ing a  guard  upon  such  fruits  as  would  refresh  a 
languishing  world,  has  hindered  mankind  lor  ma» 
ny  ages  from  hitting  upon  those  useful  inventions. 
The  benighted  world  must  jog  on,  for  thousands 
of  years,  without  the  knowledge  of  the  I -ad- 
stone,  printing,  and  spectacles."  Page  10,  ^' It 
is  not  likely  that  every  devil  does  know  every 
language.     'Tis  possible  the  experience,  or,  if  { 


MR.  M\THER,  &c.  71 

mny  call  it  so,  the  ediiCatlon,  of  all  devils  is  not 
alike."  Cases  ( J' Conscience^  P^g^  ^^^  "  '^^^^  devil 
has  inflicted  on  many  the  disease  called  the  ly- 
canthropia."  Memorable  Providences  relating  to 
Witchcraft  Disc,  page  24,  "I  am  also  apt  to 
think  that  the  devils  are  seldom  able  to  hurt  us 
in  any  of  our  exterior  concerns,  without  a  com- 
mission from  some  of  our  fellow  worms.  When 
foul  mouth'd  men  shall  wish  harm  to  their  neigh- 
bours, they  give  a  commission  to  the  devil  to 
perform  what  they  desire ;  and  if  God  should 
not  mercifully  prevent,  they  would  go  through 
with  it.  Hear  this,  you  that  in  wild  passion  will 
give  every  thing  to  the  devil;  hear  it,  you  that 
bespeak  a  rot,  a  pox,  or  a  plague,  on  all  that 
shall  provoke  you;  1  here  indict  you  as  guilty 
of  hellish  witchcraft  in  the  sight  of  God."  Jlore 
Wonders  of  the  Invisible  Worlds  p.  49,  "  They 
each  of  them  have  their  spectres  or  devils  com- 
missioned by  them,  and  representing  them." 
Page  14,  "  But  such  a  permission  from  God  ibr 
the  devil  to  come  down  and  break  in  upon  man- 
kind, must  often  times  be  accompanied  with  a 
commission  from  some  of  mankind  itself"  AV 
chantments  encountered.,  ''  Tliese  witches  have 
driven  a  trade  of  commissioning  their  conlede- 
rate  spirits  to  do  all  sorts  of  mischiefs  to  their 
neighbours."  Page  50,  ^^They  have  bewitched 
some,  even  so  far  as  to  make  them  self-destroy- 
ers." Page  144,  '*  As;  I  am  abundantly  satisfied, 
th;t  many  of  the  self-murders,  committed  here, 
have  been  the  effects  (  f  a  cruel  and  bloody  witch- 
craft, letting  fly  daemons  upon  the  miserable  Se- 
necas."    Page  51,  "  We  have  seen  some  of  their 


72  LETTERS  TO 

children  dedicated  to  the  devil,  that  in  their  in- 
fancy the  imps  have  sucked  them."      Cases  of 
Consience^  P^g^  ^"^5   "  ^^^^^y  bequeath  their  dae- 
mons to  the  children  as  a  legacy,  by  whom  they 
are  often  assisted  to  see  and  do  things   beyond 
the  power  of  nature."     Page  21,  ''There  is  in 
Spain  a  sort  of  people  railed  Zahurs,  that  can 
see  into    the  bowels  of  the  earth."     On  Tues- 
days and  Fridays,  and  to  add  that  in  page  49 ; 
the  words  are,  ^'  For  the  law  of  God  allows  of 
no  revelation  from  any  other  spirit  but  himself, 
Isa.  viii.  19.     It  is  a  sin  ao^ainst  God  to   make 
use  of  the  devil's  help,  to  know  that  which  can- 
not be  otherways  known ;  and  I  testify  against 
it  as  a  great  transgression,  which  may  justly  pro- 
voke that  Holy  One  of  Israel  to  let  loose  devils 
on  the  whole  land.     Although  the  devil's  accu- 
sation may  be  so  far  regarded,  as  to  cause  an  in- 
quiry into  the  truth  of  things,  (Job  i.  J 1,  12,  and 
ii.  5,  6)  yet  not  so  as  to  be  an  evidence  or  ground 
of  conviction;  for  the  devil's  testimony  ought 
not  to  be  taken  in  whole  nor  in  part."     It  is  a 
known  truth,  that  some  unwary  expressions  of 
the  primitive  fathers  were  afterwards  impro- 
ved for  the  introducing  and  establishing  of  er- 
ror, as  their  calling  the  Virgin  Mary  the  mother 
of  God,  &:c.     Hence    occasion  and    advantage 
were  taken  to  propagate    the  idoli2;ing  of  her. 
The  like  might  be  said  of  the  eucharist.    These 
assertions,  above    reliearsed,   being  apparently 
liable  to  a  like  mal-construction,  and  no  less  dan- 
gerous, are  therefore,  as  I  said,  highly  needful 
to  be  explained,  and  that  in  a  most  public  man- 
ner.    For  were  they  to  be  understood  literally. 


MR.  MATHEa,  &c.  73 

and  as  they  are  spoken,  it  must  seem  as  it'  the 
authors  were  introducing  among  christians  very 
dangerous  doctrines,  such  as,  were  they  asserted 
by  the  best  of  men,  yet  ought  to  be  rejected  by 
all,  &c.  viz.  That  'tis  the  devil  that  brings  the 
most  of  evils  upon  mankind,  by  way  of  infliction, 
that  do  befal  them  ;  and  that  the  witch  can 
commission  him  to  the  performance  of  these  ; 
with  many  other  as  dangerous  doctrines,  and 
such  as  seem  in  their  tendency  to  look  favoura- 
bly upon  the  antient  pagan  doctrines  of  this 
country,  who  believed  that  God  did  hurt  to  none, 
but  good  to  all,  but  that  the  devil  must  be  pleas- 
ed by  worshiping,  &c.  from  whom  came  all  their 
miseries,  as  they  believed.  For  what  were  all 
this,  but  to  rob  God  of  his  glory  in  the  highest 
manner,  and  give  it  to  a  devil  and  a  witch  ?  Is 
it  not  he  that  hath  said.  Shall  there  be  evil  in  a 
city,  and  the  Lord  hath  not  done  it  ?  But  if  any 
are  fond  of  their  own  notions,  because  some 
eminent  men  before  now  have  asserted  them, 
they  may  do  well  to  compare  them  with  that 
excellent  saying  (  Wonders  of  the  Invisible  Worlds 
p.  7)  '^  About  this  devil  there  are  many  things, 
whereof  we  may  reasonably  and  profitably  be 
inquisitive  ;  such  things  I  mean  as  are  in  our  bi- 
bles revealed  to  us  5  according  to  which  if  we 
do  not  speak  on  so  dark  a  subject,  but  according 
to  our  own  uncertain  and  perhaps  humoursome 
conjectures,  there  is  no  light  in  us."  Or  that 
other,  p.  75,  "  At  every  other  weapon  the  de- 
vil will  be  too  hard  for  us."  For  'lis  most  cer- 
tain that  other  notions,  weapons  and  praclicea 
U^ve  been  taken  up  with,  and  that  the  event 
7 


74  LIFTERS   TO 

]ias  been  answerable :  the  devil  has  been  too 
hard  for  such  as  have  so  done.  I  shall  forbear 
to  instance  from  the  dogmatical  part,  and  shall 
mention  some  practices  that  as  much  need  ex- 
plaining ;  JMem.  Provid.  RcL  to  Witchc  pages  29, 
30,  31  ;  where  account  is  given  that  it  was  pray- 
ed for  that  the  afflicted  might  be  able  to  declare, 
whom  she  apprehended  herself  affljcted  by,  to- 
gether with  the  immediate  answer  of  such 
prayer.  To  this  you  once  replied,  when  it  was 
mentioned  to  you,  that  you  did  not  then  under- 
stand the  wiles  of  satan. 

To  which  I  have  nothing  to  object,  but  it 
might  be  a  good  acknowledgment.  But  consid- 
ering that  tlie  book  is  gone  forth  into  all  the 
world,  I  cannot  but  think  the  salve  ought  to  be 
proportioned  to  the  sore,  and  the  notice  of  the 
devil's  wiles  as  universal  as  the  means  recom- 
mending them.  Another  practice  is,  (pages  20, 
21,)  "There  was  one  singular  passion  that  fre- 
quently attended  her ;  an  invisible  chain  would 
be  clapt  about  her,  and  she  in  much  pain  and  fear 
cry  out  when  they  began  to  put  it  on:  once  I 
did  with  my  own  hand  knock  it  off  as  it  began 
to  be  fastened  about  her."  If  this  were  done 
by  the  power  or  virtue  of  any  ordinance  of  di- 
vine instruction,  it  is  well ;  but  would  have  been 
much  better  if  the  institution  had  been  demon- 
strated; or  was  there  any  physical  virtue  in  that 
particular  hand  ?  But  supposing  that  neither  of 
these  will  be  asserted  by  the  author,  I  think  it 
very  requisite,  that  the  world  may  be  acquaint- 
ed with  the  operation,  and  to  what  ait  or  craft 
to  refer  their  power  of  knocking  off  invisible 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  75 

chains.  And  thus,  sir,  I  have  faltlifuliy  dis- 
charged  what  in  this  I  took  to  be  my  duty,  and 
am  so  far  from  doing  it  to  gain  applause,  or  from 
a  spirit  of  contradiction,  that  I  expect  to  pro- 
cure me  many  enemies  thereby  ;  but  (as  in  case 
of  a  fire)  where  the  glory  of  God  and  the  good 
and  welfare  of  mankind  are  so  nearly  concerned, 
I  thought  it  my  duty  to  be  no  longer  an  idle 
spectator;  and  can  and  do  say,  to  the  glory  of 
God,  in  this  whole  affair,  I  have  endeavoured  to 
keep  a  conscience  void  of  offence,  both  tow^ards 
God  and  towards  man ;  and  therein  at  the  least 
have  the  advantage  of  such  as  are  very  jealous 
they  have  done  so  much  herein,  as  to  sin  in  what 
they  have  done,  viz.  in  sheltering  the  accused; 
such  have  been  the  cowardice  and  fearl'ulness, 
into  which  a  regard  to  the  dissatisfaction  of  oth- 
er people  have  precipitated  them;  which  by 
by  the  way  must  needs  acquaint  all,  that  for  the 
future  other  measures  are  resolved  upon  (by 
such)  which,  how  bloody  they  may  prove  when 
opportunity  shall  offer,  is  with  him  v/ho  orders 
all  things  according  to  the  counsel  of  his  own 
will..  And  now,  that  the  song  of  angels  may  be 
the  emulation  of  men,  is  the  earnest  desire  and 
prayer  of,  sir,  yours  to  command  in  what  I  may, 

R   C. 

Glory  to  God  in  the  highest,  and  on  earth  peace,  and 
good  will  towards  men. 

Tvf     T>  Boston,  March  the  1st,  1694. 

Mr.  B ,  ' 

Worthy  Sir, 
After  more  than  a  year's  waiting  for  the  per- 
formance of  a  reiterated  promise  from  one  un- 


76  LETTERS  TO 

der  singular  obligations^  and  a  multitude  of  ad* 
vantages  to  have  done  it  sooner^  the  utmost  com- 
pliance I  have  met  with  is  (by  your  hands)  the 
srght  of  four  sheets  of  rescinded  papers.  But  I 
must  first  be  obliged  to  return  them  in  a  fort- 
night, and  not  copied,  which  I  have  now  com- 
plied with  :  and  having  read  them,  am  not  at  all 
surprised  at  the  author's  caution,  not  t6  admit  of 
such  crude  matter  and  impertinent  absurdities, 
as  are  to  be  found  in  it.  He  seems  concerned 
that  5  take  no  notice  of  his  several  books,  where- 
in, as  he  safth,  he  has  unanswerably  proved 
things.  To  this  I  might  reply,  that  1  have  sent 
him  letters  of  quotations  out  of  those  books,  to 
know  how  much  of  them  he  will  abide  by  ;  for 
I  thought  it  hard  to  affix  their  natural  consequent. 
ces,  till  he  had  opportunity  to  explain  them. 
And  saith,  that  he  hath  sent  me  mr.  Baxter's 
World  of  Spirits^  an  ungainsayable  book,  &c. 
(though  I  know  no  ungainsayable  book  but  the 
bible ;)  which  book,  I  think,  no  man  that  has 
read  it  will  give  such  a  title  to  but  the  author. 
He  speaks  of  my  reproaching  his  public  sermons; 
of  which  I  am  not  conscious  to  myself,  unless  it 
be  about  his  interpretation  of  a  thunder  storm 
(that  broke  into  his  house)  which  savoured  so 
much  of  enthusiasm. 

As  to  those  papers,  I  have  (as  I  read  them) 
lioted  in  the  margin  wliere,  in  a  hasty  reading,  I 
thouo-ht  it  needful ;  of  which  it  were  unreasona- 
ble for  him  to  complain,  seeing  1  might  not  take  a 
copy,  thereby  to  have  been  enabled  more  at  lei- 
sure to  digest  what  were  needful  to  be  said  on  so 
manv  heads:   and  as  I  have  not  flattered  him, 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  77 

so,  for  telling  what  was  so  needfu],  with  the 
hazard  of  making  so  many  enemies  by  it,  I  have 
approved  myself  one  of  his  best  friends.  And 
besides  his  own  sense  of  the  weakness  of  his  an- 
swer, testified  by  the  prohibition  above,  he  has 
wholly  declined  answering  to  most  of  those 
things  that  1  had  his  promise  for;  and  what  he 
pretends  to  speak  to,  after  mentioning,  without 
the  needful  answer  or  proof,  drops  it. 

His  first  main  work,  after  his  definition  of  a 
witch,  which  he  never  proves  (without  saying 
any  thing  to  mr.  Gaule's  scriptural  description, 
though  so  often  urged  to  it,  and  though  himself 
has  in  his  book  recommended  and  quoted  it)  ig 
to  m.ignify  thedeviPs  power,  and  that  as  I  think 
beyond  and  against  the  scripture  ;  this  takes  hina 
up  about   1 1    pages  ;  and  yet  in  page  22d  he 
again  returns  to  it,  and,  as  /understand  it,  takes 
part  with  the  pharisees  against  our  Saviour  in 
the  argument ;    for   they  charge   him  that  he 
cast  out  devils  through  Beelzebub  :  our  Saviour's 
answer  is,  (Matt.  xii.  25)  Every  kingdom  divided 
against  itself  is  brought  to  desolation  ;  and  every 
city  or  house  divided  against  itself  shall  not  stand  ; 
and  if  sat  an  cast  out  satan,  he  is  divided  against 
himself;    how  shall   then   his   kingdom  stand  ? 
Arid  yet,  notwithstanding  this  answer,  together 
with  what  follows,  for  further    illustration  our 
author  is  it  seems  resolved  to  assert,  that  our 
Saviour  did  not  in  this  answer  deny  that  many 
did  so,  viz.  cast  out  devils  by  Beelzebub;  and, 
page  23,   grants  that  the  devils  have  a  miracu- 
lous power,  but  yet  it  must  not  be  called  mira- 
culous, and  yet  can  be  distinguished,  as  he  inti- 


76  LETTERS  TO 

mates,  only  by  the  conscience  or  light  within,  to 
the  no  small  scandal  of  the  christian  religion  : 
though  our  Saviour  and  his  apostles  account  this 
the  chief  or  principal  proof  of  his  godhead,  (John 
XX.  30,  31.  John  x.  37,  38.  John  v.  30.  ^^Jark  xvi. 
17,  18.  j^cts]u22,  and  iv.  30.  with  many  others) 
and  that  miracles  belong  only  to  God,  who  also 
governs  the  world,  (Ps,  cxxxvi.  4.  Jer,  xiv.  22. 
Isa,  xxxviii.  8.  Ps,  Ixii.  11.  Lam,  iii.  37.  Amos  iii, 
6.)  But,  to  forbear  quoting  that  which  the  scrip- 
ture is  most  full  in,  do  only  say,  that  he  that- 
dares  assert  the  devil  to  have  such  a  miraculous 
power,  had  need  have  other  scriptures  than 
ever  I  have  seen. 

In  page  12,  our  author  proceeds,  and  states  a 
question  to  this  effect:  If  the  devH  has  such 
powers,  and  cannot  exert  them  without  permis- 
sion from  God,  what  can  the  witch  contribute 
thereunto?  Instead  of  an  answer  to  this  vreighty 
objection,  our  author  first  concedes,  that  the 
devils  do  ordinarily  exert  their  powers,  without 
the  witches  contributing  to  it;  but  yet,  that,  to 
the  end  to  increase  their  guilt,  he  may  cheat  a 
witch,  by  making  her  believe  herself  the  author 
of  them.  His  next  is,  If  witchcraft  be,  as  I  sup- 
pose it  is,  the  skill  of  applying  the  plastic  spirit 
of  the  world,  <S*c.  then  the  consent  of  the  witch 
doth  naturally  contribute  to  that  mischief  that 
the  devil  does.  And  his  last  answer  runs  to  this 
effect :  Is  it  not  the  ordination  of  God,  that 
where  the  devil  can  get  the  consent  of  a  witch 
for  the  hurting  of  others,  the  hurt  shall  as  cer- 
tainly be  as  if  they  had  set  mastiff  dogs  upon 
them,  ©r  had  given  them  poison  into  their  bow* 


MR.  MATHER,  kc.  79 

els?  and  God's  providence  must  be  as  great  in 
delivering  i'rom  one  as  Iroin  the  other.  And  this 
it  seems  is  not  only  his  belief,  but  the  most  or- 
thodox and  the  most  learned  answer  that  our 
author  could  pitch  upon:  If*  witchcralt  be,  as  I 
suppose  it  is,  &c.  and  is  it  not  the  ordination  of 
God,  that,  (fec^  What  is  all  this  but  precarious, 
and  begging  the  question,  and  a  plain  dropping 
the  argument  he  cannot  manage?  Howevei*,  to 
amuse  the  ignorant,  and  to  confound  the  learned, 
he  hooks  in  a  cramp  word,  if  not  a  nonentity,  viz. 
plastic  spirit  of  the  world;  for  who  is  it  either 
knows  that  there  is  a  plastic  spirit,  or  what  it  is, 
or  how  this  can  any  way  serve  his  purpose? 

He  then  proceeds  to  scripture  instances  of 
witches,  &c.  and  where  I  thought  it  needful,  I 
have,  as  I  said,  shewed  my  dissent  from  his  judg- 
ment. He  accounts  it  unreasonable  to  be  held 
to  the  proof  of  his  definition  of  a  witch,  which 
he  makes  to  consist  in  a  covenant  with  the  devil ; 
and  chooses  rather  a  tedious  process  about  a  pis- 
tol to  defend  him  from  it,  which  indeed  is  one 
particular  way  whereby  murder  has  been  com- 
mitted, and  so  the  doer  becomes  culpable.  But 
his  definition  of  a  witch,  which,  as  I  said,  still 
remains  to  be  proved,  is  to  this  effect :  that  a 
"witch  is  one  that  covenants  with  and  commissions 
devils  to  do  mischiefs;  that  she  is  one  in  cove- 
nant, or  that  by  virtue  of  such  covenant  she  can 
commission  him  to  kill.  The  not  bringing  scri|> 
ture  to  prove  these  two  is  a  sufficient  demonstra- 
tion there  is  none ;  and  so  our  author  leaves  off 
just  where  he  began,  viz.  in  a  bare  assertion,  to- 
gether with  his  own  bigoted  experiences,  hinting' 


30  •  LETTERS  TO 

also  at  multitudes  of  histories  to  confirm  him  in 
the  belief  of  his  definition.  Here  being  all  that 
I  take  notice  of  to  be  considerable. 

And  now,  sir,  if  you  think  fit,  improve  your 
friendship  with  tiie  author,  for  the  glory  of  Gud, 
the  sovereign  being,  the  good  and  welfare  of 
mankind,  and  for  his  real  and  true  interest.  As 
you  see  it  convenient,  put  him  in  mind,  that  the 
glory  of  God  is  the  end  why  mankind  was  made, 
and^vhy  he  hath  so  many  advantages  to  it :  tliat 
the  flames  we  have  seen,  threatening  the  utter 
extirpation  of  the  country,  must  owe  their  origi- 
nal to  these  dangerous  errors  (if  not  heresies) 
which,  if  they  remain  unextinguished,  may  and 
most  hkely  will  be  acted  over  again:  that  it  is 
more  honour  to  own  an  error  in  time,  than  tena- 
ciously after  full  conviction  to  retain  it.  But  if 
our  author  will  again  vindicate  such  matters, 
please  to  acquaint  him,  that  1  shall  not  any  mure 
receive  his  papers,  if  I  may  not  copy  and  use 
them;  and  that  when  he  does,  instead  of  such 
abstruse  matters,  1  still  pray  his  determination 
in  those  things  I  have  his  promise  for.  And 
thus  begging  pardon  for  thus  long  detaining  you, 
I  am,  sir,  yours  to  command,  R.  C 

Boston,  March  IB,  1694. 
To  the  Ministers^  whether  English,  French  or 
Dutch, 
I,  havins:  had  not  only  occasion,  but  renewed 
provocation,  to  take  a  view  ot  the  mysterious 
doctrines  which  have  of  late  been  so  much  con- 
tested among  us,  could  not  meet  with  any  that 
had  spoken  more,  or   more   plainly,  the  sense 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  H 

of  those  doctrines  (relating  to  witchcraft)  than 
the  rev*  inr.  C.  M. ;  but  how  clearly  and  con- 
sistent, either  with  himself  or  the  trutli,  1 
need  not  now  saj,  but  cannot  but  suppose  his 
strenuous  and  zealous  asserting  his  opinions 
has  been  one  cause  of  the  dismal  convul- 
sions we  have  here  lately  fallen  into*  Suppo- 
sing that  his  books  of  Memorable  Providences 
relating  to  Witchcraft^  as  also  his  Wonders  of 
the  Invisible  World,  did  contain  in  them  things 
not  warrantable,  and  very  dangerous,  I  sent  to 
him  a  letter  of  quotations  out  of  those  books,  &c. 
that  so,  if  it  might  have  been,  I  might  under- 
stand what  tolerable  sense  he  would  put  upon 
his  own  words  ;  which  1  took  to  be  a  better  way 
of  proceeding,  than  to  have  affixed  what  I 
thought  to  be  their  natural  consequences ;  and, 
lest  I  might  be  judged  a  sceptic,  I  gave  him  a 
full  and  free  account  of  my  belief  relating  to 
those  doctrines,  together  with  the  grounds  there- 
of; and  prayed  him,  that  if  I  erred  I  might  be 
shewed  it  by  scripture ;  and  this  I  had  his  rei- 
terated promise  for.  But  after  more  than  a 
year's  waiting  for  the  performance  thereof,  all 
that  is  done  in  compliance  therewith  is,  that  in 
^February  last  he  sent  me  four  sheets  of  his  wri- 
ting, as  his  belief;  but  before  I  might  receive  it 
I  must  engage  to  deliver-  it  back  in  a  fortnight, 
and  not  copied.  A  summary  account  of  which 
I  shall  give  you,  when  I  have  first  acquainted 
you  Avhat  the  doctrines  were  which  I  sent  to 
him  for  his  concurrence  with,  or  confutation  of, 
and  to  which  1  had  his  promise,  as  above. 
These  by  way  of  question,  viz.  Whether  that 


8^  LETTERS  Tl) 

fourth  head,  cited  and  recommended  by  him- 
self (in  Wonders  of  the  invisible  World)  ol"  mr* 
Gaule,  ought  to  be  behoved  as  a  truth ;  which 
runs  thus  :  "  Among  the  most  unhappy  circum- 
stances to  convict  a  witch,  one  is  a  maligning 
and  oppugning  the  word,  work  and  worship 
of  God,  and  seeking  by  an  extraordinary  sign 
to  seduce  any  from  it.  Dent  xiii.  1,  2.  Matt. 
xxiv.  24.  Jets  xiii.  8,  10.  2  Tm.  iii,  8,  Do  but 
mark  well  the  places ;  and  for  this  very  pro- 
perty of  thus  opposing  and  perverting,  they  are 
all  there  concluded  arrant  and  absolute  witches." 
And  if  in  witchcraft  the  devil  by  means  of  a 
witch  does  the  mischief,  how  is  it  possible  to 
distinguish  it  from  possession  ?  both  being  said 
to  be  performed  by  the  devil ;  and  yet,  without 
an  infallible  distinction,  there  can  be  no  certain- 
ty in  judgment.  And  whether  it  can  be  proved 
that  the  Jewish  church,  in  any  age  before,  or  in 
our  Saviour's  time,  even  in  the  time  of  their 
greatest  apostacy,  did  bcheve  that  a  witch  had 
power  to  commission  devils  to  do  mischief? 

So  much  to  the  questions.  These  were  sent 
as  m}  belief:  That  the  devil's  bounds  are  set, 
that  he  cannot  pass ;  that  the  devils  are  so  full 
of  malice,  that  it  cannot  be  added  to  by  mankind ; 
that  where  he  hath  power,  he  neither  can  nor 
will  omit  executing  it ;  that  it  is  only  the  Al- 
mighty that  sets  bounds  to  his  rage,  and  that 
only  can  commission  him  to  hurt  or  destroy. 
And  now  I  shall  give  you  the  summary  account 
of  his  four  sheets  above  mentioned,  as  near  as 
memory  could  recollect,  in  ten  particulars. 
1.    That  the  devils  have  in  their  natures  a 


MR.  MATHER,  kc.  H3 

power  to  work  wonders  and  miracles  ;  particu- 
larly that  the  pharisces  were  not  mistaken  in 
assertin«j  that  the  devils  might  be  cast  out  by 
Beelzebub ;  and  that  our  Saviour's  answer  docs 
not  oppose  that  assertion  ;  and  that  he  hath  the 
power  of  death;  that  he  can  make  the  most  so- 
lid things  invisible,  and  can  invisibly  bring  poison, 
and  force  it  down  people's  throats. 

2.  That  to  assert  this  natural,  wonderful  powd- 
er of  the  devil,  makes  most  for  the  glory  of  God, 
in  preserving  man  from  its  effects. 

3.  Yet  this  power  is  restrained  by  the  Al- 
mighty, as  pleaseth  him. 

4.  That  a  witch  is  one  that  makes  a  covenant 
with  the  devil. 

5.  That  by  virtue  of  such  a  covenant,  she  ar- 
rives at  a  power  id  commission  him. 

6.  That  God  has  ordained  that  when  the  de- 
vil is  called  upon  by  the  witch,  though  he  w^ere 
before  restrained  by  the  Almighty,  the  desired 
mischiefs  ordinarily  shall  as  certainly  be  perform- 
ed, as  if  the  witch  had  lodged  poison  in  the  bow- 
els of  her  neighbour,  or  had  set  mastiff  dogs  on 
them. 

8.  That  that  God  which  restrained  an  Abi- 
melech  and  a  Laban  from  hurting,  does  also  re- 
strain the  witch  from  calling  upon  or  improving 
the  devil,  when  he  will  not  have  his  power  so 
exerted. 

9.  That  to  have  a  familiar  spirit,  is  to  be  able 
to  cause  a  devil  to  take  bodily  shapes,  whereby 
either  to  give  responses,  or  to  receive  orders  lor 
doing  mischief. 

10.  That  this  is  the  judgment  of  most  of  the 


84  LETTERS  TO 

divines  in  the  countri',  whether  Enghsh,  Dutch, 
or  French. 

This,  as  I  said,  I  took  to  be  the  most  materi- 
al in  the  four  sheets  sent  to  me  as  his  behef, 
and  is  also  all  the  performance  he  has  yet  made 
of  his  several  promises  ;  which  ten  articles  being 
done  only  by  memory,  lest  through  mistake  or 
want  of  the  original  I  might  have  committed  any 
errors,  I  sent  them  to  him,  that,  if  there  were 
any,  they  might  be  rectified :  but  instead  of  such 
an  answer  as  might  be  expected  from  a  minister 
aiid  a  learned  gentleman,  one  mr.  W.  shewed 
me  a  letter  writ  by  mr.  C.  M.  to  himself,  which 
I  might  read,  but  neither  borrow  nor  copy,  and 
so,  if  1  were  minded,  could  give  but  a  short  ac- 
count of  it. 

And  passing  over  his  hard  lans^uage,  which, 
as  I  am  conscious  to  myse'f  I  never  deserved, 
(relating  to  my  writing  in  the  margin  of  the  four 
sheets,  and  to  these  ten  articles)  so  1  hope  I  un- 
derstand my  di;ty  better  than  to  imitate  him  in 
retorting  the  like.  Among  his  many  words  in 
his  said  letters,  I  meet  with  two  small  objections ; 
one  is  against  the  word  miracle  in  the  first  aiti- 
tle;  the  word,  I  say,  not  the  matter;  for  the 
works  he  attributes  to  the  devil  arc  the  same, 
in  their  being  above  or  against  the  course  of  na- 
ture and  all  natural  causes;  yet  he  will  not  ad- 
mit of  these  to  be  called  miracles;  and  hence 
he  reckons  it  the  greatest  difficulty  lie  meets 
with  in  this  whole  affair,  todistirguish  the  works 
of  the  devil  from  miracles.  And  hence  also  he 
concedes  to  tlie  devil  the  power  to  make  the 
«iQSt  solid  things  invisible^,  and  mvtsibly  to  bring 


MR.  MATHER,  kc.  8i. 

poison,  and  force  it  down  people's  throats,  (fee. 
Which  I  look  upon  to  be  as  true  miracles  as 
that  2  Kings,  vi.  IB ;  and  this  is  the  sense  I  un- 
derstand the  word  in ;  and  in  this  sense  he  him- 
sell",  in  the  tour  sheets,  admits  it ;  lor  he  has  an 
objection  to  this  effect,  viz.  If  the  devils  have 
such  power,  &c.  tiien  miracles  are  not  ceased  ; 
and  where  are  we  then?  His  answer  is.  Where  ! 
Even  just  where  we  were  before,  say  I :  so  that 
it  seems  the  only  offence  here  is  at  my  using 
his  words.  His  second  objection  (for  weii^ht) 
is  against  the  whole  ninth  article,  and  wonders 
how  it  is  possible  for  one  man  so  much  to  mis- 
understand another ;  yet,  as  I  remember,  he, 
speaking  of  the  witch  of  Endor,  in  the  said  four 
sheets,  says,  she  had  a  familiar  spirit,  and  that  a 
spirit  belonging  to  the  invisible  world,  upon  her 
calling,  appeared  to  Saul,  &c.  and  if  so,  it  is  cer- 
tain he  gave  responses.  He  also  tells  of  Bala- 
am, that  it  was  known  that  he  could  set  devils 
on  people  to  destroy  them  ;  and  therefore  how 
this  objection  should  bear  any  force  I  see  not. 
The  rest  of  the  objections  are  of  so  small 
weight,  that  once  reading  may  be  sufficient  to 
clear  them  up;  and  if  this  be  not  so,  he  can, 
when  he  pleases,  by  making  it  publick,  together 
with  the  margins  I  writ,  convince  all  people  of 
the  truth  of  what  he  asserts.  But  here  it  is  to 
be  noted,  that  the  2d,  3d,  4th  and  5th  articles 
he  concedes  to,  as  having  nothing  to  object 
against  them,  but  that  they  are  his  belief;  and 
that  the  6th  and  7th  he  puts  for  answer  to  an 
objection  which  he  thus  frames,  viz.  If  the  de- 
vil have  such  powers,  but  cannot  exert  them 
8 


86  LETTERS   TO 

but  by  permission  from  God,  what  can  the  witch 
contribute  thereto  ? 

And  thus  I  have  faithfully  performed  what  I 
undertook;  and  do  solemnly  declare,  I  have  not 
intentionally  in  the  least  wronged  the  gentleman 
concerned,  nor  designed  the  least  blemish  to  liis 
reputation;  but  if  it  stands  in  competition  with 
the  glory  of  God,  the  only  almighty  being,  his 
truths  and  his  people's  welfare,  1  suppose  these 
too  valuable  to  be  trampled  on  for  his  sake, 
though  in  other  things  I  am  ready  to  my  power 
(though  with  denying  some  part  of  my  own  in- 
terest) to  serve  him.  Had  this  gentleman  de- 
clined or  detracted  his  four  sheets,  I  see  not 
but  he  might  have  done  it,  and  wdiich  I  think 
there  was  cause  enough  for  him  to  have  done; 
but  to  own  the  four  sheets,  and  at  the  same 
time  to  disown  the  doctrine  contained  in  them, 
and  this  knowing  that  I  have  no  copy,  renders 
the  whole  of  the  worse  aspect. 

And  now  I  shall  give  you  a  further  account 
of  my  belief,  when  I  have  first  premised,  that 
it  is  a  prevailing  belief  in  this  country,  and  else- 
where, that  the  scriptures  are  not  full  in  the 
description  of,  and  in  the  way  and  means  how 
to  detect,  a  witch,  though  positive  in  their  pu- 
nishment to  be  by  death  ;  and  that  hence  they 
have  thought  themselves  under  a  necessity  of 
taking  up  with  the  sentiments  of  such  men  or 
places  that  are  thought  worthy  to  give  rules  to 
detect  them  by;  and  have  accordingly  practis- 
ed; viz.  in  searching  for  teats  for  the  devil  to 
suck  ;  trying  whether  the  suspected  cnn  say  the 
Lord's  prayer ;  and  whether   the  aitiictt^d  falls 


MR.  IMATHER,  kc.  87 

at  the  slglif,  and  rises  at  the  touch,  of  tlie  sup- 
posed witch ;  as  also  by  the  afflicted  or  posses- 
sed giving  account  who  is  the  witch. 

Touching  these,  rnj  behei*  is,  that  'tis  highly 
derogatory  to  the  wisdom  of  the  wise  Lawgiv- 
er, to  assert,  that  he  has  given  a  hiw  by  Moses, 
the  penalty  whereof  is  death,  and  yet  no  direc- 
tion to  his  people,  whereby  to  know  and  detect 
the  culpable,  till  our  triumvirate,  messrs.  Per- 
kins, Gaule  and  Bernard,  had  given  us  their  re- 
ceipts; and,  that  that  fourth  head  of  mr.  Gaule, 
being  so  well  proved  by  sciipture,  is  a  truth, 
and  contains  a  full  and  clear  testmiony  who  are 
Avitches  culpable  of  death,  and  that  plainly  and 
from  scripture,  yet  not  excluding  any  other 
branch,  when  as  well  proved  by  that  infallible 
rule ;  and,  that  the  going  to  the  afflicted  or  pos- 
sessed, to  have  them  divine  who  are  witches  by 
their  spectral  sight,  is  a  great  wickedness,  even 
the  sin  of  Saul  (for  which  he  also  died)  but  with 
this  difference,  the  one  did  it  for  augury,  or  to 
know  future  events  ;  the  other,  in  order  to  take 
away  life  ;  and,  that  the  searching  for  teats, 
the  experiment  of  their  saying  the  Lord's  pray- 
er, the  falling  at  the  sight  and  rising  at  the 
touch  of  the  supposed  criminal,  being  all  of  them 
foreign  from  scripture,  as  well  as  reason,  are 
abominations  to  be  abhorred  and  repented  of; 
and,  that  our  Salem  witchcraft,  either  respect- 
ing the  judges  and  juries,  their  tenderness  of 
life,  or  the  multitude  and  pertinency  of  w^itness- 
es,  both  afflicted  and  confessors,  or  the  integrity 
of  the  historians,  is  as  authentic,  and  made  as 
certain,  as  any  event  of  that  kind  in  the  world. 


iid  LETTERS  TO 

And  yet  who  is  it  that  now  sees  not  through  it, 
and  that  these  were  the  sentiments  that  have 
procured  the  sorest  affliction,  and  most  lasting 
infamy,  that  ever  bel'el  this  country,  and  most 
like  so  to  do  again,  if  the  same  notions  be  still 
entertained?  and,  finally,  that  these  are  those 
last  times,  of  which  the  Spirit  speaks  expressly, 
Tim,  iv.  1  ? 

And  now,  ye  that  are  fathers  in  the  church- 
es, guides  to  the  people,  and  the  salt  of 
the  earth,  I  beseech  you  consider  these  things; 
and  if  you  find  the  glory  of  God  diminished  by 
ascribing  such  power  to  witches  and  devils  ;  his 
truths  opposed  by  these  notions ;  and  his  people 
aspersed  in  their  doctrines  and  reputations,  and 
endangered  in  their  lives — I  dare  not  dictate 
you — you  know  your  duty  as  watchmen — and 
the  Lord  be  with  you. 

But  if  you  find  my  belief  contrary  to  sound 
doctrine,  I  entreat  you  to  shew  it  me  by  the 
scripture  ;  and  in  the  mean  time  blame  me  not  if 
I  cannot  believe  that  there  are  several  Almigh- 
ties ;  for  to  do  all  sorts  of  w^onders,  beyond  and 
above  the  course  of  nature,  is  certainly  the  work 
of  Omnipotency.  So  also,  he  that  shall  com- 
mission or  empower  to  these,  must  also  be  al- 
mighty ;  and  I  think  it  not  a  sufficient  salvo,  to 
say  they  may  be  restrained  by  the  Most  High  ; 
and  hope  you  will  not  put  any  hard  construction 
on  these  my  endeavours  to  get  information  (all 
other  ways  failing)  in  things  so  needful  to  be 
known.  Praying  the  Almighty's  guidance  and 
protection,  1  am 

Yours  to  the  utmost  of  my  power, 

R.  C, 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  89 

Boston,  Sept.  the  20th,  1695. 
Mr.  Samuel  Willard, 
Rcvci^end  Sir, 
My  lormcr,  of  Marcli  the  18th,  directed  to 
tlie  Ministers  (and  which  was  lodged  with  your- 
self) containing  several  articles  which  I  sent  as 
my  behef,  praying  them  if  I  erred  to  shew  it  me 
by  scripture,  I  have  as  yet  had  no  answer  to,  ei- 
ther by  word  or  writing,  which  makes  mc  ga- 
ther that  they  are  approved  of  as  orthodox,  or 
at  least  that  they  have  such  foundations  as  that 
none  are  wilhng  to  manifest  any  opposition  to 
them ;  and  therefore,  with  submission,  &c.  I 
think  tiiat  that  late  seasonable  and  well-design- ' 
ed  dialogue,  intituled,  Sojne  Miscellaneous  Ob- 
servations, &c.  of  which  yourself  is  the  supposed 
author,  and  which  was  so  serviceable  in  the 
time  of  it,  is  yet  liable  to  a  mal-construction, 
ev^en  to  the  danger  of  reviving  what  it  most  op- 
poses, and  ol'  bringing  tiiose  practices  again  on 
foot,  which  in  tlie  day  of  them  were  so  terrible 
to  this  whole  country.  The  words,  which  I 
suppose  so  liable  to  Qjisconstruction,  are,  p.  14, 
B.  Who  informed  them.?-  S.  The  spectre,  B.  Verif 
good,  and  thafs  the  devil  turned  informer.  How 
an  good  men  like  to  fare,  against  whom  he  hath 
particular  malice  ?  It  is  but  a  prssumption,  and. 
wise  men  will  weigh  presumptions  against  presump- 
tions. There  is  to  be  no  examination  without 
grounds  of  suspicion.  Some  perjons  credit  nothimr 
to  be  accounted  too  good  to  be  undermined  so  far 
as  to  be  suspected  on  so  slight  a  ground  ;  and  it  is 
an  injury  done  them  to  bring  them  upoi  examina- 
tion, ivhich  renders  them  openlq  suspected.     I  will 


9«  LETTERS  TO 

tiot  deny  but  for  persons  already  suspected,  and  of' 
ill  fame,  it  may  occasion  their  being  examined* 
In  which,  these  words,  ^tis  hut  a  presumption,  &;c. 
and  some  persons  credit,  &c.  and  I  ivill  not  deny 
but  for  persons  already  suspected,  &c.  I  take  to 
be  waving  the  discussion  oi"  those  points,  the 
speaking  to  which  might  at  that  tirne  have  hin- 
dered the  usefulness  and  success  of  that  book, 
rather  than  any  declaring  the  sentiments  of  the 
author.  But  notwithstanding,  many  persons  will 
be  ready  to  undersf:ind  this  as  if  the  author  did 
wholly  leave  it  witli  the  justice,  to  jud,^e  wlio 
are  ill  persons,  sucli  as  the  devil's  accusations 
may  fasten  upon;  and  that  tiie  devil's  accusation 
of  a  person  is  a  presumption  against  them  of 
their  guilt ;  and  tliat,  upon  such  presumptions, 
they  may  be  had  to  examinatic.n,  if  the  justjce 
counts  them  persons  of  ill  fame;  for  the  author 
I  suppose  knows  that  the  bare  examuiation  will 
leave  such  a  stain  upon  them  (aiid  it  would  be 
well  if  their  posterity  escaped  it!)  as  the  length 
of  a  holy  and  unblamable  life  will  be  found  too 
short  to  extirpate.  And  if  the  justice  may  go  thus 
far  with  the  devil's  evidence,  then  the  addition 
of  a  story  or  two  of  some  cart  cverset,  or  per- 
sons taken  sick  after  a  quarrel,  might  as  w  ell  be 
thought  sufficient  for  their  commitment,  in  order 
to  tlieir  trial,  as  'tis  called,  (though  this  too  of- 
ten has  been  more  like  a  stage  play,  or  a  tragi- 
comic scene^  and  so  that  other  ways  useful  book 
mav  prove  the  greatest  snare  to  revive  the  same 
practices  again. 

These  things  being  so  liable,  as  I  said,  to  such 
nial-coiistruction,  it  were  needful  that  men  might 


MR.  MATHEK,  kc.  91 

he  undeceived,  and  the  matter  more  fully  de- 
monstrated, viz.  That  tlie  devil's  accusation  is 
not  so  much  as  any  presumption  against  the  life 
or  reputation  of  any  person  ;  (for  how  are  good 
men  like  to  fare,  if  his  malicious  accusations  may- 
be taken  as  a  presumption  of  their  guilt  ?)  and, 
that  his  accusations,  as  they  are  no  presumption 
agamst  persons  of  unspotted  fame,  so  neither 
are  to  be  heard,  or  any  ways  regarded,  against 
persons  though  otherways  of  ill  life,  much  less 
for  their  having  long  since  had  their  names  abu- 
sed by  his  outcries,  or  by  the  malice  of  ill  neigh- 
bours ;  and,  that  justice  knows  no  dilference  of 
persons  ;  that,  if  this  evidence  be  sufficient  to 
bring  one  person,  'tis  so  to  bring  any  otlier,  to 
examination,  and  consequently  to  the  utmost  ex- 
tent of  odium  which  such  examination  will  cer- 
tainly expose  them  to;  for  who  can  know  any 
other,  but  that  as  the  one  may  be  maliciously 
accused  by  devils  and  a  devilish  report  gone  be- 
fore it,  so  that  another,  who  has  not  been  so 
much  as  accused  before,  being  more  cunning  or 
more  seeming  religious,  might  yet  be  more  guil- 
ty ;  the  whole  depending  upon  invisible  evi- 
dence, of  which  iii visible  stuuj  though  we  have 
iiad  more  than  sudlclent,  yet  I  find  (among  other 
reverend  persons)  your  name  to  a  certain  print- 
ed paper,  which  runs  thus  ; 

Certain  Proposals^  made  by  the  President  and  Fellows  of 
llarjard  CoUege  to  the  reverend  Alinuttrs  of  the  Gospel^ 
in  the  several  churches  of  jYew- England. 

Fir.'it.  To  observe  aiui  record  the  more  illustrious 
discoveries  of  the  Divine  Providence  in  tiie  government 
^fthe  world,  is  a  design  so  holy,  so  useful,  so  justly  ajN 


02  LETTERS  TO 

proved,  that  the  too  general  neglect  of  it  in  the  churches 
of  God  is  as  justly  to  be  lamented. 

2.  For  the  redress  of  that  neglect,  although  all  christi- 
ans have  a  duty  incunibent  on  them,  yet  it  is  in  a  peculiar 
manner  to  be  recommended  unto  the  Ministers  of  the  gos- 
pel to  improve  the  special  advantages  which  are  in  their 
hands,  to  obtain  and  preserve  the  knowledge  of  such  no- 
table occurrences  as  are  sought  out  by  all  that  have 
pleasure  in  the  great  works  of  the  Lord. 

3.  The  things  to  be  esteemed  memorable,  are  specially 
all  unusual  accidents  in  the  heaven,  or  earth,  or  water; 
ail  wonderful  deliverances  of  the  distressed  ;  mercies  to 
the  ^odly  ;  judgments  on  the  wicked ;  and  more  glorious 
fulfilments  of  either  the  pi-omises  or  threatenings  in  the 
scriptures  of  truth  ;  with  apparitions,  possessions,  enchant- 
ments, and  all  extraordmary  things,  where:n  the  existence 
and  agency  of  the  Invisible  World  is  more  sensibly  <lc- 
monstrated. 

4.  It  is  therefore  proposed,  that  the  Ministers  through- 
out this  land  would  manifest  their  pious  regards  unto  the 
works  of  the  Lord,  and  the  operation  of  his  hands,  by 
reviving  their  cares  to  take  written  accounts  of  such  Re- 
markables ;  but  still  well  attested  with  credible  and  suf- 
ficient witnesses. 

5.  It  is  desired  that  the  accounts,  thus  taken,  of  these 
remarkables,  may  be  sent  to  the  President  or  Fellows  of 
th.  college,  by  whom  they  shall  be  carefully  reserved  for 
such  a  use  to  be  made  of  them,  as  may  by  some  tit  assem- 
bly of  Ministers  be  judged  most  conducing  to  the  glory 
of  God,  and  the  service  of  his  people. 

6.  Though  we  doul^t  not  that  love  to  the  name  of  God 
will  be  a  sufficient  motive  to  all  good  men  lo  contribute 
what  assistance  they  can  unto  this  undertaking;  yet,  for 
further  encouragement,  some  singular  marks  of  respect 
shall  be  studied  for  sr.ch  good  men,  as  will  actually  assist 
it,  by  takins*  pains  to  communicate  any  important  passa- 
ges proper  to  be  inserted  in  this  collection. 

Increase  Mather,  Pros, 


James  Allen^ 
Char.  JMortGii^ 
Sam.  Willard., 
Cotton  Mather^ 


John  Lever die^ 
Will  Brattle, 

Keh.  Walter, 

Fe!lo',vs. 


-enmbrldge,  ^larch  5,  1694. 


MR.  MATHER,  &i^.  93 

Here  being  an  encouragement  to  all  good 
men  to  send  in  such  remarkables  as  are  tlierein 
expressed,  I  have  sent  in  the  following ;  not 
that  I  think  them  a  more  sensible  demonstra- 
tion of  the  being  of  a  future  state  (with  rewards 
and  punishments)  or  of  angels  good  and  bad,  &c. 
than  the  scriptures  of  truth  hold  forth,  &c. ;  or 
than  any  of  those  other  demonstrations  God  hath 
given  us ;  for  this  were  treacherously  and  per- 
fidiously to  quit  the  post  to  the  enemy.  The 
sadducee,  deist  and  atheist  would  hereby  be 
put  in  a  condition  so  triumphantly  to  deny  the 
existence  and  agency  thereof,  as  that  a  few  sto- 
ries told  (which  at  best  must  be  owned  to  be 
fallible  and  liable  to  misrepresentations)  could 
not  be  thought  infallibly  sufficient  to  demonstrate 
the  truth  against  them.  I  have  heard  that  in  lo- 
gick  a  false  argument  is  reckoned  much  worse  than 
none;  yet,  supposing  that  a  collection  of  instan- 
ces may  be  many  ways  usei'ul,  not  only  to  the 
present  but  succeeding  ages,  I  have  sent  you  the 
following  remarkables,  which  have  lately  occur- 
red, the  certainty  of  which,  if  any  scruple  it,  will 
be  found  no  hard  matter  to  get  satisfaction  there- 
in. But  here,  not  to  insist  on  those  less  occur- 
rences, as  the  sudden  death  of  one  of  our  late 
justices;  and  a  like  mortality  that  fell  upon  the 
two  sons  of  another  of  them;  with  the  fall  of  a 
man  that  was  making  provision  to  raise  the  new 
northern  bell,  which,  when  it  was  up,  the  first 
person,  whose  death  it  was  to  signify,  was  said 
to  be  a  child  of  him,  who,  by  printing  and  speak- 
ing, had  had  as  great  a  hand  in  procuring  the 
late  actions  as  any,  if  not  the  greatest;  and  the 


94  LETTERS  TO 

spllltino^  the  gun  at  Salem,  \vhere  that  furious 
marshal,  and  his  lather,  &c.  were  rent  to  pieces, 
&:c.  As  to  all  these,  it  m<ist  be  owned,  that  no 
man  knows  love  or  hatred  by  all  that  is  before 
him,  much  less  can  thej  be  more  sensible  de- 
monstrations of  the  existence  and  agency  of  the 
invisible  world,  than  the  scriptures  of  truth  afford, 
&c.  though  the  rich  man  in  the  parable  might 
think  otherwise,  &c.  who  was  seeking  to  send 
some  more  sensible  demonstrations  thereof  to 
his  brethren,  &c.  In  that  tremendous  judgment 
cf  God  upon  this  country,  by  the  late  amazing 
prosecution  of  the  people  here,  under  the  no- 
tion of  witches;  whereby  twenty  suffered  as 
evil  doers,  (besides  those  that  died  in  prison) 
about  ten  more  condemned,  and  a  hundred  im- 
prisoned, and  about  two  hundred  more  accused, 
and  the  country  generally  in  fears  when  it  would 
come  to  their  turn  to  be  accused  ;  and  the  pros- 
ecution and  manner  of  trial  such,  that  most 
w^ould  have  chosen  to  have  fallen  into  the  hands 
of  the  barbarous  enemy,  rather  than  (under 
that  notion)  into  the  hands  of  their  brethren  in 
church  fellowship;  and,  in  short,  was  such  an 
affliction  as  far  exceeded  all  that  ever  this  coun- 
try hath  laboured  under — 

Yet  .in  this  mount  God  is  seen.  When  it  was 
thus  bad  with  this  distressed  people,  a  full  and 
a  sudden  stop  is  put,  not  only  without,  but 
against,  the  inclination  of  many;  for  out  of  the 
eater  came  forth  meat :  those  very  accusers, 
which  had  been  improved  as  witnesses  against 
so  many,  by  the  providence  of  the  Most  High, 
and  perhaps  blinded  with  malice,  are  left  to  ae- 


MR.  MATTFR,  &c.  95 

cuse  those  in  most  high  esteem,  both  macjis- 
trates  and  ministers,  as  guilty  ol*  witchcrait ; 
which  shewed  our  rulers,  that  necessity  lay  up- 
on them  to  conl'ound  that  v\  hicii  had  so  long  con- 
founded the  countiy,  as  being  themselves  unwil- 
ling to  run  the  same  risk :  this,  that  wns  in  the 
event  of  it,  to  this  country,  as  life  from  the  dead, 
is  most  easy  w  ith  Hnn,  in  whose  hands  are  the 
hearts  of  all  men,  and  was  a  very  signal  delive- 
rance to  this  whole  country.  No  less  observa- 
ble was  it,  tliat  though  at  the  time  when  the 
devil's  testimony,  by  the  afflicted,  was  first  laid 
aside,  there  were  great  numbers  of  (real  or  pre- 
tended) afflicted ;  yet  w  hen  this  was  once  not  judg- 
ed of  validity  enough  to  be  any  longer  brought 
into  the  court  against  tlie  accused  as  ca  ideixe, 
the  affliction  generally  ceased,  and  only  some 
remainders  of  it  in  such  places,  where  more  en- 
couragement was  given  to  the  actors,  God  seem- 
ing thereby  plainly  to  decipher  that  sin  of  go- 
ing to  the  devil,  &c.  as  the  rise  and  foundation 
of  those  punishments. 

And  thus,  reverend,  1  have,  as  I  understand  if, 
performed  my  duty  herein,  for  the  glory  of 
God,  and  the  well-being  of  men.  And  for  my 
freedom  used  in  this  and  former  writinp^s,  rela- 
ting to  the  actors  in  this  tragedy,  I  shall  not 
apologize,  but  give  you  the  words  oi"  one  to 
whom  some  can  aiford  the  title  of  venerable 
(when  he  is  arguing  for  that  which  they  have 
undertaken  to  assert,  thougli  at  other  times  more 
diminutive  epithets  must  serve)  ;  it  is  the  rever- 
end mr.  R.  Baxter,  in  hjs  book,  the  Cure  of 
Church  Divisions,  pages    257,  258.     "But   [I 


96  LETTERS  TO 

pray  you  mark  it]  the  way  of  God  is  to  shame 
the  sinner,  how  good  soever  in  other  respects, 
that  the  sin  may  have  the  greater  shame,   and 
rehgion  may  not  be  ashamed,  as   if  it   allowed 
men  to  sin:  nor  God,  the  author  of  rehgion,  be 
dislionoured ;  nor  others  be  without  the  warning : 
but  the  way  of  the  devil  is,  to  hide  or  justiiy  the 
sin,   as  if  it   were  for   fear  of  disparaging   the 
goodness  of  the  persons  that  committed  it ;  that 
so  he  may  hereby  dishonour  rehgion  and  godh- 
ness   itself,  and  make   men    believe  it  is   but  a 
cover  for  any  wickedness,  and  as  consistent  with 
it  as  a  looser  life   is,  and  that  he  may  keep  the 
sinner  from  repenting,  and   blot  out  the   memo- 
ry of  that  warning  which  should  have  preserved 
after  ages  from  the  like  falls.     Scripture  sham- 
eth  the  professors  (though  a  David,  a  Solomon, 
Peter,  JVoah^  or  Lot)  that  the  religion  profest 
may  not  be    ashamed,   but    vindicated.     Satan 
would   preserve  the   honour  of  professors,  that 
the  religion  professed  may  bear  the  shame ;  and 
so  it  may  fall  on  God  himself." 

And  now  that  all  that  have  had  a  hand  in 
any  horrid  and  bloody  practices  may  be  brought 
to  give  glory  to  God,  and  take  the  due  shame 
to  themselves;  and  that  our  watchmen  may  no 
longer  seek  to  palliate,  (much  less  give  thanks 
for  such,  d:c.  thereby  making  them  their  own) 
and  that  the  people  may  no  longer  perish  for 
want  of  knowledge  in  the  midst  of  such  means 
of  light,  nor  God  be  any  longer  dishonoured  by 
false  sentiments  in  these  matters,  is  the  earnest 
desire  and  prayer  of,  sir.  yours  to  my  power, 


MR.  MATHER,  &c  .^7 

Mr.  Cotton  Mather, 
Reverend  Sir^ 
Having  long  since  sent  you  some  doctrinals 
as  to  my  belief,  together  with  my  request  to 
you,  that  if  I  erred  you  Avould  be  pleased  to 
shew  it  me  by  scripture,  viz.  That  the  devil's 
bounds  are  set,  which  he  cannot  pass;  that  the 
devils  are  so  full  of  malice  that  it  cannot  be  ad- 
ded to  by  mankind  ;  that  where  he  hath  poAver 
he  neither  can  nor  will  omit  executing  it;  that 
'tis  only  the  Almighty  that  sets  bounds  to  his 
rage,  and  that  only  can  commission  him  to  hurt 
and  destroy,  &;c.  But  instead  of  such  an  an- 
swer as  was  promised  and  justly  expected,  you 
were  pleased  to  send  me  a  book,  which  you 
since  called  an  ungainsayable  one;  which  book, 
till  lately  I  have  not  had  opportunity  so  fully  to 
consider.  And  to  the  end  you  may  see  1  have 
now  done  it,  I  have  sent  to  you  some  of  the  re- 
markables  contained  in  the  said  book,  intituled, 
"  The  Certainty  of  the  World  of  Spirits^'*  written 
by  Mr,  R.  B.  London^  printed  1691.  It  is 
tlierein  conceded  (preface)  that  to  see  devils 
and  spirits  ordinarily  would  not  be  enough  to 
convince  atheists.  Page  88,  Atheists  are  not 
to  be  convinced  by  stories;  their  own  senses  are 
not  enough  to  convince  them  any  more  than 
sense  will  convince  a  papist  from  transubstantia- 
tion.  (Z).  Laderd.)  P.  4,  No  spirit  can  do  any 
thing  but  by  God's  will  and  permission.  Pre- 
face, 'Tis  the  free  will  of  man  that  gives  the 
devils  their  hurting  power;  and  without  our 
own  consent  they  cannot  hurt  us.  It  is  asserted, 
p.  222,  223,  That  it  is  a  perverse  opposition  of 
9 


93  LETTERS  TO 

poperj  which  causes  many  protcstants  not  Co 
regard  the  benefits  we  receive  by  angels.  And 
ministers  are  faulty,  that  do  not  pray  and  give 
thanks  to  God  lor  their  ministry ;  and  that  ne- 
glect to  teach  believers,  v,hat  love  and  what 
thanks  thej-  owe  to  angels.  P.  225,  Most  good 
people  look  so  much  to  God  and  to  ministers^ 
that  they  take  little  notice  of  angels,  which  are 
God's  great  ministers.  P.  234,  The  author 
dares  not,  as  some  have  done,  judge  the  catho- 
lic church  to  become  antichristian  idolaters,  as 
soon  ^s  they  gave  too  mucli  worship  to  saints 
and  angels.  P.  7,  The  blessed  souls  shall  be  like 
the  angels,  therefore  may  appear  here.  P.  3,  4, 
'Tis  hard  to  know  whether  it  be  a  devil  or  a 
human  soul  that  appears,  or  whether  the  soul  of 
a  good  or  a  bad  person;  p,  61,  or  the  soul  of 
some  dead  fiiend  tliat  suifers,  and  yet  retains 
love,  kc.  P.  222,  No  doubt  the  souls  of  the 
Avicked  carry  with  them  their  former  inclina- 
tions of  covetousness,  revenge,  &c.  P.  7,  When 
revengeful  things  are  done,  as  on  murderers, 
de fraud ers,  &c.  it  seems  to  be  from  the  revenge- 
ful wrath  of  some  bad  soul ;  if  it  be  about  money 
or  lands,  then  from  a  worldly-minded  one;  some 
significations  of  God's  mercy  to  wicked  souls 
after  this  life.  P.  4,  'Tis  a  doubt  whether,  be- 
sides the  angels  (good  and  bad)  and  the  souls  of 
men,  there  is  not  a  third  sort,  called  fairies  and 
goblins.  It  is  unsearchable  to  us  liow  far  God 
leaves  spirits  to  free  will  in  small  things,  suspend- 
ing his  predetermining  motion.  P.  246,  The 
devils  have  a  marvellous  power,  if  but  a  silly 
wretched  witch  consent.     P.  10,  202,  TItc  sto- 


MR.  MATIIKR,  &c.  99 

ties  of  witches  and  spirits  arc  many  ways  useful, 
particularly  to  convince  atheists,  and  confirm 
believers,  and  to  prove  the  operation  of  spirits. 
P.  232,  To  help  men  to  understand  tliat  devils 
make  no  small  number  of  laws,  and  rulers  in  the 
world,  and  are  authors  of  most  of  the  wars,  and 
of  many  sermons,  and  of  books  that  adorn  the 
libraries  of  learned  men.  P.  6,  102,  The  devil's 
lying  with  the  witch  is  not  to  be  denied,  and  is 
more  to  exercise  the  lust  of  the  witch  than 
of  the  devil,  who  can  also  bring  in  anothei* 
witch  without  opening  the  door,  and  so  perform 
it  by  one  witch  with  another.  P.  105,  Witches 
can  raise  storms,  sell  winds,  &c.  as  is  commonly 
affirmed.  P.  107,  In  America  it  is  a  common 
thing  to  see  spirits,  day  and  night.  P.  95, 
96,  97,  110,  Stories  of  a  child  that  could  not 
be  cured  of  witchcraft,  because  the  ember- 
weeks  were  past ;  vomited  a  knife  a  span  long, 
cart  nails,  &c.  and  neither  eat  nor  drank,  fifteen 
days  and  nights  together;  a  long  piece  of  wood, 
four  knives,  and  two  sharp  pieces  of  iron,  everv 
one  above  a  span  long,  taken  out  of  the  sto- 
mach, ike.  hair,  stones,  bones,  vomited,  <kc.  a 
thousand  pounds  of  blood  lost  by  one  person  in 
a  year's  time.  P.  250,  A  story  that  makes  the 
author  think  it  possible  that  such  great  things, 
as  he  mentions,  should  be  gotten  down  and  up  peo- 
ple's throats.  P.  I6i,  Partial  credibility  spoils 
many  a  good  story.  R  125,  The  devil's  sub- 
stance enters  into  the  possessed.  P.  174,  Dis- 
tracted are  possessed.  P.  149,  A  sick  woman, 
while  she  lay  in  bed,  went  to  see  her  children. 
P.  15:^,  A  dog  appeared  like   a  fly    or  a  fleas 


aOO  LETTERS   TG 

P.  165,  Some  knowing  agents  direct  thunder 
storms,  though  the  author  knows  not  who ;  and 
that  they  so  often  fall  on  churches,  he  knows 
not  why.  P.  2,  80,  Mr.  I.  M.  and  mr.  C.  M. 
recommended,  together  with  Bodin,  ^^c.  P.  237, 
A.crispian,  if  through  ignorance  he  beheves  not 
what  he  saith,  may  be  a  christian. 

In  this,  sir,  I  suppose  that  if  1  have  not  wrong- 
ed the  sense  of  the  author  in  the  places  quoted 
(which  I  trust  you  shall  not  find  I  have  done)  I 
cannot  be  thought  accountable  for  the  errors  or 
contradictions  to  himself  or  to  the  truth,  if  any 
such  be  found,  particularly  what  he  grants  in  the 

Ere  face,  of  the  free  will  of  man  giving  the  devil 
is  hurting  power ;  this  being  not  only  more 
than  those  called  witch-advocates  would  desire 
to  be  conceded  to  them,  but  is  a  palpable  and 
manifest  overturning  the  author's  design  in  all 
his  witch  stories  ;  (for  who  would  consent  to 
have  the  devil  afflict  himself?)  as  also  his  con- 
cession, that  no  spirit  can  do  any  thing  but  by 
God's  will  and  permission;  I  cannot  persuade 
myself  but  you  must  be  sensible  of  their  appa- 
rent contradictoriness  to  the  rest.  Others  there 
are  of  a  very  ill  aspect ;  as,  p.  234,  the  catho- 
licks  are  much  encouraged  in  their  adoration 
of  angels  and  saints,  if  that  were  so  innocent  as 
not  to  render  them  antichristian  Idolaters;  and 
that,  p.  4,  if  admitted,  will  seem  to  lay  an  un- 
gainsayable  foundation  for  the  pagan,  Indian 
and  diabollst's  faith,  by  telling  us  it  is  beyond 
our  search  to  know  how  far  God  leaves  the  de- 
vils to  free  will,  to  do  what  they  please,  in  this 
world,  with  a  suspension  of  God's  predetermina- 


MR.  MATHER,  &,c.  101 

tion ;  which  if  it  were  a  truth,  what  were  more 
rational  than  to  obhge  him  that  has  such  power 
over  us  ?     The  atheists  also  would  take  encou- 
ragement if  it  were  granted  that  we  cannot  know 
how  far  God  suspends  his  predetermining  mo- 
tion :  they  would  thence  affirm,  we  as  little  know 
that  there  is  a  predetermining;  motion,  and  con- 
sequently whether  there  be  a  God,  and  p.  165 
would  abundantly  strengthen  them,  when  such 
a   learned,    experienced     and   Iiighly-esteemed 
christian  shall  own  that  he  knows  not  who  it  is 
that  governs  the  thunder-storms  :  for  it  might 
as  well  discover  ignorance,  who  it  is  that  dispo- 
ses of  earthquakes,  gun-shot,  and  afflictions  that 
befal   any,    with   the  rest   of  mundane  events. 
I  design  not  to  remark  all  that  in  the  book  is  re- 
markable, such  as  the  departed  souls  wandering 
again  hither  to  put  men  upon  revenge,  &;c.  sa- 
vouring so  much  of  Pythagoras's  transmigration 
of  souls,  and  the  separation  of  the  soul  from  the 
body  without  death,  as  in  the  case  of  her  that 
went  to  see  her  children,  while  yet  she  did  not 
stir  out  of  her  bed,  which  seems  to  be  a  new 
speculation ;  unless  it  determines  in  favour  of 
transubstantiation,  that  a  body  may  be  at  the 
same  time  in  several  places.     Upon  the  Avhole, 
it  is  un^ainsavable,    that  that   book,  thouirh  so 
higiily  extolled,  may  be  justly  expected  to  occa- 
sion the  staggering  of  the  weak,  and  th^  har- 
dening of  unbelievers  in  their  infidelity.    And  it 
seems  amazing,  that  you  should  not  only  give  it 
such  a  recommendation,  but  that  you  should  send 
it  to  me,  in  order  (as  I  take  it)  to  pervert  me 

from  the  belief  of  these  fundamental  doctrinals 
9# 


102  LETTERS  TO 

(above  recited)  though  I  account  ihem    tiiore 
firm  than  heaven  and  earth.    But  that  which  is 
yet  more  strange  to  me,  is,  that  mr.  B's  friends 
did  not  advise  him  better,  than  in  his  decHned 
age  to  emit  such  crude  matter  to   the  pubhck. 
As  to  the  sometime  reverend  author,    let  his 
works  praise  the  remembrance  of  him  ;  but  for 
such  as  are  either  erroneous  and  foisted  upon 
him,  or  the  effect  of  an  aged  imbecihtj,  let  them 
be  detected,  that  thej  may  proceed  no  further* 
I  am  not  ignorant  that  the  manner  of  educa- 
tion of  youth,   in,  I  think,   almost  all  christian 
schools,  hath  a  natural  tdndency  to  propagate 
those  doctrines  of  devils  heretofore  solely  prc- 
fest  among  ethnicks,  and  particularly  in  matters 
of   witchcraft,    &c.     For,  notwithstanding    the 
council    of  Carthage,    taking   notice    that    the 
christian  doctors  did  converse  much  with  the 
writings  of  the  heathens  for  the  gaining  of  elo- 
quence, forbad  the  reading  of  the  books  of  the 
gentiles  ;  yet  it  seems  this  was  only  a  bill  with- 
out a  penalty,    which  their  successors  did  not 
look  upon  to  be  binding.    He  that  should  In  this 
age  take  a  view  of  the  schools,  might  be  induced 
to  believe   that    the  ages  since  have  thought, 
that  w^ithout  such  heathen  learning  a  man  can- 
not be  so  accomplished,  as  to  have  any  pretence 
to   academick  literature  ;  and  that  the  vulgar 
might  not  be  without  the  benetit  of  such  iearPi- 
ing,  some  of  their  disciples  have  taught  them  to 
speak  english,  w^hich  has  given  me  the  opportu- 
nity to  send  you  these  following  verse?. 

Virg.  Bucolicks — Ed.  13. 
Sure  love  k  not  the  cause  their  bones  appear  j. 
Some  eyes  bewitch  mv  teodfr  Jamb?!.  I  fear 


MR.  MATHER,  kc.  103 

Ed.  8. 
For  me  these  herbs  in  Pontu^,  Maeris  chose  ,* 
There  evVy  powerful  drug  in  plenty  grows;. 
Transformed  to  a  wolf  1  often  MaRris  saw, 
Then  into  shady  woods  himself  withdraw  : 
Olt  he  from  deepest  sepulchres  would  charm 
Departed  souls  ;  and  from  another's  farm, 
Into  his  own  ground,  corn  yet  standing  take. 
Now  from  the  town  my  charms  bring  Daphnis  back. 
V'anquish'd  with  charms,  from  heaven  the  moon  descends, 
Circe  with  charms  transform''d  Ulysses'  friends; 
Charms  in  the  tield  will  burst  a  poisonous  snake. 
Now  from  the  town,  &c. 

OviWs  Metam.  Lib.  7. 
Her  arms  thrice  turns  about,  thrice  wets  her  crown 
With  gather'd  dew,  thrice  yawns,  and  kneeling  down;. 
Oh  night !  thou  friend  to  secrets!  you,  clear  tires, 
That  with  the  moon  succeed  when  day  retires ; 
Great  Hecate  thou  know'st,  and  aid  imparts, 
To  our  design,  your  charms  and  magick  arts  : 
And  thou,  oh  earth,  that  to  magicians  yields 
Thy  powerful  simples  ;  air,  winds,  mountains,  fields, 
Soft  murmuring  springs,  still  lakes,  and  rivers  clear. 
Ye  gods  of  woods,  ye  gods  of  night,  appear  ; 
By  you,  at  will,  I  make  swift  streams  retire 
To  their  first  fountam,  while  their  banks  admire  ; 
Seas  rough  make  smooth  ;  clear  skies  with  clouds  deform ; 
Storms  turn  to  calms,  and  make  a  calm  a  storm. 
With  spells  and  charms,  1  break  the  viper's  jaw, 
Cleave  solid  rock*;,  oaks  from  their  fissures  draw  ; 
Whole  woods  remove,  the  airy  mountains  shake; 
Earth  force  to  groan,  and  ghosts  from  graves  awake.. 
Lib.  14. 

her  journey  takes 

To  Rhegium,  opposite  to  Zante's  shore, 
And  treads  the  troubled  waves,  that  loudly  roar; 
Running  with  unwet  feet  on  that  profound, 
As  if  sh'  had  trod  upon  the  solid  ground. 
This  with  portentous  poison  she  pollutes. 
Besprinkled  with  the  juice  of  wicked  roots  ; 
In  words  dark  and  perplexed,  nine  times  thrice. 
Enchantments  utters  with  her  wicked  voice.  Stc. 


104  LETTERS  TO 

These  fables  of  the  heathens  (though  in 
themselves  of  no  more  validity  than  the  idle 
tales  of  an  indian,  or  the  discourses  of  a  known 
romancer)  are  become  the  school-learning,  not 
to  say  the  faith,  of  christians,  and  are  the  scrip- 
tures brought  (instead  of  that  most  sure  word) 
if  not  to  prove  doctrine,  yet  as  illustrations 
thereof.  Cases  of  Conscience  concerning  Witchc, 
page  25 ;  Remarkable  Providences^  page  250. 
This  perhaps  might  be  the  cause  that  in  Eng- 
land, a  people  othf  rwise  sober  and  religious,  have 
for  some  ages  in  a  manner  wholly  refused  admit- 
ting those  not  so  educated  to  the  work  of  the 
ministry.  Such  education  and  practice  have  so 
far  prevailed,  that  it  has  been  a  means  of  cor- 
rupting the  christian  world,  almost  to  that  de- 
gree as  to  be  ungainsayable ;  for  though  there 
is  reason  to  hope  that  these  diabolical  principles 
have  not  so  prevailed  (with  multitudes  of  chris- 
tians) as  that  they  ascribe  to  a  witch  and  a  devil 
the  attributes  peculiar  to  the  Almighty  ;  yet 
how  few  are  willing  to  be  found  opposing  such 
a  torrent,  as  knowing  that  in  so  doing  they  shall 
be  sure  to  meet  with  opposition  to  the  utmost, 
from  the  many,  both  of  magistrates,  ministers 
and  people  ;  and  the  name  of  sadducee,  atlieist, 
and  perhaps  witch  too,  cast  upon  them  most  li- 
berally, by  men  of  the  highest  profession  in  god« 
liness;  and  if  not  so  learned  as  some  of  them- 
selves, then  accounted  only  fit  to  be  trampled 
on,  and  their  arguments  (though  both  rational 
and  scriptural)  as  fit  only  for  contempt.  But 
though  this  be  the  deplorable  dilemma,  yet 
some  have  dared  I'rcm  time  to  time  (for  the  glo- 


MR.  MATHER,  &g.  105 

ry  of  God,  and  the  ^ood  and  safety  of  men's 
lives,  &c.)  to  run  all  these  risks.  And  that  God 
who  has  said.  My  glory  I  will  not  give  to  another^ 
is  able  to  protect  those  that  are  found  doing 
their  duty  herein  against  ail  opposers ;  and, 
however  otherways  contemptible,  can  make 
them  useful  in  his  own  hand,  who  has  sometimes 
chosen  the  weakest  instruments,  that  his  power 
may  be  the  more  illustrious. 

And  now,  reverend  sir,  if  you  are  conscious 
to  yourself,  that  you  have,  in  your  principles  or 
practices,  been  abetting  to  such  grand  errors,  I 
cannot  see  how  it  can  consist  with  sincerity,  to 
be  so  convinced  in  matters  so  nearly  relating  to 
the  glory  of  God,  and  lives  of  innocents,  and  at 
the  same  time  so  much  to  fear  disparagement 
among  men,  as  to  trifle  with  conscience,  and  dis- 
semble an  approving  of  former  sentiments.  You 
know  that  word.  He  that  honoureth  me  I  will  ho- 
nour^ and  he  that  despiseth  me  shall  be  lightly 
esteemed.  But  if  you  think  that  in  these  matters 
you  have  done  your  duty,  and  taught  the  peo- 
ple theirs ;  and  that  the  doctrines  cited  from 
the  above  mentioned  book  are  ungainsayable  ; 
I  shall  conclude  in  almost  his  words,  He  that 
teaches  such  doctrine,  if  through  ignorance  he 
believes  not  wiiat  he  saith,  may  be  a  christian  ; 
but  if  he  believes  them,  he  is  in  the  broad  path 
to  heatlienism,  devilism,  popery,  or  atheism.  It 
is  a  solemn  caution,  (Gal.  i.  8)  But  though  ive^  or 
an  angel  fiom  heaven^  preach  any  other  gospel  un- 
to you  than  that  which  we  have  preached  unto  you, 
let  him  be  accursed.  I  hope  you  will  not  miscon- 
strue my  intentions  herein,  who  am,  reverend 
sir,  yours  to  command  in  what  I  may,       K,  C, 


i06  LETTERS  TO 

To  the  Ministers  in  and  near  Boston. 

Jan.  12,  1696. 

Christianity  had  been  but  a  short  time  in  the 
world,  when  there  was  raised  against  it,  not  on- 
ly open  profest  enemies,  but  secret  and  inbred 
underminers,  who  sought  thereby  to  effect  that 
which  open  force  had  been  so  often  baffled  in. 
And  notwithstanding  that  primitive  purity  and 
sincerity,  which  in  some  good  measure  was  still 
retained,  yet  the  cunning  deceivers  and  apostate 
hereticks  found  opportunity  to  beguile  the  un- 
wary, and  this  in  fundamentals. 

Among  others  which  then  sprung  up,  with 
but  too  much  advantage,  in  the  third  century, 
the  maniche  did  spread  his  pestiferous  senti- 
ments, and  taught  the  existence  of  two  beings,  or 
causes  of  all  things,  viz.  a  good  and  a  bad:  but 
these  were  soon  silenced  by  the  more  orthodox 
doctors,  and  anathematized  by  general  councils. 
And  at  this  day  the  american  indians,  another 
sort  of  maniche,  entertaining  (thus  far)  the  same 
belief,  hold  it  their  prudence  and  interest  to 
please  that  evil  being,  as  well  by  perpetrating 
other  murders,  as  by  their  bloody  sacrifices,  that 
so  he  may  not  harm  them.  The  iron  teeth  of 
time  have  now  almost  devoured  the  name  of 
the  former;  and  as  to  the  latter,  it  is  to  be  ho- 
ped that  as  Christianity  prevails  among  them, 
they  WAX  abhor  such  abominable  belief 

And  as  those  primitive  times  were  not  privil- 
eged against  the  spreading  of  dangerous  heresy, 
so  neither  can  any  now  pretend  to  any  such  im- 
munity, though  professing  the  enjoyment  of  a 
primitive  purity. 


MR.  MATHER,  kc.  107 

Might  a  judgment  be  made  from  the  books  of 
the  modem  learned  divines,  or  from  the  [practice 
of  courts,  or  from  the  faith  of  many  who  call 
tliemselves  cliristians,  it  might  be  modestly, 
though  sadly,  concluded,  that  the  doctrine  of  the 
maniche,  at  least  great  part  of  it,  is  so  far  from 
being  forgotten,  that  it  is  almost  cvcrv  where 
prolest.  We  in  these  ends  of  the  earth  need 
not  seek  far  for  instances  in  each  respect  to  de- 
monstrate this.  The  books  here  printed  and 
recommended,  not  only  by  the  respective  au- 
thors, but  by  many  of  their  brethren,  do  set  forth 
that  the  devil  inflicts  plagues,^  wars,t  diseases,^ 
tempests,§  and  can  render  the  most  solid  things 
invisible, II  and  can  do  things  above  and  against 
the  course  of  nature,  and  all  natural  causes. 

Are  tliese  the  expressions  of  orthodox  believ- 
ers ?  or  are  they  not  rather  expressions  becoming 
a  maniche,  or  a  heathen,  as  agreeing  far  better 
with  these  than  with  the  sacred  oracles,  our 
only  rulf}?  the  whole  current  whereof  is  so  dia- 
metrically opposite  thereto,  that  it  were  almost 
endless  to  mention  all  the  divine  cautions  against 
such  abominable  belief;  he  that  runs  may  read, 
Ps,  Ixii.  11,  andcxxxvi.  4.  Lam.  ill.  37.  .^?nos  ill,  6. 
Jer,  iv.  22.  Ps.  Ixxvlii.  26,  and  clxviil.  6,  8.  Job 
xxxviii.  22  to  34. 

These  places,  with  a  multitude  more,  do  abun- 
dantly testily,  that  the  asserters  of  such  power 
to  be  in  the  evil  being,  do  speak  in  a  dialect 
different  from  the  scriptures,    (laying    a    firm 

*  Wonders  of  the  Invisible  World  p.  17,  18. tp.  IS. 

J  Cases  of  Conscience,  p.  G3. §  Remarkable  Provi- 
dences, p.  124. j]  Wonders  of  the  Invisible  World,  p. 

141. 


108  LETTERS  TO 

foundation  for  the   Indians'    adorations,   which^ 
aojrees  well  with  what  A.  Ross  sets  forth,  in  his 
Mistag.  Poetic,  p.    116,  that  their   ancients  did 
worship  the  furies  and  their  god  Averinci^  that 
they  might  forbear  to  hurt  them.) 

And  have  not  the  courts  in  some  parts  of  the 
world,  by  their  practices,  testified  their  concur- 
rence w^ith  such  belief;  prosecuting  to  death 
many  people  upon  that  notion,  of  their  improv- 
ing such  power  of  the  evil  one,  to  the  raising  of 
storms  ;  afflicting  and  killing  of  others,  though 
at  great  distance  from  them;  doing  things  in 
their  own  persons  above  human  strength  ;  des- 
troy i.'g  cattle,  flying  in  the  air,  turning  themselves 
into  cats,  dugs,  <kc.  ?  which  by  the  way  must  needs 
imply  something  of  goodness  to  be  in  that  evil 
being,  who,  though  he  has  such  power,  would 
nor  exert  it,  were  it  not  for  this  people,  or  else 
that  the\  can  some  way  add  to  this  mighty 
power. 

And  are  the  people  a  whit  behind  in  their 
belief?  Is  there  any  thing  above  mentioned, 
their  strong  faith  looks  upon  to  be  too  hard  for 
this  evil  being  to  etiect? 

Here  it  will  be  answered,  God  permits  it 
Which  answ^er  is  so  I'ar  an  owning  the  doctrine, 
that  the  devil  lias  in  his  nature  a  power  to  do 
ail  these  things,  and  can  exert  this  powxr,  except 
when  he  is  restrained,  that  it  is  in  effect  to  say 
that  God  has  made  nature  to  fight  against  itself; 
that  he  has  made  a  creature,  who  has  it  in  the 
power  of  his  nature  to  overthrow  nature,  and  to 
act  above  and  against  it.  Which  he  that  can 
believe  may  as  vvell  believe  the  greatest  contra- 


MR.  MATHER,  kc.  109 

diction.  That  being  which  can  do  this  in  the 
smallest  thing,  can  do  it  in  the  greatest.  Il  Mo- 
ses, with  a  bare  permission,  might  stretch  fortli 
his  rod,  yet  he  was  not  able  to  bring  plagues 
upon  the  Egyptians,  or  to  divide  the  waters, 
without  a  commission  from  the  Most  High  ;  so 
neither  can  that  evil  being  perfjiin  any  of  this 
without  a  commission  from  tlie  same  power. 
The  scripture  recites  more  miracles  wrought 
by  men  than  by  angels  good  and  bad.  Though 
this  doctrine  be  so  dishonourable  to  tlie  only 
Almighty  Being,  as  to  ascribe  such  attributes  to 
the  evil  one,  as  are  the  incommunicable  [)rero- 
gative  oihim,  who  is  the  alone  Sovereign  Being, 
yet  here  is  not  all ;  but,  as  he  that  steers  by  a 
false  compass,  the  further  he  sails  the  more  he 
is  out  of  his  way;  so,  though  there  is  in  some 
things  a  variation  from,  there  is  in  others  a  fur- 
ther progression  in,  or  building  upon,  the  said 
doctrine  of  the  maniche. 

Men  in  this  age  are  not  content  barely  to  be- 
lieve such  an  exorbitant  power  to  be  in  the  na- 
ture of  this  evil  being;  but  have  imagined  that 
he  prevails  with  many  to  sign  a  book,  or  make 
a  contract  with  him,  whereby  they  are  enabled 
to  perform  all  the  tilings  above  mentioned. 
Another  account  is  given  hereof,  viz.  That  by 
virtue  of  such  a  covenant  they  attain  power  to 
commission  him.  And  though  the  two  parties 
are  not  agreed  which  to  put  it  upon,  whether 
the  devil  empowers  the  witch,  or  the  witch 
commissions  him;  yet  both  parties  ^re  agreed 
in  this,  that  one  way  or  other  the  mischief  is  ef- 
fected, and  so  the  criminal  becomes  culpable  of 
10 


110  LETTERS  TO 

death.  In  the  search  after  such  a  sort  of  cri- 
minals, how  many  countries  have  fallen  into 
such  convulsions,  that  neither  the  devastations 
made  by  a  conquering  enemy,  nor  the  plague 
itself,  have  been  so  f  )nnidable. 

That  not  only  good  persons  have  thus  been 
blemished  in  their  reputations,  but  much  inno- 
cent blood  hath  been  shed,  is  testified  even  by 
those  very  books.:  Cases  of  Conscience,  p.  33. 
Remarkable  Frovicl.  p.  179.  Memor,  Provid, 
p.  28. 

And  (to  add)  what  less  can  be  expected, 
when  men,  having  taken  up  such  a  belief,  of  co- 
venanting, afflicting  and  killing  witches,  aud, 
comparing  it  with  the  scripture,  finding  no  foot- 
steps therein  of  such  a  sort  of  wntch,  have 
thereupon  desperately  concluded,  that  though 
the  scripture  is  full  in  it,  that  a  witch  should  not 
live,  yet  that  it  has  not  at  all  described  ihe 
crime,  nor  means  whereby  the  culpable  might 
be  detected  } 

And  hence  they  are  fallen  so  far  as  to  reckon 
it  necessary  to  make  use  of  those  diabolical  and 
bloody  ways,  always  heretofore  practised,  for 
their  discovery  ;  as  finding  that  the  rules,  given 
to  detect  other  crimes,  are  w4iolly  useless  for 
the  discovery  of  such. 

This  is  that  which  has  produced  that  deluge 
of  blood  mentioned,  and  must  certainly  do  so 
again,  the  same  belief  remaining. 

And  wdio  can  wonder,  if  christians  that  are 
so  easily  prevailed  with  to  lay  aside  their 
swords  as  useless,  and  so  have  lost  their 
strength,  are  (with  vSamson)    led   blindfold  in- 


MR.  MATllETl,  kc.  Ill 

to  an  idol  tcrn[)lc,  to  make  sport  for  enemies 
and  inlidels,  and  to  do  abominable  actions,  not 
only  not  christian,  but  ao;ainst  even  tlie  light 
ol"  nature  and  reason  ?  And  now,  reverend  la- 
thers, you  who  are  appointed  as  guides  to  the 
people,  and  whose  li[js  should  preserve  know- 
ledge ;  who  are  set  as  shepherds,  and  as  watch- 
men ;  this  matter  appertains  to  you.  I  wrote 
to  you  formerly  under  this  head,  and  acquainted 
you  with  my  sentiments,  requesting  that  if  1  er- 
red, you  would  be  pleased  to  shew  it  me  by 
scripture  ;  but  from  your  silence  I  gather  that 
you  approve  thereof.  For  I  may  reasonably 
presume,  that  you  would  have  seen  it  your  duty 
to  have  informed  me  better,  if  you  had  been 
sensible  of  any  error.  But  if  in  this  matter  you 
have  acquitted  yourselves  beconaing  the  titles 
you  are  dignified  with,  you  have  cause  of  re- 
joicing in  the  midst  of  calamities  that  afflict  a 
sinning  w^orld. 

Particularly,  if  you  have  taught  the  people 
to  fear  God,  and  trust  in  him,  and  not  to  fear  a 
witch  or  a  devil — That  the  devil  has  no  power 
to  afflict  any  with  diseases,  or  loss  of  cattle,  &;c. 
without  a  commission  from  the  Most  High — 
That  he  is  so  filled  with  malice,  that  whatever 
commission  he  may  have  against  any,  he  will 
not  fail  to  execute  it — That  no  mortal  ever  was, 
or  can  be,  able  to  commission  him,  or  to  length- 
en his  chain  in  the  least,  and  that  he  who  only 
can  commission  him  is  God  ;  and  that  the  scrip- 
tures of  truth  not  only  assign  the  punishment  of 
a  witch,  but  give  suihcient  rules  to  detect  them 
by  ^  and  that,   according  to  mr.  Gaule's  fourth 


Hi;  LETTERS  TO 

head,  a  witch  is  one  that  hates  and  opposes  the 
word,  work  and  worship  of  God,  and  seeks  by 
a  sign  to  seduce  therefrom — That  they  who  are 
gu iky  according  to  that  head,  are  guiUy  of  witch- 
craft, and  by  the  law  given  to  Moses  were  to  be 
put  to  death  :— If  you  have  taught  the  people 
the  necessity  of  charity,  and  the  evil  of  enter- 
taining so  much  as  a  jealousy  against  their  neigh- 
bours for  such  crimes,  upon  the  devil's  sugges- 
tions to  a  person  pretending  to  a  spectral  or  di- 
abolical  sight ;  who  utter  their  oracles  from 
malice,  frenzy,  or  a  satanical  delusion— That  to  be 
inquisitive  of  such,  whose  spectres  they  see,  or 
who  it  is  that  afflicts,  in  order  to  put  the  accu- 
sed's life  in  question,  is  a  v/ickedness  beyond 
what  Saul  was  guilty  of  in  going  to  the  wntch — 
That  to  consult  with  the  dead,  by  the  help  of 
such  as  pretend  to  this  spectral  sight,  and  so  to 
get  information  against  the  life  of  any  person,  is 
the  worst  sort  of  necromancy — That  the  pre- 
tending to  drive  away  spectres,  i.  e.  devils,  with 
the  hand,  or  by  strikmg  these  to  wound  a  per- 
son at  a  distance,  cannot  be  without  witchcraft, 
as  pretending  to  a  sign  in  order  to  deceive  in 
matters  of  so  high  a  nature — That  'tis  ridicu- 
lous to  think,  by  making  laws  against  feeding, 
employing  or  rewarding  of  evil  spirits,  thereby 
to  get  rid  of  them — That  their  nature  requires 
no  sucking  to  support  it — That  it  is  a  horrid  in- 
jury and  barbarity  to  search  those  parts,  which 
even  nature  itself  commands  the  concealing  of, 
to  find  some  excrescence  to  be  called  a  teat  for 
these  to  suck ;  which  yet  is  said  sometimes  to 
appear    as    a    fleabite: — Finally,    if  you   have 


MR.  MATHIiR,  &c.  ilj 

taught  the  people  what  to  beheve  and  practise, 
as  to  the  probation  of  the  accused,  by  their 
saying  or  not  saying  the  Lord's  prayer,  and  as 
to  praying  that  the  afflicted  may  be  able  to  ac- 
cuse, and  have  not  shunned  in  these  matters  to 
declare  the  whole  mind  of  God  ;  you  have  then 
well  acquitted  yourselves  (in  time  of  genera!  de- 
fection) as  faithful  watchmen.  But  if,  instead 
of  this,  you  have,  some  by  word  and  writing 
propagated,  and  others  recommended,  such  doc- 
trines, and  abetted  the  false  notions,  which  are  so 
prevalent  in  this  apostate  age,  it  is  high  time  to 
consider  it.  If  when  authority  found  them- 
selves almost  nonplust  in  such  prosecutions, 
and  sent  to  you  for  your  advice  what  they 
ought  to  do,*"  and  you  have  then  thanked  them 
for  what  they  had  already  done  (and  thereby 
encouraged  them  to  proceed  in  those  very  by- 
paths already  fallen  into)  it  so  much  the  more 
nearly  concerns  you.  Ezek.  xxiii.  2  to  8. 

To  conclude :  This  whole  people  are  invited 
and  commanded  to  humble  their  souls  before 
God,  as  for  other  causes,  ibr  the  errors  that 
may  have  been  fallen  into  in  these  prosecutions 
on  either  hand,  and  to  pray  that  God  would 
teach  us  what  we  know  not,  and  help  us  where- 
in we  have  done  amiss,  that  we  may  do  so  no 
more.t 

This  more  Immediately  concerns  yourselves; 
for  'tis  not  supposed  to  be  intended,  that  God 
w^ould  shew  us  these  things  by  inspiration  ;  but 
that  such  who  are  called  to  it  should  shew  th© 

*  Cases  of  Conscience,  vlt.       t  Vide  the  proolanaatioD 
for  a  fast,  to  be  the  1 1th  in^t,  as  set  forth  by  authority. 
10* 


114  LETTERS  TO 

mind  of  God  in  these  things  on  both  hands,  i.  e.. 
whether  there  has  been  anj  error  in  excess  or 
deficiency,  or  neither  in  the  one  nor  the  other. 
And  If  you  do  not  thus  far  serve  the  publick,you 
need  not  complain  of  great  sufferings  and  un- 
righteous discouragements,  if  people  do  not  ap- 
plaud your  conduct,  as  you  might  otherways 
have  expected.^  But  if  you  altogether  hold 
vour  peace  at  such  a  time  as  this  is,  your  silence, 
at  least  seemujgly,  will  speak  this  language  ; 
that  you  are  not  concerned,  though  men  ascribe 
the  power  and  providence  of  the  Almighty  to 
the  worst  of  his  creatures — that  if  other  ages 
or  countries  improve  the  doctrine  and  examples 
given  them,  either  to  the  taking  away  of  the 
life  or  reputations  of  innocents,  you  are  well  sa- 
tisfied. Which,  that  there  may  be  no  shadow  of 
a  reason  to  believe  but  that  your  conduct  herein 
may  remove  all  such  jealousies,  and  that  God 
■would  be  with  you  in  declaring  his  whole  mind 
to  the  people,  is  the  earnest  desire  and  prayer 
ef,  reverend  sirs,  vours  to  my  utmost, 

R.  C. 

Mr.  Benjamin^  Wads  worth, 
Reverend  Sii\ 
After  that  dreadful  and  severe  persecution  of 
such  a  multitude  of  people,  under  the  notion  of 
Avitches,  which,  in  the  day  thereoi',  was  the 
sorest  trial  and  ailliction  that  ever  befel  this 
country  :  and  after  many  of  i\\e  principal  actors 

^  The  declaration,  as  drawn  by  the  Deputies  with  thf- 
assistance  of  the  Ministers ;  but  received  a  nonconcor- 
rence. 


MR.  MATHER,  ^c.  iio 

had  declared  tlicir  i'cars  and  jealousies,  that 
they  had  greatly  erred  in  those  prosecutions ; 
and  after  a  solemn  day  of  fastinaj  had  been  kept, 
with  prayers  that  God  would  shew  us  what  we 
knew  not,  viz.  what  errors  might  therein  have 
been  fcilleninto,&c.;  and  after  most  people  were 
convinced  of  the  evil  of  some,  if  not  of  most,  of 
those  actions  ;  at  such  a  time  as  this,  it  might 
have  been  justly  expected  that  the  ministers 
would  make  it  their  work  to  explain  the  scrip- 
tures to  the  people  ;  and  from  thence  to  have 
shown  them  the  evil  and  danger  of  those  false 
notions,  which  not  only  gave  some  occasion,  but 
in  a  blind  zeal  hurried  tliem  into  those  unwar- 
rantable practices,  so  to  prevent  a  falling  into 
the  like  for  the  I'uture. 

But  instead  of  this,  for  a  minister  of  the  gos- 
pel (pastor  of  the  old  meeting)  to  abet  such  no- 
tions, and  to  stir  up  the  magistrates  to  such  pro- 
secutions, and  this  without  any  cautions  given, 
is  what  is  truly  amazing,  and  of  most  dangerous 
consequence. 

It  is  a  truth,  witchcraft  is,  in  the  text  then 
insisted  on,  reckoned  up  as  a  manifest  work  of 
the  flesh,  viz.  Gal.  v.  19.  But  it  is  as  true,  that 
in  recounting  those  other  works  (which  are  in- 
deed manifest  fleshly  works)  the  magistrate  was 
not  stirred  up  against  those  others  ;  as  if  the 
rest  were  either  not  to  be  taken  notice  of  by 
jiim,  or  as  if  all  zeal  against  murder,  adulteries, 
<fec.  was  swallowed  up  and  overshadowed  by 
this  against  witchcraft. 

The  description  that  was  then  given,  was, 
that   thoy  were  such  as  made  a  covenant   with 


116  LETTERS   TO 

the  devil,  and  sold  themselves  to  the  evil  angels. 
It  seems  faulty,  when  such  minister  is  inquir- 
ed of,  and  requested  to  give  the  reasons,  or 
grounds  in  scripture,  of  such  descrijDtion,  for  such 
minister  to  assert  that  it  is  the  inquirer's  work 
to  disprove  it.  And  his  saying  further,  in  an- 
swer, that  there  are  many  things  true,  that  are 
not  asserted  in  scripture,  seems  to  speak  this 
language,  viz.  that  the  law  of  God  is  imperfect, 
in  not  describing  this  crime  of  witchcraft,  though 
it  be  therein  made  capital. 

These  perfect  oracles  inform  us,  concerning 
AJiab,  that  he  sold  himself  to  work  wickedness; 
which  may  signify  to  us,  that  great  height  of 
wickedness  he  had  arrived  at;  which  yet  might 
be,  without  his  being  properly,  or  justly,  account- 
ed a  witch;  any  more  than  those  that  are  said 
to  have  made  a  covenant  with  death,  and  with 
hell,  &c.  Can  it  be  thought  that  all  those,  or 
such  as  are  there  spoken  of,  are  witches,  and 
ought  to  suffer  as  witches  ? 

As  the  servants  and  people  of  God  have  made 
a  solemn,  explicit  covenant  with  him,  (^Josh.xx'iv. 
25.  JVehem*  ix  38,  &c.)  so  no  doubt  a  covenant 
has  been  made  by  heathen  indian  nations,  to 
serve  and  adore  the  devil;  yet  even  for  this,  it 
were  very  hard  to  affix  the  character  of  a  witch 
upon  each  of  those  heathen  that  so  do,  and  ac- 
cordingly to  execute  them  as  such.  It  is  also 
possible,  that  some  that  have  been  called  chris- 
tians have  sealed  a  writing,  signed  with  their 
own  blood,  or  other  ways,  thereby  covenanting 
to  be  the  devil's  servants,  Sic.  but  from  far  other 
grounds,  or  inducements,  than  what  s\Yays  with 


MR.  MATHER,  &c.  117 

the  indians ;  these  heathen  hoping  to  please 
him,  that  so  he  may  not  liarm  them.  But  these 
having  heen  educated  and  confirmed  in  tlie  be- 
hef,  that  by  virtue  of  such  covenant  tliey  shall 
have  a  knowledge  and  power  more  than  hu- 
man assisting  them  ;  this  may  have  prevailed 
with  some  to  so  horrible  a  wickedness ;  for 
none  can  seek  evil  for  evil's  sake  ;  but  as  the 
serpent,  in  his  first  tempting  man,  made  use  of 
the  knowledge  of  good  and  evil,  so  to  teacli 
men  that  such  effects  do  i!sually  follow  such  co- 
venant is  properly  the  work  of  the  serpent ; 
for,  without  this,  what  inducement,  or  tempta- 
tion, could  they  have  to  make  such  a  covenant? 

These,  having  thus  chosen  a  false  god,  may 
well  be  accounted  the  worst  sort  of  idolaters. 
Yet  it  does  not  hence  follow,  that,  in  a  scripture 
sense,  they  are  thereby  become  witches,  till 
they  have,  or  rather  till  they  pretend  to  have, 
assistances  answerable  :  and  do  thereby  endea- 
vour to  deceive  others  ;  which  endeavours  to 
deceive,  by  a  sign,  may  be  without  any  previ- 
ous covenant. 

But  supposing  none  of  all  those  several  sorts 
of  covenants  was  intended,  it  remains  that  the 
covenant,  that  was  understood  to  be  intended,  in 
that  discourse  at  the  old  meeting,  is  agreeable 
to  the  late  dan^rerous  notion  that  has  so  much 
prevailed,  viz.  That  the  devil  appears  to  the 
persons  ;  that  they  and  the  devil  make  mutual 
engagments  each  to  other,  confirmed'  by  signing 
to  the  devil's  book  ;  and  are  I'rom  hence  ena- 
bled, not  only  to  know  futurities,  and  things 
done  at  a  distance,  but  are  also  thereby  empow- 


118  LETTERS  TO 

ered  to  do  harm  to  their  neighbours,  to  raise 
storms,  and  do  thinors  above  and  a^jainst  the 
course  of  nature.  This  being  the  notion  that  has 
occasioned  the  shedding  so  much  blood  in  the 
world,  it  may  be  thought  to  need  explaining. 

For  as  reason  knows  nothing  of  an  afflicting, 
covenanting  witch,  so  it  seems  as  foreign  from 
scripture  in  general,  as  it  is  from  the  text  then  in- 
sisted on;  which  speaks  of  such  wickednesses 
as  are  manifestly  the  works  of  the  fiesh  :  but 
such  communication  with  spirits,  the  flesh  doth 
manifestly  dread  even  as  death  itself.  There- 
fore the  usual  salutation  of  the  holy  angels  to 
the  best  of  men  was,  fear  not;  and  experience 
shews,  that  the  most  wicked  are  most  affrighted 
at  the  apprehensions  of  the  appearances  of  dev- 
ils; therefore  such  an  explicit  covenanting  can- 
not be  a  manifest  work  of  the  flesh. 

Yet  this  is  manifest,  that  the  belief  of  the 
witches  power  to  do  the  things  above  mentioned, 
is  an  ancient  belief  of  the  heathen;  and  that 
from  them  it  was  received  by  the  papists,  as  a 
part  of  their  faith,  who  have  since  improved 
upon  it  and  brought  in  the  notion  of  a  covenant. 
But  it  seems  yet  a  further  improvement,  lately 
made  by  protestants,  that  such  witches  can 
commission  devils  to  do  those  mischiefs,  thereby 
setting  the  witch  in  the  place  of  God;  for 
though  few^  of  the  papists  are  known  to  be  thus 
absurd,  yet  when  such  doctrines  have  beeji 
preached  'and  printed  in  New-England,  they 
have  met  with  none  to  oppose,  but  many  to 
encourage  them.  Other  considerable  additions, 
^r  new   improvements,  have    been  made  here  ; 


m\.  MATHER,  kc.  119 

as  the  art  to  knock  oHT  invisible  chains  with  the 
hand,  to  drive  away  spectres  (i.  e.  devils)  by 
brushing,  and  spelNng  words  to  the  aillicted,  <kc. 
What  has  fohowed  u[)on  these  notions,  and  upon 
such  improvements,  is  necdioss  liere  to  repeat  ; 
it  were  unaccountable  to  recount  that  eiiusion 
of  blood  that  has  been  hereby  occasioned  ;  such 
remaining  scars,  and  such  yet  bleeding  wounds, 
as  are  to  be  found;  which  none  can  wholly  pre- 
tend Ignorance  of. 

And  ii' blood  shall  be  required  of  that  watch* 
man  that  seeth  the  swokI  coming,  and  gives  not 
the  neediul  warning,  how  much  more  of  such  as 
join  with  the  enemy,  to  bring  in  the  sword  to 
destroy  them,  over  whom  he  w  as  placed  a  watch- 
man ! 

And  if  the  law  of  God  l)e  perfect,  and  exceed- 
ing broad,  as  being  given  forth  by  the  Omniscient 
Lawgiver,  it  is  exceeding  high  presumption  and 
arrogance,  and  highly  destnxtive  to  the  lives  of 
innocents,  for  any  to  pretend  to  give  another, 
and  a  pretended  better,  description  of  a  crime 
made  thereby  capital,  with  new  rules  to  try  such 
oftenders  by. 

Reverend  sir,  the  matter,  being  of  such  high 
concern,  requires  (and  it  is  again  prayed)  that 
you  would  be  pleased  to  consider,  and  give  the 
grounds  from  scripture,  or  reason,  of  such  defi- 
nition ;  or  else  that  you  would  explode  it,  as  in- 
consistent with  both.  From,  reverend  sir,  yours 
to  my  utmost,  R.  C 


TPART  III. 
ACCOUiNTOF  THE  DIFFERENCES 

IN 

SALEM  VILLAGE. 


Grounds  of  Complaint  against  Mr,  Parrisj  8rc^ 

J.  HE  reasons  why  we  withdraw  from  com- 
munion with  the  church  of  Salem  Village,  both 
as  to  hearing  the  word  preached,  and  from  par- 
taking with  them  at  the  Lord's  table,  are  as 
follow : 

Why  we  attend  not  on  publick  prayer,  and 
preaching  the  word,    there  are, 

1.  The  distracting  and  disturbing  tumults,  and 
noises,  made  by  the  persons  under  diabolical 
power  and  delusions  ;  preventing  sometimes  our 
hearing,  understanding,  and  profiting  by,  the 
"Word  preached.  We,  having  after  many  trials 
and  experiences  found  no  redress  in  this  matter, 
accounted  ourselves  under  a  necessity  to  go 
where  we  might  hear  the  word  in  quiet. 

2.  The  apprehension  of  danger  of  ourselves 
being  accused  as  the  devil's  instruments  to  afflict 

11 


|2«  DIFFERENCES  IN 

the  persons  complaining,  we  seeing  those,  that 
we  have  reason  to  esteem  better  than  ourselves, 
thus  accused,  blemished,  and  of  their  lives  be- 
reaved :  for  seeing  this,  thought  it  our  prudence 
to  withdraw. 

3.  We  found  so  frequent  and  positive  preach- 
ing up  some  principles  and  practices  by  mr. 
Parris,  referring  to  the  dark  and  dismal  mystery 
of  iniquity  working  among  us,  was  not  profitable, 
but  offensive. 

4.  Neither  could  we  in  conscience  join  with 
mr.  Parris,  in  many  of  the  requests  which  he 
made  in  prayer,  referring  to  the  trouble  then 
among  us  and  upon  us :  therefore  thought  it 
our  most  safe  and  peaceable  way  to  withdraw. 

The  reasons  why  we  hold  not  communion 
with  them  at  the  Lord's  table,  are,  because  we 
find  ourselves  justly  aggrieved  and  offended  with 
the  officer  who  does  administer,  for  the  reasons 
following : 

1.  From  his  declared  and  published  princi- 
ples, referring  to  our  molestations  from  the  in- 
visible world  :  differing  from  the  opinion  of  the 
generality  of  the  orthodox  ministers  oi'  the 
country. 

2.  His  easy  and  strong  faith  and  belief  of  the 
fore-mentioned  accusations,  made  by  those  called 
the  afflicted. 

3.  His  laying  aside  that  grace  (which  above 
all  we  are  to  put  on)  viz.  charity  towards  his 
neighbours,  and  especially  tii  ^^e  of  iiis  chuich, 
when  there  is  no  apparent  reason  but  for  the 
cpntrary. 

4.  His  approving  and  practising  unwarrant- 


SALEM  VILLAGE.  123 

able  and  ungrounded  methods,  for  discovering 
what  he  was  desirous  to  know  relerring  to  the 
bewitched  or  possessed  persons,  as  in  bringing 
some  to  others,  and  by  them  pretending  to  in- 
form himseh'  and  others,  who  were  the  devil's 
instruments  to  afflict  the  sick  and  maimed. 

5.  His  unsafe,  unaccountable  oath,  given  by 
him  against  sundry  of  the  accused. 

6.  His  not  rendering  to  the  world  so  fair  (if 
so  true)  account  of  what  lie  wrote  on  examina- 
tion of  the  afflicted. 

7.  Sundry  unsafe,  if  sound,  points  of  doctrine, 
delivered  in  his  preaching,  which  we  find  not 
warrantable  (if  christian.) 

8.  His  persisting  in  these  principles,  and  jus- 
tifying his  practice;  not  rendering  any  satisfac^ 
tion  to  us,  when  regularly  desired,  but  rather  of- 
fending and  dissatisfying  ourselves. 

We,  whose  names  are  under  written,  heard  this  paper 
read  to  our  pastor,  Mr.  Samuel  Parris,  the  21st  of  Aprilj 
1693. 


JVathaniel  Jigarson^ 
Edward  Putman^ 
Aaron  Way^ 
William  Way^ 


Peter  Cloyce^  senior^ 
Samuel  J\'urse^ 
John  Tarboll^ 
Thomas  Wilkins. 


Mr.  P arrises  Jlcknowlcdgment. 
For  as  much  as  it  is  the  undoubted  duty  oi 
all  christians  to  pursue  peace,  Psal.  xxxiv.  14, 
even  te  a  reaching  of  it,  if  it  be  possible ;  {Jlmos 
xii.  18,  19)  and  whereas,  through  the  righteous, 
sovereign  and  awful  providence  of  God,  the  grand 
enemy  to  all  christian  peace  has  been  of  late 
tremendously  let  loose  in  divers  places  hereabout, 
and  more  especially  among  our  sinful  selves,  not 


iU  DfFFERENCES  m 

only  to  interrupt  that  partial  peace  which  we 
sometimes  enjoyed,  but  also,  through  his  wiles 
•and  temptations,  and  our  weakness  and  corrup- 
tions, to  make  wider  breaches,  and  raise  more 
bitter  animosities  between  too  many  of  us;  io 
which  dark  and  difficult  dispensations,  we  have 
been  all  or  most  of  us  of  one  mind  for  a  time, 
and  afterwards  of  diifering  apprehensions;  and 
at  last  we  are  but  in  the  dark,  upon  serious 
thoughts  of  all ;  and  after  many  prayers,  I  have 
been  moved  to  present  to  you  (my  beloved  tlock) 
the  following  particulars,  in  way  of  contribution 
towards  a  regaining  of  christian  concord,  if  so  be 
we  be  not  altogether  unappeaseable,  irreconcile- 
able,  and  so  destitute  of  that  good  spirit,  which 
is  first  pure,  then  peaceable,  gentle,  and  easy  to 
be  entreated,  James  m.  17.    viz. 

1.  In  that  the  Lord  ordered  the  late  horrid 
calamity  (which  afterward  plague-like  spread  in 
many  other  places)  to  break  out  first  in  my  fami- 
ly, I  cannot  but  look  upon  as  a  very  sore  rebuke* 
and  humbling  providence,  both  to  myself  and 
mine,  and  desire  so  we  may  improve  it. 

2.  In  that  also  in  my  family  were  some  of 
both  parties,  viz.  accusers  and  accused,  I  look 
also  upon  as  an  aggravation  of  that  rebuke,  as 
an  addition  of  wormwood  to  the  gall. 

3.  In  the  means  which  were  used  in  my  fam- 
ily, though  totally  unknown  to  me  or  mine  (ex- 
cept servants)  till  afterwards,  to  raise  spirits 
and  apparitions  in  no  better  than  a  diabolical 
way,  I  do  also  look  upon  as  a  further  rebuke  of 
Divine  Providence.  And  by  all,  1  do  humbly 
<>wn  this  day,  before  the  Lord  and  his  people 


SALEM  VILLAGE.  12^ 

that  God  has  been  righteously  spitting  in  my 
lace,  JVumb.  xii.  14.  And  I  desire  to  lie  lovv 
under  all  this  reproach,  and  to  lay  my  hand  on 
my  mouth. 

4.  As  to  the  management  of  these  mysteries, 
as  far  as  concerns  myself,  I  am  very  desirous 
upon  further  light  to  own  any  errors  1  have 
therein  fallen  into,  and  can  come  to  a  discerning 
of;  in  the  mean  while  I  do  acknowledge,  upon 
after-considerations,  that  were  the  same  trou- 
bles again,  (which  the  Lord  of  his  rich  mercy 
forever  prevent)  1  should  not  agree  with  my 
former  apprehensions  in  all  points.  As  for  in-, 
stance, 

1.  I  question  not  but  God  sometimes  suffers 
the  devil,  as  of  late,  to  afflict  in  shape  of  not 
only  innocent,  but  pious  persons ;  or  so  to  de- 
lude the  senses  of  the  afflicted,  that  they 
strongly  conceit  their  hurt  is  from  such  persons^ 
when  indeed  it  is  not. 

2.  The  improving  of  one  afflicted,  to  inquire 
by  who  afflicts  the  other,  I  fear  may  be,  and 
has  been,  unlawfully  used  to  satan's  great  ad- 
vantage. 

3.  As  to  my  writing,  it  was  put  upon  me  by 
authority,  and  therein  1  have  been  very  careful 
to  avoid  the  wronging  of  any. 

4.  As  to  my  oath,  I  never  meant  it,  nor  do  I 
know  how  it  can  be  otherwise  construed,  than 
as  vulgarly,  and  every  one  understood,  yea,  and 
upon  inquiry  it  may  be  found  so  worded  also. 

5.  As  to  any  passage  in  preaching,  or  praying, 
in  the  soi'e  hour  of  distress  and  darkness,  1  al- 
•ways  intended  but  due  justice  on  each  hand,  and 

11* 


126  DIFFERENCES  11^ 

that  not  according  to  men,  but  God,  who  knovvt' 
all  things  most  perfectly;  hoAvever,  through 
weakness  or  sore  exercise,  1  might  sometimes, 
yea,  and  possibly  sundry  times,  unadvisedly  ex- 
press myself. 

6.  As  to  several  that  have  confessed  against 
themselves,  they  being  wholly  strangers  to  me, 
but  yet  of  good  account  with  better  men  than 
myseU,  to  whom  also  they  are  well  known,  I 
do  not  pass  so  much  as  a  secret  condemnation 
upon  them;  but  rather,  seeing  God  hath  so 
amazingly  lengthened  out  satan's  chain,  in  this 
most  formidable  outrage,  I  much  more  incline  to 
side  with  the  opinion  of  those  that  have  grounds 
to  hope  better  of  them. 

7.  As  to  all  that  have  unduly  suffered  in  these 
matters,  either  in  their  persons  or  relations, 
through  the  clouds  of  human  weakness,  and  Sa- 
tan's wiles  and  sophistry,  1  do  truly  sympathize 
with  them;  taking  it  for  granted,  that  such  as 
know  themselves  clear  of  this  great  transgres- 
sion, or  that  have  sufficient  grounds  so  to  look 
upon  their  dear  friends,  have  hereby  been  un- 
der those  sore  trials  and  temptations,  that  not 
an  ordinary  measure  of  true  grace  would  be  suf- 
ficient to  prevent  a  bewraying  of  remaining  cor- 
ruption. 

8.  I  am  very  much  in  the  mind,  and  abund- 
antly persuaded,  that  God,  for  holy  ends,  though 
for  what  in  particular  is  best  known  to  himself, 
has  suffered  the  evil  angels  to  delude  us  on  both 
hands;  but  how  far  on  the  one  side,  or  the 
other,  is  much  above  me  to  Sxiy ;  and  if  we  cai> 

jiot  reconcile  till  we  come  to  a  full  discerning  oi 


c^ALEM  VILLAGi:.  H^ 

these  things,  I  fear  we  sliall  never  come  to  an 
agreement,  or  at  soonest  not  in  this  world. 

9.  Therefore,   in  fine,   the    matter  being  so 
dark  and  perplexed,  as  that  there  is  no  present 
appearance  that  aU  God's  servants  should  be  al- 
together of  one  mind  in  all  circumstances,  toucli- 
ing  the  same,  I   do  most  heartily,  fervently  and 
humbly   beseech  pardon  of   the  mcrcil'ul    God, 
through  the  blood  of  Chrisrt,  for  all  my  mistakes 
and  trespasses  in  so  weighty  a  matter;  and  also 
all  your  forgiveness  of  every  ollencc,  in  this  or 
other  affairs,  wherein  you  see  or  conceive  that 
I  have  erred  and  otlended ;  professing,    in   the 
presence  of  the    Ahnighty   God,    that    what  1 
have  done  has  been,  as  ibr  substance,  as  1  ap* 
prehended  was  duty,  however  through  weak- 
ness, ignorance,  (fee.  I  may  have  been  mistaken- 
1  also  through  grace  promising  eacli  of  you  the 
like  of  me,  so  again   I  beg,  entreat  and  beseech 
you,  that  satan,  the  devil,  the  roaring  lion,  the 
old  dragon,  the  enemy  of  all  righteousness,  may 
no   longer   be   served  by  us,  by  our  envy  and 
strifes,   where  every  evil  work   prevails  whilst 
these  bear  sway,  (James  iii.  14,  15,  16)  but  that 
all  from  this  day  lor  ward  may  be  covered  with 
tiie  mantle  of  love,  and  we    may  on  all   hands 
forgive  eacii  other  heartily,  sincerely  and   thor- 
oughly, as  we  do  hope  and   pray  that  God   for 
Christ's  sake   would  forgive    each  of  ourselves^ 
(AlatU  xviii.  21,  to  the  end.)    Coloss.  iii.  12,  13, 
Put  on  therpfore  {as  the  elect  of  God,  holy  and  be- 
loved) bowels  of  mercies,  kindness,  hninbleness  of 
nnind,    meekness,   long-sffffering :  forbearing    one 
-einolher,  and'  forgiving  one  another^  if  any  man 


128  DIFFERENCES  IN 

have  a  quarrel  against  any  ;  even  as  Christ  for^ 
gave  you^  so  also  do  ye.  Eplu  iv.  31,  32,  Let 
all  bitterness,  and  anger ,  and  clamour,  and  evil" 
speaking,  be  put  away  from  you,  with  all  malice. 
And  be  ye  kind  one  to  another,  tender-hearted,  for- 
mvins  one  another  even  as  God  for  Chrisfs  sake 
hath  forgiven  you.     Amen.     Amen. 

Samuel  Parris* 

Given  to  the  dissenting  brethren,  for  their  considera- 
tion, at  their  request.     JS^ov ember  2i),  1694. 


The  Elders  and  Messengers  of  the  churches  met 
at  Salem  Village,  April  3,  1695,  to  consider 
and  determine  what  is  to  be  done,  for  the  com-^ 
posure  of  the  present  unhappy  differences  in  that 
place  ;  after  solemri  invocation  of  God  in  Christ 
for  his  direction,  do  unanimously  declare,  as 
followeth,  viz. 

1.  We  judge  that  although  in  the  late  and 
dark  time  of  the  confusions,  wherein  satan  had 
obtained  a  more  than  ordinary  Hberty,  to  sift  this 
plantation,  there  were  sundry  unwarrantable 
and  uncomfortable  steps  taken  by  rnr.  Samuel 
Parris,  the  pastor  of  the  church  in  Salem  Vil- 
lage, then  under  the  hurrying  distractions  of 
amazing  afflictions;  yet  the  said  Mr.  Parris,  by 
the  good  hand  of  God  brought  unto  a  better 
sense  of  things,  hath  so  fully  exprest  it,  that  a 
christian  charity  may  and  should  receive  satis- 
faction therewith. 

2.  Inasmuch  as  divers  christian  brethren,  in 
the  church  of  Salem  Village,  have  been  offend- 
ed at  mr.  Parris,  for  his  conduct  in  the  time  of 
their  dlfiiculties,  which  have  distressed  them-; 


9ALEM  VILLAGE:  129 

we  now  advise  tliem  charltiihly  to  accept  tiie 
satisl'action  whicli  lie  hatli  tendered  in  his  chris- 
tian acknowledgment  ol  the  errors  theiein  cum- 
mitted;  yea,  to  endeavoui-,  as  far  as  it  is  possi- 
ble, the  i'ullest  reconciliation  ol'  tlieir  minds  unto 
communion  with  him,  in  the  \vhol(>  exercise  of 
his  ministry,  and  with  the  rest  ol"  the  churcli. 
Matt.  vi.  12,  14.  Luke  xviii.  3.  James  v.  16. 

3.  Considering  the  extreme  trials  and  trou- 
bles, which  the  disaffected  brethren  in  the 
churcii  of  Salem  Village  have  undergone,  in  the 
day  of  sore  temptation  which  hath  been  upon 
them;  we  cannot  but  advise  the  church  to  treat 
them  with  bowels  of  much  compassion,  instead 
of  more  critical  or  rigorous  proceedings  against 
them  for  the  infirmities  discovered  by  them,  in 
such  an  heart-breaking  day ;  and  if,  after  a  pa- 
tient waiting  for  it,  the  said  brethren  cannot  so 
far  overcome  the  uneasiness  of  their  spirits,  in 
the  remembrance  of  the  disasters  that  have 
happened,  as  to  sit  under  his  ministry,  we  ad- 
vise the  church  with  all  tenderness  to  grant 
them  admission  to  any  other  society  of  the  faith- 
ful, w hereunto  they  may  be  desirous  to  be  dis- 
missed. GaL  vi.  1,2.  Psal,  ciii.  13,  14.  Job  xix.  21. 

4.  Mr.  Parris  having,  as  we  understand,  with 
much  fidelity  and  integrity  acquitted  himself,  in 
the  main  course  of  his  ministry,  since  he  hath 
been  pastor  of  the  church  of  Salem  Village; 
about  his  first  call  whereunto,  we  look  upon  all 
contests  now  to  be  both  unreasonable  and  un- 
seasonable ;  and  our  Lord  having  made  him  a 
blessing  to  the  souls  of  not  a  few,  both  old  and 
young,  in  this  place,  we  advise  that  he   be  af- 


13a  DIFFERENCES  IN 

cordingly  respected,  honoured  and  supported, 
with  all  the  regards  that  are  due  to  a  painful  mi* 
nister  of  the  gospel.  1  Thess,  v.  12,  13.  1  Tirr^. 
V.  17. 

5.  Having  observed  that  there  is  in  Saleim 
Village  a  spirit  full  of  contention  and  animosity, 
too  sadly  verifying  the  blemish  which  hath 
heretofore  lain  upon  them;  and  that  some  corn- 
plaints  against  mr.  Parris  have  been  either 
causeless  or  groundless,  or  unduly  aggravated; 
we  do,  in  the  name  and  fear  of  the  Lord,  so- 
lemnly warn  them  to  consider  whether,  if  they 
continue  to  devour  one  another,  it  will  not  be 
bitterness  in  the  latter  end;  and  beware  lest 
the  Lord  be  provoked  thereby  utterly  to  de- 
prive them  of  those  which  they  should  count 
their  precious  and  pleasant  things,  and  abandon 
them  to  all  the  desolations  of  a  people  that  sin 
aAvay  the  mercies  of  the  gospel.  James  iii.  16. 
Gal  V.  15.  2  Sam,  ii.  26.  ha.  v.  45.  MatL  xxi. 
43. 

6.  If  the  distempers  in  Salem  Village  should 
be  (which  God  forbid)  so  incurable,  that  mr. 
Parris,  after  all,  find  that  he  cannot  with  any 
comfort  and  service  continue  in  his  present  sta- 
tion, his  removal  from  thence  will  not  expose 
him  to  any  hard  character  with  us  ;  nor,  we 
hope,  witfi  mQ  res-  of  the  people  ofGod,  amorg 
whom  we  live.  Matt,  x.  14.  Acts\i^\\,  18.  All 
which  advice  we  follow  with  our  prayers,  that 
th*^  G;>d  of  peace  would  bruise  Satan  under  our 
i^eX.     Now  the  Lord  of  peace  himself  give  you 

peace  always  by  all  means. 


Jos.  Bridghain^f      I  Jer.  Dummer^ 
Samuel  Chickley^  \  Aeh.  Jewitt^ 


James  AUen^ 


SALEM  VILLAGE.  15*1 


William  Tory^ 
Jos.  Boynton^ 
R.  Middlecult^ 
John  Walley^ 


Ephr.  Ifunt^ 
A'.  Williams^ 
Incr.^lalher^ 
S.  r/tillips, 


S.  rVillard, 
E.  Fmyson^ 
C.  Mather, 


To  the  Reverend  Elders  of  the  three  churches  of 

Christ  at  Boston^  icith  others  the  Elders  and 

Brethren  of  other  churches,  late  of*  a  Council  cU 

Salem  Village, 

We  whose  names  are  hereunto  subscribed, 
are  bold  once  more  to  trouble  you  with  our 
hunrble  proposals  : — That  whereas  there  have 
been  long  and  uncomfortable  dilferences  among 
us,  chiefly  relating  to  mr.  Pariis  ;  and  we  having, 
as  we  appreliend,  attended  all  probable  means 
for  a  composure  of  our  troubles  :  and  whereas 
we  had  hopes  of  an  happy  issue,  by  your  en- 
deavours among  us,  but  now  are  utterly  I'rust rat- 
ed in  our  expectations,  and  that  instead  of  unit- 
ing, our  rent  is  made  worse,  and  our  breach 
made  wider: 

We  humbly  query,  whether  yourselves,  being 
straightened  of  time,  might  not  omit  such  satis- 
factory liberty  of  debating  the  whole  of  our 
controversy;  whereby  yourselves  had  not  so 
large  an  opportunity  of  understanding  the  ca?e, 
nor  the  onended  so  much  reason  to  be  satisfied 
in  your  advice:  We  therefore  humbly  propose, 
imd  give  full  liberty  of  proving  and  defending  of 
what  may  be  charged  on  either  hand,  leaving  it 
to  yourselves  to  appoint  both  time  and  plajce, 

1-  That  if  yourselves  please  to  take  the  troir- 
ble,  with  patience  once  more  to  hear  the  whole 
case. 

2*  Or  (hat  you  will  more  plainly  advise  mF.- 


132  DIFFERENCES  m 

Parris  (the  case  being  so  circumstanced  tliat  he 
cannot,  with  comfort  or  profit  to  himself  or 
others,  abide  in  the  work  of  the  ministry  among 
us)  to  cease  his  labours,  and  seek  to  dispose  him- 
self elsewhere,  as  God  in  his  providence  may  di- 
rect; and  that  yourselves  would  please  to  help 
us  in  advising  to  such  a  choice,  wherein  we  may 
be  more  unanimous;  which  we  hope  would  tend 
much  to  a  composure  of  our  diiferences. 

3.  Or  that  we  may  without  any  offence  take 
the  liberty  of  calling  some  other  proved  minister 
of  the  gospel,  to  preach  the  word  of  God  to  us 
and  ours;  and  that  we  may  not  be  denied  our 
proportionable  privilege,  in  our  public  disburse- 
ments in  the  place. 

So  leaving  the  whole  case  with  the  Lord  and 

yourselves,  we  subscribe  our  names. 

Signed  by  16  yciing  men,  from  16  upwards;  and  52 
householders,  and  18  church  members.  This  was  deli- 
vered to  the  mmisters,  May  3,  1695. 

The  copy  of  a  paper  that  icas  handed  about^  touch- 
ing!; those  differences. 

As  to  the  contest  between  mr.  Parris  and  his 
hearers,  (kc.  it  may  be  composed  by  a  satisfac- 
tory answer  to  Lcvit.  xx.  6,  "And  the  soul  that 
turneth  after  such  as  have  familiar  spirits,  and 
■after  wizards,  to  go  a  whoring  after  them,  I 
will  set  my  face  against  that  soul,  and  will  cut 
him  off  from  among  his  people."  1  Chron,  x.  13, 
14,  "  So  Saul  died  for  his  trangression,  which  he 
committed  against  the  Lord,  even  against  the 
word  of  the  Lord,  which  he  kept  not;  and  also 
for  asking  counsel  of  one  that  had  a  familiar  spi- 


SALEM  VILLAGE  i»h 

rlt,  to  inquire  of  it ;  and  inquired  not  of  the  Lord; 
therefore  he  slew  hiui.""  cSic. 

Some  part  of  the  detcrminntion  of  the  Elders  and 
Messengers  of  the  churches^  wet  at  Salem  Vil- 
lage^ Jfpril'd',  1695,  relating  to  the  differences 
there. 

If  the  distemper  in  Salem  Village  should  be 
(which  God  forbid)  so  incurable  that  mr.  Parris, 
after  all,  find  that  he  cannot  with  any  comfort 
and  service  continue  in  his  present  station,  his 
removal  from  thence  will  not  ex|X)se  him  to  any 
hard  character  with  us,  nor,  we  hope,  with  the 
rest  of  the  people  of  God,  among  whom  we  live. 
Matt.  X.  14,  Jlnd  whosoever  shall  not  receive  you^ 
nor  hear  your  words  ;  when  you  depart  out  of  that 
house,  or  city,  shake  off  the  dust  of  your  feet,  cSt. 
Acts  xxii.  18.  All  which  advice  we  follow  with 
our  prayers,  that  the  God  of  peace  would  bruise 
satan  under  our  ^gqU  Now^  the  Lord  of  peace 
give  you  peace  alv^ays,  by  all  means,  &:c. 

Quest.  Whether  Mr.  Parris's  going  to  Abi- 
gail Williams  and  others,  whom  he  supposed  to 
have  a  spectral  sight,  to  be  informed  who  were 
witches  and  who  afflicted  those  pretended  suf- 
ferers by  witchcraft,  in  order  to  their  being 
questioned  upon  their  lives  upon  it,  were  not  a 
turning  after  such  as  had  familiar  spirits;  and  a 
greater  wickedness  than  Saul  was  guilty  of,  in 
that  he  did  not  intend  thereby  bodily  hurt  to 
any  others? 

And  whether,  in  a  crime  of  such  a  high  na- 
ture, the  making  a  slender  and  general  confcs- 
12 


134  DIFFERENCES  IN 

sion,  Without  any  proposals  of  reparations,  or 
due  time  for  probation,  ought  so  far  to  be  ac- 
counted sufficient,  from  such  a  pastor  to  his  peo- 
ple? 

And  whether  such  as  were  accused,  or  the 
'Surviving  friends  and  relations  of  those  that 
were  any  ways  sufferers  by  accusations  so  by 
him  proved,  are  in  duty  and  conscience  bound  to 
continue  their  respect,  honour  and  support  to 
him,  in  the  ministry,  after  such  known  depar- 
tures from  the  rule  of  God's  word,  and  after 
such  dire  effects  as  followed  thereupon,  under 
the  penalty  of  the  dust  shaken  from  his  feet  ^  tes- 
tifying against  them,  even  so  as  to  render  them 
in  a  worse  case  than  those  of  Sodom  and  Go- 
morrah ? 

To  the  Honourable  Wait  JVinthrop,  EUsha  Cook 

and  Samuel  Seicall^  Esquires^  arbitrators^  indif 
fcrently  chosen,  between  Mr,  Samuel  P arris  and 

the  inhabitants  of  Salem  Village, 

The  remonstrances  of  several  aggrieved  per- 
sons in  the  said  village,  with  further  reasons  why 
they  conceive  they  ought  not  to  hear  mr.  Parris, 
nor  to  own  him  as  a  minister  of  the  gospel,  nor 
to  contribute  any  support  to  him  as  such,  for 
several  years  past;  humbly  offered  as  fit  for 
consideration. 

We  humbly  conceive  that  having,  in  April, 
1693,  given  our  reasons  why  we  could  not  join 
with  mr.  Panis  in  prayer,  preaching,  or  sacra- 
ments; if  these  reasons  are  Ibund  sufficient  for 
our  withdra vying,  (and  we  cannot  yet  find  but 
they  are)  then  we  conceive  ourselves  virtually 


SALEM  VILLAGE.  13^ 

dischatfijed,  not  only  in  conscience,  but  also  in 
law;  which  requires  maintenance  to  be  given  to 
such  as  are  orthodox,  and  blameless;  the  said 
mr.  Parris  having  been  teaching  such  dangerous 
errors,  and  preached  such  scandalous  immorali- 
ties, as  ought  to  discharge  any  (though  ever  so 
gifted  otherways)  from  the  work  of  the  ministry. 

Particularly  in  his  oath  against  the  lives  of 
several,  wherein  he  swears  that  the  prisoners 
with  their  looks  knock  down  those  pretended 
suiFerers.  We  humbly  conceive,  that  he  that 
swears  to  more  than  he  is  certain  of,  is  equally 
guilty  of  perjury  with  him  that  swears  to  what 
is  false.  And  though  they  did  fall  at  such  a 
time,  yet  it  could  not  be  known  that  they  did  it, 
much  less  could  they  be  certain  of  it ;  yet  did 
swear  positively  against  the  lives  of  such,  as  he 
could  not  have  any  knowledge  but  they  might 
be  innocent. 

His  believing  the  devil's  accusations,  and  rea- 
dily departing  from  all  charity  to  persons,  though 
of  blameless  and  godly  lives,  upon  such  sugges- 
tions; his  promoting  such  accusations;  as  also 
his  partiality  therein,  in  stifling  the  accusations 
of  some,  and  at  the  same  time  vigilantly  promo- 
ting others,  as  we  conceive,  are  just  causes  for 
our  refusal,  &:c. 

That  mr.  Parris's  going  to  Mary  Walcut,  or 
Abigail  Williams,  and  directing  others  to  them, 
to  know  who  afflicted  the  people  in  their  ill- 
nesses— we  understand  this  to  be  a  dealing  with 
them  that  have  a  familiar  spirit,  and  an  impli- 
cit denying  the  providence  of  God,  who  alone, 
as  we  believe,  can  send  afflictions,  or  cause  d^- 


136  DIFFERENCES  IN 

yils  to  afflict  any ;  tills  we  also  conceive  suffi- 
cient to  justify  such  refusal. 

That  mr.  rarris,  by  these  practices  and  prin- 
ciples, has  been  the  beginner  and  procurer  of 
the  sorest  afflictions,  not  to  this  Village  only, 
but  to  this  whole  country,  that  did  ever  befal 
them. 

We,  the  subscribers,  in  behalf  of  ourselves, 
and  of  several  others  of  the  same  mind  with  us, 
(touching  these  things)  having  some  of  us  had 
our  relations  by  these  practices  taken  oif  by  an 
wntimely  death ;  others  have  been  imprisoned, 
and  suffered  in  our  persons,  reputations  and  es- 
tates; submit  the  whole  to  your  honours  deci- 
sion, to  determine  whether  we  are  or  ought  to 
be  any  ways  obliged  to  honour,  respect  and  sup- 
port such  an  instrument  of  our  miseries;  pray- 
ing God  to  guide  your  honours  to  act  herein  as 
may  be  for  his  glory,  and  the  future  settlement 
l^f  our  village  in  amity  and  unity. 

John  Tarholl^   \ 

Samuel  Nurse^  f  Attorneys  for  the  people 
Jos.  Putman^   ?  of  the  village. 

Dan,  Andrew^  j 
Boston,  July  21,  1697. 

According  to  the  order  of  the  aforesaid  arbi^ 
trators,  the  said  mr.  Parris  had  some  of  his  ar- 
rears paid  him,  as  also  a  sum  of  money  for  his 
repairs  of  the  ministerial  house  of  the  said  vil- 
lage, and  is  dismissed  therefrom. 


PART  IV. 
LETTERS 

OF  A  GENTLEMAN  UNINTEREvSTED, 

ENDEAVOURING    TO    PROVE    THE    RECEIVED    OPINIONS 
ABOUT  WITCHCRAFT  TO  BE  ORTHODOX, 


Sir, 

I  TOLD  you  I  had  some  thoughts  concern- 
ing witchcraft,  and  an  intention  of  conferring  with 
the  gentleman  who  has  published  several  trea- 
tises about  witchcraft,  and  persons  afflicted  by 
them,  lately  here  in  New-England;  but  since 
you  have  put  those  three  books  into  my  hands, 
1  find  myself  engaged  in  a  very  hard  province, 
to  give  you  my  opinion  of  them.  I  plainly  fore- 
see, that  should  this  scribbling  of  mine  come  to 
public  view,  it  would  displease  all  parties,  but 
that  is  the  least.  Moreover  it  is  so  far  out  of  my 
road  to  set  my  thoughts  to  consider  a  matter  on 
every  side,  which  in  itself  is  so  abstruse,  and 
every  step  I  advance  therein,  ii'  I  miss  truth 
(which  is  a  narrow  and  undivided  line)  I  must 
tumble  down  headlong  into  iiie  (;u]ph  of  dange- 
rous error.  Yet.  notwithstanding,  I  have  forced 
jnyseU  to  senti  these  few  lines,  if  so  be  1  may 
12* 


13a  LETTERS  OF 

clear  to  you  a  truth  you  now  seem  to  be  offend- 
ed at,  because  of  the  ill  consequences  which  (you 
think)  lately  have  and  again  may  be  drawn  from 
it,  by  the  ill  condui:t  oi*  some  men.  I  am  not 
ignorant  that  the  pious  frauds  of  the  ancient,  and 
the  inbred  fire  (I  do  not  call  it  pride)  of  many 
of  our  modern,  divines,  have  precipitated  them 
to  propagate  and  maintain  truth  as  well  as  false- 
hoods, in  such  an  unfair  manner,  as  has  givea 
advantage  to  the  enemy  to  suspect  the  whole 
doctrine,  these  men  have  profest,  to  be  nothing 
but  a  mere  trick.  But  it  is  certain,  that  as  no 
lover  of  truth  will  justify  an  illegitimate  corol- 
lary, though  drawn  from  a  true  proposition;  so 
neither  will  he  reject  a  truth,  because  some  or 
many  men  take  unfair  means  to  prove  it,  or  draw 
false  consequences  from  it.  The  many  heresies 
among  christians  must  not  give  a  mortal  wound 
to  the  essence  of  the  christian  religion;  neither 
must  any  one  christian  doctrine  be  exterminated, 
because  evil  men  make  use  of  it  as  a  cloak  to 
cover  their  own  self-ends ;  particularly,  because 
=!ome  men,  perhaps  among  all  sorts  of  christians, 
have,  under  pretence  of  witchcraft,  coloured 
their  own  malice,  pride  and  popularity,  we  must 
not  therefoi'e  conclude  (1.)  that  there  are  no 
witches;  (2.)^or  that  witches  cannot  be  convict- 
ed by  such  clear  and  undeniable  proof,  as  the 
law  of  God  requires  in  the  case  of  death :  (3.)  or 
that  a  witch  so  convicted  ought  not  to  be  put  to 
death. 

1.  Thai  there  are  witches,  is  manifest  from 
ihe  precept  of  Moses,  Thou  shalt  not  svffer  a 
r^ltcli  to  live.  Exod.  xxii.  13.     For  it  is  certain 


A  GENTLEMAN,  .vc.  ijj 

God  would  not  have  given  a  vain  and  unintelli- 
gible law,  as  this  uiust  be,  of  putting  witches  to 
death,  it*  there  are  no  witches.  But  you  object, 
that  this  doth  not  answer  our  case,  for  we  have 
formed  another  idea  of  witches  than  what  can 
be  gathered  from  the  scriptures;  you  quote 
four  places,  viz.  Dent.  xiii.  Matt.  xxiv.  Jlcts  xlii, 
2  Tim.  iii.  from  all  which  you  infer,  that  witch- 
craft is  a  maligning  and  oppugning  the  word, 
works  and  worship  of  God,  and  by  an  extraor- 
dinary sign  seeking  to  seduce  any  from  it;  and 
this  you  readily  graiit.  But  then  you  say,  What 
is  this  to  witches  now  a  days,  who  are  said  to 
have  made  an  explicit  covenant  with  the  devil, 
and  to  be  empowered  by  him  to  the  doing  of 
thinfijs  strange  in  themselves,  and  besides  their 
natural  course?  This  you  say  does  not  follow; 
and  herein  indeed  consists  the  whole  controver- 
sy;  therefore  it  is  necessary,  that  first  of  all  we 
clear  this  point,  hiying  aside  those  prejudices  we 
may  have  from  the  fatal  application  of  this  doc- 
trine to  some  who  were  (in  your  judgment)  re- 
ally, at  least  in  law,  and  before  men,  innocent. 
In  a  word,  we  are  seeking  after  truth,  and  truth 
shall  and  will  be  truth,  in  spite  of  men  and  devils. 
I  do  not  repeat  this  caution  to  forestall  you  to 
believe^the  doctrine  of  witchcraft,  as  it  is  above 
defined,  without  inquiring  into  the  reason  and 
'truth  of  it;  only  I  desire  you  to  inquire  into  it, 
as  a  thing  doubtful.  For  no  man  can  be  certain 
of  a  negative,  unless  either  the  affirmative  ira|)ly 
a  contradiction,  or  he  can  prove  it  by  certain 
testimony;  to  neither  of  which  you  pretend; 
only  you  alledge  it  cannot  be  proved  by  scrip- 


140  lETTERS  OF 

ture,  i.  e.  you  cannot  prove  it,  nor  have  seen  it 
proved  by  any  other  you  have  read  on  that  sub- 
ject. I  am  not  so  vain  as  to  think  I  can  do  bet- 
ter than  the  learned  authors  you  have  consuUecJ 
with  (though  I  know  not  what  they  have  done, 
for  I  had  no  other  book  but  the  bible,  to  make 
use  of  on  this  occasion  ;)  but  because  I  am  satis- 
fied myself,  and  am  willing  to  communicate  my 
reasons,  which  I  divide  into  three  heads,  1.  The 
appearance  of  angels.  2.  The  nature  of  pos- 
session; and,  3d,  The  scripture  notion  of  witch- 
craft. 

1.  Good  angels  did  appear  to  Abraham,  and 
did  eat,  Gen.  xv.  It  seems  he  washed  their  ie^i ; 
it  is  certain  he  saw  and  heard  them;  therefore 
there  is  no  impossibility  in  angels  being  conver- 
sant with  men.  God  is  true,  and  whatever 
is  contained  in  sacred  writ  is  true ;  if  we  poor 
shallow  mortals  do  not  comprehend  the  manner 
how,  that  argues  only  our  weakness  and  igno- 
rance in  this  dark  prison  of  flesh,  wherein  we 
are  enclosed  during  our  abode  in  this  vale  of 
misery,  but  doth  not  in  the  least  infringe  the 
verity  of  scripture  ;  it  is  sufficient  that  we  ui> 
doubtedly  know  they  have  appeared  unto  men 
in  bodily  shape,  and  done  their  errand  they 
were  sent  on  from  God.  Now  if  good  angels 
have  appeared,  why  may  not  bad  .^  Surely  the 
devils,  because  fallen  and  evil,  have  not  there- 
fore lost  the  nature  of  angels;  neither  is  there 
any  contradiction  in  their  appearing  in  a  bodily 
sha])e,  now  after, any  more  than  before,  their  fall. 
But  you  will  say  you  must  allow  of  the  appear- 
ances of  good  angels,  because  of  the  scripture 


A  GENTLEMAN,  i.c.  141 

testimony;  but  not  oi'  bad,  seeing  there  is  no 
place  ol' scripture  tliat  clearly  proves  it.  Afati. 
IV,  The  words  in  the  gos[)el  do  as  plainly  signil'y 
the  devil's  outward  appearance  to  our  Saviour, 
when  he  was  tempted,  as  can  be  expressM; 
J^nd  when  the  tempter  came  to  him  he  said — hut 
he  answered.  The  same  form  St.  Luke  useth 
to  signify  the  appearance  of"  Moses  and  Elias, 
in  the  transfiguration :  ^nd  behold  there  talked 
with  him  two  men;  for  what  lollows,  ver.  3], 
who  appeared^  is  used  to  signify  (not  their  ap- 
pearance, but)  the  manner  of  their  appearance 
in  great  glory.  But  you  will  urge,  that  it  is  very 
easy  to  be  understood,  that  Moses  and  r  has 
did  appear,  because  they  had  human  bodies;  but 
that  it  is  unintelligible  to  you,  how  the  devil,  be- 
ing a  spirit,  can  appear,  a  spirit  being  a  substance 
void  of  all  dimensions;  therefore  the  words  in 
the  history  must  not  be  taken  in  a  literal  sense. 
Do  not  mistake :  though  some  philosophers  are 
of  opinion  (which  whether  true  or  false  is  all  one 
to  our  present  argument)  that  a  spint^'s  sub- 
stance is  extended,  and  hath,  besides  length, 
breadth  and  depth,  a  i'ourth  dimension,  viz.  es- 
sential spissitude ;  yet  the  same  do  not  say,  that 
pure  substance  is  perceptible  by  our  bodily 
senses;  on  the  contrary,  they  tell  us,  that  spirits 
are  clothed  with  vehicles,  «.  e.  they  are  united 
to  certain  portions  of  matter,  which  they  inform, 
move  and  actuate.  Now  this  we  must  not  re- 
ject as  impossible,  because  we  cannot  compre- 
hend the  formal  reason,  how  a  spirit  acts  upon 
matter:  for  who  can  give  the  reason,  that,  upon 
the  volition  of  the  human  soul,  tlio  hand  should 


142  LETTERS  OP 

be  lifted  up,  or  any  ways  moved?  for  to  say  the 
contraction  of  the  muscles  is  the  mechanic  cause 
of  voluntary  motion,  is  not  to  solve  the  question, 
which  recurs,  Why,  upon  volition,  should  that 
contraction  ensue   which  causes   that   motion? 
All  that  I  know  the  wisest  man  ever  said  upon 
this  head  is,   that  it  is  the  will  of  the  Creator, 
who  has  ordered  such  a  species  of  thinking  crea- 
tures, by  a  catholic  law,  to  be  united  to  such  por- 
tions of  matter,  so  and  so  disposed ;  or,  if  you  will, 
in  the  vulgar  phrase,  to  organized  bodies ;    and 
that  there  should  be  between  them  and  the  se- 
veral bodies  they  are  united  to  a  mutual  reaction 
and  passion.  Now  you  see  how  little  we  know  of 
the  reason  of  that  which  is  most  near  to  us,  and 
most  certain,  viz.  the  soul's  informing  the  body^ 
yet  you  would  think  it  a  bad  argument,  if  one 
should,  as  some  have  done,  conclude,  from  this 
our  ignorance,  that  there  was  nothing  in  us  but 
matter;  it  is  no  otherways  than  to  deny  a  spirit's 
acting  a  veliicle.     The  plainest  and  most  certain 
things  when  denied  are  hardest  to  be   proved; 
therefore  the  axiom  saith  well,  contra  principia, 
Src,     There  are  some  certain  truths,  which  are 
rather  to  be  explained  to  young  br^ginners  than 
proved,  upon  which  all  science  is  built;  as  eve- 
ry whole  is  more  tlian  its  part ;  and  of  this  sort 
1  take  these  two  following:    1.  That  there  are 
two  substances,  corpus  and  mew^,  body  and  spirit, 
altogether  different,   for  the  ideas    we  have  of 
them   are   quite  distinct.     2.  That  a  spirit  can 
actuate,  animate  or  inform  a  certain  portion  of 
matter,  and   be  united  to  it;  from  whence  it  is 
very  evident,  that  the  devil,  united  to  a  portion 


A  GENTLEMAN,  &c.  143 

of  matter  rwlilch  hercal'ter  I'll  call  a  vehicle) 
may  lall  unuer  the  cognizance  of  our  senses,  and 
be  conversant  with  us  in  a  bodil)  sfiape.  Where 
then  is  the  reason  or  need  to  run  to  a  metapho- 
rical and  forced  interpretation,  wIilii  tiie  words 
arc  so  plain,  and  the  literal  sense  iinplieth  no 
contradiction,  nor  any  greater  dilTiculty  than  (as 
has  been  said)  what  ariseth  from  the  union  of 
the  soul  and  body,  which  is  most  certain?  Now 
after  all  to  say,  God  will  not  permit  the  devil  so 
to  appear,  is  to  beg  the  question,  without  saying 
any  thing  to  the  preceding  argument;  and  it  is 
against  the  sense  of  almost  all  mankind;  for  in 
all  ages,  and  all  places,  there  have  been  many 
witnesses  of  the  appearances  of  daemons,  all  of 
whom,  that  taught  any  thing  contrary  to  the 
right  worship  of  the  true  God,  were  certainly 
evil  ones  :  and  it  were  most  presumptuous,  bare- 
ly to  assert  that  all  these  witnesses  were  always 
deceived,  and  it  is  impossible  they  could  all  agree 
to  deceive. 

2.  We  come  to  consider  the  nature  of  pos- 
session. The  man  possest  (^Luke  viii.  27)  had 
a  power  more  than  natural,  for  he  brake  the 
bands,  which  he  could  not  have  done  with  his 
own  strength.  Now  from  whom  had  he  this 
power?  1  he  scripture  saith,  he  had  devils  a 
long  time,  and  oftentimes  it  had  caught  him,  6cc. 
he  was  kept  bound  with  chains  and  in  fetters, 
and  he  br.ike  the  bands,  and  was  driven  of  the 
devil  into  tlie  wilderness.  This  power  then  was 
immediately  from  the  devil,  and  whatsoever  a 
possessed  person  doe-,  or  suifers,  beyond  his  na- 
tural power,  he  is  euabied  by  the  daemon  so  to 


144  LETTERS  OF 

do;  or,  to  speak  more  properly,  it  is  the  dasmon 
who  acteth  the  same,  as  is  plain  from  St.  Mark's 
relation  of  this  passage,  y,  2v,  A  man  with  an 
unclean  spirit.  3  v.  And  no  man  could  bind  him^ 
no,  not  with  chains,  6  %\  But  when  he  saw  Jesus 
ajar  o^,  he  came  and  worshiped  him;  and  the 
same  /le,  7  v,  said,  /  adjure  thee  by  God  that  thou 
torment  me  not ;  and  9  v.  My  name  is  Legion,  for 
we  are  many.  10  v.  And  he  besought  him  much^, 
that  he  would  not  send  them  away  out  of  the  coun- 
try. It  is  manifest  from  hence,  that  it  was  not 
the  poor  man  who  was  possest,  but  the  devils 
who  possessed  him,  by  whom  the  chains  had 
been  plucked  asunder,  and  the  fetters  broken  in 
pieces.  Now  here  is  divine  testimony,  that  the 
devils  have  actuated  a  human  body  to  the  doing 
of  things  beyond  the  natural  strength  of  that 
body,  as  it  was  simply  united  to  its  human  soul : 
how  much  more  then  can  the  devil  actuate  any 
other  portion  of  simple  matter,  earth,  air,  fire 
or  water,  and  make  it  a  fit  organ  for  himself  to 
act  in! 

But  enough  of  this  already:  let  us  rather  in- 
quire how  tile  devil  enters  into  the  body  of  the 
possest,  to  move  it  at  his  pleasure.  This  I  think 
he  cannot  do  as  a  mere  spirit,  or  by  any  never 
so  strict  union  with  the  human  soul ;  for  in  that 
case  he  is  only  a  tempter  or  seducer,  and  no- 
thing above  human  strength  can  be  done:  but 
here  there  being  something  performed  (the 
bonds  broken)  by  a  force  which  could  not  pro- 
ceed from  human  strength,  it  necessarily  follow^s 
that  the  devils  entered  into  t\ie  possest,  other- 
ways  qualified  them  as  a  mere  spirit ;  he  did 


A  GENTLEMAN,  kc.  U5 

not  enter  without  some  portion  of  matter,  to 
which  he  was  united,  by  the  intermedium 
whereof  lie  acted  U})on  and  actuated  the  human 
body.  Again,  it'  it  is  said  that  the  devil  entered 
as  a  mere  spirit,  and  immediately  acted  upon 
and  moved  that  body,  it  follows,  the  devil  hath 
a  vehicle,  a  certain  portion  oi'  matter  (that  bo- 
dy) to  actuate  and  dispose  of  at  will;  whicli  is 
absurd:  1,  Because  it  asserts  what  it  seems  to 
deny,  viz.  the  deviPs  having  a  vehicle  to  act  im- 
mediately upon;  and  to  be  united  to  a  portion 
of  matter  (is  has  been  said  before)  is  the  same 
thing.  2,  It  fights  against  the  catholic  law  of  the 
union  of  soul  and  body,  by  which  the  Omnipo- 
tent hath  ordained  the  voluntary  motion  of  a  hu- 
man body  to  depend  upon  the  will  of  its  human 
soul,  and  those  that  are  not  voluntary  to  proceed 
either  from  its  own  mechanism  or  material 
force;  hence  we  may  certainly  conclude,  that  it 
is  by  the  intervening  of  the  devil's  vehicle,  that 
he  enters  into  the  body  of  the  possest.  But 
what  if  you  and  I  cannot  agree  about  this  no- 
tion of  possession,  must  we  therefore  reject  the 
truth  itself,  and  run  to  a  far-fetched  and  intoler- 
able sense  of  the  words  .^  No,  our  opinions  do 
not  alter  the  nature  of  things;  it  is  certain  there 
were  persons  possest,  and  it  is  as  certain  that 
the  devil  entered  into  them,  either  with  or  with- 
out a  vehicle;  it  is  all  one  which  part  of  the 
contradiction  you  take,  the  consequence  is  the 
same,  viz.  That  the  devil  doth  act  immedi- 
ately upon  matter. 

There  is  another  acceptation  of  the    word, 
possession  in  scripture,  {./lets  xvi.  17)  where  one 
13 


146  ,     LETTERvS  OF 

is  said  to  be  possest  with  a  spirit  of  divination, 
the  word  commonly  used  to  the  priestess  oY 
Aoollo,  who  gave  responses;  and  it  seems  this 
damsel  was  such  an  one,  for  she  brought  her 
masters  much  money,  or  gain,  by  soothsaying,  till 
they  Avere  full  of  the  god.  Now  if  the  history 
«f  them  be  true,  that  they  were  demented,  and 
knew  not  themselves  what  they  uttered,  (as 
they  word  it)  their  case  is  not  ditferent,  but  the 
same  with  the  foregoing;  but  if  they  understood 
what  they  spoke,  then  had  they  familiar  spirits, 
whereof  there  is  frequent  mention  made  in  the 
old  testament,  and  one  good  king  is  commended 
for  having  cut  off  them  that  had  such  ;  thercibre 
I  think  the  meaning  of  the  word  was  very  ob- 
vious in  his  time  ;  neitlier  was  it  ever  contro- 
verted being  joined  with  any  other  name  than 
spirit,  familiar,  one  of  our  own  family;  that  is, 
oft,  every  day,  conversant  with  us,  and  almost 
ever  ready  upon  call  to  attend  us.  But  the 
consideration  of  them,  who  have  familiar  spirits, 
falleth  under  the  head  of  witchcraft,  which  we 
are  to  consider  in  the  third  place. 

3.  Witchcraft,  to  inquire  into  the  scripture 
notion  of  it,  and  compare  whether  it  be  the 
same  with  that  above  defmed.  The  cabalistick 
Jiearning  would  be  of  great  use  in  this  search, 
and  afford  us  much  light;  there  is  little  doubt 
but  that  there  arn  nrany  great  truths  not  com- 
monlj  known.  And  our  Saviour  expressly  cau- 
tions his  disciples  that  tliey  do  not  throw  their 
pearls  before  swino  :  therefore  it  is  no  wonder 
that  s*>m?  do  t'ii;e-.  tliougi  imquestionably  true^ 
are  not  so  lully  described,  because  the  authors 


A  GENTLEMAN,  Sicr  UJ 

who  treat   of  them  are  afraid,   lest  evIF    men 
should  be  the  more  depraved  by  being  inform- 
ed: but  I  am  in  no  such  fear;  nor  can   I  give 
you  any  other  thoughts  but  what  are  obvious  to 
any  man,  from  the  plain  sense  of  the  scripture. 
Our  detinition  we'll  divide  into  two  propositions, 
and     handle     them    severally.       1    Proposition. 
The    witch   is  empowered  by  the  devil  to  do 
things  strange  in  themselves,  and  beside  their 
natural    course.     2    Prop.     The    manner   how 
the   witch   is  empowered  to  do   those  strange 
things,  is  by  explicit  compact,  or  covenant,  with 
the  devil.     For  clearing  of  the   first,   we   will 
consider  the  four  places  above  cited,  wherein  a 
witch  is  called  a  false  prophet,  a  false  Christ,  a 
sorcerer,  a  resistor  of  the  truth,  and    is  said  to 
shew  signs  to  seduce  the  people  to  seek  after 
other  gods:  whence  let  us  note   three    things 
1.  That  those  terms,  witch,  false  Christ,  false 
prophet  and  sorcerer,    are   all   synonimous,  i.  e. 
signify  the  same  thing.     2.  That  a  witch  doth 
do   things  strange    in   themselves,  and  beyond 
their  natural  course :  for  it    were    most  ridicu- 
lous to  alledge  that  our  blessed  Saviour,    when 
he  said,  there  shall  arise  false  Christs,  and  shall 
shew  great  signs  and  wonders^  in  so  much  that  {if 
it  were  possible)  they  shoidd  deceive  the  very  elect, 
meant    that   cunning  cheats   should    arise,  and 
shew  legerdemain  tricks;  the  words  will  in  no 
wise  bear  it,  and  I  believe  you  are  far  from  thus 
interpreting  them ;  so  it  is  manifest  they  signify 
not  a  feigned,  but  a  real,  doing  of  things,  beyond 
their  natural  course ;  therefore  the  sorceries  of 
Elymas  and  Simon  were  not  simple  delusions. 


148  LETTERS  OF 

but  real  effects,  that  could  not  have  been  pro- 
duced by  physical  causes  in  the  ordinary  course 
of  nature.  3.  That  the  end  of  the  witches* 
shewing  these  signs,  is  to  seduce  the  people  to 
seek  after  other  gods;  from  which  premises  I 
infer,  that  the  witches  have  the  power  of  doing 
those  wonders,  or  strange  things,  immediately 
from  the  devil :  they  are  without  the  reach  of 
nature,  and  therefore  above  human  power,  and 
no  mere  man  can  etfect  them;  the  witch  then 
who  does  them  must  have  the  power  of  doing 
them  from  another;  but  who  is  the  other? 
God  will  not  give  his  testimony  to  a  He;  and  to 
say  God  did  at  any  time  empower  a  witch  to 
work  wonders,  to  gain  belief  to  the  doctrine  of 
devils,  were  Avith  one  breath  to  destroy  root 
and  branch  of  all  revealed  religion;  no,  it  can- 
not be,  it  is  only  God's  permission,  who  proveth 
his  people,  whether  they  love  him  with  all  their 
heart,  and  with  all  their  soul.  Therefore  the 
witch  has  a  power  of  doing  wonders,  or  strange 
things,  immediately  from  the  devil.  2  Propo- 
sition, w^e  will  subdivide  into  these  two. 
1.  That  there  is  an  express  covenant  between 
the  witch  and  the  devil.  2.  That  it  is  not  rea- 
sonable to  suppose  this  covenant  to  be  trans- 
acted mentally.  1.  The  devil  cannot  communi- 
cate this  power,  by  never  so  strict  a  union  with 
the  soul  of  the  witch;  for  in  that  case  he  is  only 
a  tempter,  and  nothing  above  human  power  can 
be  done,  as  has  been  already  proved ;  therefore 
the  devil,  who  improves  the  witch  to  do  things 
above  human  power,  must  either  appear  in  an 
external  shape,  and  instruct  him  how,  and  upon 


A  GENTLEMAN,  &c.  149 

what  terms,  he  will  enable  him  to  do  those  won- 
ders ;  or  else  he  must  enter  iiito  the  body  of 
tfie  witch,  and  possess  it.  The  demoniacs  in 
the  gospel  are  such  whom  the  devils  invade  by 
main  force,  tlieir  soul  having  no  further  com- 
mand of  their  bodies,  which  are  subjected  to  the 
Avill  of  the  devils  ;  whose  end  is  to  wound  and 
torment  those  miserable  creatures,  to  throw 
them  into  the  fire,  and  into  the  water :  but  the 
witch,  who  likewise  is  possessed,  is  not  treated 
in  such  an  outrstgeous  manner;  his  daemon  is 
tame  and  familiar  unto  him,  and  suffers  liim  for 
a  time  to  live  quietly,  without  any  further  mo- 
lestation, than  prompting  him  to  do  his  utmost 
endeavour  to  withdraw  men  from  God  ;  he  is 
not  bereaved  of  his  senses  as  the  poor  lunatic, 
but  is  conscious  of  all  he  does,  and  willeth  all 
his  crimes :  he  receiveth  power  from  the  devil 
to  do  wonders,  and  doth  them  to  serve  the  de- 
vil's turn.  Therefore  there  must  be  a  cove- 
nant, an  express  covenant,  between  the  devil  and 
him,  viz.  that  he  shall  obey  the  devil  and  serve 
him,  and  that  the  devil  shall  both  enable  him 
so  to  do,  and  also  reward  him  for  so  doing; 
for  if  there  is  no  contract  between  them,  how 
comes  the  witch  to  know  he  has  a  supernatural 
power  ?  or  how  can  he  so  peremptorily  pretend 
to  do  that  which  is  so  much  above  his  natural 
power,  not  knowing  he  has  a  supernatural  one 
enabling  him  to  do  the  same  ?  There  can  be 
no  doubt  but  there  was  a  very  intimate  com- 
merce between  satan  and  him  who  is  called  by 
St.  Paul  tliou  child  of  the  devil,  not  as  other  un- 
holy men,  but  in  an  especial  manner,  as  being 
13* 


150  LETTERS  OF 

the  enemy  of  all  righteousness,  who  would  not 
cease  to  pervert  the  right  w^ays  of  the  Lord.  It 
is  not  to  be  supposed  that  he  entered  into  this 
so  near  a  relation  with  satan,  with  which  he  is 
stigmatized,  that  others  may  beware  of  him, 
without  his  own  knowledge  and  consent.  And 
is  not  this  a  covenant,  an  express  covenant,  on 
his  part,  to  serve  the  devil  incessantly;  and  on. 
the  devil's,  to  empower  him  to  act  his  sorceries 
•wherewith  he  bewitched  the  people  ?  Now  I 
think  I  have  from  scripture  fully  satisfied  you  of 
the  truth  of  what  1   offered  in    a  discourse    at 

.     But,  since,  you  have  told  me  an  explicit 

covenant  with  the  devil  signifies  the  devil's 
appearing  in  a  bodily  shape  to  the  witch,  and 
their  signifying  an  express  covenant,  which  you 
say  cannot  be  proved  from  scripture.  It  were 
most  unreasonable  to  imagine  that  the  ceremo- 
nies of  this  hellish  mystery  are  particularly  set 
down  in  the  word  of  God;  therefore  we  must 
gather  by  analogy  and  reason  the  matter  how 
this  express  covenant  is  transacted ;  and  to  that 
end  I  will  set  down  these  following  considera- 
tions. 

1.  Under  the  law  God  did  ordain  his  people 
in  all  their  matters  to  have  recourse  immedi- 
ately to  himself,  and  depend  upon  him  for  coun- 
sel, which  they  were  ready  to  obey,  with  full 
assurance  of  aid  and  protection  from  him  against 
their  enemies.  This  the  devil  imitateth  by  set- 
ting up  of  oracles  among  the  heathen,  to  which 
all  the  kings,  nations  and  mighty  conquerors  up* 
on  earth,  did  come,  and  paid  their  humblest  ado- 
ration to  the  god  (as  the  devil  blasphemously 


A  GKNTLEMAN,  iic.  151 

called  himself)  of  the  temple,  in  which  they 
were  imploring  his  direction  and  assistance  in 
their  doubtliil  and  |)rosj>erous  allairs.  Again, 
God  instituted  sacriliccs  to  put  men  in  mind  of 
their  duty  to  the  Creator,  to  whom  they  owe 
all  things,  eyen  themselves  ;  but  the  devil  is  not 
contented  with  the  bare  imitation  hereof;  the 
acknowledgment  and  worship  he  receiveth 
from  the  deluded  world  is  not  enough,  though 
they  oiFer  up  unto  him  innumerable  hecatombs, 
unless  they  cause  their  children  to  pass  through 
the  fire  unto  him,  to  whom  no  sacrifice  is  so 
Avell  pleasing  as  that  of  human  blood.  And 
there  is  no  reason  to  think,  that  now,  under  the 
economy  of  the  gospel,  the  devil  hath  left  olF  to 
vie  with  God,  and  thereby  to  ensnare  men. 
No,  it  is  rather  to  be  feared  that  his  kingdom 
doth  now  more  prevail;  for  by  how  much  the 
light  is  greater,  so  much  greater  is  their  con- 
demnation who  do  not  receive  it :  it  is  reasona- 
ble to  su[)pose  that  (seeing  the  Son  of  God, 
when  he  came  to  transact  with  men  the  wond- 
erful covenant  of  their  redemption,  took  upon 
him  their  nature,  and  was  perfect  man)  the  de- 
vil likewise  doth  counterfeit  the  same,  in  up- 
pearing  in  an  human  shape  to  them  who  receive 
him,  and  confederate  themselves  with  him,  and 
become  his  vassals. 

2.  Consider,  it  is  not  probable  that  those  false 
apostles  mentioned,  2  Cor.  xi.  13,  erred  only  in 
ceremonies  or  circumstances,  or  that  their  er- 
rors, though  great,  did  proceed  rather  from 
their  ignorance  than  I'rom  the  perverseness  of 
their  minds.    ]  Cor.  iii.  15.     For,  for  such  we 


152  LETTERS  OF 

may  have  charity  and  hope,  that  God  will  be 
merciful  unto  them,  if  they  sincerely  do  the  best 
they  know,  though  they  dissent  in  some,  nay 
many  things,  from  the  practices  and  belief  of 
the  christian  church;  but  those  St.  Paul  threat- 
ens with  a  heavy  curse,  that  their  end  shall  be 
according  to  their  works  ;  therefore  it  seems 
they  immediately  struck  at  the  very  root  and 
being  of  the  christian  religion,  and  were  the 
same  with  them  spoken  of^  2  Tim.  iii.  6,  but 
with  this  difference,  that  they  did  not  resist, 
but,  beholding  the  miracles  and  signs  which 
were  done  by  the  true  apostle  of  our  Lord, 
wondered, and  believed  also,  and  were  baptized; 
yet,  being  sorcerers,  they  were  unwilling  to  lose 
that  great  esteem  they  had  obtained ;  as  it  is 
related  of  Simon,  who  had  bewitched  the  people 
of  Samaria,  giving  out  that  he  himself  was  some 
great  one,  to  whom  they  all  gave  heed,  from 
the  least  to  the  greatest,  saying,  this  man  is  the 
great  power  of  God  ;  therefore  he  could  not 
brook  that  Peter  or  John  should  have  a  great- 
er power  than  himself;  but  offered  them  money, 
that  on  whomsoever  he  laid  hands,  he  (that 
person)  should  receive  the  Holy  Ghost ;  which 
shews  him,  who  thus  designed  to  make  merchan- 
dise of  the  Spirit,  though  baptized,  to  have  been 
no  true  believer,  but  still  a  sorcerer,  in  the  gall 
of  bitterness,  and  in  the  bond  of  iniquity.  Such 
were  those  deceitful  workers,  who,  not  being 
able  barefaced  to  resist,  did  put  on  Christianity 
as  a  mask,  that  they  might  undermine  the  truth, 
and  introduce  the  doctrines  of  devils.  Samaria 
and  Paphos    were  not    the    only    two    places 


A  GENTLEMAN,  &c.  15S 

where  the  devil  had  sucli  agents ;  there  was  no 
part  of  the  earth  where  his  kingdom  was  not  es- 
tabhshcd,  and  wliere  he  had  not  his  emissaries 
before  the  preaching  of  the  gospel;  and  since 
the  text  telleth  us  lie  hath  his  ministers,  who 
imitate  their  master,  by  being  transformed  into 
the  apostles  of  Christ,  as  he  himself  is  transform- 
ed into  an  angel  of  light:  whose  design,  in  b(Mng 
thus  transformed,  cannot  be  to  impose  upon  the 
Almigiity;  for  whatever  shape  he  appears   in, 
he  cannot  hide  his  ugliness  from  the  eyes  of  him 
who  is  omniscient;  therefore  he  appeareth  thus 
in  the  shape  of  an  angel  of  light,  either  to  ternpt 
and  seduce  the  blessed  spirits  to  rebel  against 
God,   or  to  ensnare  wicked  men,  who  by  their 
heinous  crimes  (being  lovers  of  themselves,  cove- 
tous, boasters,  proud,  blasphemers)  were  before 
disposed  to  be  tit  instruments  to  serve  him,  and 
to  enter  into  league  with   him.     Surely  I,   who 
am   ignorant  of  the  laws  by   which  the  intel- 
lectual woild  is  governed,  dare  not  afhrm  that 
it  is  impossible  for  satan  so  to  appear,  as  to  hide 
his  deformities  from  the  good  angels,  and  under 
that  vail  to  tempt  them:  but  certain  I  am  that 
it  is  more  consonant  to  reason,  to  think  that  the 
aposde's  intention  here  was  to   teach  that   the 
devil  appeared  as  a  glorified  angel  unto  men,  to 
gain  ministers,  whom  he  might  imbue  with  the 
poison  of  his  black  art,  and  (when  he  had  got- 
ten full  possession  of  them)  instruct  theni  by  his 
own  example  to  transform  themselves  into  the 
apostles  of  Christ,  that  under  that  vizard  they 
might  with  the  greater  advantage  promote    his 
ends,  and  join  with  him  in  doing  the  utmost  des- 
pite to  the  spirit  of  grace. 


154  LETTERS  OF 

3d  Consideration:  It  is  against  the  nature  of 
this  covenant,  that  it  should  he  C(;nsuniinated  by 
a  mental  colloquy  between  the  devil   and  the 
witch.     I  know  not  how  many  articles  it  con- 
sists of;  but  it  is  certain,  from  what  has  been 
already  proved,  that  the  renouncing  of  Christ  to 
be  the  Son  of  God,  and  owning  the  devil  to  be, 
and  worshiping  him  as  God,  are  the  two  chiefs, 
to  which  our  Saviour,  who  weis  accused  of  cast- 
ing out  devils  by  Beelzebub,  i.  e.  of  being  con- 
federated with  Beelzebub,  was  tempted  to  con- 
sent :  If  thou  be  the  Son  of  God^  command  that 
these  stones  be  made  bread :  and  again,  throw  thy- 
self  down  from  hence  ;  for  it  is  written^  he  will  give 
his  angels  charge  over  thee  ;  and  again,  all  these 
things  will  I  give  thee^  if  thou  wilt  fall  down  and 
ivorship  me.     Whence  it  is   evident  that   here 
the  devil   laboured    to  insinuate  into  our  Lord, 
either  to  do  things  rash   and  unwarrantable,  or 
to  suspect  his  sonship,   revolt  from  God  his  fa- 
ther, and  worship  satan,  that  he  might   obtain 
the  glory  of  the  world.     Now   it  has  been  al- 
ready said,   that  when  Jesus   was  tempted,  the 
devil  appeared   unto   him  in    a    bodily    shape; 
therefore  it  is  agreeable  to  reason,  that  he  doth 
appear  in  the  same  manner  to  all  them,  whom 
he  also  tempteth  to   worship    him:  moreover, 
the  form  of  renouncing  a  covenant  ought  to  bear 
resemblance   to   the  form  of  entering  into  the 
same  covenant;  therefTe  men  who  are  receiv- 
ed into  the   mystic.il  body  of  Christ    by    God's 
minister,    who  in  God's  stead   expressly    cove- 
nanteth  with  and   tlien  administerelh  the  sacra- 
ment of  baptism  unto  them,  must  in  the  like 


A  GENTLEMAN,  kc.  155 

manner  ^o  out  of,  or  renounce,  the  said  cove- 
nant ;  at)cl  olthein  there  are  two  sorts,  one  who, 
through  tlie  perversenoss  of  their  own  hearts, 
the  lucre  of  the  world,  the  fear  of  men  more 
than  of  God,  abjure  their  Saviour,  turn  apos- 
tates, turks,  or  pagans.  The  other  sort  is  of 
them  who  contract  with  the  devil  to  be  his  sub- 
jects, in  the  initiation  of  whom  it  is  not  to  be 
supposed  that  the  devil  will  omit  any  material 
circumstance  which  tends  both  to  bring  them  in- 
to and  conhrm  them  in  his  service.  To  etiisct 
vs^hich,  his  outward  appearance,  when  he  re- 
ceives his  catechumens,  is  of  greater  force  than 
any  mental  contract ;  for  many  wicked  men^, 
who  have  denied  God  and  Christ,  not  only  in 
their  practice,  but  also  bl;jsphemously  in  pro- 
fession, yet  have  repented,  and  at  last  obtamed 
some  hope  of  mercy.  I  dare  not  say  it  is  im- 
possible for  a  witch  to  repent,  ar:d  find  mercy; 
the  secrets  of  the  Almighty  are  too  high  for 
me  ;  but  it  is  certain  that  these  wretches  are 
strangely  hardened,  by  what  passes  between 
them  and  the  devil,  in  a  bodily  shape,  particu- 
larly their  worshiping  Irim,  which  necessarily 
implies  his  outward  appearance  unto  them  ;  for 
no  man  can  love  evil  as  evil,  because  the  law  of 
self-preservation,  deeply  rooted  in  all  men,  de- 
tertnineth  their  will  to  pursue  that  which  seems 
good,  and  dy  from  that  which  seems  evil  to 
tliem;  but  the  inbred  notion  that  every  man 
has  of  the  devil,  is,  that  he  is  an  rnemv  and  de- 
stroy(!r  of  mankik.d,  tlierefore  every  man  hath 
a  natural  aversion  fr-  m  him,  aiid  consequently 
<jannot  formally  wouh:j:  him  as  such,  because 


156  LETTERS  OF 

the  object  of  worship  must  be  esteemed  to  be 
propitious  and  placable  by  the  worshipers;  oth- 
erwise, if  fear  alone  be  the  adequate  cause  of 
adoration,  it  follows  tliat  the  devils  and  damned 
in  hell  do  worship  God,  which  is  contrary  to 
scripture,  which  saith  they  blasphemed,  because 
of  their  pains  ;  whence  it  follows,  that  they 
who  worship  the  devil  must  have  changed  the 
innate  idea  that  they  had  of  him,  viz,  that  he  is  an 
implacable  worrier  of  men,  and  take  him  to  be 
benign  at  least  to  his  own ;  but  this  change  can- 
not be  wrought  by  any  suggestion  of  satan  into 
the  minds  ot  men,  whom  indeed  he  mentally 
tempteth  to  lust,  pride  and  malice  ;  but  it  is 
his  greatest  artifice  to  cause  his  insinuations  to 
arise  in  the  hearts  of  men,  as  their  own  natural 
thouojhts;  and  if  conscience  discovers  their  au- 
thor, and  opposes  them,  then  he  varnishes  them 
over  with  the  specious  colours  of  pleasure,  hon-_ 
our  and  glory  ;  and  so  represents  them  as 
really  good,  to  be  willed  and  desired  by  the 
soul,  which  judgeth  of  all  things  without  agree- 
ing to  the  ideas  she  hath  of  them  ;  but  because 
most  objects  have  two,  and  some  many,  faces^ 
and  she  not  always  attends,  therefore  she  often 
errs  in  her  choice  ;  nevertheless  it  is  impossible 
for  her  to  love  an  object,  whose  simple  idea  is 
evil ;  but  the  idea  we  have  of  the  devil  is  such, 
for  w'e  cannot  represent  him  in  our  minds  any 
otherwise  than  the  great  destroyer  of  men, 
therefore  no  mental  temptation  can  make  us  be- 
lieve this  our  grand  efiemy  to  be  ever  exorablo 
by,  or  in  any  measure  favourable  to  us  ;  whence 
it  evidently  follows,  that  the  devil,  to  work  thi;& 


A  GENTLEMAN,  &c.  151 

change  of  opinion  his  worshipers  have  of  him, 
must  appear  unto  them  in  a  bodily  shape,  and 
impose  upon  them,  whom,  because  of  their  great 
corruption  and  sinfuh)ess,  God  hath  wholly  left, 
and  given  up  to  strong  delusions,  that  they  should 
believe  a  he,  and  the  father  of  lies  ;  who,  now 
appearing  in  a  human  shape,  telleth  them  that 
he  is  not  such  a  monster  as  he  has  been  repre- 
sented to  them  by  his  enemy,  who  calls  himself 
God,  which  title  of  right  belongs  to  him;  and 
that  he  (if  they  contract  to  be  his  servants)  will 
both  amply  reward  them,  by  giving  them  power 
to  do  many  things  very  suitable  to  their  abomina- 
ble depraved  nature,  that  the  christians,  what- 
ever opinion  they  may  pretend  to  have  of  their 
God,  cannot  so  much  as  pretend  to,  and  also  that 
he  will  protect  and  defend  them  against  him, 
whom  heretofore  they  have  mistaken  for  the 
Almighty,  and  his  pretended  Son  Christ,  whom 
they  must  abjure  before  they  can  be  received 
by  or  expect  any  benefit  from  him.  Upon  no 
other  consideration  is  it  possible  for  any  man  to 
worship  the  devil ;  for  the  atheists,  who  deny 
the  being  of  a  God,  do  likewise  deny  the  exis- 
tence of  any  spirit  good  or  bad  ;  therefore  their 
drinking  the  devil's  health,  even  upon  their 
knees  (though  a  most  horrid  crime)  cannot  be 
construed  any  part  of  worship  paid  to  him, 
whom  they  assert  to  be  a  chimera,  a  mere  fig- 
ment of  statesmen  to  keep  the  vulgar  in  awe. 
Now  I  have  evinced  to  you  that  there  arc 
witches;  that  the  witch  receiveth  power  from 
the  devil  to  do  strange  things;  that  there  is  an 
express  covenant  between  the  devil  and  (he 
11 


158  LETTERS  OF 

witch;  that  this  covenant  cannot  be  transacted 
mentally,  but  that  the  devil  must  appear  in  a 
bodily  shape  to  the  witch;  therefore  I  con- 
clude, that  a  witch  in  the  scripture  is  such,  who 
has  made  an  explicit  covenant  with  the  devil, 
and  is  empowered  by  him  to  do  things  strange  in 
themselves,  and  beside  their  natural  course. 

II.  I  persuade  myseli'you  do  not  expect  from 
me  any  essay  concerning  the  methods  how  witch- 
es may  or  ought  to  be  convicted;  I  wish  those 
gentlemen,  whose  eminent  station  both  enables 
them  to  perform  it,  and  likew'ise  makes  it  their 
duty  so  to  do,  may  take  this  province  upon  them, 
and  handle  it  so  fully  as  to  satisfy  you  herein. 
I  once  intended  to  have  provided  some  materials 
for  this  work,  by  defining  four  principal  things 
relating  to  witchcraft,  viz.  1.  Witch-fits.  2.  The 
imps  that  are  said  to  attend  on  the  witch.  3.  The 
transportation  ol'  the  witch  through  the  air. 
4.  Lastly,  the  invisibihty  of  the  witch.  But  up- 
on second  thought,  that  it  v/as  foreign  from  my 
purpose,  who  am  not  concerned  to  compose  a 
just  treatise  of  witchcraft,  which  would  require 
more  vacant  time  than  my  present  circumstan- 
ces will  allow ;  only  I  proposed  to  give  you  my 
opinion  privately;  therefore  I  Will  venture  to 
make  use  of  an  argument,  which  sheweth  neither 
art  nor  learning  in  the  author;  and  it  is  this, 
That  seeing  there  are  witches,  and  that  the  law^ 
of  God  doth  command  them  to  be  put  to  death, 
therefore  there  must  be  means  to  convict  them, 
by  clear  and  certain  proof,  otherwise  the  law 
were  in  vain;  for  no  man  can  be  justly  condemn- 
ed,  who  ib  not  fairly  convicted  bv  full  and  certain 
evidence* 


A  GKNTLEMAN,  Lc.  159 

III.  In  the  last  place  we  arc  to  iiifjulre, 
nvlietlier  a  witch  ought  to  be  put  to  death  or  no? 
You  answer  in  tiic  negative;  because  you  say 
that  that  law,  Thou  siialt  not  sulier  a  witch  to 
live,  is  judicial,  and  extcndeth  only  to  the  peo- 
ple of  the  Jews;  but  our  Saviour,  or  his  apos- 
tles, have  not  delivered  any  where  any  such 
command,  therei'ore  they  ought  to  be  suH'ered 
to  live.  This  indeed  seems  somewhat  plausi- 
ble at  first  view,  but  upon  thorough  examina- 
tion hath  no  weight  in  it  at  all,  lor  these  rea- 
sons, 1.  All  penal  laws  receive  their  sanction 
from  him  or  them  who  have  the  sovereign 
power  in  any  state;  as.  Thou  shalt  not  commit 
■  adultery,  is  a  moral  law,  and  obligatory  over  the 
consciences  of  men  in  all  places  and  ages;  but 
that  the  adulterers  shall  be  put  to  death,  is  a 
judicial  law,  and  in  force  only  in  that  state, 
where  it  is  enacted  by  the  sovereign.  2.  The 
government  of  the  Jews  was  a  theocracy,  and 
God  himself  condescended  to  be  their  King,  not 
only  as  he  is  King  of  kings;  for  in  that  sense  ho 
is,  always  was,  and  ever  will  be,  supreme  Lord 
and  Governor  of  all  his  creatures;  but  in  an  es- 
pecial manner  to  give  them  laws  lor  the  gov- 
ernment of  their  state,  and  to  protect  them 
against  their  enemies;  in  one  word,  to  be  im- 
mediately their  Sovereign.  3.  Our  Saviour's 
kingdom  was  not  of  this  world;  he  was  no  judge 
to  divide  so  much  as  an  inheritance  between  two 
brethren ;  nay,  he  himself  submitted  patiently 
to  the  unjust  sentence  of  the  governor  of  the 
country  in  which  he  lived;  therefore  both  the 
rewards  and  punishments  annexed  to  his  laws 


im  LETTERS  OF 

are  spiritual,  and  then  shall  have  their  full  ac- 
complishment, when  the  Son  of  Man  at  the  last 
day  shall  pronounce,  come  unto  me  ye  blessed^  and 
depart  ye  cursed  into  everlasting  fire,  4.  That 
sovereigns,  who  have  received  the  gospel  of  our 
Lord,  have  not  therefore  lost  their  power  of 
enacting  laws  for  the  ruling  and  preserving  their 
people,  and  punishing  malefactors  even  with 
death;  so  that  the  criminal  is  as  justly  con- 
demned to  die  by  our  municipal,  as  he  was  here- 
tofore by  the  judicial  law  among  the  Jews* 
How  much  more  then  ought  our  law  to  advert 
against  the  highest  of  all  criminals,  those  exe- 
crable men  and  women,  who,  though  yet  alive, 
have  listed  themselves  under  satan's  banner,  and 
explicitly  sworn  allegiance  to  him,  to  fight 
.against  God  and  Christ !  indeed  all  unholy  men 
afford  great  matter  to  the  devils  of  blasphem- 
ing; but  these  wretches  have  confederated 
themselves  Vv^ith  the  devils,  to  blaspheme  and 
destroy  all  they  can.  And  do  you  think  that 
these  common  enemies  of  God  and  mankind 
ought  to  be  suffered  to  live  in  a  christian  com- 
monwealth ?  especially  considering  that  we  have 
a  precedent  of  putting  them  to  death  from  God 
himself,  when  he  acted  as  King  over  his  own  pe- 
culiar people.  But  methinks  I  hear  you  saying, 
All  this  doth  not  satisfy  me,  for  1  am  sure  noth- 
ing can  be  added  to  the  devil's  malice ;  and  if 
he  could,  he  certainly  would,  appear,  and  fright- 
en all  men  out  of  their  wits.  I  answer,  1.  We 
must  not  reject  a  truth,  because  we  cannot  re- 
solve all  the  questions  that  may  be  proposed 
about   it:  otherwise   all  our   science    must   be 


A  GENTLEMAN,  &c.  161 

turned  Into  scepticism,  for  we  have  not  a  com- 
prehensive knowledge  of  any  one  thing. — 
2.  When  you  say,  that  if  the  devil  could,  he 
would  appear  and  frighten  all  men — the  lawful 
consequence  is,  not  that  he  cannot  appear  at  all, 
for  we  have  undoubtedly  proved  the  contrary, 
but  that  we  are  ignorant  of  the  bounds  that  the 
Almighty  hath  set  to  him,  whose  malice  in- 
deed, if  he  were  not  restrained,  is  so  great  as  to 
destroy  all  men ;  but  the  goodness  of  our  God  is 
greater,  who  hath  given  us  means  to  escape  his 
fury,  if  we  will  give  earnest  heed  to  the  gospel 
of  our  Saviour,  which  only  is  able  to  comfort  us 
against  the  sad  and  miserable  condition  of  our 
present  state ;  for  not  only  the  devils,  but  llke- 
>vise  all  do  conspire  against  us  to  work  our  ruin. 
The  deluge  came  and  swept  away  all  the  race 
(save  eight  persons)  of  mankind :  the  fire  will 
in  time  devour  what  the  water  has  left;  and  all 
this  Cometh  to  pass  because  of  sin:  but  we,  who 
have  received  the  Lord  Jesus,  look  for  new 
heavens,  and  a  new  earth,  wherein  dwelleth 
righteousness.  Therefore  he,  if  we  purity  our- 
selves as  he  is  pure,  will  save  us  (for  when  he 
appears  we  shall  be  made  like  unto  him,  to  whom 
be  glory  forever.  Amen)  from  the  great  de- 
struction that  must  come  upon  all  the  world, 
and  inhabitants  thereof.  Farewell. 
March  8,  1693. 

Worthy  Sir,  ^^^^^^'  -^^^^^  20,  1693. 

The  great  pains  you  have  taken  for  my  infor- 
mation and  satisfaction  in   those   controverted 
14* 


I€2  LETTERS  OF 

points  relating  to  witchcraft,  whether  it  attai« 
the  end  or  not,  cannot  require  less  than  suitable 
acknowledgments  and  gratitude ;  especially  con- 
sidering you  had  no  particular  obligation  of  of- 
fice to  it,  and  when  others,  whose  proper  pro- 
vince it  was,  had  declineci  it.  It  is  a  great  truth, 
that  the  many  heresies  among  the  christians 
(not  the  lying  miracles,  or  witchcrafts,  used  by 
some  to  induce  to  the  worship  of  images,  &;c.) 
must  not  give  a  mortal  wound  to  Christianity  or 
truth ;  but  the  great  question  in  these  contro- 
verted points  still  is.  What  is  truth?  And  in 
this  search,  being  agreed  in  the  judge  or  rule, 
there  is  great  hopes  of  the  issue.  That  there 
are  witches,  is  plain  from  that  rule  of  truth,  the 
scriptures,  which  commands  their  punishment 
by  death.  But  what  that  witchcraft  is,  or 
"wherein  it  does  consist,  is  the  whole  difficulty. 
That  head  cited  from  mr.  Gaule,  and  so  well 
proved  thereby  (not  denied  by  any)  makes  the 
work  yet  shorter;  so  that  it  is  agreed  to  consist 
in  a  maligning,  Sic,  and  seeking  by  a  sign  to  se- 
duce, *&;c.  not  excluding  any  other  sorts  or 
branches,  when  as  well  proved  by  that  infallible 
rule.  That  good  angels  have  appeared,  is  cer- 
tain; though  that  instance  of  those  to  Abraham 
may  admit  of  a  various  construction;  some  di- 
vines supposing  them  to  be  the  Trinity;  others, 
that  they  were  men-messengers,  as  Judges  ii.  1 ; 
and  others,  that  they  were  angels.  But  though 
this,  as  I  said,  might  admit  of  a  debate,  yet  1 
see  no  question  of  the  angel  Gabriel's  appear- 
ance, particularly  to  the  blessed  virgin;  for 
though  the  angels  are  spirits,  and  so  not  per* 


A  GENTLEMAN,  &c.  icn 

ceptible  by  our  bodily  eyes  without  the  appoint- 
ment of  the  Most  itJioh,  yet  lie,  who  made  all 
things  by  his  word  in  the  creation,  can  with  a 
word  speak  tilings  into  being.  And  whether  the 
angels  did  assume  matter  (or  a  vehicle)  and  by 
that  appear  to  the  bodily  eye;  or  whether  by 
the  same  word  there  were  an  idea  framed  in 
the  mind,  which  needed  no  vehicle  to  represent 
them  to  the  intellects,  is  with  the  All-wise,  and 
not  lor  me  to  dispute.  If  we  poor  shallow  mor- 
tals do  not  comprehend  the  manner  hc-w,  that 
argues  only  our  weakness.  Two  other  times 
did  this  glorious  angel  appear.  Dan.  viii.  16. 
Dan,  ix.  21.  The  fust  of  these  times  was  in  vi- 
sion, as  by  the  text  and  context  will  appear. 
The  second  was  the  same  as  the  first;  which, 
being  considered  as  it  will,  ascertains  that  angels 
have  appeared,  so  that  it  is  at  the  will  of  the 
sender  how  they  shall  appear,  whether  to  the 
bodily  eye,  or  intellect  only.  MatL  i.  20.  The 
appearance  of  the  angel  to  Joseph  was  in  a 
dream,  and  yet  a  real  appearance;  so  was  there 
a  real  appearance  to  the  apostle,  but  whether 
in  the  body  or  out  of  the  body  he  could  not 
tell;  and  that  tliey  are  sent,  and  come  not  of 
their  own  motion.  Luke  i.  26,  ^nd  in  the  sixth 
month  the  an^rcl  Gabriel  was  sent  from  God,  Dan. 
ix.  23,  Jit  the  beginning  of  thy  supplication  the 
comniandnient  cameforth^  and  I  am  come.  v.  21, 
Being  caused  to  fly  swifly^  iyc.  But  Irom  these 
places  may  be  set  down,  as  undoubted  truths  or 
conclusions, 

1.  That  the  glorious  angels  have   their  mis- 
sion and  commission  Irom  the  Most  High. 


164  -  LETTERS  OF 

2.  That  without  this  they  cannot  appear  to 
mankind.  And  from  these  two  will  necessarily 
flow  a  third : 

3.  That  if  the  glorious  angels  have  not  that 
power  to  go  till  commissioned,  or  to  appear  to 
mortals,  then  not  the  fallen  angels;  who  are 
held  in  chains  of  darkness  to  the  judgment  of 
the  great  day.  Therefore  to  argue,  that  be- 
cause the  good  angels  have  appeared,  the  evii 
may  or  can,  is  to  me  as  if,  because  the  dead 
have  been  raised  to  life  by  holy  prophets, 
therefore  men,  wicked  men,  can  raise  the  dead. 
As  the  sufferings,  so  the  temptations,  of  our  Sa- 
viour were  (in  degree)  beyond  those  common 
to  man.  He  being  the  second  Adam,  or  public 
head,  the  strongest  assaults  were  now  improved  ; 
and  we  read  that  he  was  tempted,  that  he 
might  be  able  to  succour  them  that  are  tempt- 
ed; as  also  that  he  was  led  of  the  Spirit  into 
the  wilderness,  that  he  might  be  tempted,  &c. 
But  how  the  tempter  appeared  to  him  who  was 
God  Omniscient;  whetlier  to  the  bodily  eye,  or 
to  the  intellect,  is  as  far  beyond  my  cognizance^ 
a§  for  a  blind  man  to  judge  of  colours.  But 
from  the  whole  set  down  this  fourth  conclusion  : 

4.  That  when  the  Almighty  Free  Agent  has 
a  work  to  bring  about  for  his  own  glory,  or 
man's  good,  he  can  employ  not  only  blessed  an- 
gels, but  the  evil  ones,  in  it,  as  2  Cor,  xii.  7,  ^.^nd 
lest  I  should  he  exalted  above  iwas^ire,  there  was 
given  to  me  a  thorn  in  the  flf'sh^  the  messenger  of 
sat  an  to  buffet  me.  1  Sam.  xvi.  14,  15  k,  23,  ^n 
evil  spirit  from  the  Lord  troubled  him^  &:c.  It  is  a 
,great  truih,  that  we  understand  little,  very   lit* 


A  GENTLEMAN,  kc.  166 

tie,  and  that  in  common  things;  liow  much  less 
then  in  spirituals,  such  as  are  above  human  cog- 
nizance! But  though  upon  the  strictest  scruti- 
ny in  some  natural  things  we  can  only  discover 
our  ignorance,  yet  we  must  not  hence  deny 
what  we  do  know,  or  suiFer  a  rape  to  be  com- 
mitted upon  our  reason  and  senses  in  the  dark. 
And  to  say  that  the  devil  by  his  ordinary  power 
can  act  a  vehicle,  i.  e.  some  matter  distinct  Irom 
himseir,  who  is  wholly  a  spirit,  and  yet  this  mat- 
ter not  to  be  I'elt  nor  heard,  and  at  the  same, 
time  to  be  seen;  or  may  be  felt,  and  not  heard, 
nor  seen,  &;c.  seems  to  me  to  be  a  ciiimera,  in- 
vented at  firsi  to  puzzle  the  belief  of  reasonable 
creatures,  and  since  calculated  to  a  roman  lati- 
tude, to  uphold  the  doctrine  of  transubstantia- 
tion;  who  teacli,  that  under  the  accidents  of 
bread  is  contained  the  body  of  our  Saviour,  his 
human  body,  as  long,  and  as  broad,  &c.  for  here 
the  power  of  the  Almighty  must  not  be  con- 
fined to  be  less  than  the  devil's,  and  it  is  he  that 
has  said,  hoc  est  meum  corpus.  As  to  the  con- 
sent of  almost  all  ages,  I  meddle  not  now  with 
it,  but  come  to  the  fifth  conclusion: 

5.  That  when  the  Divine  Being  v/ill  employ 
the  agency  of  evil  spirits  for  any  service,  it  is 
with  him  to  determine  how  they  shall  exhibit 
themselves,  whether  to  the  bodily  eye,  or  intel- 
lect only;  and  whether  it  shall  be  more  or  less 
formidable.  To  deny  these  three  last,  were  to 
n^ake  the  devil  an  independent  power,  and  con- 
sequently a  God.  As  to  the  nature  of  posses- 
sions by  evil  spirits,  for  the  better  understanding 
of  it,  it  may  be  needful  to  compare  it  with  its 


156  LETTERS  OF 

contraries ;  and  to  instance  in  Samson,  of  vvhon^ 
it  was  foretold,  that  he  should  begin  to  deliver 
Israel.  And  how  was  he  enabled  to  this  work? 
Judges  xiii.  S5,  The  spirit  of  the  Lord  began 
to  move  him  at  times  in  the  camp^  Szc.  Chap.  xv. 
13,  14.  V,  Add  they  bound  him  with  two  new 
cords^  and  brought  him  up  from  the  rock;  and 
when  they  came  to  Lehi,  the  Phifistines  shouted 
against  him. ;  and  the  spirit  of  the  Lord  came 
might il if  upon  hini^  and  the  cords  that  were  upon 
his  arms  became  as  flax,  that  icas  burnt  with  fire, 
and  his  bands  loosed frtfnt his  hands^  &c.  I  might 
instance  further;  but  this  may  suffice  to  show 
that  he  had  more  than  a  natural  strength,  as  al- 
so wiience  his  strength  was,  viz.  he  Avas  empow- 
ered by  the  spirit  from  God.  And  now  will  any 
say,  that  it  was  not  Samson,  but  the  spirit,  that 
did  these  things;  or,  that  these  being  things 
done,  bonds  broken,  &:c.  by  a  force  that  could 
not  proceed  from  human  strength,  that  there- 
fore the  spirit  entered  into  him  otherwise 
qualified  than  as  a  mere  spirit;  or,  that  the  spi- 
rit entered  not  without  some  portion  of  matter, 
and  by  the  intermediation  thereof  acted  Sam- 
son's body?  If  any  say  this  and  more  too,  this 
doth  not  alter  the  truth,  which  remains,  viz. 
that  the  spirit  of  God  did  enable  Samson  to  the 
doing  of  things  beyond  his  natural  strength.  And 
now  what  remains  but,  upon  parity  of  reason,  to 
apply  this  to  the  case  of  possession  ?  which  may 
be  summed  up  in  this  sixth  conclusion: 

6.  That  God,  for  wise  ends,  only  known  to 
himself,  may  and  has  empowered  deviis  to  pos- 
sess and  strangely  to  actuate  human  bodies,  even 


A  GENTLEMAN-,  kc.  167 

to  the  doliitT;  of  things  beyond  the  natural 
strength  ol'  that  body.  And  lor  any  to  tell  ola 
vehicle,  or  matter  used  in  it,  I  must  observe  that 
general  rule,  Coloss.  ii.  u,  *' Beware  lest  any 
spoil  you  through  philosophy,  and  vain  deceit, 
alter  the  tradition  of  men,  alter  the  rudiments 
of  the  world,  and  not  after  Christ."  To  come 
next  to  that  of  witciicraft,  and  here  taking  that 
cited  head  of  mr.  Gauleto  be  uncontroverted, 
set  it  as  a  seventh  conclusion: 

7.  That  witchcraft  consists  in  a  maligning  and 
opposing  the  word,  wp^*]fc  and  worship  of  God, 
and  seeking  by  any  extraordinary  sign  to  seduce 
any  from  it.  Dent.  xiii.  12.  Matt,  \\\v.  24. 
Acts  xiii.  8,  10.  2  Tinu  iii.  8.  Do  but  mark  well 
the  places;  and  for  tliis  very  property  of  thus 
opposing  and  perverting,  they  are  all  there  con- 
cluded afrant  and  absolute  witches;  and  it  will 
be  easily  granted,  that  tiie  same  that  is  called 
witch,  is  called  a  false  Christ,  a  false  prophet, 
and  a  sorcerer,  and  that  the  terms  are  synoni- 
mous  ;  and  that  what  the  witches  aim  at  is,  to 
seduce  the  people  to  seek  after  other  gods. 
But  here  the  question  will  be,  whether  the 
witch  really  do  things  strange  in  themselves, 
and  beyond  their  natural  course,  and  all  this  by 
a  power  immediately  from  the  devil.  In  this 
inquiry,  as  we  have  nothing  to  do  with  unwrit- 
ten verities,  so  but  little  with  cabalistic  learning, 
which  might  perhaps  but  lead  us  more  astray; 
as  in  the  instance  of  their  charging  our  Saviour 
with  casting  out  devils  by  Beelzebub;  his  an- 
swer is,  if  satan  be  divicled  against  himselli  \m 
kingdom  hath  an  end.  But  seeing  «Il  are  agreed, 
.sei  this  eighth  conclusion : 


168  LETTERS  OF 

8.  That  God  will  not  give  his  testimony  to  a 
lie.  To  say  that  God  did  at  any  time  empower 
a  witch  to  work  wonders,  to  gain  behef  to  the 
doctrine  of  devils,  were  w^ith  one  breath  to  de- 
stroy the  root  and  branch  of  all  revealed  reli- 
gion. And  hence  it  is  clear  the  witch  has  no 
such  wonder-working  power  from  God.  And 
must  we  then  conclude  she  has  such  a  miracu- 
lous power  from  the  devil?  If  so,  then  it  follows, 
that  either  God  gives  the  devil  leave  to  empow- 
er the  witch  to  make  use  of  this  seal,  in  order 
to  deceive,  or  else  that  the  devil  has  this  power 
independent  of  himself.  To  assert  the  first  of 
these  were  in  etfect  to  say,  that  though  God 
will  not  give  his  testimony  to  a  lie,  yet  that  he 
may  empower  the  devil  to  set  to  it  God's  own 
seal,  in  order  to  deceive.  And  what  were  this 
but  to  overthrow  all  revealed  religion?  The 
last,  if  asserted,  must  be  to  own  the  devil  to  be 
an  unconquered  enemy,  and  consequently  a  sov- 
ereign deity,  and  deserving  much  thanks,  that 
he  exerts  his  power  no  more.  Therefore  in 
this  dilemaia  it  is  wisdom  for  shallow  mortals  to 
have  recourse  to  their  only  guide,  and  impar- 
tially to  inquire,  whether  the  witches  really 
have  such  a  miraculous  or  wonder-working 
power.  And  it  is  remarkable  that  the  apostle, 
GaL  V.  20,  reckons  up  witchcraft  among  the 
works  of  the  flesh;  which  were  it  indeed  a 
wonder-working  power,  received  immediately 
from  the  devil,  and  wholly  beyond  the  power 
of  nature,  it  were  very  improper  to  place  it 
with  drunkenness,  murthers,  adulteries,  &c.  all 
manifest  fleshly  works.     'Tis  also    remarkable^ 


A  GKNTLKMAN,  &c.  169 

that  witchcrai't  Is  generally  in  scrinfurc  joined 
with  spiiitual  whurcdoin,  i.  e.  idolatry.  This 
thence  will  plainly  appear  to  be  the  same;  only 
pretending  to  a  sign,  in  order  to  deceive,  seems 
to  be  yet  a  I'lirther  degree  ;  and  in  this  sense 
Manasseh  and  Jezebel,  2  Chroiu  xxxiii.  6 ; 
2  Kin<rs  ix.  22,  used  witchcraft  and  whcredcms. 
JVahiim  iii.  4,  the  idolatrous  city  is  called  mis- 
tress of  witchcrafts.  But  to  instance  in  one 
place  instead  of  many,  2  Thcss.  ii.  3  to  12,  par- 
ticularly 9  and  10  v.  Even  him^  ivhose  coming  is 
after  the  ivorking  of  satan,  ivitli  all  power  and 
signs,  and  lying  wonders,  and  with  all  deceivable- 
ness.  And  for  this  cause  God  shall  send  them 
strong  delusions  that  they  should  believe  a  lie,  that 
they  all  might  be  damned,  who  believed  not  the 
truth,  (St.  This  that  then  was  spoken  in  the 
prophecy  of  that  man  of  sin,  that  was  to  appear, 
how  abundantly  does  history  testify  the  iuUil- 
ment  of  it,  particularly  to  seduce  to  the  worship 
of  images!  Have  not  the  images  been  made  to 
move,  to  smile,  &c.  ?  Too  tedious  were  it  to 
mention  the  hundredth  part  of  what  undoubted 
history  doth  abundantly  testify.  And  hence  do 
set  down  this  ninth  conclusion: 

9.  That  the  man  of  sin,  or  seducer,  &c.  makes 
use  of  lying  wonders  to  the  end  to  deceive,  and 
that  God  in  righteous  judgment  may  send  strong 
delusions  that  they  should  believe  a  lie,  that  they 
might  be  damned,  who  believe  not  the  truth,  &c. 

'Tis  certain  that  the  devil  is  a  proud  being, 
and  would  be  thought  to  have  a  power  equal  to 
the  Almighty;  and  it  cannot  but  be  very  grate- 
ful  to  him  to  see  mortals  charpiriir  one  anotlier 


170  LETTERS  OF 

with  doing  such  works  by  the  devil's  power,  as 
in  truth  is  the  proper  prerogative  of  the  Almigh- 
ty, Omnipotent  Being.  The  next  head  should 
have  been  about  an  explicit  covenant  between 
the  witch  and  the  devil,  <fcc.  But  in  this,  the 
v/holc  of  it,  I  cannot  persuade  myself  but  you 
must  be  sensible  of  an  apparent  leaning  to  edu- 
cation (or  tradition)  the  scriptures  being  wholly 
silent  on  it;  and  supposing  this  to  fall  in  as  a  de- 
pendent on  what  went,  be  fore,  I  shall  say  the 
less  to  it;  for  if  the  devil  has  no  such  power  to 
communicate  upon  such  compact,  then  the  whole 
is  a  fiction;  though  I  cannot  but  acknowledge 
you  have  said  so  much  to  uphold  that  doctrine, 
that  I  know  not  how  any  could  have  done  more. 
However,  as  I  said,  I  iind  not  myself  engaged 
(unless  scripture  proof  were  cifered)  to  meddle 
with  it :  for  as  you  have  in  such  cases  your  rea- 
son for  your  guide,  so  I  must  be  allowed  to  use 
that  little  that  I  have,  and  do  only  say,  that  as 
God  is  a  spirit,  so  he  must  be  worshiped  in  spi- 
rit and  in  trutlj ;  so  also  that  the  devil  is  a  spirit, 
and  that  his  rule  is  in  the  hearts  of  the  children 
of  disobedience,  and  that  an  explicit  covenant  of 
one  nature  or  another  can  have  little  force,  any 
further  than  as  the  heart  is  engaged  in  it.  And 
so  I  pass  to  the  last,  viz.  whether  a  •.vlich  ought 
to  be  put  to  death;  and  without  accumulation 
of  the  offence  do  judge,  that  where  the  law  of 
any  country  is  to  punish  by  death  such  as  seduce 
and  tempt  to  the  worship  of  strange  gods  (or 
idols,  or  statues)  by  as  good  authority  may  they, 
no  doubt,  punish  these  as  capital  offenders,  who 
are   distinguished    by   that  one  remove,  viz.  to 


OENTLEMAY,  kc.  171 

tlieir  seducing  Is  added  a  sign,  i.  c.  they  pretend 
to  a  sign  in  order  to  seduce.  And  thus,  worthy 
sir,  I  have  i'reely  given  you  my  thoughts  uj)on 
yours,  which  you  so  much  obhged  me  with  the 
sight  oi";  and  upon  the  whole,  though  I  cannot 
in  tlic  general  but  commend  your  caution  in  not 
asserting  many  things  contended  for  by  others, 
yet  must  say,  that  in  my  esteem  there  is  retain- 
ed so  mucli  as  will  secure  all  the  rest :  (to  in- 
stance) if  a  spirit  has  a  vehicle,  i.  e.  some  j)ortion 
of  matter  which  it  acts.  Sic.  hence  as  necessarily 
may  be  inferred  that  doctrine  of  incubus  and  sue- 
cubus,  and  why  not  that  also  of  procreation  by 
spirits  both  good  and  bad?  Thus  was  Alexan- 
der the  Great,  the  British  Merlin,  and  Martin 
Luther,  and  many  others,  said  to  be  begotten. 
Again,  if  the  witch  had  such  a  wonder-working 
power,  why  not  to  aflllct  ?  Will  not  the  devil 
thus  far  gratify  her?  And  have  none  this  mi- 
raculous power,  but  the  covenanting  witch? 
Then  the  offence  lies  in  the  covenant;  then  it  is 
not  only  hard,  but  impossible,  to  find  a  witch  by 
such  evidence  as  the  law  of  God  requires;  for  it 
will  not  be  supposed  that  they  call  witness  to 
this  covenant;  therefore  it  will  here  be  neces- 
sary to  admit  of  such  as  the  nature  of  such  co- 
venant will  bear  (as  Mr.  Gaule  hath  it  in  his 
(ifth  head,  i.  e.)  the  testimony  of  the  afflicted, 
with  their  s|)ectral  sight,  to  tell  who  afflicts 
themselves  or  others;  the  experiment  of  saying 
the  Lord's  prayer,  falling  at  the  sight,  and  rising 
at  the  touch,  searching  for  teats,  (i.  e.  excrescen- 
ces of  nature)  strange  and  foreign  stories  of  the 
death  of  some  cattle,   or  oversetting  some  carf. 


172  LETTERS  OF 

And  what  can  juries  have  better  to  guide  them 
to  find  out  this  covenant  by? 

It  is  matter  of  lamentation,  and  let  it  be  for 
a  lamentation,  to  consider  how  these  things  have 
opened  the  floodgates  of  malice,  revenge,  un- 
charitableness  and  bloodshed,  and  what  multi- 
tudes have  bsen  swept  away  by  this  torrent. 

In  Germany^  countries  depopulated;  in  Scot- 
land^ no  less  than  4000  are  said  to  have  suf- 
fered by  fire  and  halter  at  one  heat. 

Thus  we  may  say  with  the  prophet,  Isa,  lix. 
10,  We  grope  for  the  wall  like  the  blind,  and  ive 
grope  as  if  we  had  no  eyes :  ice  stumble  at  noon- 
day as  in  the  night,  ice  are  in  desolate  places  as 
dead  men:  and  this  by  seeking  to  be  wise  above 
what  is  written,  in  framing  to  ourselves  such 
crimes  and  such  ordeals  (or  ways  of  trial)  as  are 
wholly  foreign  from  the  direction  of  our  only 
guide,  which  should  be  a  light  to  our  hei,  and 
a  lanthorn  to  our  paths  ;  but  instead  of  this,  if 
we  have  not  followed  the  direction,  we  have 
followed  the  example,  of  pagan  and  papal  Rome, 
thereby  rendering  us  contemptible  and  base  be- 
fore all  people,  according  as  we  have  not  kept 
his  ways,  but  have  been  partial  in  his  lawc 

And  now,  that  we  may,  in  all  our  sentiments 
and  ways,  have  regard  to  his  testimonies,  and  give 
to  the  Almighty  the  glory  due  to  his  name,  is  the 
earnest  desire  and  prayer  of,  sir,  yours  to  com- 
mand, R.  C. 

Sir, 

Since  your  design  of  giving  copies  of  our  pa- 
pers, if  not  to   the    public,  at  least  out  of  your 


A  GENTLEMAN,  6ic.  17o 

hands,  I  find  myself  obliged  to  make  a  reply  to 
your  answer,  lest  silence  should  be  construed  an 
assent  to  the  positions  whereby,  1  think,  truth 
^vould  be  scandalized. 

I  remember  that  some  have  taught  that  it  is 
not  certain  there  is  any  such  thing  really  in  be- 
ing as  matter ;  because  the  ideas  which  w^e 
have  of  our  own  and  all  other  bodies  may  be 
caused  to  arise  in  us  by  God,  without  the  real 
existence  of  the  objects  they  represent.  But 
this  opinion  is  not  only  absurd  and  false,  but 
hkewise  atheistical,  destroying  the  veracity  of 
the  Almighty,  Avhom  it  asserts  to  have  determ- 
ined us  by  a  fatal  necessity  to  believe  things  to 
be,  which  are  not;  and  1  wonder  that  you 
should  allude  unto  it,  because  that  angels  have 
appeared  in  a  dream,  in  a  vision;  for  we  dream 
also  of  trees,  birds,  kc.  Are  there  therefore 
no  such  things  in  naiure,  because  we  sometimes 
dream  to  see  and  hear  them,  when  we  are 
asleep?  St.  Paul  in  his  vision  was  so  far  from 
believing  the  objects  that  were  represented  to 
hmi  to  come  by  the  intermedium  of  his  senses, 
that  he  declares,  he  does  not  know  whether  he 
was  in  the  body  or  out  of  the  body;  therefore 
the  instance  is  in  no  wise  })roper.  For  Abra- 
ham and  the  Blessed  Virgin  did  see  and  hear; 
and  if  there  were  not  such  things  really,  as  were 
represented  to  them  by  their  senses,  they  were 
deluded,  by  being  made  to  believe  they  saw  and 
heard  what  was  not.  There  is  none  who  deni- 
eth  God  causeth  thoughts  to  arise  in  men's 
minds;  but  thence  to  infer  he  maketh  objects 
which  are  not,  by  forming  their  ideas  in  cm*' 
15* 


174  LETTERS  OF 

minds,  to  appear  to  us  through  the  ministry  of^ 
our  senses  as  though  they  were,  is  a  piece  not 
only  of  vain,  but  very  dangerous,  philosophy. 

It  is  true,  the  good  angels  will  not  appear 
without  the  appointment  of  God  ;  they  will  not 
do  any  one  action,  but  according  to  the  laws  he 
has  prescribed  to  them.  But  you  say  they  can- 
not, (which  does  not  follow  from  your  premises) 
supposing  their  not  appearing  to  proceed  from 
the  defect  of  their  power,  and  not  the  rectitude 
of  their  will ;  which  fallacy  has  deceived  you  in- 
to a  third  conclusion:  for  the  fallen  angels  are 
not  so  held  under  chains  of  darkness,  but  that 
they  can,  and  do,  go  to  and  fro  on  the  earth, 
seeking  whom  they  may  devour.  Before  their 
fall  they  could  have  appeared  if  sent,  and  would 
not  then  do  any  thing  without  a  divine  command ; 
but  now  they  have  rebelled  against  God,  and  do 
all  they  can  to  despite  him;  therefore  then'  not 
appearing  now  (if  it  were  true  they  never  did, 
they  never  shall,  appear)  must  proceed  from  a 
restraint  they  are  under,  which  is  accidental, 
not  essential  to  their  nature;  so  that  the  true 
conclusion  is,  the  fallen  angels,  while  they  are 
under  forcible  restraint  from  God  to  the  contra- 
ry, cannot  appear.  But  what  thi^  (being  clear- 
ed from  the  ambiguity  you  express  it  in)  maketh 
to  the  purpose,  I  know  not,  unless  God  had 
promised  for  a  determinate  lime  to  detain  them 
under  this  restraint. 

I  do  not  understand  what  you  intend  by  the 
dead  being  raised  by  holy  men;  the  most  natu- 
ral inference  is,  that,  in  imitation  of  them,  wick- 
<!*d  raen^  by  their  enchantments  calling  on  a  da?- 


A  GENTLEMAN,  .^e.  175 

iiion  to  appear  In  the  shape  of  the  dead,  will 
|Heteiid  that  they  also  can  raise  tlic  dead. 

The  Romanists  are  much  obhged  to  you  for 
making  transubstantiation  (so  much  contended 
for  by  them)  to  be  of  as  old  a  date  as  the  ap- 
pearance of  devils,  and  that  the  one  implieth  no 
more  contradiction  than  tlie  other  :  if  so,  we  do 
well  to  think  seriously  whether  we  are  not  guil- 
ty of  great  sin  in  separating  from  them;  for 
certainly  whatever  private  men's  notions  in  this 
age  may  be,  yet  it  is  matter  of  great  moment, 
that  all  antiquity  (the  sadducees,  the  elder 
brethren  of  our  Hobbists,  excepted)  liath  be- 
lieved the  appearance  of  evil  spirits  and  their 
delusions. 

I  should  be  too  officious  if  I  offered  to  explain 
how  matter,  real  matter,  may  fall  under  the  cog- 
nisance of  one  of  our  senses,  and  not  the  rest.  It 
is  for  you  to  shew  the  impossibility  thereof,  if  you 
will  build  any  thing  upon  your  assertion;  to 
prove  which,  your  first  argument  is  (it  seems  to 
me)  a  chimera;  which  is  not  enough,  when 
there  are  many  to  whom  it  seems  to  be  a  truth. 
Your  second  is  very  dangerous,  and  highly  de- 
rogatory of  the  honour  of  God,  between  whom 
and  the  devil  you  make  comparison  more  than 
once,  as  the  power  of  the  Almighty  must  not  be 
considered  to  be  less  than  the  devil's.  And  again, 
to  deny  these  three  last  were  to  make  the  de- 
vil an  independent  powei'.  and  consequently  a 
God.  These  expressions  (which  cannot  but  be 
very  pleasing  to  the  devil,  who  vainly  boasts 
himself  to  be  a  being  without  dependence)  arc 
altogether  groundless,  and  very  unmeet  to  pro- 


176  LETTERS  OF 

ceed  from  a  christian.  Consider  what  you  are 
doino- ;  to  estabhsh  a  doctrine  (the  contrary 
Avhereot'the  greatest  part  of  mankind  does  be- 
lieve) you  run  upon  such  precipices,  as,  if  you 
are  mistaken,  (and  that  is  not  impossible)  must 
totally  destroy  all  religion,  natural  and  revealed  ; 
for  suppose  it  were  generally  believed,  accord- 
ino-  to  you,  that  the  devil  cannot  appear,  because 
if  he  could  he  must  be  a  God,  independent,  an 
unconquered  enemy,  and  he  doth  appear  to  us 
as  we  hear  he  hath  to  multitudes,  both  of  the 
past  and  present  ages  ;  in  such  a  case  what  re- 
mains for  us  to  do,  but  to  fall  down  and  worship 
him? 

Upon  the  head  of  possession,  you  have  re- 
course to  that  instance  of  Samson,  who  was  em- 
powered by  God  to  the  doing  of  things  beyond 
the  natural  strength  of  common  men;  and  thence 
you  say,  we  may  at  least  learn  the  nature  of 
possession  by  evil  spirits.  This  comparison  is 
indeed  very  odious,  and  I  had  rather  think  you 
have  fallen  into  it  unawares;  for  what  greater 
blasphemy,  than  that  God  and  the  devil  do  act 
the  bodies,  which  the  one  and  tiie  other  do  pos- 
sess, in  the  same  manner?  If  the  hypothesis  I 
laid  down  had  not  pleased  you,  yet  you  ought 
not  (for  fear  of  being  deceived  by  vain  philoso- 
phy) to  have  run  to  so  horrible  an  extreme,  as 
to  assimilate  God's  manner  of  working  to  the 
devil's,  which  necessarily  implies,  that  either 
their  powers  are  equal,  or  at  least  that  they  do 
not  dilier  in  kind,  but  in  degree  only  ;  than  which 
nothing  c^^n  be  more  impious  or  absurd:  i'or  the 
most  possible  perfect  creature  is  infinitely  distant 


A  GENTLEMAN,  &c 


from  the  Creator,  and  there  can  be  no  compar- 
ison between  them. 

On  the  head  of  witchcraft,  you  acknowledge 
the  witch  has  not  his  wonder-working  power 
from  G.)d;  but  then  you  say,  the  devil  has  no 
such  power  to  give;  for  if  he  had,  lie  must  be 

.    This  way  of  reasoning,  as  I  noted  belbre, 

is  very  dangerous,  and  I  think  ought  not  to  be 
used ;  besides,  there  is  a  great  fallacy  in  your 
dilemma  ;  which,  because  I  perceive  you  lay  the 
whole  weight  of  the  matter  upon  it,  1  will  evince 
unto  you.  The  devil,  though  superlatively  arro- 
gant and  proud,  nevertheless  depends  on  the 
First  Cause  for  his  being,  and  all  his  powers, 
without  whose  influx  he  or  any  other  creature 
cannot  subsist  a  moment,  but  must  either  return 
to  their  primitive  nothing,  or  be  continually 
preserved  by  the  same  power,  by  the  whicii 
they  were  at  first  produced;  therefore  the  being 
and  powers  of  all  creatures  (because  they  imme- 
diately flow  from  God)  are  good,  and  conse- 
quently the  simple  actions,  as  they  proceed 
from  those  powers,  are  in  their  own  nature  like- 
wise good,  the  evil  proceeding  only  from  the 
rebellious  will  of  the  creature;  wherefore  it  is 
no  paradox,  but  a  certain  tiuth,  that  the  same 
action  in  respect  of  the  first  cause  is  good,  but 
in  respect  of  the  second  is  evil;  for  instance,  the 
act  of  copulation  is  in  itself  good,  instituted  by 
God,  and  may  be  explicitly  willed  and  df  sired 
by  the  soul,  which  sinneth  not  lor  exerting  the 
simple  act,  but  for  exerting  it  contrary  to 
the  laws  prescribed  by  God :  as  in  wedlock 
and  adultery  there  is  the  same    special    natii^ 


173  LETTERS  OF 

ral  action,  which,  considered  simply,  as  Agw 
ing  from  a  power  given  to  man  by  God,  h 
certainly  good;  but  considered  with  relation  to 
the  rebellious  will  of  the  adulterer  (who  iieth 
with  his  neighbour's  wife,  whom  he  is  for- 
bid to  touch)  is  a  very  great  evil.  Wc  may 
say  the  same  of  all  human  actions;  the  execu- 
tioner and  the  murtherer  do  the  same  natural 
act  of  striking  and  killing:  the  diiference  con- 
sists in  the  rectitude  of  the  one's,  and  deprava- 
tion of  the  other's,  will.  These  things  premised, 
what  more  reason  have  we  to  conclude  tliat  the 
devil  (because  he  shews  signs  and  wonders  to 
gain  belief  to  lies,  which  is  very  contrary  to  the 
Avill  of  God)  must  be  therefore  an  independent- 
power,  than  that  the  adulterer,  the  murtherer, 
or  any  other  sinner  (because  their  actions  being 
evil,  of  which  God  cannot  be  the  cause)  must  be 
independent  beings?  The  deceit  of  the  last  is 
very  palpable,  and  I  doubt  not  but  you  will  rea- 
dily acknov^'ledge  it;  for  it  is  obvious  from  what 
has  been  said,  to  the  meanest  capacity,  to  dis- 
tinguish between  the  action  itself,  which  is  good, 
and  flows  I'rom  God,  and  the  circumstances  of 
the  action,  the  choice  w^hereof  proceeds  from 
the  iniquity  of  the  will,  wherein  doth  solely  con- 
sist the  sin;  the  parallel  is  so  exact,  that  I  can- 
not see  the  least  shadow  ol'  reason,  why  we 
ouffht  not  in  like  manner  todistino^uish  whatever 
effect  is  produced  by  the  devil;  to  whom  (as  to 
man)  God,  havmg  given  powers,  and  a  will  to 
rule  those  powers,  is  truly  and  properly  the 
cause  of  all  the  actions  (in  a  natural,  but  not 
moral  sense)  that  flow  from  the  powers  he  has 


A  GENTLEMAN.  «.(  J7S 

given.  Tlicrcfore  the  wonder-working  power 
of  the  devil,  and  the  edects  thereof,  considered 
as  acts  of  one  of  God's  creatures,  are  not  evil 
but  good ;  the  using  that  power  (wliich  pro- 
ceeds froQi  tide  rebelhon  of  satan)  to  bear  testi- 
mony to  a  he,  is  that  one,  which  constitutes 
the  evil  theicoi". 

And  now  1  have  done  with  your  argument, 
wherein  you  have  indeed  shewn  great  skill  and 
dexterity  in  turning  to  your  advantage  what,  be- 
ing fairly  stated,  makes  against  you,  as  the  ap- 
pearance of  angels,  <S:c.  observing  nicely  the 
rules  of  pirt,  and  particularly  that  grand  one  of 
concealing,  nay  dissembling,  the  sauie  art;  as 
Avhen  you  quote  that  scripture  coucerning  vain 
philosophy  (of  which,  though  altogether  foreign 
i'rom  the  matter  in  iiand,  yet)  you  intend  to 
serve  yourself  with  the  unthinking,  who  mea- 
sure the  sense  of  words  by  their  jingle,  not 
knowing  how  to  weigli  the  things  they  signify; 
and  truly  herein  your  end  is  very  artificial :  for 
you  intend  both  to  throw  dirt  at  them  that  dif- 
fer from  you,  and  at  the  same  time  to  cover 
yourself  with  such  a  subtle  web,  through  which 
you  may  see,  and  not  be  seen.  What  Ibllon  s  is 
rather  a  rhetorical  lecture,  such  as  the  patriots 
of  sects  (who  commonly  ex})l'ain  the  holy  scrip- 
tures according  to  their  own  dogmas,  and  so  ob- 
trude human  invention  for  the  pure  word  of 
God)  use  with  their  auditors,  to  recommend  any 
principle  they  have  a  mind  to  establish,  than  an 
impartial  and  thorough  disquisition  of  a  contro- 
verted point ;  wherefore  1  do  not  tliink  mysell' 
obliged  to  take    aijy  inrthcr  notice  of  it  :.  espc- 


180  LETTERS  OF 

cially  seeing  truth,  which  for  the  most  part  is 
little  regarded  in  such  florid  discourses,  and  not 
anj  prejudice  of  education,  interest  or  parly,  did 
set  me  about  this  subject.  I  have  never  been 
used  to  coinpHment  in  points  of  controversy, 
therefore  1  hope  you  will  not  be  angry  because 
1  have  given  you  my  thoughts  naked  and  plain. 
1  have  not  the  least  motion  in  my  mind  of  accus- 
ing you  of  any  formal  design  to  injure  religion: 
I  only  observe  unto  you,  that  your  over  eager 
contention  to  maintain  your  principle  has  hurried 
you  to  assert  many  things  of  much  greater  dan- 
ger, both  in  themselves  and  their  consequences, 
than  those  you  would  seem  to  avoid;  which  do 
amount  to  no  more  than  that  men,  being  (in  the 
ordinary  course  of  providence)  the  depositories 
of  both  divine  and  human  laws,  may  (instead  of 
using  them  to  preserve)  pervert  them  to  de- 
stroy; which  indeed  is  very  lamentable.  But 
it  is  the  inevitable  consequent  of  our  depraved 
nature,  and  cannot  be  wholly  remedied,  till  sin, 
and  the  grand  author  of  sin,  the  devil,  be  entire- 
ly conquered,  and  God  be  all  in  all;  to  whom, 
with  the  Son,  and  Holy  Ghost,  be  glory  for  ever, 
Amen. 

Sir,  your  affectionate  friend  to  serve  you. 
Boston,  July  2b,  1694. 

jrr     7     o-  Boston.  Jlumist  17,  1694. 

Worthy  Sir,  '       *  ' 

Yours  of  July  25  being  in  some  sort  surpris- 
ing to  me,  I  could  do  no  less  than  say  somewhat, 
as  well  to  vindicate  myself  I'rom  those  many  re- 
flections, mistakes  and  hard  censures  therein,  as 


A  GENTLEMAN,  &c.  181 

also  to  vindicate  what  I  conceive  to  be  impor- 
tant truth ;  and  to  that  end  find  it  needful  to  re- 
peat some  part  ol'  mine,  viz.  conclusion 

1.  That  the  glorious  angels  have  their  mis- 
sion and  commission  from  the  Most  Hlo^h. 

2.  That  without  this  they  cannot  appear  to 
mankind. 

3.  That  if  the  glorious  angels  have  not  that 
power  to  go  till  commissioned,  or  to  appear  to 
mortals,  then  not  the  fallen  angels,  who  are  held 
in  chains  of  darkness  to  the  judgment  of  the 
great  day. 

4.  That  when  the  Almighty  Free  Agent  has 
a  work  to  briiig  about  for  his  own  glory,  or  man's 
good,  he  can  employ  not  only  the  blessed  angels, 
but  evil  ones,  in  it. 

5.  That  when  the  Divine  Being  will  employ 
the  agency  of  evil  spirits  for  any  service,  it  is 
with  him  the  manner  how  they  shall  exhibit 
themselves,  whether  to  the  bodily  eye,  or  intel- 
lect only,  or  whether  it  shall  be  more  or  less 
formidable. 

To  deny  these  three  last,  were  to  make  the 
devil  an  independent  power,  and  consequently  a 
God. 

The  bare  recital  of  these  Is  sufficient  to  vin- 
dicate me  I'rom  that  reiterated  charge,  of  deny- 
ing all  appearances  oi*  angels  or  devils. 

That  the  good  angels  cannot  appear  without 
mission  and  commission  from  the  Most  High,  is, 
you  say,  more  than  follows  from  the  premises; 
but  if  you  like  not  such  negative  deduction, 
though  so  natural,  it  concerns  you  (if  you  will 
assert  this  power  to  be  in  their  natures,  and  tiieir 
16 


182  LETTERS  OF 

non-appearance  only  to  proceed  from  the  recti- 
tude of  their  wills,  and  that  without  such  com- 
mission they  have  a  power  to  appear  to  mortals, 
and  upon  this  to  build  so  prodigious  a  structure, 
&c.)  very  clearly  to  prove  it  H^ scripture;  for 
christians  have  good  reason  to  taKe  the  apostle's 
warning  (if  some  philosophers  have  taught  that 
man  is  nothing  but  matter,  and  others  that  'tis 
not  certain  there  is  any  matter  at  all)  to  take  heed 
lest  theij  should  be  spoiled  through  vain  philosO' 
phv^  &c.  but  that  this  should  be  alluded  to  such 
as  never  heard  of  either  notion,  or  that  it  was 
asserted  that  those  real  appearances  to  Joseph, 
and  to  the  apostle,  were  through  the  ministry  of 
the  senses,  is  as  vam  as  such  philosophy.  As  to 
the  dead  being  raised,  had  I  used  art  or  rheto- 
rick  enough  (o  explain  my  meaning  to  you,  I 
needed  not  now  to  rejoin, — that  'tis  as  good  an 
argument  to  say,  that  because  holy  prophets 
have  raised  the  dead,  therefore  wicked  men  have 
a  power  to  raise  the  dead,  as  'tis  to  say,  because 
good  angels  have  appeared,  therefore  the  evil 
have  a  power  to  appear;  for  who  can  doubt, 
but  if  the  Almighty  shall  commission  a  wicked 
man  to  it,  he  also  shall  raise  the  dead  ?  as  is  in- 
timated. Matt.  vii.  22,  ^nd  in  thy  name  done  ma- 
mj  wonderful  vorks.  As  to  comi^jarisons  being 
odious,  particularly  that  concerning  Samson,  I 
think  it  neecli'ul  here  to  add  rhese  scriptures  fur- 
ther to  cotifirm  the  fourth  conclusion.  2  Sam. 
xxiv.  1,  compared  with  1  Chron.  xxi.  1.  In  one 
'tis  God  movcd^  &c.  and  in  tlie  other  Satan  pro- 
voked  David  to  number  the  people.  2  Chron. 
xviii.  21,  Jind  the  Lord  said,  thou  shall  entice  him^ 


A  GENTLEMAN,  &c.  13^ 

and  thou  shah  also  prevail ;  go  out  anil  do  even  so ; 
all  wliich,  with  many  more  that  mi^ht  be  pro- 
duced, will  shew  the  truth  ol'  the  conclu- 
sion; so  that  'tis  no  odious  comparison  to  say, 
that  as  the  Almighty  can  make  use  of  good,  so 
also  ot"  evil  spirits,  tor  the  accomplishing  ol'  his 
own  wise  ends,  and  can  empower  either  with- 
out the  help  of  a  vehicle:  for  possessions  must 
be  numbered  among  God's  afflictive  dispensa- 
tions, who  also  orders  all  the  circumstances 
thereoil  But  if  any  object,  God  is  not  the  au- 
thor of  evil,  &;c.  you  have  furnished  me  with  a 
very  learned  answer,  by  distinguishing  between 
the  act,  and  the  evil  of  the  act,  and  to  which 
'tis  adapt,  but  will  no  wise  suit  where  it  is  pla- 
ced, till  it  be  fu'st  proved  that  the  devil  hath  of 
himself  such  power  not  only  ol'  appearing  at 
pleasure,  but  of  working  miracles,  and  to  the 
Almighty  reserved  only  the  power  of  restrain- 
ing; iov,  till  this  be  proved,  the  dilemma  must 
remain  stable.  He  that  asserts,  that  because 
good  angels  have  appeared,  tlierefore  the  fallen 
angels  have  a  power  of  themselves  to  appear 
to  mortals,  and  that  they  cannot  be  employed 
by  the  Almighty,  nor  that  he  does  not  order  the 
manner  and  circumstances  of  such  appearance, 
what  doth  he  less  than  make  the  devil  an  inde- 
pendent power,  and  consequently  a  God  ?  So 
he  that  asserts  that  the  devil  hath  a  power  of 
himself,  and  independent,  to  work  wonders,  and 
miracles,  and  to  empower  witches  to  do  like  in 
order  to  deceive,  &ic.  what  doth  he  less  than 
own  him  to  be  an  unconquered  enemy,  and  conse- 
quently a  sovereign  deity  ?  and  who  is  he  that 


184  LETTERS  OF 

is  culpable  ?  he  that  ascribes  such  attributes  to 
the  evil  one,  or  he  that  asserts  that  the  so  doing 
gives  him  (or  ascribes  to  him)  such  power  as  is 
the  prerogative  of  him  only  who  is  almighty? 
And  here,  sir,  it  highly  concerns  you  to  consider 
your  foundations,  what  proof  from  scripture  is 
to  be  found  for  your  assertions,  and  who  it  is 
you  are  contending  for:  for  hitherto  nothing 
like  a  proof  hath  been  offered  from  scripture, 
which  abounds  so  with  the  contrary,  that  he 
that  runs  may  read  ;  as.  Shall  there  he  evil  in  the 
city,  and  the  Lord  hath  not  done  it  ?  Who  is  he 
that  saith,  and  it  cometh  to  pass,  when  the  Lord 
comniandeth  not  ?  Who  among  the  gods  of  the  hea- 
then (of  which  the  devil  is  one)  can  give  rain  ?  &;c. 

But  I  shall  not  be  tedious  in  multiplying  proofs, 
to  that  which  all  seem  to  own.  For  as  to  that 
stale  plea  of  universality,  do  say  that  I  have 
read  of  one,  if  not  several,  general  councils,  that 
have  not  only  disapproved,  but  anathematised 
them  that  have  ascribed  such  powers  to  the  de- 
vils. And  several  national  protestant  churches 
at  this  day,  in  their  exhortations  before  the  sa^ 
crament  (among  other  enormous  crimes)  admo- 
nish all  that  believe  any  such  power  in  the 
witch,  &c.  to  withdraw,  as  unmeet  to  partake 
at  the  Lord's  table. 

And  I  believe  christians  in  general,  if  they 
were  asked,  would  own  that  what  powers  the 
devil  may  at  any  time  have  to  appear,  to  afflict, 
destroy,  or  cause  tempests,  (fee  must  be  by  pow- 
er or  commission  from  the  Sovereign  Being; 
and  that,  having  such  a  commission,  not  only 
hail,  but  frogs,  lice,  or  fleas,  shall  be  empower- 


A  GENTLEMAN,  &c.  105 

ed  to  plague  a  great  king  and  kingdom.  And  if 
so,  this  sandy  structure  of  the  devil's  appearance, 
and  working  wonders,  at  pleasure,  and  of  em- 
powering witches  to  afflict,  &:c.  (for  to  this  nar- 
row crisis  is  that  whole  doctrine  reduced)  the 
whole  disappears  at  the  first  shaking. 

Thus,  worthy  sir,  I  have  given  you  my  senti- 
ments, and  the  grounds  thereof,  as  plainly  and 
as  concise  as  1  was  able;  though  'tis  indeed  a 
subject  that  calls  for  the  ablest  pens  to  discuss, 
acknowledging  myself  to  be  insufficient  for  these 
things.  However,  I  think  I  have  done  but  my 
duty,  for  the  glory  of  God,  the  sovereign  being; 
and  have  purposely  avoided  such  a  reply  as 
some  parts  of  yours  required;  and  pray  that 
not  only  you  and  I,  but  all  mankind,  may  give 
to  the   Almighty  the  glory  due  unto  his  nam^. 

From,  sir,  yours  to  command,  R.  C. 

Witchcraft  is  manijeatly  a  tvork  ofthejlesh. 
16* 


189 


PART  V. 
AN  IMPARTIAL  ACCOUNT 

OF  THE  MOST   MEMORABLE 

MATTERS  OF  FACT, 

TOUCHING  THE  SUPrOSED  WITCHCRAFT  IN   KEVV-ENGLAND. 


J-tXR.  PARRIS  had  been  some  years  a  mi- 
nister in  Salem  Village,  when  this  sad  calamity, 
as  a  deluge,  overflowed  them,  spreading  itself 
far  and  near.  He  was  a  gentleman  of  liberal 
education;  and,  not  meeting  with  any  great  en- 
couragement, or  advantage,  in  merchandising, 
to  which  for  some  time  he  applred  himself,  be- 
took himself  to  the  w^ork  of  the  ministry;  this 
Village  being  then  vacant,  hq  met  with  so  much 
encouragement,  as  to  settle  in  that  capacity 
amons:  them. 

After  he  had  been  there  about  two  years,  he 
obtained  a  grant  from  a  part  of  the  town,  that 
the  house  and  land  he  occupied,  and  which  had 
been  allotted  by  the  whole  people  to  the  min- 
istry, should  be  and  remain  to  him,  (fee.  as  his 
own  estate  in  fee  simple.  This  occasioned  great 
divisions   both  between  the   inhabitants   them- 


MATTERS 

selves,  and  between  a  considerable  part  of  them 
and  their  said  minister;  which  divisions  were 
but  as  a  beginning,  or  prelude,  to  what  immedi* 
ately  followed. 

It  was  the  latter  end  o{' February,  1691,  when 
V  divers  young  persons  belonging  to  mr.  Parris's 
^  family,  and  one  or  more  of  the  neiglibourhood, 
began  to  act  alter  a  strange  and  unusual  manner, 
viz.  as  by  getting  into  holes,  and  creeping  un- 
der chairs  and  stools,  and  to  use  sundry  odd  pos- 
tures and  antick  gestures,  uttering  foolish,  ri- 
diculous speeches,  which  neither  they  them- 
selves nor  any  others  could  make  sense  of. 
The  physicians  that  were  called  could  assign  no 
reason  for  this;  but  it  seems  one  of  them,  hav- 
ing recourse  to  the  old  shift,  told  them,  he 
was  afraid  they  were  bevvitched.  Upon  such 
suggestions,  they  that  were  concerned  applied 
themselves  to  lasting  and  prayer,  which  w^as  at- 
tended not  only  in  their  own  private  families, 
but  with  calling  in  the  help  of  others.  March 
the  ll/A,  mr.  Parris  invited  several  neighbour- 
ing ministers  to  join  with  him  in  keeping  a  so- 
lenm  day  of  prayer  at  his  own  house.  The 
time  of  the  exercise,  those  persons  were  for  the 
most  part  silent;  but  after  any  one  prayer  was 
ended,  they  would  act  and  speak  strangely  and 
ridiculously;  yet  were  such  as  had  been  well 
educated,  and  of  good  behaviour;  the  one,  a  girl 
of  11  or  12  years  old,  would  sometimes  seem  to 
be  in  a  convulsion  fit,  her  limbs  bong  twisted 
several  ways,  and  very  stiti",  but  presently  her 
fit  would  be  over. 

A  few  days  before  this  solemn  day  of  prayer. 


OF  FACT,  kc.  189 

mr.  Parris's  Indian  man  and  woman  made  a 
cake  ol"  rye  meal,  with  tlie  children's  water,  and 
baked  it  in  the  ashes,  and,  as  is  said,  gave  it 
to  the  dog;  this  was  done  as  a  means  to  disco- 
ver witchcraft ;  soon  after  which,  those  ill  af- 
fected or  afflicted  persons  named  several  that 
they  said  they  saw,  when  in  their  fits,  afflicting 
them. 

The  first  complained  of  was  the  said  Indian 
woman,  named  Tituba:  she  confessed  that  the 
devil  urged  her  to  sign  a  book,  which  he  pre* 
sented  to  her,  and  also  to  work  mischief  to  the 
children,  &:c.  She  was  afterwards  committed 
to  prison,  and  lay  there  till  sold  for  her  fees. 
Tiie  account  she  since  gives  of  it  is,  that  her 
master  did  beat  her,  and  otherways  abuse  her, 
to  make  her  confess  and  accuse  (such  as  he 
called)  her  sister-witches;  and  that  whatsoever 
she  said  by  way  of  confessing,  or  accusing  oth- 
ers, was  the  elFect  of  such  usage;  her  master 
refused  to  pay  her  fees,  unless  she  would  stand 
to  what  she  had  said. 

The  children  complained  likewise  of  two  oth- 
er women,  to  be  the  authors  of  their  hurt,  viz. 
Sarah  Good,  who  had  long  been  counted  a  me- 
Jancholy  or  distracted  woman ;  and  one  Osborn, 
an  old  bed-ridden  woman;  which  two  were  per- 
sons so  ill  thought  of,  that  the  accusation  was 
the  more  readily  believed;  and,  after  examina- 
tion before  two  Salem  magistrates,  were  com- 
mitted. March  9th,  mr.  Lowson  (who  had 
been  formerly  a  preacher  at  the  said  village) 
came  thither,  and  hath  since  set  forth,  in  print, 
an  account  of  wjjat  then  passed;  about  which 


190  MATTERS 

time,  as  he  saith,  thej  complained  of  goodwife 
Corj,  and  goodwife  Nurse,  members  of  church- 
es at  the  Village  and  at  Salem,  many  others  be- 
ing by  that  time  accused. 

March  21.  Goodwife  Cory  was  examined  be- 
fore the  magistrates  of  Salem,  at  the  meeting 
house  in  the  Village,  a  throng  of  spectators  being 
present  to  see  the  novelty.  Mr.  Noyes,  one  of 
\tiie  miiiislGrs  of  Salem,  began  with  prayer;  after 
which  ihc  prisoiier  being  called,  in  order  to  an- 
swer to  what  should  be  alledged  against  her, 
she  desired  that  she  might  go  to  prayer;  and 
w-as  answered  by  the  magistrates,  that  they  did 
not  come  to  hear  her  pray,  but  to  examine  her. 

The  number  of  the  afflicted  w^ere  at  that 
time  about  ten,  viz.  mrs.  Pope,  mrs.  Putman, 
goodwife  Bibber  and  goodwife  Goodall,  Mary 
VVolcott,  Mercy  Lewes  (at  Thomas  Putman's) 
and  Dr,  Grigg's  maid,  and  thvce  girls,  viz,  Ehza- 
beth  Parris,  daughter  to  the  minister,  Abigail 
Williams,  his  niece,  and  Ann  Putman;  which 
last  three  were  not  only  the  beginners,  but  were 
also  the  chief,  in  these  accusations.  These  ten 
were  most  of  them  present  at  the  examination, 
and  did  vehemently  accuse  her  of  afflicting  them, 
by  biting,  pincliing,  strangling,  <kc.  and  they  said 
they  did  in  their  fits  see  her  likeness  coming  to 
them,  and  bringing  a  book  for  them  to  sign. 
Mr.  Hathorn,  a  magistrate  of  Salem,  asked  her 
\Yhy  she  afflicted  those  children.  She  said,  she 
did  not  afflict  them.  He  asked  her  who  did 
then.  She  said,  1  do  not  know,  how  should  I 
know?  She  said,  they  were  poor  distracted 
creatures,  and  no  heed  ought  to  be  given   ta 


OF  FACT,  kc.  191 

what  thej  said.  Mr.  Ilalhs-n  and  nir.  Noycs 
replied  that  it  was  (he  jiid^jjrnciit  of"  all  that 
were  there  present,  tliat  they  were  bewitched, 
and  only  she  (the  accused)  said  they  were  dis- 
tracted. Siie  was  accuse^I  hy  tliem,  that  the 
black  man  wliispered  to  her  in  her  ear  now^ 
(while  she  was  upon  examination)  and  that  she 
had  a  yellow  bird,  that  did  use  to  suck  between 
lier  finders,  and  that  the  said  bird  did  suck  now 
in  the  assembly.  Order  being  given  to  look  in 
that  place  to  see  il'  there  were  any  sign,  the 
girl  that  pretended  to  see  it  said,  that  it  was  too 
late  now,  for  she  had  removed  a  pin,  and  put  it 
on  her  head ;  it  was  upon  search  found,  that  a 
pin  was  there  sticking  upright.  When  the  ac- 
cused had  any  motion  of  their  body,  hands  or 
mouth,  the  accusers  wx)uld  cry  out ;  as  when 
she  bit  a  lip,  they  would  cry  out  of  being  bitten; 
if  she  grasped  one  hand  with  the  other,  they 
would  cry  out  of  being  pinched  by  her,  and 
would  produce  marks;  so  of  the  other  motions 
of  her  body,  as  comj)laining  of  being  prest,  when 
she  leaned  to  the  seat  next  her;  if  she  stirred 
her  feet,  they  would  stamp,  and  cry  out  of  pain 
there.  After  the  hearing,  the  said  Cory  was 
committed  to  Salem  prison,  and  then  their  cry- 
ing out  of  her  abated. 

J^la-xh  24,  goodwife  Nurse  was  brought  be- 
fore mr.  Hathorn  and  mr.  Curwii)  (magistrates)  \/ 
in  the  meeting  house.  Mr.  Hale,  minister  of 
Beverly,  began  with  prayer;  alter  which  she, 
being  nccused  of  much  the  same  crimes,  made 
the  like  answers,  asserting  her  own  innocence 
with  earnestness.    Tiie  accusers  were  mostly  the 


192  MATTERS 

same,  Thomas  Putman's  wife,  &c.  complaining 
much.  The  dreadful  shrieking  from  her  and 
others  was  very  amazing,  which  was  heard  at  a 
great  distance.  She  was  also  committed  to  pri- 
son. 

A  child  of  Sarah  Good's  was  likewise  appre- 
hended, being  between  4  and  5  years  old.  The 
accusers  said  this  child  bit  them,  and  would  shew 
such  like  marks,  as  those  of  a  small  set  of  teeth, 
upon  their  arms:  as  many  of  the  afflicted  as  the 
child  cast  its  eye  upon,  would  complain  they 
were  in  torment:  which  child  they  also  com- 
mitted. 

V  Concerning  those  that  had  been  hitherto  ex- 
amined and  committed,  it  is  among  other  things 
observed,  by  Mr.  Lawson  (in  print)  that  they 
w^ere  by  the  accusers  charged  to  belong  to  a 
company  that  did  muster  in  arms,  and  were  re- 
ported by  them  to  keep  days  of  last,  thanksgiv- 
ing and  sacraments  ;  and  that  those  afflicted  (or 
accusers)  did  in  the  assembly  cure  each  other, 
even  with  a  touch  of  their  hand,  when  strangled 
and  other  ways  tortured,  and  would  endeavour 
to  get  to  the  afflicted  to  relieve  them  thereby 
(for  hitherto  they  had  not  used  the  experiment 
of  bringing  the  accused  to  touch  the  afflicted,  in 
order  to  their  cure)  and  could  foretel  one  anoth- 
er's fit  to  be  coming^,  and  would  say,  look  to  such 
a  one,  she  will  have  a  tit  presently,  and  so  it 
happened;  and  that  at  the  same  time  when  the 
accused  person  was  present,  the  afflicted  said 
they  saw  her  spectre  or  hkeness  in  other  places 
of  the  meeting-house  sucking  their  familiars. 
The  said  mr.  Lawson  being  to  preach  at  the 


OF  FACT,  SiC.  193 

Village,  after  the  psalm  was  siin^y,  Abigail  Wil- 
liams said,  jYow  stand  up  and  name  your  text ; 
alter  it  was  read,  she  said,  it  was  a  long  text, 
Mrs.  Pope  in  the  beg'r.ning  of  sermon  said  to 
him,  now  there  is  enough  of  that.  In  sermon,  he 
referring  to  his  doctrine,  Abigail  Williams  said 
to  him,  /  know  no  doctrine  you  had ;  if  you  did 
name  one^  I  have  forgot  it*  Ann  Putrijan,  an  af- 
flicted girl,  said,  there  was  a  yellow  bird  sat  oti 
his  hat  as  it  hung  on  the  pin  in  the  pulpit, 

March  31,  1692,  was  set  apart  as  a  day  of 
solemn  humiliation  at  Salem,  upon  the  account 
of  this  business  ;  on  which  day  Abigail  Williams 
said,  that  she  saw  a  great  yiumber  of  persons  in 
the  Village  at  the  administration  of  a  mock  sacra- 
mcnt^  where  they  had  bread  as  red  as  raw  fleshy  and 
red  drink, 

jSpril  1.  Mercy  Lewis  affirmed,  that  she  saw 
a  man  in  white,  with  ivhom  she  went  into  a  crlorious 
place,  viz.  in  her  fits,  where  icas  no  light  of  the 
sun,  much  less  of  candles,  yet  was  full  (flight  and 
brightness,  with  a  great  multitude  in  white  glitter- 
ing  robes,  icho  sang  the  song  in  Rev.  v.  9.  and  the 
cxlix  Psalm  ;  and  was  given  that  she  might  tar- 
ry  no  longer  in  this  place.  T\m  white  man  is 
said  to  have  appeared  several  times  to  others  of 
them,  and  to  have  given  them  notice  how  long  it 
should  be  before  they  should  have  another  fit. 

./^pril  3.  Being  sacrament  day  at  the  Village, 
Sarah  Cloyce,  sister  to  goodwife  Nurse,  a  mem- 
ber of  one  of  the  churches,  was  (though  it  seems 
with  difficulty  prevailed  with  to  be)  present ; 
but  being  entered  the  place,  and  mr.  Parris 
naming  his  text,  John  \l  70,  Have  not  1  chosen 
17 


i.94  MATTERS 

you  twelve^  and  one  of  you  is  a  devil;  (for  what 
cause  may  rest  as  a  doubt,  whether  upon  the 
account  of  her  sisters  being  committed,  or  be- 
cause of  the  choice  of  that  iQXi)  she  rose  up 
and  went  out;  the  wind  shutting  the  door  forci- 
bly, gaye  occasion  to  some  to  suppose  she  went 
out  in  anger,  and  might  occasion  a  suspicion  of 
her ;  however,  she  was  soon  after  complained  of^ 
examined  and  committed. 

^j^pril  11.  By  this  time  the  number  of  the  ac- 
cused and  accusers  being  much  increased,  there 
was  a  publick  examination  at  Salem,  six  of  the 
magistrates  with  several  ministers  being  present. 
There  appeared  several  who  complained  against 
others  with  hideous  clamours  and  screechings. 
Goodwife  Proctor  was  brought  thither,  being 
accused  or  cried  out  against :  her  husband 
coming  to  attend  and  assist  her,  as  there  might 
be  need,  the  accusers  cried  out  of  him  also,  and 
that  with  so  much  earnestness, -that  he  was  comr 
mitted  with  liis  wife.  About  this  time,  besides 
the  experiment  of  the  afflicted  felling  at  the 
sight,  (fee.  they  put  the  accused  upon  saying  the 
Lord's  prayer,  which  one  among  them  peribrm- 
ed,  except  in  that  petition,  deliver  us  from  evil^ 
she  exprest  it  thus,  deliver  us  from  all  evil :  this 
was  looked  upon  as  if  she  prayed  against  what 
she  was  now  justly  under,  and  being  put  upon 
it  again,  and  repeating  those  words,  hallowed  he 
thy  name,  she  exprest  it,  hollowed  he  thy  name  : 
this  was  counted  a  depraving  the  words,  as  sig- 
nifying to  make  void,  and  so  a  curse  rather  than 
a  prayer:  upon  the  whole  it  was  concluded  that 
she  also  could  not  say  it,  6ic*     Proceeding  in  this 


OF  FACT,  &c.  195 

work  of  examination  and  commitment,  many 
were  sent  to  prison.  As  an  instance,  sec  the 
following  mittimus. 

To  their  Majesties''  Gaol-keeper  in  Salem. 

You  are  in  tlielr  majesties'  names  hereby  re- 
quired to  take  into  your  care,  and  safe  custody, 
tile  bodies  of  William  Hobs  and  Deborah  his 
wife,  Mary  Easty,  the  wife  of  Isaac  Easty,  and 
Sarah  Wild,  the  wife  of  John  Wild,  all  of  Tops- 
field;  and  Edward  Bishop,  of  Salem  Village, 
husbandman,  and  Sarah  his  wife,  and  Mary 
Black,  a  negro  of  lieutenant  Nathaniel  Putman, 
of  Salem  Village  ;  also  Mary  English,  the  wife 
of  Philip  English,  merchant,  in  Salem;  who 
stand  charged  with  high  suspicion  of  sundry  acts 
of  witchcraft,  done  or  committed  by  them  lately 
upon  the  bodies  of  Ann  Putman,  Mary  Lewis 
and  Abigail  Williams,  of  Salem  Village  ;  where- 
by great  hurt  and  damage  hath  been  done  to 
the  bodies  of  the  said  persons,  according  to  the 
complaint  of  Thomas  Putman  and  John  Buxton, 
of  Salem  Village,  exhibited;  whom  you  are  to 
secure  in  order  to  their  further  examination. — 
Fail  not. 

John  Hathorn.  )        •  ,     , 
,         ^       .     >  assistants. 
Jona.  Lurwin^  ^ 

Dated  Salem,  April  22,  1692. 

To   marshal  George  Herrick^ 

of  Salem^  Essex. 

You  are  in   their  majesties'  names  hereby  required 

to  convey  the  above  named  to  the   gaol  at  Salem. — Fail 

not.  John  Hathonu  }       •  i     i,. 

T        r^       .  '  >  assistants. 
Jona.  Lurzvm^  ^ 

Dated  Salem,  April  22,  1692. 


196  MATTERS 

The  occasion  of  Bishop's  being  cried  out  of, 
v/as,  he  being  at  an  examination  in  Saiem,  when 
at  the  inn  an  afflicted  Indian  was  very  unruly, 
whom  he  undertook,  and  so  managed  him,  that 
he  was  very  orderly ;  after  which,  in  riding 
home,  in  company  of  him  and  other  accusers, 
the  Indian  fell  into  a  fit,  and  clapping  hold  with 
his  teeth  on  the  back  of  the  man  that  rode  be- 
fore him,  thereby  held  himself  upon  the  horse; 
but  said  Bishop  striking  him  with  his  stick,  the 
Indian  soon  recovered,  and  promised  he  would 
do  so  no  more;  to  which  Bishop  replied,  that 
he  doubted  not  but  he  could  cure  them  all,  with 
more  to  the  same  effect.  Immediately  after  he 
was  parted  from  them,  he  was  cried  out  of,  &;c. 

May  14,  1692.  Sir  William  Phips  arrived 
with  commission  from  their  majesties  to  be  go- 
vernor, pursuant  to  the  new  charter,  which  he 
now  brought  with  him,  the  ancient  charter  hav- 
ing been  vacated  by  king  Charles  and  king 
James,  (by  which  they  had  a  power  not  only  to 
make  their  own  laws,  but  also  to  choose  their 
ow^n  governor  and  officers)  and  the  country  for 
some  years. was  put  under  an  absolute  commis- 
sion-government, till  the  Revolution,  at  which 
time,  though  more  than  two  thirds  of  the  people 
were  for  reassuming  their  ancient  government,  (to 
which  they  had  encouragement  by  his  then  royal 
highness's  proclamation)  yet  some  that  might 
have  been  better  emplojcd  (in  another  station) 
made  it  their  business  (by  printing,  as  w^ell  as 
speaking)  to  their  utmost  to  divert  them  from 
such  a  settlement;  and  so  far  prevailed,  that 
for  about  seven  weeks  after   the  Revolution. 


OF  FACT,'&c.  197 

here  was  not  so  much  as  a  lace  of  any  govern- 
ment; but  some  lew  men  upon  their  own  nomi- 
nation would  be  called  a  committee  of  safety; 
but  at  Icngtii  tlie  assembly  prevailed  with  tiiose 
that  had  been  of  the  government,  to  promise 
that  they  would  reassume;  and  accordiiifi^lv  a 
proclamation  was  drawn,  but  before  publishing 
it,  it  was  underwritten,  that  they  would  not 
have  it  understood  that  they  did  reassume  char- 
ter-government ;  so  that  between  government 
and  no  government,  this  country  remained  till 
sir  William  arrived :  agents  being  in  this  time 
empowered  in  England,  which  no  doubt  did  not 
all  of  them  act  accordmg  to  the  minds  or  inter- 
ests of  those  that  empowered  them,  whicli  is 
manifest  by  their  not  acting  jointly  in  what  was 
done;  so  that  this  place  is  perhaps  a  single  in- 
stance (even  in  the  best  of  reigns)  of  a  charter 
not  restored  after  so  happy  a  revolution.  This 
settlement  by  sir  William  Phips's  having  come 
governor  put  an  end  to  all  disputes  of  these  things; 
and  being  arrived,  and  having  read  his  com- 
mission, the  first  thing  he  exerted  his  power  in, 
was  said  to  be  his  giving  orders  that  irons  should 
be  put  upon  those  in  prison;  for  though  for 
some  time  after  these  were  committed,  the  ac- 
cusers ceased  to  cry  out  of  them,  yet  now  the 
cry  against  them  was  renewed,  which  occasion- 
ed such  order;  and  though  there  was  partiali- 
ty in  the  executing  it  (some  having  them  taken 
off  almost  as  soon  as  put  on)  yet  the  cry  of  these 
accusers  against  such,  ceased  after  this  order. 
Mai/  24.     Mrs.  Cary,  of  Charlestown,  was 

examined  and  committed.     Her  husband,  rar 

,7# 


198  MATTERS 

Jonathan  Gary,  has  given  account  thereof,  as 
also  of  her  escape,  to  this  effect : 

"I  having  heard,  some  clays,  that  my  wife  was 
accused  of  witchcraft,  being  much  disturbed  at 
it,  by  advice  we  went  to  Salem  Village,  to  see  if 
the  afflicted  knew  her;  we  arrived  there  24th 
May;  it  happened  to  be  a  day  appointed  for 
examination  ;  accordingly,  soon  after  our  arrival, 
mr.  Hathorn  and  mr.  Curwin,  &:c.  went  to  the 
meeting-house,  which  was  the  place  appointed 
for  that  work;  the  minister  began  with  prayer; 
and  having  taken  care  to  get  a  convenient  place, 
I  observed  that  the  afflicted  were  two  girls  of 
about  ten  years  old,  and  about  two  or  three 
others,  of  about  eighteen;  one  of  the  girls  talk- 
ed most,  and  could  discern  more  than  the  rest. 
The  prisoners  were  called  in  one  by  one,  and  as 
they  came  in  were  cried  out  of,  (S:c.  The  pri- 
soners were  placed  about  seven  or  eight  leet 
from  the  justices,  and  the  accusers  between  the 
justices  and  them ;  the  prisoners  were  ordered 
to  stand  right  before  the  justices,  with  an  officer 
appointed  to  hold  each  hand,  lest  they  should 
therewith  afflict  them;  and  the  prisoners'  eyes 
must  be  constantly  on  the  justices  ;  for  if  tiiey 
looked  on  the  afflicted,  they  would  either  fall 
into  their  fits,  or  cry  out  of  being  hurt  by  them. 
After  an  examination  of  the  prisoners,  who  it 
was  afflicted  these  girls,  &c.  they  were  put  up- 
on saying  the  Lord's  prayer,  as  a  trial  of  their 
o-uilt.  After  the  afflicted  seemed  to  be  out  of 
their  ffts,  they  would  look  steadfastly  on  some 
one  person,  and  frequently  not  speak ;  and  then 
the  justices  said  they  were  struck  dumb^  and  a!- 


OF  FACT,  &c.  199 

ter  a  little  time  would  speak  again;  then  the 
justices  said  to  the  accusers,  Which  of  you  will 
go  aixl  touch  the  prisoner  at  the  bar?  Then  the 
most  courageous  would  adventure,  but  before 
they  had  made  three  steps  would  ordinarily  fall 
down  as  in  a  fit.  The  justices  ordered  that 
they  should  be  taken  up  and  carried  to  the  pri- 
soner, that  she  might  touch  them;  and  as  soon 
as  they  were  touched  by  the  accused,  the  justi- 
ces would  say,  they  are  well,  before  1  could  dis- 
cern any  alteration;  by  which  I  observed  that 
the  justices  understood  the  manner  of  it.  Thus 
far  I  was  only  as  a  spectator ;  my  wife  also  was 
there  part  of  the  time,  but  no  notice  taken  of 
her  by  the  alHicted,  except  once  or  twice  they 
came  to  her  and  asked  her  name. 

'•  But  I  having  an  opportunity  to  discouse  mr. 
Hale  (with  whom  I  had  formerly  acquaintance) 
I  took  his  advice  what  1  had  best  to  do,  and 
desired  of  him  that  I  might  have  an  opportuni- 
ty to  speak  with  her  that  accused  my  wife; 
which  he  promised  should  be,  I  acquainting  him 
that  I  reposed  my  trust  in  him.  Accordingly 
he  came  to  me  after  the  examination  was  over, 
and  told  me  I  had  now  an  opportunity  to  speak 
with  the  said  accuser,  viz.  Abigail  Williams,  a 
girl  of  11  or  12  years  old;  but  that  we  could 
not  be  in  private  at  mr.  Parris's  house,  as  he 
had  promised  me;  we  went  therefore  into  the 
alehouse,  where  an  Indian  man  attended  us, 
who  it  seems  was  one  of  the  atjjie4«d  :  to  him 
we  gave  some  cider  :  he  shew^'d  several  scars, 
that  seemed  as  if  they  had  been  long  there,  and 
shewed  them  as  done  by  witchcraft,    and  ac- 


200  MATTERS 

quainted  us  that  his  wife,  who  also  was  a  slave, 
was  imprisoned  for  witchcraft.  And  now,  in- 
stead of  one  accuser,  thej  all  came  in,  and  be- 
gan to  tumble  down  like  swine  ;  and  then  three 
women  were  called  in  to  attend  them.  We  in 
the  room  were  ail  at  a  stand,  to  see  who  they 
would  cry  out  of ;  but  in  a  short  time  they  cri- 
ed out,  Gary;  and  immediately  after  a  warrant 
was  sent  from  the  justices  to  bring  my  wife  be- 
fore them,  who  were  sitting  in  a  chamber  near 
by,  waiting  ior  this. 

''Being  brought  before  the  justices,  her  chief 
accusers  were  two  girls.  My  wife  declared  to 
the  justices,  that  she  never  had  any  knowledge 
of  them  before  that  day.  She  was  i'orced  to 
stand  with  her  arms  stretched  out.  I  requested 
that  I  might  hold  one  of  her  hands,  but  it  was 
denied  me;  then  she  desired  me  to  w^ipe  the 
tears  from  her  eyes,  and  the  sweat  from  her 
face,  which  1  did;  then  she  desired  she  might 
lean  herself  on  me,  saying  she  should  faint. 

"  Justice  Hathorn  replied,  she  had  strength 
enough  to  torment  those  persons,  and  she  should 
have  strength  enough  to  stand.  1  speaking 
something  against  their  cruel  proceedings,  they 
commanded  me  to  be  silent,  or  else  I  should  be 
turned  out  of  the  room.  The  Indian  before 
mentioned  was  also  brought  in,  to  be  one  of  her 
accusers:  being  come  m,  he  now  (when  belbre 
the  justices)  fell  down  and  tumbled  about  like  a 
hog,  but  said  nothing.  The  justices  asked  the 
girls  who  afilicted  the  Indian;  they  answered, 
she,  (meaning  my  wife)  and  that  she  now  lay 
upon   him ;  the  justices  ordered  her  to  touch 


OF  FACT,  kc.  201 

him,  in  order  to  his  cure,  but  her  head  must  be 
turned  another  way,  lest,  instead  of  curing,  she 
should  make  liim  worse,  by  licr  looking  on  him, 
her  hand  being  guided  to  take  hold  of  his;  but 
the  Indian  took  liold  of  her  liand,  and  pulled  her 
down  on  the  floor,  in  a  barbarous  manner  ;  then 
his  hand  was  taken  oi\\  and  her  hand  put  on  his, 
^nd  the  cure  was  quickly  wrought.  I,  being 
extremely  troubled  at  their  inhuman  dealings, 
uttered  a  hasty  speech,  That  God  would  take 
vengeance  on  them,  and  desired  that  God  would 
deliver  us  out  of  the  hands  of  unmerciful  men. 
Then  her  mittmius  was  writ.  I  did  with  diffi- 
culty and  charge  obtain  ihe  liberty  of  a  room, 
but  no  beds  in  it ;  il' there  had  been,  could  have 
taken  but  little  rest  that  night.  She  was  com- 
mitted to  Boston  prison  ;  but  1  obtained  a  ha- 
beas corpus  to  remove  her  to  Cambridge  pri- 
son, which  is  in  our  county  of  Middlesex.  Hav- 
ing been  there  one  night,  next  morning  the  jail- 
er put  irons  on  her  legs  (having  received  such 
a  command  ;)  the  weight  of  them  was  about 
eight  pounds  :  these  irons  and  her  other  afflic- 
tions soon  brought  her  into  convulsion  fits,  so 
that  I  thought  she  would  have  died  that  night. 
I  sent  to  entreat  that  the  irons  might  be  takeu 
ofi';  but  all  entreaties  were  in  vain,  if  it  would 
have  saved  her  life,  so  that  in  this  condition  she 
must  continue.  The  trials  at  Salem  coming  on, 
1  went  thither,  to  see  how  things  were  mana- 
ged ;  and  finding  that  the  spectre  evidence  was 
there  received,  together  with  idle,  if  not  mali- 
cious stories,  against  people's  lives,  1  did  easily 
perceive  which  way  the  rest  would  go  ;  for  the 


:202  MATTERS 

same  evidence  that  served  for  one,  would  serve 
for  all  the  rest.  I  acquainted  her  with  her 
danger ;  and  that  if  she  were  carried  to  Salem 
to  be  tried,  I  feared  she  would  never  return.  I 
did  my  utmost  that  she  might  have  her  trial  in 
our  own  county,  I  with  several  others  petition- 
ing the  judge  for  it,  and  were  put  in  hopes  of  it; 
but  I  soon  saw  so  much,  that  I  understood  there- 
by it  was  not  intended,  which  put  me  upon  con- 
sulting the  means  of  her  escape  ;  which  through 
the  goodness  of  God  was  effected,  and  she  got 
to  Rhode-Island,  but  soon  found  herself  not  safe 
when  there,  by  reason  of  the  pursuit  after  her  ; 
from  thence  she  went  to  New-York,  along  with 
some  others  that  had  escaped  their  cruel  hands ; 
where  we  found  his  excellency  Benjamin  Fletch- 
er, esq.  governor,  who  was  very  courteous  to  us. 
After  this,  some  of  my  goods  were  seized  in  a 
friend's  hands,  with  whoin  I  had  lett  tliem,  and 
myself  imprisoned  by  the  sheritif',  and  kept  in 
custody  half  a  day,  and  then  dismissed  ;  but  to 
speak  of  their  usage  of  the  prisoners,  and  the 
inhumanity  shewn  to  them  at  the  time  of  their 
execution,  no  sober  christian  could  bear.  They 
had  also  trials  of  cruel  mockings ;  which  is  the 
more,  considering  wliat  a  people  for  religion,  I 
mean  the  profession  of  it,  we  have  been ;  those 
that  suffered  being  many  of  them  church  mem- 
bers, and  most  of  them  unspotted  in  their  con- 
versation, till  their  adversary  the  devil  took  up 
this  method  for  accusing  them. 

"Per  Jonathan  Gary." 
May  31.     Capt.  John  Aldin   was   examined 
la  Salem,  and  committed  to  Boston  prison.    The 


OF  FACT,  ij-c.  203 

prison-koepen  seeing  such  a  man  committed,  of 
wliom  he  had  a  good  esteem,  was  ai'ter  this  the 
more  compassionate  to  those  that  were  in  prison 
on  the  like  account ;  and  re  Trained  from  such 
hard  things  to  the  prisoners,  as  hefore  he  had 
used.  Mr.  Aldin  himself  has  given  an  account 
of  his  examination,  in  tliese  words : 

An  account  how  John  Jlldin^  senior,  ivas  dealt  with 
at  Salem  Village, 

John  Aldin,  senior,  ol  Boston,  in  the  county  of 
Sulfolk,  manner,  on  the  28th  day  of  May,  1692, 
was  sent  for  by  the  magistrates  of  Salem,  in  the 
county  of  Essex,  upon  the  accusation  of  a  com- 
pany of  poor  distracted  or  possessed  creatures 
or  witches ;  and  being  sent  by  mr.  Stoughton, 
arrived  there  the  31st  of  May,  and  appeared  at 
Salem  Village,  before  mr.  Gidney,  mr.  Hathorn 
and  rar.  Cur  win. 

Those  wenches  being  present,  who  played 
their  juggling  tricks,  falling  down,  crying  out, 
and  staring  in  people's  faces;  the  magistrates 
demanded  of  them  several  times,  who  it  was  of 
all  the  people  in  the  room  that  hurt  them :  one 
of  these  accusers  pointed  several  times  at  one 
captain  Hill,  there  present,  but  spake  nothing; 
the  same  accuser  had  a  mac  standing  at  her 
back  to  hold  her  up;  he  stooped  down  to  her 
ear,  then  she  cried  out,  Aldin,  Aidin  afflicted  her; 
one  of  the  masfist rates  asked  her  if  she  had  ever 
seen  Aldin,  she  answered  no ;  he  asked  how  she 
knew  it  wis  Aldin;  she  said  the  man  told  her  so. 

Then  all  were  ordered  to  go  down  into  the 
street,  where  a  ring  was  made;  and  the  same 
accuser  cried  out,  There  stands  Aldin,  a  bold    / 


204  MATTERS 

fellow,  with  his  hat  on  before  the  judges;  he 
sells  powder  and  shot  to  the  Indians  and  French, 
and  hes  with  the  Indian  squaws,  and  has  Indian 
papooses.  Then  was  Aldin  committed  to  the 
marshal's  custody,  and  his  sword  taken  from 
him;  for  they  said  he  afflicted  them  with  his 
sword.  After  some  hours  Aldin  was  sent  for 
to  the  meeting-house  in  the  Village,  before  the 
magistrates;  who  required  Aldin  to  stand  upon 
a  chair,  to  the  open  view  of  all  the  people. 

The  accusers  cried  out  that  Aldin  pinched 
them,  then,  when  he  stood  upon  the  chair,  in 
the  sight  of  all  the  people,  a  good  way  distant 
from  them.  One  of  the  magistrates  bid  the 
marshal  to  hold  open  Aldin's  hands,  that  he 
mi^ht  not  pinch  those  creatures.  Aldin  asked 
them  why  they  should  think  that  he  should 
come  to  that  Village  to  afflict  those  persons 
that  he  never  knew  or  saw  before.  Mr.  Gid- 
ney  bid  Aldin  confess,  and  give  glory  to  God. 
Aldin  said,  he  hoped  he  should  give  glory  to 
God,  and  hoped  he  should  never  gratify  the 
devil;  but  appealed  to  all  that  ever  knew  him, 
if  they  ever  suspected  him  to  be  such  a  per- 
son, and  challenged  any  one,  that  could  bring 
in  any  thing  upon  their  own  knowledge,  that 
might  give  suspicion  of  his  being  such  an  one. 
Mr.  Gidney  said  he  had  known  Aldin  many 
years,  and  had  been  at  sea  with  him,  and  al- 
ways looked  upon  him  to  be  an  honest  man, 
but  now  he  saw  cause  to  alter  his  judgment. 
Aldin  answered,  he  was  sorry  for  that,  but  he 
hoped  God  would  clear  up  his  innocency,  that 
he  w^ould  recal  that  judgment  again  ;  and  added, 


OF  FACT,  iX-c.  206 

that  he  hoped  that  he  should  with  Job  maintain  his 
integrity  till  he  died.  Thej  bid  Aldin  look  upon 
the  accusers,  which  he  did,  and  then  thej  fell 
down.  Aldin  asked  mr.  Gidney  what  reason 
there  could  be  given,  why  Aldin's  looking  upon 
hirn  did  not  P  >ike  him  down  as  well ;  but  no  rea- 
son was  given  that  I  heard.  But  the  accusers 
were  brought  to  Aldin  to  touch  them,  and  this 
touch  they  said  made  them  well.  Aldin  began 
to  speak  of  the  providence  of  God,  in  suffeiing 
these  creatures  to  accuse  innocent  persons.  Mr. 
Noyes  asked  Aldin  why  he  w^ould  otfer  to  speak 
of  the  providence  of  God :  God  by  his  provi- 
dence (said  mr.  Noyes)  governs  the  world,  and 
keeps  it  in  peace  ;  and  so  went  on  with  discourse, 
and  stopt  Aldin's  mouth  as  to  that.  Aldin  told 
Mr.  Gidney,  that  he  could  assure  him  that  there 
Avas  a  lying  spirit  in  them,  for  I  can  assure  you 
that  thei-e  is  not  a  w^ord  of  truth  in  all  these  say 
of  me.  But  Aldin  was  again  committed  to  the 
marshal,  and  his  mittimus  written,  which  was  as 
follows : 

To  im\  John  j^rnold^  keeper  of  the  prison  in  Bos^ 
ton,  in  the  county  of  Suffhlk* 

Whereas  captain  John  Aldin,  of  Boston,  mari- 
ner, and  Sarah  Rice,  Avife  of  Nicholas  Rice, 
of  Reading,  husbandman,  have  been  this  day 
brought  before  us,  John  Hathorn  and  Jonathan 
Curwin,  esquires ;  being  accused  and  suspected 
of  perpetrating  divers  acts  of  witchcraft,  contra- 
ry to  the  form  of  the  statute,  in  that  case  made 
and  provided:  these  are  therefore,  in  their  ma- 
jesties king  William  and  queen  Mary's  names, 
18 


206  MATTERS 

to  will  and  require  you  to  take  into  your  custo- 
dy the  bodies  of  the  said  John  Aldin  and  Sarah 
Rice,  and  them  safely  keep,  until  they  shall  be 
delivered  by  due  course  of  law,  as  you  will  an- 
swer the  contrary  at  your  peril ;  ^^nd  this  shall 
be  your  sufficient  warrant.  GH'^'n  under  our 
hands  at  Salem  Village,  the  31st  of  May,  in  the 
fourth  year  of  the  reign  of  our  sovereign  lord 
and  lady,  William  and  Mary,  now  king  and 
queen  over  England,  &c.     Anno  Domini  1692. 


John  Hat  horn.  )        •  ^     ^ 
7         r^       '      }  assistants, 
Jona,  Cunvin,  ^ 


To  Boston,  Aldin  was  carried  by  a  constable  ; 
no  bail  would  be  taken  for  him ;  but  vv'as  deli- 
vered to  the  prison-keeper,  where  he  remained 
fifteen  weeks ;  and  then,  observing  the  manner 
of  trials,  and  evidence  then  taken,  was  at  length 
prevailed  with  to  make  his  escape,  and  being  re- 
turned, was  bound  over  to  answer  at  the  supe- 
rior court  at  Boston,  the  last  Tuesday  in  April, 
anno  1693;  and  was  there  cleared  by  procla- 
mation, none  appearing  against  him. 

Per  John  Aldin. 

At  the  examination,  and  at  other  times,  it  was 
usual  for  the  accusers  to  tell  of  the  black  man, 
or  of  a  spectre,  as  being  then  on  the  table,  &c. 
The  people  about  would  strike  with  swords,  or 
sticks,  at  those  places.  One  justice  broke  his 
cane  at  this  exercise  ;  and  sometimes  the  accu- 
sers would  say,  they -struck  the  spectre,  and  it 
is  reported  several  oi'the  accused  were  hurt  and 
wounded  thereby^  though  at  home  at  the  same 
time. 


OF  FACT,  &c.  207 

The  justices  proceeding  in  these  works  of  ex- 
nmination  and  conunitrnent  to  the  end  of  May, 
I  here  were  by  that  time  about  a  hundred  per- 
bons  imprisoned  upon  that  account. 

June  2.  A  special  commission  of  oyer  and  ter- 
miner having  been  issued  out,  to  mr.  Stoughton, 
the  new  lieutenant  governor,  major  Saltonstall, 
major  Richards,  major  Gidney,  mr.  Wait  Win- 
throp,  captain  Sewall,  and  mr.  Sergeant,  a  quo- 
rum of  wliom  sat  at  Salem  this  daj,  where  the 
most  that  was  done  this  week  was  the  trial  of 
one  Bishop,  alias  Oliver,  of  Salem  ;  who  had 
long  undergone  the  repute  of  a  witch,  occasioned 
by  f  hr»  accusationc  oi'  oiie  Samucl  Gray ;  he, 
about  twenty  years  since,  having  charged  her 
with  such  crimes;  and  though  upon  his  death- 
bed he  testified  his  sorrow  and  repentance  for 
such  accusations,  as  being  Avholly  groundless, 
yet  the  report,  taken  up  by  his  means,  continu- 
ed, and  she  JDeing  accused  by  those  afflicted, 
and  upon  search  a  teat,  as  they  call  it,  being 
found,  she  was  brought  in  guilty  by  the  jury  ; 
she  received  her  sentence  of  death,  and  was 
executed  June  10,  but  made  not  the  least  coD' 
fession  of  any  thing  relating  to  witchcraft. 

June  13.  Several  ministers  in  and  near  Bos- 
ton, having  been  to  that  end  consulted  by  his 
excellency,  exprest  their  minds  to  this  etfect,  viz. 

That  they  were  affected  with  the  deplorable  V 
state  of  the  afflicted;  that  they  were  thankful 
for  the  diligent  care  of  the  rulers  to  detect  the 
abominable  witchcrafts  which  have  been  com- 
mitted in  the  country,  praying  for  a  perfect  dis- 
covery thereof;  but  advised  to  a  cautious  pro- 


^On  MATTERS 

ceeding,  lest  many  evils  ensue,  &;c.  and  that 
tenderness  be  used  towards  those  accused,  re- 
lating to  matters  presumptive  and  convictive, 
and  also  to  privacy  in  examinations ;  and  to  con- 
sult mr.  Perkins  and  mr.  Bernard  what  tests  to 
make  use  of  in  the  scrutiny  :  that  presumptions 
and  convictions  ought  to  have  better  grounds 
than  the  accusers  affirming  that  they  see  such 
persons'  spectres  afflicting  them  ;  and  that  the 
devil  may  afflict  in  the  shape  of  good  men;  and 
that  falhng  at  the  sight,  and  rising  at  the  touch, 
of  the  accused,  is  no  infallible  proof  of  guilt; 
that  seeing  the  devil's  strength  consists  in  such 
accusations,  our  disbelieving  them  may  be  a 
means  to  put  a  period  to  the  dreadful  calami- 
ties. Nevertheless  they  humbly  recommend  to 
the  government,  the  speedy  and  vigorous  pros- 
ecution of  such  as  have  rendered  themselves 
obnoxious,  according  to  the  direction  given  in 
the  laws  of  God,  and  the  wholesome  statutes  of 
the  English  nation,  for  the  detection  of  witch- 
craft. 

This  IS  briefly  the  substance  of  what  may  be 
seen  more  at  large  in  Cases  of  Conscience*  Qdt.) 
And  one  of  them  since  taking  occasion  to  repeat 
some  part  of  this  advice,  (^Wonders  of  the  Invisi- 
hie  World,  p.  83)  declares  (notwithstanding  the 
dissatisfaction  of  others)  that  if  his  said  book 
niay  conduce  to  promote  thankfulness  to  God 
for  such  executions,  he  shall  rejoice,  &c. 

The  30th  of  June,  the  court  according  to  ad- 
journment again  sat ;  five  more  were  tried,  viz. 
Sarah  Good  and  Rebecca  Nurse,  of  Salem  Vil- 
lage ;  Susanna  Martin,  of  Amsbury ;  Elizabeth 


OF  FACT,  &c.  20^ 

How  of  [pswlcli;  and  SarahWildcs  of  Topsficld: 
these  were  all  coiidenined  that  session,  and  were 
all  executed  on  the  19th  of  July. 

At  the  trial  of  Sarah  Good,  one  of  the  afflict- 
ed fell  in  a  fit ;  and  after  coming  out  of  it  she 
cried  out  of  the  prisoner,  for  stabbing  her  in  the 
breast  with  a  knife,  and  that  she  had  broken 
the  knife  in  stabbing  of  her;  accordingly  a  piece 
ol'  the  blade  of  a  knife  was  found  about  her. 
Immediately  information  being  given  to  the 
court,  a  young  man  was  called,  who  produced  a 
haft  and  part  of  the  blade,  which  the  court  hav- 
ing viewed  and  compared,  saw  it  to  be  the  same; 
and  upon  inquiry  the  young  man  affirmed,  that 
yesterday  he  happened  to  break  that  knife,  and 
that  he  cast  away  the  upper  part.  This  afflicted 
person  being  then  present,  the  young  man  was 
dismissed,  and  she  was  bidden  by  the  court  not 
to  tell  lies;  and  was  improved  after  (as  she  had 
been  before)  to  give  evidence  against  the  pri- 
"soners. 

At  the  execution,  Mr.  Noyes  urged  Sarah 
Good  to  confess,  and  told  her  she  was  a  witch, 
and  she  knew  she  was  a  witch;  to  which  she 
replied,  you  are  a  liar;  I  am  no  more  a  witch 
than  you  are  a  wizard;  and  if  you  take  away 
my  life,  God  will  give  you  blood  to  drink. 

At  the  trial  of  Uebecca  Nurse,  it  was  remarka- 
ble that  the  jury  brought  in  their  verdict  not 
gailty  ;  immediately  all  the  accusers  in  the  court, 
aiid  suddenly  after  all  the  afflicted  out  of  court, 
made  an  hideous  outcry,  to  the  amazement  not 
only  of  the  spectators,  but  the  court  also  seemed 
strangely  surprised :  one  of  the  judges  exprest 
18* 


^10  MATTERS 

himself  not  satisfied ;  another  of  them,  as  he  was 
going  off  the  bench,  said  they  would  have  her 
indicted  anew.  The  chief  judge  said  he  would 
not  impose  upon  the  jury;  but  intimated  as  if 
they  had  not  well  considered  one  expression  of 
the  prisoner  when  she  was  upon  trial,  viz.  that 
when  one  Hobbs,  \vho  had  confessed  herseh"  to 
be  a  witch,  was  brought  into  the  court  to  wit- 
ness against  her,  the  prisoner,  turning  her  head 
to  her,  said,  What,  do  you  bring  her  ?  she  is  one 
of  us,  or  to  that  effect;  this,  together  with  the 
clamours  of  the  accusers,  induced  the  jury  to  go 
put  again,  after  their  verdict,  not  guilty.  But 
not  agreeing,  they  came  into  the  court ;  and  she 
being  then  at  the  bar,  her  words  were  repeated 
to  her,  in  order  to  have  her  explanation  of  them ; 
and  she  making  no  reply  to  them,  they  found  the 
bill,  and  brought  her  in  guilty ;  these  words 
being  the  inducement  to  it,  as  the  foreman  ha^? 
signified  in  writing,  as  follows : 

July  4,  1692.  I,  Thomas  Fisk,  the  subscrib- 
er  hereof,  being  one  of  them  that  were  of  the 
lury  last  week  at  Salem  court,  upon  the  trial  of 
Rebecca  Nurse,  &c.  being  desired  by  some  of 
the  relations  to  give  a  reason  why  the  jury 
brought  her  in  guilty,  after  her  verdict  not  guil- 
ty; 1  do  hereby  give  my  reasons  to  be  as  fol- 
lows, viz. 

When  the  verdict  was,  not  guilty,  the  honour- 
ed court  was  pleased  to  object  against  it,  saying 
to  them,  that  they  think  they  let  slip  the  words 
which  the  prisoner  at  the  bar  spake  against  her- 
self, which  were  spoken  in  reply  to  goodwife 
Hobbs  and  her  daughter,  who  had  been  faulty  in 


OF  FACT,  &c.  211 

setting  tlielr  hands  to  the  devil's  book,  as  they 
iiad  conlessed  I'orinerly  ;  the  words  were,  IVkat, 
do  tkese  persons  give  in  evidence  against  me  now  ? 
they  used  to  come  among  us.  Alter  the  honoured 
court  had  manil'ested  their  dissati^slaction  of  the 
verdict,  several  of  the  jury  dech^red  themselves 
desirous  to  go  out  again,  and  tliereupon  the  court 
gave  leave;  but  when  we  came  to  consider  of 
the  case,  I  could  not  tell  how  to  take  lier  words 
as  an  evidence  against  her,  till  she  had  a  further 
opportunity  to  put  her  sense  upon  them,  if  she 
would  take  it;  and  then,  going  into  court,  I  men- 
tioned the  words  aforesaid,  w^hich  by  one  of  the 
court  were  affirmed  to  have  been  spoken  by 
her,  she  being  then  at  the  bar,  but  made  no  re- 
ply, nor  interpretation  of  tliem;  whereupon 
these  words  weie  to  me  a  principal  evidence 
against  her.  ThoiMas  Fisk. 

When  good  wife  Nurse  was  informed  what 
use  was  made  of  these  words,  she  put  in  this 
following  declaration  into  the  court: 

These  presents  do  humbly  shew  to  the  hon- 
oured court  and  jury,  that  I  being  informed  that 
the  jury  brought  me  in  guilty,  upon  my  saying 
that  good  wife  Hobbs  and  her  daughter  were  of 
our  companv  ;  but  I  intended  no  otherways,  than 
as  they  were  prisoners  with  us,  and  therefore 
did  then,  and  yet  do,  judge  them  not  legal  evi- 
d(^nce  against  their  fellow  prisoners.  And  1  be- 
ins^  somethinsj  hard  of  hearinor,  and  full  of  ornef, 
none  miormmg  me  Ijovv  the  court  took  up  my 
words,  and  therefore  had  no  opportunity  to  de- 
clare what  I  intended,  when  I  said  they  were  of 
our  company.  Rf.becca  *Nurs^ 


'ilQ  MATTERS 

After  Tier  condemnation  she  was  by  one  of 
the  ministers  of  Salem  excommunicated;  yet 
the  governor  saw  cause  to  grant  a  reprieve; 
which  when  known  (and  some  say  immediately 
upon  granting)  the  accusers  renewed  their  dis- 
mal outcries  against  her,  insomuch  that  the  go- 
vernor was  by  some  Salem  gentlemen  prevailed 
with  to  recall  the  reprieve,  and  she  was  execut- 
ed with  the  rest. 

The  testimonials  of  her  christian  behaviour, 
both  in  tlie  course  of  her  life  and  at  her  death, 
and  her  extraordinary  care  in  educating  her  chil- 
dren, and  setting  them  good  examples,  &;c.  un- 
der the  hands  of  so  many,  are  so  numerous,  that 
for  brevity  they  are  here  omitted. 

It  was  at  the  trial  of  these  that  one  of  the 
accusers  cried  out  publicly  of  Mr.  Willard,  mi- 
nister in  Boston,  as  afflicting  of  her :  she  was 
sent  out  of  the  court,  and  it  was  told  about  she 
was  mistaken  in  the  person. 

August  5,  the  court  again  sitting,  six  more 
were  tried  on  the  same  account,  viz.  mr.  George 
Burroughs,  sometime  minister  of  Wells,  John 
Proctor,  and  Elizabeth  Proctor  his  wife,  with 
John  Willard,  of  Salem  Village,  George  Jacobs 
senior,  of  Salem,  and  Martha  Carrier,  of  Ando- 
ver;  these  were  all  brought  in  guilty,  and  coi> 
demned;  and  were  all  executed,  August  19,  ex- 
cept Proctor's  wife,  who  pleaded  pregnancy. 

Mr.  Burroughs  was  carried  in  a  cart  with  the 
others,  throu^^h  the  streets  of  Salem  to  execu- 
tion. When  he  was  upon  the  ladder,  he  made 
a  speech  for  the  clearing  of  his  innecency,  Avith 
such  solemn  and  serious  expressions,  as  were  to 


OF  FACT,  Lc.  t\3 

Ihe  admiration  of  all  present:  his  prayer  (which 
he  concluded  by  repeating  the  Lord's  prayer) 
was  so  well  worded,  and  uttered  with  such  coiri- 
posedness,  and  such  (at  least  seeming)  fervency 
of  spirit,  as  was  very  aifecting,  and  drew  tears 
from  many,  so  that  it  seemed  to  some  that  the 
spectators  would  hinder  the  execution.  The 
accusers  said  the  black  man  stood  and  dictated 
to  him.  As  soon  as  he  was  turned  otij  mr.  Cot- 
ton Mather,  being  mounted  upon  a  horse,  ad- 
dressed himself  to  the  people,  partly  to  declare 
that  he  [Burroughs]  was  no  ordained  minister, 
and  partly  to  possess  the  people  of  his  guilt,  say- 
ing that  the  devil  has  often  been  transformed  in- 
to an  angel  of  light;  and  this  somewhat  appeas- 
ed the  people,  and  the  executions  went  on. 
When  he  was  cut  down,  he  was  dragged  by  the 
halter  to  a  hole,  or  grave,  between  the  rocks, 
about  two  feet  deep,  his  shirt  and  breeches  be- 
ing pulled  olf,  and  an  old  pair  of  trowsers  of  one 
executed  put  on  his  lower  parts  ;  he  was  so  put 
in,  together  with  Willard  and  Carrier,  that  one 
of  his  hands  and  his  chin,  and  a  foot  of  one  of 
them,  were  left  uncovered. 

John  Willard  had  been  employed  to  fetch  in 
several  that  were  accused  ;  but  taking  dissatis- 
faction from  his  being  sent  to  fetch  up  some 
that  he  had  better  thoughts  of,  he  declined  the 
service ;  and  presently  after  he  himself  was  ac- 
cused of  the  same  crime,  and  that  with  such  ve- 
hemency,  that  they  sent  after  him  to  apprehend 
him.  He  had  made  his  escape  as  far  as  Nasha- 
wag,  about  forty  miles  from  vSalem;  yet  it  is 
said  those  accusers  did  then  presently  tell  the 
exact  time,  saying,  Now  Willard  is  takei> 


214  MATTERS 

John  Proctor  and  his  wife  being  in  prison,  the 
sheriiFcame  to  his  house  and  seized  all  the  goods, 
provisions  and  cattle  that  he  could  come  at,  and 
sold  some  of  the  cattle  at  half  price,  and  killed 
others,  and  put  them  up  for  the  West-Indies ; 
threw  out  the  beer  out  of  a  barrel,  and  carried 
away  the  barrel ;  emptied  a  pot  of  broth,  and 
took  away  the  pot,  and  left  nothing  in  the  house 
for  the  support  of  the  children.  No  part  of  the 
said  goods  are  known  to  be  returned.  Proctor 
earnestly  requested  mr.  Noyes  to  pray  with  and 
for  him;  but  it  was  wholly  denied,  because  he 
would  not  own  liimself  to  be  a  witch. 

During  his  imprisonment  he  sent  the  follow- 
ing letter,  in  behalf  of  himself  and  others. 

Snlem  Prison.  July  23,  1692. 
Mr.  Mather,  Mr.  Allen,  Mr.  Moody,  Mr.  VVuLr 
LARD,  and  Mr.  Baily. 

Reverend  Gentlemen, 
The  Innocency  of  our  case,  with  the  enmity 
of  our  accusers  and  our  judges  and  jury,  whom 
nothing  but  our  innocent  blood  will  serve,  hav- 
ing condemned  us  already  before  our  trials,  be- 
ing so  much  incensed  and  enraged  against  us  by 
the  devil,  makes  us  bold  to  beg  and  implore 
your  favourable  assistance  of  this  our  humble 
petition  to  his  excellency,  that  if  it  be  possible 
our  innocent  blood  may  be  spared,  which  un- 
doubtedly otherwise  will  be  shed,  if  the  Lord 
doth  not  mercifully  step  in;  the  magistrates, 
ministers,  juries,  and  all  the  people  in  general, 
being  so  much  enraged  and  incensed  against  us 
by  the  delusion  of  the  devil,  which  we  can  term 


OF  FACT,  kc.  215 

no  other,  by  reason  we  know  in  our  own  con- 
sciences we  are  all  innocent  persons.  Plerc  are 
live  persons  who  have  lately  confessed  them- 
selves to  be  witches,  and  do  accuse  some  of  us 
oi"  being  along  with  them  at  a  sacrament,  since 
we  were  committed  into  close  prison,  which  we 
know  to  be  lies.  Two  of  the  five  are  (Carrier's 
sons)  young  men,  who  would  not  confess  any 
thing  till  they  tied  them  neck  and  heels,  till  the 
blood  was  ready  to  come  out  of  their  noses ;  and 
it  is  credibly  believed  and  reported  this  was  the 
occasion  of  making  them  confess  what  they  ne- 
ver did,  by  reason  they  said  one  had  been  a 
witch  a  month,  and  another  five  weeks,  and  that 
their  mother  had  made  them  so,  who  has  been 
confined  here  this  nine  weeks.  My  son  William 
Proctor,  when  he  was  examined,  because  he 
would  not  confess  that  he  was  guilty,  when  he 
was  innocent,  they  tied  him  neck  and  heels  till 
the  blood  gushed  out  at  his  nose,  and  would 
have  kept  him  so  twenty-four  hours,  if  one,  more 
merciful  than  the  rest,  had  not  taken  pity  on 
him,  and  cacsed  him  to  be  unbound.  These 
actions  are  very  like  the  popish  cruelties.  They 
have  already  undone  us  m  our  estates,  and  that 
will  not  serve  their  turns  without  our  innocent 
blood.  If  it  cannot  be  granted  that  we  can 
have  our  trials  at  Boston,  we  humbly  beg  that 
you  would  endeavour  to  have  these  magistrates 
changed,  and  others  in  their  rooms;  begging 
^Iso  and  beseeching  you  would  be  pleased  to  be 
here,  if  not  all,  some  of  you,  at  our  trials,  hoping 
thereby  you  may  be  the  means  of  saving  the 
shedding  of  our  innocent  blood.    Desiring  your 


tie  MATTERS 

prayers  to  the  Lord  in  our  behalf,  we  rest  your 
poor  aliiicted  servants, 

John  Proctor,  &;c. 

He  pleaded  very  hard  at  execution  for  a  little 
respite  of  time,  saying  that  he  was  not  fit  to  die ; 
but  it  was  not  granted. 

Old  Jacobs  being  condemned,  the  sheriff  and 
officers  came  and  seized  all  he  had ;  his  wife  had 
her  wedding  ring  taken  from  her,  but  with  great 
difficulty  obtained  it  again.  She  was  Ibrced  to 
buy  provisions  of  the  sheriff,  such  as  he  had  ta- 
ken, towards  her  own  support,  which  not  being 
sufficient,  the  neighbours  in  charity  relieved  her. 

Margaret  Jacobs  being  one  that  had  confess- 
ed her  own  guilt,  and  testified  against  her  grand- 
father Jacobs,  mr.  Burroughs  and  John  Willard, 
she  the  day  before  execution  came  to  Mr.  Bur- 
roughs, acknowledging  that  she  had  belied  them, 
and  begged  mr.  Burroughs's  forgiveness;  who 
not  only  forgave  her,  but  also  prayed  with  and 
for  her.  She  wrote  the  following  letter  to  her 
father : 

From  the  dmigeon  in  Salem  prison,  Aug,  20,  1692. 
Honoured  Father^ 
After  my  humble  duty  remembered  to  you, 
hoping  in  the  Lord  of  your  good  health,  as  bles- 
sed be  G(;d  I  enjoy,  though  in  abundance  of  af- 
fliction, being  close  confined  here  in  a  loathsome 
dungeon;  the  Lord  look  down  in  mercy  upon 
me,  not  knowing  how  soon  I  shall  be  put  to 
death,  by  means  of  the  afflicted  persons;  my 
grandfather  having  suffered  already,  and  all  his. 
estate  seized  for  the  king.     The  reason  of  my 


OF  FACT,  kc.  217 

confinement  is  this:  I  linving,  through  the  ma- 
gistrates' threatcnings,  and  my  own  vile  and 
wretched  heart,  conlessed  several  things  contra- 
ry to  my  conscience  and  knowledge,  though  to 
the  wounding  ol'  my  own  soul,  (the  Lord  pardon 
me  lor  it);  but  oh!  the  terrors  of  a  wounded 
conscience  who  can  bear?  But  blessed  be  the 
Lord,  he  would  not  let  me  go  on  in  my  sins,  but 
in  mercy,  1  hope,  to  my  soul,  would  not  suffer 
me  to  keep  it  in  any  longer,  but  I  was  forced  to 
confess  the  truth  of  all  before  the  magistrates, 
who  would  not  believe  me;  but  'tis  their  plea- 
sure to  put  me  in  here,  and  God  knows  how 
soon  I  shall  be  put  to  death.  Dear  father,  let 
me  beg  jpuv  prayers  to  the  Lord  on  my  behalij 
and  send  us  a  joyful  and  liappy  meeting  in  hea- 
ven. My  mother,  poor  woman,  is  very  crazy, 
and  remembers  her  kind  love  to  you,  and  to  un- 
cle, viz.  D.  A.  So  leaving  you  to  the  protection 
of  the  Lord,  I  rest  your  dutiful  daughter, 

Margaret  Jacobs. 

At  the  time  appointed  for  her  trial,  she  had  an 
imposthume  in  her  head,  which  w^as  her  escape. 

September  9,  six  more  were  tried,  and  re- 
ceived sentence  of  death,  viz.  Martha  Cory,  of 
Salem  Village  ;  Mary  Easty,  of  Topsfield  ;  Alice 
Parker  and  Ann  Pudeater,  of  Salem  ;  Dorcas 
Hoar,  of  Beverly,  and  Mary  Bradberry,  of  Sa- 
lisbury. Sept.  16,  Giles  Cory  was  prest  to 
deatli. 

September  17,  nine  more  received  sentence  of 
death,  viz.  Margaret  Scot,  of  Rowley  ;  good- 
wife  Reed,  of  JViarblehead  ;  Samuel  Wardweil 
19 


D 


2i§  MATTERS 

and  Mary  Parker,  of  Andover ;  also  Abigail 
Falkner,  of  Andover,  who  pleaded  pregnancy  ; 
Rebecca  Eames,  of  Boxford,  Mary  Lacy  and 
Ann  Foster,  of  Andover,  and  Abigail  Hobbs,  of 
Topsfield.  Of  these,  eight  were  executed,  Sept. 
22,  viz.  Martha  Cory,  Mary  Easty,  Alice  Par- ' 
leer,  Ann  Pudeater,  Margaret  Scot,  William 
Reed,  Samuel  Ward  well  and  Mary  Parker. 

Giles  Cory  pleaded  not  guilty  to  his  indict- 
ment, but  would  not  put  himself  on  trial  by  the 
iury  (they  having  cleared  none  upon  trial)  and 
knowing  there  would  be  the  same  witnesses 
against  him,  rather  chose  to  undergo  what  death 
they  would  put  him  to.  In  pressing,  his  tongue 
being  prest  out  of  his  mouth,  the  sheriff  with 
his  cane  forced  it  in  again  when  he  was  dying. 
He  was  the  first  in  New-England  that  was  ever 
prest  to  death. 

The  cart,  going  to  the  hill  with  these  eight 
to  execution,  was  for  some  time  at  a  set ;  the 
afflicted  and  others  said,  that  the  devil  hindered 
it,  &c. 

Martha  Cory,  wife  to  Giles  Cory,  protesting 
her  innccency,  concluded  her  life  with  an  emi- 
nent prayer  upon  the  ladder. 

Wardwell,  having  formerly  confessed  himself 
guilty,  and  after  denied  it,  was  soon  brought  up- 
on his  trial ;  his  former  confession  and  spectre 
testimony  was  all  that  appeared  against  him. 
At  execution,  while  he  was  speaking  to  the  peo- 
ple, protesting  his  innocency,  the  executioner 
being  at  the  same  time  smoking  tobacco,  the 
smoke  coming  in  his  face  interrupted  his  dis- 
course ;  those  accusers  said  that  the  devil  did 
hinder  him  with  smoke. 


OF  FACT,  kc.  219 

Mary  Easty,  sister  also  to  Rebecca  Nurse, 
when  she  took  lier  last  larevvell  of  hor  husband, 
children  and  i'riends,  was,  as  is  reported  by  them 
present,  as  serious,  religious,  distinct  and  affec- 
tionate as  could  well  be  expiest,  drawing  tears 
from  the  eyes  of  almost  all  present.  It  seems, 
besides  the  testimony  of  the  accusers  and  con- 
fessors, another  proof,  as  it  was  counted,  ap- 
peared against  her :  it  having  been  usual  to 
search  the  accused  for  teats,  upon  some  parts 
of  her  body,  not  here  to  be  named,  was  found 
an  excrescence,  which  they  called  a  teat.  Be- 
fore her  death  she  presented  the  following  pe- 
tition : 

"  To  the  honourable  judge  and  bench  now 
sitting  in  judicature  in  Salem,  and  the  reverend 
ministers,  humbly  sheweth,  That  whereas  your 
humble  poor  petitioner,  being  condemned  to 
die,  doth  humbly  beg  of  you  to  take  It  into  your 
judicious  and  pious  consideration,  that  your  poor 
and  humble  petitioner,  knowing  my  own  inno- 
cency  (blessed  be  the  Lord  for  it)  and  seeing 
plainly  the  wiles  and  subtilty  of  my  accusers,  by 
myself,  cannot  but  judge  charitably  of  others, 
that  are  going  the  same  way  with  myself,  if  the 
Lord  step  not  mightily  in.  I  was  confined  a  whole 
month  on  the  same  account  that  I  am  now  con- 
demned, and  then  cleared  by  the  afflicted  persons, 
as  some  of  your  honours  know;  and  in  two  days 
time  1  was  cried  out  upon  by  them  again,  and 
have  been  confined,  and  now  am  condemned  to 
die.  The  Lord  above  knows  my  innocence  then, 
and  likewise  doth  now,  as  at  the  great  day  will 
be  known  by  men  and  angels.    I  petition  to  your 


2^0  MATTERS 

honours  not  for  my  own  life,  for  I  know  1  must 
die,  and  my  appointed  time  is  set ;  but  the  Lord 
he  knows  if  it  be  possible  that  no  more  innocent 
blood  be  shed,  which  undoubtedly  cannot  be 
avoided  in  the  way  and  course  you  go  in.  I  ques- 
tion not  but  your  honours  do  to  the  utmost  of 
your  powers,  in  the  discovery  and  detecting  of 
witchcraft  and  witches,  and  would  not  be  guilty 
of  innocent  blood  for  the  world  ;  but  by  my  own 
innocency  1  know  you  are  in  the  wrong  way. 
The  Lord  in  his  infinite  mercy  direct  you  in  this 
great  work,  if  it  be  his  blessed  will,  that  innocent 
biood  be  not  shed.  I  would  humbly  beg  of  you 
that  your  honours  would  be  pleased  to  examine 
some  of  those  confessing  witches,  I  being  confi- 
dent there  are  several  of  them  have  belied  them- 
selves and  others,  as  will  appear,  if  not  in  this 
world,  I  am  sure  in  the  world  to  come,  whither 
I  am  going;  and  I  question  not  but  yourselves 
will  see  an  alteration  in  these  things.  They 
say,  myself  and  others  have  made  a  league 
with  the  devil;  w^e  cannot  confess;  1  know  and 
the  Lord  knows  (as  will  shortly  appear)  they 
belie  me,  and  so  I  question  not  but  they  do 
others;  the  Lord  alone,  who  is  the  searcher  of 
?dl  hearts,  knows,  as  I  shall  answer  it  at  the 
tribunal  seat,  that  I  know  not  the  least  thing 
of  witchcraft,  therefore  I  cannot,  I  durst  not, 
belie  my  own  soul.  I  beg  your  honours  not  to 
deny  this  my  humble  petition,  from  a  poor  dying, 
innocent  person,  and  I  question  not  but  the  Lord 
will  give  a  blessing  to  your  endeavours. 

"Mary    East\%" 


OF  FACT,  Sic.  221 

After  execution,  mr.  Noyes,  turning  him  to 
the  bodies,  said,  What  a  sad  thing  it  is  to  see 
eiffht  firebrands  of  hell  hanging  there ! 

In  October,  1692,  one  of  Wenham  complained 
of  rars.  Hale,  whose  husband,  the  minister  of 
Beverly,  had  been  very  forward  in  these  prose- 
cutions; but  being  fully  satisfied  of  his  wife's 
sincere  Christianity  caused  him  to  alter  his  judg- 
ment ;  for  it  was  come  to  a  stated  controversy, 
among  the  New-England  divines,  whether  the 
devil  could  afflict  in  a  good  man's  shape ;  it  seems 
nothing  else  could  convince  him,  yet  when  it 
came  so  near  to  himself  he  was  soon  convinced, 
that  the  devil  might  so  afflict.  Which  same  rea- 
son did  afterwards  prevail  with  many  others,  and 
much  influenced  to  the  succeeding  change  at 
trials. 

October  7.  Edward  Bishop  and  his  wife  hav- 
ing made  their  escape  out  of  prison,  this  day  mr. 
Corwin,  the  sheriff,  came  and  seized  his  goods 
and  chattels,  and  had  it  not  been  for  his  second 
son  (who  borrowed  ten  pound  and  gave  it  him) 
they  had  been  wholly  lost.  The  receipt  fol- 
lows ;  but  it  seems  they  must  be  content  with 
such  a  receipt  as  he  would  give  them  : 

Received,  this  7th  day  of  October,  1692,  of  Samuel 
Bishop,  of  the  town  of  Salem,  of  the  county  of  Essex,  in 
New-England,  cordwainer,  in  full  satisfaction,  a  valuable 
sum  of  money,  for  the  goods  and  chattels  of  Edward  Bi- 
shop, senior^  of  the  town  and  county  aforesaid,  husband- 
man ;  which  goods  and  chattels  being  seized,  for  that  the 
said  Edward  Bishop,  and  Sarah  his  wife,  having  beea 
committed  for  witchcraft  and  felony,  have  made  their 
escape  ;  and  their  goods  and  chattels  were  forfeited  unto 
their  majesties,  and  now  being  in  possession  of  the  said 
Samuel  Bishop;  and  in  behalf  of  their  majesties.  1  do 
19* 


222  MATTERS 

hereby  discharge  the  said  goods  and  chattels,  the  day  and 
year  above  written,  as  witness  my  hand, 

George  Corwin,  Sheriff. 

But  before  this,  the  said  Bishop's  eldest  son 
having  married  into  that  family  of  the  Putmans, 
who  were  chief  prosecutors  in  this  business,  he 
holding  a  cow  to  be  branded  lest  it  should  be 
seized,  and  having  a  push  or  boil  upon  his  thigh, 
Avith  his  straining  it  broke  ;  this  is  that  that  was 
pretended  to  be  burnt  with  the  said  brand,  and 
is  one  of  the  bones  thrown  to  the  dogmatical  to 
pick,  in  yVonders  of  the  Invisible  World,  p.  143. 
The  other,  of  a  corner  of  a  sheet,  pretended  to 
be  taken  from  a  spectre  ;  it  is  known  that  it 
was  provided  the  day  before  by  that  afflicted 
person  ;  and  the  third  bone  of  a  spindle  is  almost 
as  easily  provided,  as  the  piece  of  the  knife;  so 
that  Apollo  needs  not  herein  be  consulted,  &c. 

Mr.  Philip  English,  and  his  wife,  having  made 
their  escape  out  of  prison,  mr.  Corwin,  the  she- 
riff, seized  his  estate,  to  the  value  of  about  fifteen 
hundred  pound,  which  was  wholly  lost  to  him, 
except  about  three  hundred  pound  value  (which 
was  afterward  restored.) 

After  goodwnfe  Hoar  was  condemned,  her 
estate  was  seized,  and  was  also  bought  again  for 
eight  pound. 

George  Jacobs,  son  to  old  Jacobs,  being  ac- 
cused, he  fled ;  then  the  officers  came  to  his 
house  ;  his  wife  was  a  w^oman  crazy  in  her  sen- 
ses, and  had  been  so  several  years.  She  it 
seems  had  been  also  accused.  There  were  in 
the  house  w  ith  her  only  four  small  children,  and 
one  of  them  sucked  her  eldest  dau2:hter,  being 


OF  FACT,  &c.  223 

in  prison  :  llie  officer  persuaded  her  out  of"  the 
house,  to  go  along  with  hlni,  teHing  her  she 
should  speedily  return;  the  children  ran  a  great 
way  alter  her,  crying. 

When  she  came  where  the  afflicted  >vere, 
being  asked,  they  said  tliey  did  not  know  her; 
at  length  one  said,  Don't  you  know  Jacobs^  the 
old  witch  ?  and  then  they  cried  out  of  her,  and 
fell  down  in  their  lits.  She  was  sent  to  prison, 
and  lay  there  ten  months  ;  the  neighbours  of 
pity  took  care  of  tlie  children  to  preserve  them 
from  perishing. 

About  this  time  a  new  scene  was  begun;  one 
Joseph  Ballard,  of  Andover,  whose  w  lie  was  ill 
(and  after  died  of  a  fever)  sent  to  Salem  for 
some  of  those  accusers,  to  tell  him  who  afflicted 
his  wife  ;  others  did  the  like  :  horse  and  man 
were  sent  from  several  places  to  fetch  those  ac- 
cusers who  had  the  spectral  sight,  that  they 
might  thereby  tell  who  alBlcted  those  that  were 
any  ways  ill. 

When  these  came  into  any  place  where  such 
were,  usually  they  fell  into  a  fit :  after  which, 
being  asked  who  it  was  that  afflicted  the  per- 
son, they  would,  for  the  most  part,  name  one 
who  they  said  sat  on  the  head,  and  another  that 
sat  on  the  lower  parts,  of  the  afflicted.  Soon 
after  Ballard's  sending  (as  above)  more  than 
fifty  of  the  people  of  Andover  were  complained 
of,  for  afflicting  their  neighbours.  Here  it  w  as 
that  many  accused  themselves  of  riding  upon 
poles  through  the  air;  many  parents  believing 
their  children  to  be  witches,  and  many  husbands 
their  wives, &c.     When  these  accusers  came  to 


224  ,  MATTERS 

the  house  of  any  upon  such  account,  it  was  or- 
dinary for  other  young  people  to  be  taken  in 
fits,  and  to  have  the  same  spectral  sight. 

Mr.  Dudley  Bradstreet,  a  justice  of  peace  in 
Andover,  having  granted  out  warrants  against, 
and  committed,  thirty  or  forty  to  prison,  for  the 
supposed  witchcrafts,  at  length  saw  cause  to 
forbear  granting  out  any  more  warrants.  Soon 
after  which,  he  and  his  wife  were  cried  out  of; 
himself  was  (by  them)  said  to  have  killed  nine 
persons  by  witchcraft,  and  he  found  it  his  safest 
course  to  make  his  escape. 

A  dog  being  afflicted  at  Salem  Village,  those 
that  had  the  spectral  sight  being  sent  for,  they 
accused  mr.  John  Bradstreet  (brother  to  the 
justice)  that  he  afflicted  the  said  dog,  and  now 
rid  upon  him.  He  made  his  escape  into  Pisca- 
tuqua  government,  and  the  dog  was  put  to  death, 
and  was  all  of  the  afflicted  that  suffered  death. 

At  Andover,  the  afflicted  complained  of  a 
dog,  as  afflicting  them,  and  would  fall  into  their 
fits  at  the  dog's  looking  upon  them ;  the  dog 
was  put  to  death. 

A  worthy  gentleman  of  Boston  being  about 
this  time  accused  by  those  at  Andover,  he  sent 
by  some  particular  friends  a  writ  to  arrest  those 
accusers  in  a  thousand  pound  action  for  defama- 
tion, with  instructions  to  them  to  inform  them- 
selves of  the  certainty  of  the  proof,  in  doing 
which  their  business  was  perceived,  and  from 
thenceforward  the  accusations  at  Andover  gen- 
erally ceased. 

In  October  some  of  these  accusers  were  sent 
for  to  Gloucester,  and  occasioned  four  women  to 


GF  FACT,  &c.  225 

be  sent  to  prison;  but  Salem  prison  bcin^  so  lull 
it  could  receive  no  more,  two  were  sent  to  Ips- 
wich prison.  In  November  they  were  sent  lor 
again  by  lieutenant  Stephens,  wfio  was  told  that 
a  sister  ol'  his  was  bewitclicd;  in  their  way 
passing  over  Ipswich-bridge,  they  met  with  an 
old  woman,  and  instantly  fell  into  their  fits. 
But  by  this  time  the  validity  oisuch  accusations 
being  much  questioned,  they  Ibund  not  that  en- 
couragement they  had  done  elsewhere,  and  soon 
withdrew. 

These  accusers  swore  that  they  saw  three 
persons  sitting  upon  lieutenant  Stephens's  sister 
till  she  died ;  yet  bond  was  accepted  for  those 
three: 

And  now^  nineteen  persons  having  been  hang- 
ed, and  one  prest  to  death,  and  eight  more  con- 
demned, in  all  twenty-eight,  of  which  above  a 
third  part  were  members  of  some  of  the  church- 
es in  New-England,  and  more  than  half  of  them 
of  a  good  conversation  in  general,  and  not  one 
cleared;  about  fifty  having  confest  themselves 
to  be  witches,  of  which  not  one  executed ;  above 
an  iiundred  and  fifty  in  prison,  and  above  two 
hundred  more  accused  ;  tlie  special  commission 
of  oyer  and  terminer  comes  to  a  period,  which 
has  no  other  foundation  than  the  governor's  com- 
mission; and  iiad  proceeded  in  the  manner  of 
swearing  witnesses,  viz.  by  holding  up  the  hand, 
(and  by  receiving  evidences  in  writing)  accord- 
ing to  the  ancient  usage  of  this  country;  as  also 
having  their  indictments  in  English.  In  the  tri- 
als, when  any  were  indicted  for  afflicting,  pining 
and  wasting  the  bodies  of  particular  persons  by 


226  BIATTERS 

witchcraft,  it  v/as  usual  to  hear  evidence  of  mat- 
ter foreign,  and  of  perhaps  twenty  or  thirty 
years  standing,  about  oversetting  carts,  the  death 
of  cattle,  unkindness  to  relations,  or  unexpected 
accidents  befalHng  after  some  quarrel.  Wheth- 
er this  was  admitted  by  the  law  of  England,  or 
by  what  other  law,  wants  to  be  determined; 
the  executions  seemed  mixt,  in  pressing  to  death 
for  not  pleading,  Avhich  most  agrees  with  the 
laws  of  England;  and  sentencing  women  to  be 
hanged  for  witchcraft,  according  to  the  former 
practice  of  this  country,  and  not  by  burning,  as 
is  said  to  have  been  the  law  of  England.  And 
though  the  confessing  witches  were  many,  yet 
not  one  of  them  that  confessed  their  own  guilt, 
and  abode  by  their  confession,  was  put  to  death. 
Here  folioweth  what  account  some  of  those 
miserable  creatures  give  of  their  confession  un- 
der their  own  hands; 

"  We,  whose  names  are  under  written,  inhabi- 
tants of  Andover,  when  as  that  horrible  and  tre- 
mendous judgment  beginning  at  Salem  Village,  in 
the  year  1692,  (by  some  called  witchcraft)  first 
breaking  forth  at  mr.  Parrls's  house,  several 
young  persons  being  seemingly  afflicted,  did  ac- 
cuse several  persons  for  afflicting  them,  and  ma- 
ny there  believing  it  so  to  be;  we  being  inform- 
ed that  if  a  person  were  sick,  the  afflicted  per- 
son could  tell  what  or  who  was  the  cause  of  that 
sickness:  Joseph  Ballard,  of  Andover  (his  wife 
being  sick  at  the  same  time)  he  either  from 
himself,  or  by  the  advice  of  others,  fetched  two 
of  the  persons,  called  the  afflicted  persons,  from 


OF  FACT,  4c.  227 

Salem  Village  to  Andover:  which  was  the  be- 
ginning of  that  dreadful  calamity  that  befel  us 
in  Andover.  And  the  authority  in  Andover, 
believing  the  said  accusations  to  be  true,  sent  for 
the  said  persons  to  come  together  to  the  meet- 
ing-house in  Andover  (the  afflicted  persons  be- 
ing there.)  After  mr.  Barnard  had  been  at 
prayer,  we  were  blindfolded,  and  our  hands 
were  laid  upon  the  afflicted  persons,  they  being 
in  their  fits,  and  falling  into  their  fits  at  our 
coming  into  their  presence  (as  they  said)  and 
some  led  us  and  laid  our  hands  upon  them,  and 
then  they  said  they  were  well,  and  that  we 
were  guilty  of  afflicting  of  them ;  whereupon 
we  were  all  seized  as  prisoners,  by  a  warrant 
from  a  justice  of  the  peace,  and  forthwith  car- 
ried to  Salem.  And  by  reason  of  that  sudden 
surprisal,  we  knowing  ourselves  altogether 
innocent  of  that  crime,  we  were  all  exceed- 
ingly astonished  and  amazed,  and  affrighted 
even  out  of  our  reason;  and  our  nearest  and 
dearest  relations,  seeing  us  in  that  dreadful  con- 
dition, and  knowing  our  great  danger,  appre- 
hending that  there  was  no  other  way  to  save 
our  lives,  as  the  case  was  then  circumstanced, 
but  by  our  confessing  ourselves  to  be  such  and 
such  persons,  as  the  afflicted  represented  us  to 
be,  they  out  of  tender  love  and  pity  persuaded 
us  to  confess  what  we  did  confess.  And  indeed 
that  confession,  that  it  is  said  we  made,  was  no 
other  than  what  was  suggested  to  us  by  some 
gentlemen;  they  telling"  us,  that  we  were 
witches,  and  they  knew  it,  and  we  knew  it, 
and  they  knew  that  we  knew  it,  which  made 


228  MATTERS 

us  think  that  it  was  so;  and  our  understand- 
ing, our  reason  and  our  faculties  almost  gone, 
we  were  not  capable  of  juds;irjg  our  condi- 
tion; as  also  the  hard  measures  they  used  with 
us  rendered  us  uncapable  of  making  our  defence ; 
but  said  any  thing  and  every  thing  which  they 
desired;  and  most  of  what  we  said  was  but  in 
effect  a  consenting  to  what  they  said.  Some- 
time after,  when  we  were  better  composed, 
they  telling  of  us  what  we  had  confessed,  we 
did  profess  that  we  were  innocent,  and  ignorant 
of  such  things.  And  we  hearing  that  Samuel 
Ward  well  had  renounced  his  confession,  and 
quickly  after  was  condemned  and  executed, 
some  of  us  were  told  that  we  were  going  after 
Wardweil. 

Mary  Osgood^ 

Mary  Tiler ^ 

Deliv.  Dane, 


Abigail  Barker^ 
Sarah  Wilson, 
Hannah  Tiler,''^ 


It  may  here  be  further  added,  concerning 
those  that  did  confess,  that  besides  that  power- 
ful argument,  of  life  (and  freedom  from  hard- 
ships, not  only  promised,  but  also  performed  to 
all  that  ow-ned  their  guilt)  there  are  numerous 
instances,  too  many  to  be  here  inserted,  of  the 
tedious  examinations  before  private  persons, 
many  hours  together;  they  all  that  time  urging 
them  to  confess  (and  taking  turns  to  persuade 
them)  till  the  accused  were  wearied  out  by  be- 
ing forced  to  stand  so  long,  or  for  want  of  sleep, 
&c.  and  so  brought  to  give  an  assent  to  what 
they  said  ;  they  then  asking  them.  Were  you  at 
such  a  witch-meeting  ?  or,  Have  you  signed  the 


OF  FACT,  &c.  229 

t)evil's  book  ?  (fee.  Upon  their  replying,  Yes, 
the  whole  was  drawn  into  form,  as  their  con- 
I'ession. 

But  that  which  did  mightily  further  puch 
confessions  was,  their  nearest  relations  urging 
them  to  it.  These,  seeing  no  other  way  of 
ecape  for  them,  thought  it  the  best  advice  that 
could  be  given ;  hence  it  was  that  the  husbands 
of  some,  by  counsel  often  urging,  and  utmost 
earnestness,  and  children  upon  their  knees  in- 
treating,  have  at  length  prevailed  with  them  to 
say  they  were  guilty. 

As  to  the  manner  of  trials,  and  the  evidence 
taken  for  convictions  at  Salem,  it  is  already  set 
forth  in  print,  by  the   rev,,  mr.  Cotton  Mather, 
in  his  Wonders  of  the  Invisible  World,  at  the  com- 
mand of  his  excellency  feir  William  Phips;  with 
not  only  the  recommendation,  but  thanks,  of  the 
heutenant  governor;  and  with  the  approbation 
of  the  rev.  mr.  I.  M.  in  his  postscript  to  his  Cases  \/^ 
of  Conscience  ;  which  last  book  was  set  forth  by    X 
the  consent  of  the  ministers  In  and  near  Boston.       \ 
Tvvo  of  the  judges  have  also  given  their  sen- 
timents in  these  words,  p.  147. 

The  reverenrl  and  worthy  author  having:,  at  the  direc- 
tion of  his  excellency  the  governor,  so  far  obliged  the 
puMick,  as  to  give  some  account  of  tlie  sufferings  brought 
upon  the  country  by  witchcrafts,  and  of  the  trials  which 
have  passed  upon  several  executed  tor  the  same  : 

Upon  perusal  thereof,  we  find  the  matters  of, fact  and 
evidence  truly  repo.'ted,  and  a  prospect  given  of  the  me- 
thods of  conviction,  used  in  the  proceedings  of  the  court 
at  Salem.  ,,^  ^ 

U  ILLIAM    bTOUGHTOIf, 

Boston,  Oct  U,m2.  ^^''''^^^  ^^'''^^^• 

20 


250  MATTERS 

And  considering  that  this  may  fall  Into  the 
hands  of  such  as  never  saw  those  IVonders,  it 
may  be  needful  to  transcribe  the  whole  account 
he  has  given  thereof,  without  any  variation  (but 
■with  one  of  the  Indictments  annexed  to  the  tri- 
al of  each)  which  is  thus  prefaced,  pp.  8], 
82,  83. 

"  But  I  shall  no  longer  detain  my  reader  from 
his  expected  entertainment,  in  a  brief  account 
of  the  trials  which   have  passed   upon  some  of 
the  malefactors  lately   executed  at   Salem  for 
the  witchcrafts  whereof  they  stood  convicted. 
For  my  own  part  I   was  not  present  at  any  of 
them;  nor  ever  had    1  any  personal  prejudice 
against  the  persons  thus  brought  upon  the  stage ; 
much  less,  at  the  surviving  relations   of  those 
persons,  with   and   for   whom   I    would    be    as 
hearty   a   mourner,  as   any   man  living  in   the 
world :   The  Lord  comfort  them  !     But  having  re- 
ceived a  command  so  to  do,  I  can  do  no  other 
than  shortly  relate   the   chief  matters  of  fact, 
which  occurred  in  the  trials  of  some  that  were 
executed,  in  an  abridgment  collected  out  of  the 
court-papers,  on  this  occasion  put  into  my  hands. 
.You  are  to  take  the  truth,  just  as  It  was ;  and 
the  truth  will  hurt  no  good  man.     There  might 
have  been  more  of  these  :  and  if  some  other 
worthy  hands  did  not  perhaps  intend  something 
further  in  these  collections ;  for  wdilch  cause  I 
have  only  singled  out  four  or  five,  which  may 
serve  to  illustrate  the  way  of  dealing,  wherein 
witchcrafts  use  to  be  concerned  ;   and  I  report 
matters,  not  as  an  advocate,  but  as  an  historian. 
"  These  were  some  of  the  gracious  words  in- 


OF  FACT,  kc.  2»1 

serted  in  the  advice,  wliich  many  of  llic  noi£(h- 
bouring  ministers  did  this  summer  iiumbly  lay 
before  our  honourable  judges  :  '  We  cannot  but 
with  all  thankfulness  acknowledge  the  success, 
which  the  mercii'ul  God  has  given  unto  the  se- 
dulous and  assiduous  endeavours  of  our  honour- 
able rulers,  to  detect  the  abominable  witchcrafts 
which  have  been  committed  in  the  country  ; 
humbly  praying  that  the  discovery  of  those  mys- 
terious and  mischievous  wickednesses  may  be 
perfected.'  If,  in  the  midst  of  the  many  dissat- 
isfactions among  us,  the  publication  of  these 
trials  may  promote  such  a  pious  thankfulness 
unto  God,  for  justice  being  so  far  executed 
among  us,  I  shall  rejoice  that  God  is  glorified ; 
and  pray  that  no  wrong  steps  of  ours  may  ever 
sully  any  of  his  glorious  works." 

The  Indictment  of  George  Burroughs. 

Essex  ss.            Anno  Regni  Regis  Sf  Rcgince  Willielmi  ^  Marice,  nunc. 
Anglice^  8fc.  quarto. 

The  jurors  for  our  sovereign  lord  and  lady  the  king 
and  queen  present,  that  George  Burroughs,  late  of  Fal- 
mouth, in  the  province  of  the  Massachusetts  Bay,  in  New- 
England,  clerk,  the  9th  day  of  May,  in  the  fourth  year  of 
the  reign  of  our  sovereign  lord  and  lady  William  and 
Mary,  by  the  grace  of  God,  of  England,  Scotland,  France 
and  Ireland,  king  and  queen,  defenders  of  the  faith,  &c. 
and  divers  other  days  and  times,  as  well  before  as  after, 
certain  detestable  arts,  called  witchcrafts  and  sorceries, 
wickedly  and  feloniously  hath  used,  practised  and  exer- 
cised, at  and  within  the  township  of  Salem,  in  the  county 
of  Essex,  aforesaid,  in,  upon  and  against  one  Mary  Wol- 
cott,  of  Salem  Village,  in  the  county  of  Essex," single  wo- 
man ;  by  which  said  wicked  arts  the  said  Mary  Wolcott, 
the  9th  day  of  May,  in  the  fourth  year  abovesaid,  and  di- 
vers other  days  and  times,  as  well  betore  as  after,  was 
and  is  tortured,  alllictcd,  pined,  consumed,  wasted   and 


t5t  MATTERS 

tormented,  against  the  peace  of  onr  sovereign  lord  and 
lady,  the  king  and  queen,  and  against  the  form  of  the 
statute  in  that  case  made  and  provided. 

Witnesses,  Mary  Wolcott,  Sarah  Fibber^  Mercy  Le-^is^ 
Ann  Putman,  Eliz.  Hubbard. 

Endorsed  by  the  grand  jury,  Billa  Vera. 

There  was  also  a  second  indictment,  for  af- 
flicting Elizabeth  Hubbard.  The  witnesses  to 
the  said  indictment  were  Elizabeth  Hubbard^ 
Mary  Wolcoit  and  ^^nn  Putman. 

The  third  indictment  was  for  afflicting  Mercy 
Lewis:  the  witnesses,  the  said  Mercy  Lewis, 
Mary  iVolcott,  Elizabeth  Hubbard  and  Ann  Put- 
man, 

The  fourth,  for  acts  of  witchcraft  on  Ann 
Putman:  the  witnesses,  the  said  Ann  Putman, 
Mary  Wolcott,  Elizabeth  Hubbard  and  Mary 
Warren* 

The  Trial  of  G.  B.  as  printed  in  Wonders  of  the 
Invisible  World, from  p,  94  to  104. 

Glad  should  I  have  been,  if  I  had  never 
known  the  name  of  this  man,  oi'  never  had  this 
occasion  to  mention  so  much  as  the  hrst  letters 
©f  his  name;  but  the  gov^ernment  requiring 
some  account  of  his  trial  to  be  inserted  in  this 
took,  it  becomes  me  with  all  obedience  to  sub- 
mit unto  the  order. 

1.  This  G.  B.  was  indicted  for  witchcrafts; 
and,  in  the  prosecution  of  the  charge  against 
him,  he  was  accused  by  fwe  or  six  of  the  be- 
witched, as  the  author  of  their  miseries;  he 
was  accused  by  eight  of  the  confessing  witches, 
as  being  a  head  actor  at  some  of  their  hellish 
rendezvous,  and  who  had  the  promise  of  being 


OF  FACT,  &c.  233 

/ 

5  king  m  Satan's  kingdom,  now  going  to  be  erect- 
ed ;  he  was  accused  by  nine  persons,  for  extra- 
ordinary lilting,  and  such  feats  of  strength  as 
could  not  be  done  without  a  diabolical  assist- 
ance; and  for  other  such  things  he  was  accused, 
until  about  thirty  testimonies  were  brought  in 
against  him;  nor  were  these  judged  the  half  of 
what  might  have  been  considered,  for  his  con- 
viction: however,  they  were  enough  to  fix  the 
character  of  a  witch  upon  him,  according  to  the 
rules  of  reasoning,  by  the  judicious  Gaule  in  that 
case  directed. 

2.  The  court  being  sensible  that  the  testimo- 
nies of  the  parties  bewitched  used  to  have  a 
room  among  the  suspicions,  or  presumptions, 
brought  in  against  one  indicted  for  witchcraft, 
there  were  now  heard  the  testimonies  of  several 
persons  who  were  most  notoriously  bewitched, 
and  every  day  tortured  by  invisible  hands,  and 
these  now  all  charged  the  spectres  of  G.  B.  to 
have  a  share  in  their  torments.  At  the  exam- 
ination of  this  G.  B.  the  bewitched  people  were 
grievously  harassed  with  preternatural  mischiefs, 
which  could  not  possibly  be  dissembled;  and 
they  still  ascribed  it  unto  the  endeavours  of  G. 
B.  to  kill  them.  And  now,  upon  his  trial,  one 
of  the  bewitched  persons  testified,  that  in  her 
agonies  a  little  black-haired  man  came  to  her, 
saying  his  name  was  B.  and  bidding  her  set  her 
hand  unto  a  book,  which  he  shewed  unto  her; 
and  bragging  that  he  was  a  conjurer  above  the 
ordinary  rank  of  witches ;  that  he  often  perse- 
cuted her  with  the  offer  of  that  book,  saying, 
she  should  be  well,  and  need  fear  nobody,  if  she 


V 


234  MATTERS 

would  but  sign  it :  but  he  inflicted  cruel  pains 
and  hurts  upon  her,  because  of  her  denying  go 
to  do.  The  testimonies  of  the  other  suiTerers 
concurred  with  these ;  and  it  was  remarkable, 
that  whereas  biting  was  one  of  the  ways  which 
the  witches  used  for  the  vexing  of  the  sufferers, 
when  they  cried  out  of  G.  B.  biting  them,  the 
print  of  his  teeth  would  be  seen  on  the  flesh  of 
the  complainers;  and  just  such  a  set  of  teeth  as 
G.  B's  would  then  appear  upon  them,  which 
could  be  distinguished  from  those  of  some  other 
men's. 

Others  of  them  testified,  that  in  their  tor- 
ments G.  B.  tempted  them  to  go  unto  a  sacra- 
ment, unto  which  they  perceived  him  with  a 
sound  of  trumpet  summoning  other  w^itches ; 
who  quickly  after  the  sound  w^ould  come  from 
all  quarters  unto  the  rendezvous.  One  of  them, 
falling  into  a  kind  of  a  trance,  afterwards  affirm- 
ed, that  G.  B.  had  carried  her  into  a  very  high 
mountain,  where  he  showed  her  mighty  and 
glorious  kingdoms,  and  said  he  w^ould  give  them 
all  to  her,  if  she  would  write  in  his  book  ;  but 
she  told  him,  they  were  none  of  his  to  give,  and 
refused  the  motion,  enduring  much  misery  for 
that  refusal. 

It  cost  the  court  a  w^onderful  deal  of  trouble 
to  hear  the  testimonies  of  the  sufferers ;  for 
when  they  were  going  to  give  in  their  deposi- 
tions, they  would  for  a  long  w^hile  be  taken  with 
fits,  that  made  them  uncapable  of  saying  any 
thing.  The  chief  judge  asked  the  prisoner,  who 
he  thought  hindered  these  witnesses  from  giving 
their  testimonies;  and  he  answered,  he  supposed 


OF  FACT,  &c.  235 

it  was  the  devil.  That  honourable  person  then 
re|jlicd,  How  comes  the  devil  so  loth  to  iiave 
aij)  testimony  borne  against  you  ?  which  cast 
hnn  into  very  great  confusion. 

3,  It  hath  been  a  frequent  thing  for  the  be- 
witched people  to  be  entertained  with  appari- 
tions of  ghosts  of  murdered  people,  at  the  same 
time  that  the  spectres  of  tlie  witches  trouble. 
them.  These  ghosts  do  always  alfright  tlie  be- 
holders, more  than  all  the  other  spectral  re]> 
resentations ;  and  when  they  exhibit  themselves, 
they  cry  out  of  being  murdered  by  the  witch- 
crafts or  otiier  violences  of  the  persons  who  are 
then  in  spectre  present.  It  is  further  consider- 
able, that  once  or  twice  these  apparitions  have 
been  seen  by  others,  at  the  very  same  time  they 
have  shown  themselves  to  the  bewitched;  and 
seldom  have  there  been  these  apparitions,  but 
w'hen  something  unusual  and  suspected  hath 
attended  the  death  of  the  party  thus  appearing. 
Some,  that  have  been  accused  by  these  appari- 
tions, accosting  the  bewitched  people,  who  had 
never  heard  a  word  of  any  such  persons  ever 
being  in  the  world,  have,  upon  a  fair  examination, 
freely  and  fully  confessed  the  murders  of  those 
very  persons,  although  these  also  did  not  know^ 
how  the  apparitions  had  complained  of  them. 
Accordingly  several  of  the  bewitched  had  given 
in  their  testimony,  that  they  had  been  troubled 
\fith  the  apparitions  of  two  women,  who  said 
they  were  G.  B's  two  wives ;  and  that  he  had 
been  the  death  of  them;  and  that  the  magis- 
trates must  be  told  of  it,  before  whom,  if  B. 
Mpon  his  trial  denied  it,  they  did  not  know  but 


236  JMATTERS 

that  they  should  appear  agafn  in  the  court. 
Now  G.  B.  had  been  infamous,  for  the  barbarous 
usage  of  his  two  successive  wives,  all  the  coun- 
try over.  Moreover,  it  was  testified,  the  spectre 
of  G.  B.  threatening  the  sufferers,  told  tliern  he 
had  killed  (besides  others)  mrs.  Lawson  and  her 
daughter  Ann.  And  it  was  noted,  that  tlrese 
were  the  virtuous  wife  and  daughter  of  one,  at 
whom  this  G.  B.  might  have  a  prejudice,  for 
being  serviceable  at  Salem  Village,  from  whence 
himself  had  in  ill  terms  removed  some  years  be- 
fore ;  and  that  when  they  died,  which  was  long 
since,  there  were  some  odd  circumstances  about 
them,  which  made  some  of  the  attendants  there 
suspect  something  of  witchcraft,  though  none 
imagined  from  what  quarter  it  should  come. 

Well,  G.  B.  being  now  upon  his  trial,  one  of 
the  bewitched  persons  was  cast  into  horror  at 
the  ghosts  of  B's  two  deceased  wives,  then  ap- 
l^earing  before  him,  and  crying  for  vengeance 
against  him.  Hereupon  several  of  the  bewitch- 
ed persons  were  successively  called  in,  who  all, 
not  knowing  what  the  former  had  seen  and  said, 
concurred  in  their  horror  of  the  apparition, 
which  they  affirmed  that  he  had  before  him. 
But  he,  though  much  appalled,  utterly  denied 
that  he  discerned  any  thing  of  it,  nor  w^as  it  any. 
part  of  his  conviction. 

4.  Judicious  v/riters  have  assigned  it  a  great 
place  in  the  conviction  of  witches,  when  persons 
are  impeached  by  other  notorious  witches  to  be 
as  ill  as  themselves,  especially  if  the  persons 
have  been  much  noted  for  neglecting  the  wor- 
ship of  God.     Now,  as  tliere  might  have  been 


OF  FACT,  ^.  237 

testimonies  enough  of  G.  B's  antipathy  to  prayer, 
and  the  other  ordinances  ol"  God,  though  by  his 
proiession  singularly  obliged  thereunto;  so  there 
now  came  in  against  the  prisoner,  the  testi mo- 
Dies  oi' several  persons,  who  conlesscd  their  own 
having  been  horrible  witches,  and,  ever  since 
their  confessions,  had  been  themselves  terribly 
tortured  by  the  devils  and  other  witches,  even 
like  the  other  suiFerers,  and  therein  undergone 
the  pains  of  many  deaths  for  their  confessions. 

These  now  testified,  that  G.  B.  had  been  at  \ 
witch-meetings  with  them;  and  that  he  was  the 
person  who  had  seduced  and  compelled  them 
into  the  snares  of  witchcraft ;  that  he  promised 
them  fine  clothes  for  doing  it;  that  he  brought 
poppets  to  them,  and  thorns  to  stick  into  those 
poppets,  for  the  afflicting  of  other  people ;  and 
that  he  exhorted  them,  with  the  rest  of  the 
crew,  to  bewitch  all  Salem  Village  ;  but  be  sure 
to  do  it  gradually,  if  they  would  prevail  in  what 
they  did. 

When  the  Lancashire  witches  were  condem- 
ned, I  do  not  remember  that  there  was  any  con- 
siderable further  evidence,  than  that  of  the  be- 
witched, and  than  that  of  some  that  had  confes- 
sed. We  see  so  much  already  against  G.  B. 
B>it  this  being  indeed  not  enough,  there  were 
otlier  things  to  render  what  had  already  been 
produced  credible. 

5.  A   famous  divine  recites   this   among  the 
convictions   of   a   witch;  the.  testimony  of  the      . 
party   bewitched,  whether  pining  or  dying;  to-  V 
o-ether  with  the  joint  oaths  of  sulhcicnt  persons,  /\ 
that  have  seen  certam  prodigious  pranks,  or  feats, 


238  MATTERS 

wrought  by  the  party  accused.  Now,  God  had 
been  pleased  so  to  leave  G.  B.  that  he  had  en- 
snared himself,  by  several  instances,  which  he 
had  i'ornierly  given,  of  a  preternatural  strength; 
and  which  were  now  produced  against  him.  He 
was  a  very  puny  man,  yet  he  had  often  done 
things  beyond  the  strength  of  a  giant.  A  gun 
of  about  seven  feet  barrel,  and  so  heavy  that 
strong  men  could  not  steadily  hold  it  out,  with 
both  hands;  there  were  several  testimonies  giv- 
en in  by  persons  of  credit  and  honour,  tliat  he 
made  nothing  of  taking  up  such  a  gun  behind  the 
lock  w^ith  but  one  hand,  and  holding  it  out,  like 
a  pistol^  at  arm's  end.  G.  B.  in  his  vindication 
was  so  foolish  as  to  say,  that  an  Indian  was  there, 
and  held  it  out,  at  the  same  time ;  whereas,  none 
of  the  spectators  ever  saw  any  such  Indian ;  but 
they  supposed  the  black  man  (as  the  witches 
call  the  devil,  and  tliey  generally  say  he  resem- 
bles an  Indian)  might  give  him  that  assistance* 
There  w^as  evidence  likewise  brought  in,  that 
he  made  nothing  of  taking  up  whole  barrels  filled 
with  molasses,  or  cider,  in  very  disadvantageous 
postures,  and  carrying  them  off,  through  the 
most  diificult  places,  out  of  a  canoe  to  the  shore. 

Yea,  there  were  two  testimoDies,  that  G.  B. 
with  only  putting  the  fore-finger  of  his  right  hand 
into  the  muzzle  of  an  heavy  gun,  a  fowling  piece 
of  about  six  or  seven  i'eet  barrel,  lifted  up  the 
gun,  and  held  it  out  at  arm's  end ;  a  gun  which 
the  deponents,  though  strong  men,  could  not 
with  both  hands  lift  up,  and  hold  out  at  the  but- 
end,  as  is  usual.  Indeed  one  of  these  witnesses 
was  over-persuaded  by  some  persons  to  be  out 


OF  FACT,  &c.  23y 

ei'  the  way  upon  G.  B's  trial ;  but  he  came  after- 
wards, with  sorrow  lor  his  withch'awinc^,  and 
gavfe  in  his  testimony,  Nor  were  either  oi  these 
witnesses  made  use  of  as  evidence  in  the  trial. 

There  came  in  several  testimonies,  relating 
to  the  domestic  all'airs  of  G.  B.  which  had  a  ve- 
ry hard  aspect  upon  him;  ar)d  not  only  proved 
him  a  very  ill  man,  but  also  confirmed  the  belief 
of  the  character  which  had  been  already  fasten- 
ed on  him.  'Twas  testified,  that,  keeping  his 
two  successive  wives  in  a  strange  kind  of  sla- 
very, he  would,  when  he  came  home  from 
abroad,  pretend  to  tell  the  talk  which  any  had 
with  them:  that  he  has  brought  them  to  the 
point  of  death,  by  his  harsh  dealings  with  his 
wives,  and  then  made  the  people  about  him  to 
promise  that  in  case  death  should  happen  they 
v»'ould  say  nothing  of  it :  that  he  used  all  means 
to  make  his  wives  write,  sign,  seal  and  swear  a 
covenant  never  to  reveal  any  of  his  secrets : 
that  his  wives  had  privately  complained  unto 
the  neighbours  about  frightly  apparitions  of  evil 
spirits,  with  which  their  house  was  sometimes 
infested;  and  that  many  such  things  had  been 
whispered  among  the  neighbourhood.  There 
were  also  some  other  testimonies,  relating  to 
the  death  of  people,  whereby  the  consciences 
of  an  impartial  jury  were  convinced  that  G.  B. 
had  bewitched  the  persons  mentioned  in  the 
complaints.  But  I  am  forced  to  omit  several 
such  passages  in  this  as  well  ss  m  all  the  suc- 
ceeding trials,  because  the  scribes  who  took  no- 
tice of  them  have  not  supplied  me. 

7.    One    Mn    Ruck,  brother-in-law    to    this 


240  MATTERS 

G.  B.  testified,  that  G.  B.  and  he  himself,  aud 
his  sister,  who  was  G.  B's  wife,  j^oing  out  for 
two  or  three  miles,  to  gather  strawberries, 
Ruck,  with  his  sister,  the  wife  of  G.  B.  rode 
home  very  softly,  with  G.  B.  on  foot,  in  their 
company;  G.  B.  stept  aside  a  little  into  the 
bushes,  whereupon  they  halted  and  hollowed 
for  him :  he  not  answering,  they  went  away 
homcAvards,  with  a  quickened  pace,  without 
any  expectation  of  seeing  him  in  a  considerable 
while  ;  and  yet,  when  they  were  got  near  home, 
to  their  astonishment  they  found  him  on  foot, 
with  them,  having  a  basket  of  strawberries. 
G.  B.  immediately  then  fell  to  chiding  his  wife, 
on  the  account  of  what  she  had  been  speaking 
to  her  brother  of  him  on  the  road;  Avhich  when 
they  w^ondered  at,  he  said,  he  knew  their 
thoughts.  Ruck,  being  startled  at  that,  made 
some  reply,  intimating  that  the  devil  himself 
did  not  know  so  far ;  but  G.  B.  answered,  my 
God  makes  known  your  thoughts  unto  me. 
The  prisoner  now  at  the  bar  had  nothing  to  an- 
swer unto  what  was  thus  witnessed  against  him, 
that  was  worth  considering;  only  he  said,  Ruck 
and  his  wife  left  a  man  with  him,  when  they 
left  him;  which  Ruck  now  affirmed  to  be  false; 
and  when  the  court  asked  G.  B.  what  the  man's 
name  was,  his  countenance  was  much  altered, 
nor  could  he  say  who  it  was.  But  the  court 
began  to  think  that  he  then  stept  aside,  only 
that  by  the  assistance  of  the  l)lack  man  he 
might  put  on  his  invisibility,  and  in  that  fascin- 
ating mist  gratify  his  own  jealous  humour,  to 
hear  what  they  said  of  him :   which   trick   of 


OF  FACT,  kc.  241 

rendering  themselves  invisible,  our  witches  do 
in  their  conlessions  pretend  that  they  sometimes 
are  masters  ol';  and  it  is  the  more  credible,  be- 
cause there  is  demonstration  that  they  ol'ten 
render  many  other  things  utterly  invisible. 

8.  Faultering,  faulty,  unconstant  and  contrary 
answers,  upon  judicial  and  deliberate  examina- 
tion, are  counted  some  unlucky  symptoms  of 
guilt  in  all  crimes,  especially  in  witchcrafts. 
No^v  there  never  was  a  prisoner  more  eminent 
for  rhem  than  G.  B.  both  at  his  examination  and 
on  his  trial.  His  tergiversations,  contradictions 
and  falsehoods  were  very  sensible;  he  had  little 
to  say,  but  that  he  had  heard  some  things,  that 
he  could  not  prove,  reflecting  upon  the  reputa- 
tion of  some  of  the  witnesses:  only  he  gave  in  a 
paper  to  the  jury,  wherein,  although  he  had  ma- 
ny times  before  granted,  not  only  that  there  are 
witches,  but  also  that  the  [)resent  sufferings  of 
the  country  are  the  elfects  of  horrible  witch- 
crafts, yet  he  now  goes  to  evince  it,  that  there 
neither  are,  nor  ever  were,  witches,  that,  hav- 
ing made  a  compact  with  the  devil,  can  send  a 
devil  to  torment  other  people  at  a  distance. 
This  paper  was  transcribed  out  of.Ady;  which 
the  court  presently  knew,  as  soon  as  they  heard 
it.  But  he  said,  he  had  taken  none  of  it  out  of 
any  book  ;  for  which  his  evasion  afterwards  was, 
that  a  gentleman  gave  him  the  discourse  in  a 
manuscript,  Irom  whence  he  transcribed  it. 

9.  The  jury  brought  him  in  guilty  ;  but  when 
he  came  to  die,  he  utterly  denied  the  fact,  where- 
of he  had  been  thus  convicted. 


21 


242  MATTERS 

The  Indictment  of  Bridget  Bishop. 

Essex  SB.           Anno  Regni  Regis  8^  Regince,  Willielmi  8;  Marice,  nunc 
Jinglice^  8fc.  quarto. 

The  jurors  for  our  sovereigfn  lord  and  lady  the  king 
and  queen  present,  that  Bridget  Bishop,  alias  Oliver,  the 
wife  of  Edward  Bishop,  in  Salem,  in  the  county  of  Essex, 
sawyer,  the  nineteenth  day  of  April,  in  the  fourth  year  of 
the  reign  of  our  sovereign  lord  and  lady  William  and 
Mary,  by  the  grace  of  God,  of  England,  Scotland,  France 
and  Ireland,  king  and  queen,  defenders  of  the  faith,  &c. 
and  divers  other  days  and  times,  as  well  before  as  after, 
certain  detestable  arts,  called  witchcrafts  and  sorceries, 
wickedly  and  feloniously  hath  used,  practised  and  exer- 
cised, at  and  within  the  township  of  Salem,  in  the  county 
of  Essex,  aforesaid,  in,  upon  and  against  one  Mercy  Lew- 
is, of  Salem  V^illage,  in  the  county  aforesaid,  single  wo- 
man ;  by  which  said  wicked  arts  the  said  Mercy  Lewis, 
the  said  19th  day  of  April,  in  the  fourth  year  abovesaid,  and 
divers  other  days  and  times,  as  well  before  as  after,  was 
and  is  hurt,  tortured,  afflicted,  pined,  consumed,  wasted 
and  tormented,  against  the  peace  of  our  sovereign  lord 
and  lady,  the  king  and  queen,  and  against  the  form  of 
the  statute  in  that  case  made  and  provided. 
Endorsed,  Billa  Vera. 

Witnesses,  Mercy  Lbkdu.^  JVathaniel  Ingersoll.^  mr.  Sum- 
nel  Parris^  Thomas  Putman.  junior,  Mary  Woicott.,  junior, 
Ann  Putman^  junior,  EHz.  Hubbard.,  and  Abigail  Williams. 

There  was  also  a  second  indictment,  on  the 
said  Bishop,  for  afflicting  and  practising  Avitch- 
craft  on  Jlbigail  WilUams,  Witnesses  to  the 
said  indictment  were,  the  said  Abigail  Williams, 
mr.  Parris,  Nathaniel  Ingersoll,  Thomas  Put- 
man,  Ann  Putman,  Mary  Wolcott,  Elizabeth 
Hubbard. 

The  third  indictment  was  for  afflicting  Mary 
Wolcott;  witnesses  to  which  said  indictment 
•were,  Mary  Wolcott,  Mary  Lewis,  mr,  Samuel 
Parris,   Nathaniel   Ingersoll,  Thomas  Putman, 


OF  FACT,  kc.  24S 

Ann  Putman,  Elizabctli  Hubbard,  Abigail  Wil- 
Hiams. 

The  fourth  indictment  was  for  afflicting  Eliza- 
beth Hubbard;  witnesses  to  which  said  indict- 
ment were,  the  said  EHzabcth  Hubbard,  Mercy 
Lewis,  mr.  Parris,  Nathaniel  Ingersoll,  Thomas 
Putman,  Ann  Putman,  Mary  Wolcott,  Abigail 
Williams. 

The  fifth  indictment  was  for  afflicting  ^nn 
Putman;  witnesses  to  which  said  indictment 
were  the  said  Ann  Putman,  mr.  Samuel  Parris, 
Nathaniel  IngersoU,  Thomas  Putman,  Mercy 
Lewis,  Mary  Wolcott,  Abigail  Williams,  Eliza- 
beth Hubbard. 

The  Trial  o/*  Bridget  Bishop,  as  printed  in  Won- 
ders of  the  Invisible  Worlds  June  2,  1692,yrom 
p.  104  top,  114. 

1.  She  was  indicted  for  bewitching  several 
persons  in  the  neighbourhood.  The  indictment 
being  drawn  up,  according  to  the  form  in  such 
cases  usual,  and  pleading  not  guilty,  there  were 
brought  in  several  persons,  who  had  long  under- 
gone many  kinds  of  miseries,  which  were  pre- 
ternaturally  inflicted,  and  generally  ascribed  un- 
to an  horrible  witchcraft.  There  was  little  oc- 
casion to  prove  the  witchcraft,  it  being  evident 
and  notorious  to  all  beholders.  Now  to  fix  the 
witchcraft  on  the  prisoner  at  the  bar,  the  first 
thing  used  was  the  testimony  of  the  bewitched; 
whereof  several  testified,  that  the  shape  of  the 
prisoner  did  oftentimes  very  grievously  pinch 
them,  choke  them,  bite  them,  and  afflict  them; 
urging  them  to  write  their  names  in  a  book, 


244  MATTERS 

which  the  said  spectre  called  ours.  One  of 
them  did  further  testily,  that  it  was  the  shape 
of  this  prisoner,  with  another,  which  one  day- 
took  her  from  her  wfieel,  and,  carrying  her  to 
the  river  side,  threatened  there  to  drown  her, 
if  she  did  not  sign  the  book  mentioned ;  which 
yet  she  refused.  Others  of  them  did  also  testify, 
that  the  said  shape  did,  in  her  threats,  brag  to 
them,  that  she  had  been  the  death  of  sundry 
persons,  then  by  her  named.  Another  testified, 
the  apparition  of  ghosts  unto  the  spectre  of 
Bishop,  crying  out,  You  murdered  us.  About 
the  truth  whereof,  there  was  in  the  matter  of 
fact  but  too  much  suspicion. 

2.  It  was  testified,  that  at  the  examination  of 
the  prisoner,  before  the  magistrates,  the  be- 
witched were  extremely  tortured.  If  she  did 
but  cast  her  eyes  on  them,  they  were  presently 
struck  down  ;  and  this  in  such  a  manner  as  there 
could  be  no  collusion  in  the  business.  But  upon 
the  touch  of  her  hand  upon  them,  when  they  lay 
in  their  swoons,  they  would  immediately  revive; 
and  not  upon  the  touch  of  any  one's  else.  More- 
over, upon  some  special  actions  of  her  body,  as 
the  shaking  of  her  head,  or  the  turning  of  her 
eyes,  they  presently  and  painfully  fell  into  the 
like  postures.  And  many  of  the  like  accidents 
now  fell  out,  while  she  was  at  the  bar ;  one  at 
the  same  time  testifying,  that  she  said,  she 
could  not  be  troubled  to  see  the  afflicted  thus 
tormented. 

3.  There  was  testimony  likewise  brought  in, 
that  a  man  striking  once  at  the  place  where  a 
feewitched  person  said  the  shape  of  this  Bishop 


OF  FACT,  kc.  245 

stood,  the  bewitched  cried  out  that  he  had  torn 
her  coat,  in  the  place  then  particularly  specifi- 
ed; and  the  woman's  coat  was  found  to  be  torn 
in  the  very  place. 

4.  One  Deliverance  Hobbs,  who  had  confess- 
ed her  being  a  witch,  was  now  tormented  by  the 
spectres  for  her  confession.  And  she  now  testi- 
tied,  that  this  Bishop  tempted  her  to  sigri  the 
book  again,  and  to  deny  what  she  had  confessed. 
She  allirmed,  that  it  was  the  shape  of  this  priso- 
ner whicli  whipped  her  with  Iron  rods,  to  com- 
pel her  thereunto.  And  she  affirmed,  that  this 
bishop  was  at  a  general  meeting  of  the  witches 
in  a  field,  at  Salem  Village,  and  there  partook 
of  a  diabolical  sacrament,  In  bread  and  wine,  then 
administered. 

5.  To  render  It  further  unquestionable,  that 
the  prisoner  at  the  bar  was  the  person  truly 
charged  in  this  witchcraft,  there  were  produced 
many  evidences  of  other  witchcrafts,  by  her 
perpetrated.  For  instance,  John  Cook  testified, 
that  about  five  or  six  years  ago,  one  morning 
about  sunrise,  he  was,  in  his  chamber,  assaulted 
by  the  shape  of  this  prisoner;  which  looked  on 
him,  grinned  at  him,  and  very  much  hurt  him 
with  a  blow  on  the  side  of  the  head  ;  and  that 
on  the  same  day,  about  noon,  the  same  shape 
walked  in  the  room  where  he  was,  and  an  ap- 
ple strangely  flew  out  of  his  hand  into  the  lap 
of  his  mother,  six  or  eight  feet  from  him. 

6.  Samuel  Gray  testified,  that  about  fourteen 
years  ago,  he  waked  on  anight,  and  saw  the 
room  where  he  lay  hill  of  light ;  and  that  he 
then  saw  plainly  a  woman  between  the  cradle 

21* 


X 


,246  MATTERS 

and  the  bedside,  which  looked  upon  him.  He 
rose,  and  it  vanished,  though  he  found  the  doors 
all  fast.  Looking  out  at  the  entry  door,  he  saw 
the  same  woman  in  the  same  garb  again;  and 
said,  In  Gocfs  name^  ichat  do  you  come  for  ?  He 
went  to  bed,  and  had  the  same  woman  again 
assaulting  him.  The  child  in  the  cradle  gave  a 
great  screech,  and  the  woman  disappeared.  It 
was  long  before  the  child  could  be  quieted  ;  and 
though  it  were  a  very  likely,  thriving  child,  yet 
from  this  time  it  pined  away,  and  after  divers 
months  died  in  a  sad  condition.  He  knew  not 
Bishop,  nor  her  name  ;  but  vfhen  he  saw  her  af- 
ter this,  he  knew  by  her  countenance,  and  ap- 
parel, and  all  circumstances,  that  it  was  the 
apparition  of  this  Bishop,  which  had  thus  trou- 
bled him. 

7.  John  Bly  and  his  wife  testified,  that  he 
bought  a  sow  of  Edward  Bishop,  the  husband 
of  the  prisoner,  and  was  to  pay  the  price  agreed 
unto  another  person.  This  prisoner,  being 
angry  that  she  was  thus  hindered  from  fingering 
the  money,  quarrelled  with  Bly;  soon  after 
which  the  sow  was  taken  with  strange  fits, 
jumping,  leaping,  and  knocking  her  head  against 
the  fence ;  she  seemed  blind  and  deaf,  and 
would  neither  eat  nor  be  sucked.  Whereupon 
a  neighbour  said,  she  believed  the  creature  was 
overlooked  ;  and  sundry  other  circumstances 
concurred,  which  made  the  deponents  believe 
tiic.t  Bishop  had  bewitched  it. 

8.  Richard  Coman  testified,  that  eight  years 
ago,  as  he  lay  awake  in  his  bed,  with  a  light  burn- 
ing in  the  room,  he  was  annoyed  with  the  appari^ 


OF  FACT,  &c.  247 

tlon  of  this  Bishop,  and  of  two  more  that  were 
strangers  to  him,  who  came  and  oppressed  him, 
so  that  he  could  neither  stir  himself,  nor  wake 
any  one  else;  and  that  he  was  the  night  after 
molested  again  in  the  like  manner,  the  said  Bi- 
shop taking  him  by  the  tliroat,  and  pulling  him 
almost  out  of  the  bed.  His  kinsman  offered  for 
this  cause  to  lodge  with  him  ;  and  that  night,  as 
they  were  awake,  discoursing  together,  this  Co- 
man  was  once  more  visited  by  the  guests  which 
had  formerly  been  so  troublesome,  his  kinsman 
being  at  the  same  time  struck  speechless,  and 
unable  to  move  hand  or  foot.  He  had  laid  his 
''sword  by  him;  which  those  unhappy  spectres 
did  strive  much  to  wrest  from  him,  but  he  held 
too  fast  for  them.  He  then  grew  able  to  call 
the  people  of  his  house ;  but  although  they 
heard  him,  yet  they  had  not  power  to  speak  or 
stir,  until  at  last  one  of  tlie  people  crying  out, 
What's  the  matter?  the  spectres  all  vanished. 

9.  Samuel  Shattock  testified,  that  in  the  year 
16B0,  this  Bridget  Bishop  often  came  to  his 
house  upon  such  frivolous  and  foolish  errands, 
that  they  suspected  she  came  indeed  with  a 
purpose  of  mischief ;  presently  w^hereupon,  his 
eldest  child,  which  was  of  as  promising  health 
and  sense  as  any  child  of  its  age,  began  to  droop 
exceedingly ;  and  the  oftener  that  Bishop  came 
to  his  house,  the  worse  grew  the  child.  As 
the  child  would  be  standing  at  the  door,  he 
would  be  thrown  and  bruised  against  the  stones, 
by  an  invisible  hand,  and  in  like  sort  knock  his 
face  against  the  sides  of  the  house,  and  bruise  it 
after  a  miserable  manner.     Afterwards  this  Bi- 


248  MATTERS 

shop  would  bring  him  things  to  dye,  whereof  he 
could  not  imagine  any  use  ;  and  when  she  paid 
him  a  piece  ol'  money,  the  purse  and  money 
were  unaccountably  conveyed  out  of  a  locked 
box,  and  never  seen  more.  The  child  was  im- 
mediately hereupon  taken  with  terrible  fits, 
whereof  his  friends  thought  he  would  have  di- 
ed ;  indeed  he  did  nothing  but  cry  and  sleep, 
for  several  months  together;  and  at  length  his 
understanding  was  utterly  taken  away.  Among 
otiier  symptoms  of  an  enchantment  upon  him, 
one  was,  that  there  was  a  board  in  the  garden, 
whereon  he  would  walk;  and  all  the  invitations 
in  the  world  would  never  fetch  him  off.  About 
seventeen  or  eighteen  years  after,  there  came  a 
stranger  to  Shattock's  house,  who,  seeing  the 
child,  said,  This  poor  child  is  bewitched;  and 
yon  have  a  neighbour  living  not  far  off  who  is  a 
ivitch.  He  added,  Yonr  neighbour  has  had  a 
falling  out  with  your  wife ;  and  she  said  in  her 
heart,  your  wife  is  a  proud  woman^  and  she  woidd 
bring  down  her  pride  in  this  child.  He  then  re- 
membered that  Bishop  had  parted  from  his 
wife  in  muttering  and  menacing  terms,  a  little 
before  the  child  was  taken  ill.  The  abovesaid 
stranger  would  needs  carry  the  bewitched  boy 
with  him  to  Bishop's  house,  on  pretence  of 
buying  a  pot  of  cider.  The  woman  entertained 
him  in  a  furious  manner;  and  flew  also  upon 
the  boy,  scratching  his  face  till  the  blood  came, 
and  saying,  Thou  rogue,  what  !  dost  thou  bring 
this  fellow  here  to  plague  me  ?  Now  it  seemi  the 
man  had  said,  before  he  went,  that  he  would 
fetch   blood  of  her.     Ever  after  the  boy   was 


OF  FACT,  H.  24d 

foUovverl  by  grievo.is  fit!=»,  which  the  doctors 
theinseives  i^enerally  .iscribed  unto  witCLvil't ; 
and  wherein  fie  would  be  thrown  still  int.»  fire 
or  water,  if  he  were  not  constantly  looked  dlfer; 
and  it  was  verily  believed  that  Bishop  was  the 
cause  of  it. 

10.  John  Louder  testified,  that  upon  some 
little  controversy  with  B  sh  ip  about  her  fowls, 
going  well  to  bed,  he  awaked  in  the  night  by- 
moonlight,  and  clearly  saw  the  likeness  of  this 
woman  grievously  oppressing  him ;  in  which 
miserable  condition  siie  held  him,  unable  to  help 
himself,  till  near  day.  He  told  Bishop  of  this, 
but  she  utterly  denied  it,  and  tiireatened  him 
very  much.  Quickly  after  this,  being  at  home 
on  a  Lord's  day,  witli  the  doors  shut  about  him, 
he  saw  a  black  pig  approach  him  ;  at  which  he 
going  to  kick,  it  vanished  away.  Immediately 
after,  sitting  down,  he  saw  a  black  thing  jump 
in  at  the  window,  and  come  and  stand  before 
him :  the  body  was  like  that  of  a  monkey,  the 
feet  like  a  cock's,  but  the  face  much  like  a 
man's.  He  being  so  extremely  frighted  that 
he  could  not  speak,  this  monster  spok6  to  him, 
and  said,  /  am  a  messenger  sent  unto  you,  for  1 
understand  that  you  are  in  some  trouble  of  mindj 
and  if  you  will  be  ruled  by  me,  you  shall  want  for 
nothing  in  this  world.  Whereupon  he  endea- 
voured to  clap  his  hands  upon  it ;  but  he  could 
feel  no  substance,  and  it  jumped  out  of  the  win- 
dow again  ;  but  immediately  came  in  by  the 
porch,  though  the  doors  were  shut,  and  said, 
You  had  better  take  my  counsel  He  then  struck 
at  it  with  a  stick,  but  struck  only  the   ground- 


250  MATTERS 

sel,  and  broke  the  stick.  The  arm  with  which 
he  struck  was  presently  disenabled,  and  it  van- 
ished away.  He  presently  went  out  at  the  back 
door,  and  spied  this  Bishop,  in  her  orchard,  go- 
ing towards  her  house ;  but  he  had  not  power 
to  set  one  foot  forward  unto  her.  Whereupon, 
returning  into  the  house,  he  was  immediately 
accosted  by  the  monster  he  had  seen  before ; 
which  goblin  was  now  §^^^K  ^^  %  ^^  ^^^ ' 
w^iereat  he  cried  out,  The  whole  armour  of  God 
he  between  me  and  you  !  so  it  sprang  back,  and 
flew  over  the  apple-tree,  shaking  many  apples 
off  the  tree  in  its  flying  over.  At  its  leap,  it 
flung  dirt  with  its  feet  against  the  stomach  of 
the  man;  whereon  he  was  then  struck  dumb, 
and  so  continued  for  three  days  together.  Uf> 
on  the  producing  of  this  tetimony,  Bishop  denied 
that  she  knew  this  deponent.  Yet  their  two 
orchards  joined,  and  they  had  often  had  their 
little  quarrels  for  some  years  together. 

11.  William  Stacy  testified,  that  receiving 
money  of  this  Bishop  for  work  done  by  him,  he 
was  gone  but  about  three  rods  from  her,  and, 
looking  lor  his  money,  found  it  unaccountably 
gone  from  him.  Some  time  after,  Bishop  asked 
him  whether  his  father  would  grind  her  grist 
for  her.  He  demanded  why.  She  replied,  Be- 
cause folks  count  me  a  witch.  He  answered, 
No  question  but  he  will  grind  it  for  you.  Being 
then  gone  about  six  rods  from  her,  with  a  small 
load  in  his  cart,  suddenly  the  oti'  wheel  slumpt, 
and  sunk  down  into  an  hole,  upon  plain  ground, 
so  that  the  deponent  was  forced  to  get  help  for 
the  recovering  of  the  wheel.  But  stepping  back 


OF  FACT,  &c.  251 

to  look  for  the  hole  which  might  give  him  this 
disaster,  there  was  none  at  ail  to  be  found. 
Some  time  after  he  was  awakened  in  the  night; 
but  it  seemed  as  hght  as  day  ;  and  he  perfectly 
saw  the  shape  of  this  Bisliop  in  the  room,  trou- 
bling him  ;  but  upon  her  going  out,  all  was  dark 
again.  He  charged  Bishop  afterwards  with 
it,  and  she  denied  it  not,  but  was  very  angry. 
Quickly  after,  this  deponent  having  been  threat- 
ened by  Bishop,  as  he  was  in  a  dark  night  going 
to  the  barn,  he  was  very  suddenly  taken  or  lilt- 
ed up  from  the  ground,  and  thrown  against  a 
stone  wall;  alter  that  he  was  again  hoisfed  up, 
and  thrown  down  a  bank,  at  the  end  of  his  house. 
After  this,  again  passing  by  this  Bishop,  his  horse, 
Avith  a  small  load,  striving  to  draw,  ail  his  gears 
flew  to  pieces,  and  the  cart  fell  down;  and  this 
deponent  going  then  to  lift  a  bag  of  corn,  of 
about  two  bushels,  could  not  lift  it  with  all  his 
might. 

Many  other  pranks  of  this  Bishop,  this  depo- 
nent Was  ready  to  testify.  He  also  testified, 
that  he  verily  believed  tlie  said  Bishop  was  the 
instrument  of  his  daughter  Priscilla's  death;  of 
Avhich  suspicion,  p^^egnant  reasons  were  assigned. 
i2.  To  crown  all,  John  Bly  and  William  Bly 
testified,  that,  being  employed  by  Bridget 
Bishop  to  help  take  down  the  cellar-wall  of  the 
old  house,  wherein  she  formerly  lived,  they  did 
in  holes  of  the  said  old  wall  find  several  poppets 
made  up  of  rags  and  hogs'  bristles,  with  head- 
less pins  in  them,  the  points  being  outward: 
whereof  she  could  now  give  no  account  unto 
the  court,  that  was  reasonable  or  tolerable. 


252  MATTERS 

13.  One  thing  that  made  against  the  prisoner 
was,  her  beaig  evidcntlj  convicted  of  gross  Ijing 
in  the  court,  several  times,  while  she  vi^as  mak- 
ing her  plea.  But  besides  this,  a  jur}  of  wo- 
men found  a  preternatural  teat  upon  her  body; 
but  upon  a  second  search,  within  three  tyrkmr 
hours,  there  was  no  such  thing  to  be  seen.  There 
was  also  an  account  of  other  people,  whom  this 
woman  had  afflicted;  and  there  might  have 
been  many  more,  if  they  had  been  inquired  ibr; 
but  there  was  no  need  of  them. 

14.  There  was  one  very  strange  thing  more, 
with  which  the  court  was  newly  entertained. 
As  this-  woman  was,  under  a  guard,  passing  by 
the  great  and  spacious  meeting  house  of  Salem, 
she  gave  a  look  towards  the  house;  and  imme- 
diately a  daemon,  invisibly  entering  the  meeting- 
house, tore  down  a  part  of  it;  so  that  thcuo^h 
there  were  no  person  to  be  seen  there,  yet  the 
people,  at  the  noise  running  in,  found  a  boeid, 
which  was  strongly  fastened  with  several  nails, 
transported  uuto  another  quarter  of  the  house. 

The  Indictment  of  Susanna  JMartin, 

Essex  ss.  Anno  Regni  Rcg->s  S,-  Reg^nce  JVilliehni  8f  Marios,  nunc 

Angtlice^  Sfc.  quarto. — 

The  jurors  for  our  snverf  ^gn  lord  and  lady  the  king  and 
queen  present,  that  Susanna  Martin,  of  Amesbury,  in  the 
connty  of  Essex,  widow,  the  second  day  of  May,  in  the 
fonrth  year  of  the  reign  of  our  sovereign  lord  and  lady 
William  and  Mary,  by  the  grace  of  God,  of  England.  Scot- 
land, Franco  and  Ireland,  king  and  queen,  defenders  oithe 
faith,  &LC.  and  divers  other  days  and  times,  as  well  before 
as  after,  certain  detestable  arts,  called  witchcrafts  and  sor- 
ceries, wickedly  and  felcniousiy  hath  used,  practised  and 
exercised,  at  and  wathin  the  township  of  Salem,  in  the 
county  of  Essex,  aforesaid,  in,  upon  and  against  one  Mary 


OF  FACT,  &c.  25S 

Wolcott,  of  Salem  Village,  in  (he  county  of  Es'^ftx,  single 
woman  ;  by  which  said  wicked  arts  the  said  Mary  Wolcott, 
the  second  day  of  May,  in  the  fourth  year  aforesaid,  and 
at  divers  other  days  and  times,  as  well  l)efore  as  after, 
was  and  is  tortured,  atflicted,  pined,  consumed,  wasted  and 
tormented  ;  as  also  tor  sundry  other  acts  of  witchcraft  by 
sad  Susanna  Martin  committed  and  done  before  and  since 
that  time,  against  the  peace  of  our  sovereign  lord  and 
lady,  William  and  Mary,  king  and' queen  of  Kngland,  their 
crown  and  dignity,  and  against  the  form  of  the  statute,  in 
that  case  made  and  provided. 

lie  turned  by  the  grand  jury,  Billa  vera. 
Witnesses — Sarah  Vibber^  Mary  Wolcoti^  Samuel  Parrisj 
Elizabeth  Hubbard  and  Mercy  Lewis. 

The  second  indictment  was  for  afflicting  Mer- 
cy Lewis.  Witnesses — Samuel  Parris,  Ann  Put- 
man,  Sarah  Vibber,  Elizabeth  Hubbard,  Mary 
Wolcott  and  Mercy  Lewis. 

The  Trial  of  SusAH^x  Martin,  June  29,  1692/ 

as  is  printed  in  Wonders  of  the  Invisible  World, 

from  p.  1^4  to  p.  1 16. 

*  1.  Susanna  Martin  pleading  not  guilty  to  the 
indictment  of  witchcraft  brought  in  against  her, 
there  were  produced  the  evidences  of  many 
persons  very  sensibly  and  grievt^usly  bewitched, 
who  all  complained  of  the  prisoner  at  the  bar, 
as  the  person  Avhom  they  believed  the  cause  of 
their  miseries.  And  now,  as  well  as  in  the  other 
trials,  there  was  an  extraordinary  endeavour  by 
witchcrafts,  with  cruel  and  frequent  fits,  to  hin- 
der the  poor  sufferers  from  giving  in  their  com- 
plaints ;  which  the  court  was  forced  with  much 
patience  to  obtain,  by  much  waiting  and  watch- 
ing for  it. 

There  was  now  also  an  account  given  of  what 
had  passed  at  her  first  examination  before  the 
22 


254  MATTERS 

magistrates ;  the  cast  of  her  eye  then  striking 
the  afflicted  people  to  the  ground,  whether  they 
saw  that  cast  or  no.  There  were  these  among 
other  passages  between  the  magistrates  and  the 
examinant : 

Magistrate,  Pray,  what  ails  these  people  ? 
Martin.  I  don't  know. 
Mag.  But,  what  do  you  think  ails  them  ? 
Martin.  I  do  not  desire  to  spend  my  judgment 
upon  it. 

Maxr,  Don't  you  think  they  are  bewitched? 
Martin.  No,  I  do  not  think  they  are. 
Mag.  Tell  us  your    thoughts    about    them, 
then. 

Martin.  No,  my  thoughts  are  my  own  when 
they  are  in,  but  when  they  are  out  they   are 

another's.     Their  master 

Mag.  Their  master!     Who  do  you  think  is 
their  master  ? 

Martin.  If  they  be  dealing  in  the  black  art, 
you  may  know-  as  well  as  I. 

Mag.  Well,  what  have  you  done  towards 
this  } 

Martin.  Nothing  at  all. 
Mag.  Why,  'tis  you  or  your  appearance. 
Martin.  I  can't  help  it. 

Mag.  Is  it  not  your  master  ?  How  comes 
your  appearance  to  hurt  these  ? 

Martin.  How  do  I  know  ?  He  that  appeared 
in  the  shape  of  Samuel,  a  glorified  saint,  may  ap- 
pear in  any  one's  shape. 

It  was  then  also  noted  in  her,  as  in  others 
like  her,  that  if  the  afflicted  wont  to  approach 
her,  they  were  flung  down  to  the  ground ;  and 


OF  FACT,  &c.  25& 

Nvheh  she  was  asked  the  reason  of  it,  she  said,  I 
cannot  tell;  it  may  be  the  devil  bears  me  more 
malice  than  another. 

The  court  accounted  tlicniselvcs  alarmed  by 
these  things  to  inquire  further  into  the  conversa- 
tion of  the  prisoner,  and  see  what  there  might 
occur  to  render  these  accusations  further  cred- 
ible. Whereupon  John  Allen,  of  Salisbury, 
testified,  tiiat  he  refusing,  because  of  the  weak- 
ness of  his  oxen,  to  cart  some  staves  at  the  request 
of  this  Martin,  she  was  displeased  at  it,  and  said, 
it  had  been  as  good  that  he  had,  for  his  oxen 
should  never  do  him  much  more  service.  Where- 
upon this  deponent  said,  Dost  thou  threaten  me, 
fhoxx  old  witch ?  I'll  throw  thee  into  the  brook; 
which  to  avoid,  she  flew  over  the  bridge,  and 
escaped.  13ut  as  he  was  going  home,  one  of  his 
oxen  tired,  so  that  he  was  forced  to  unyoke  him 
that  he  might  get  him  home.  He  then  put  his 
oxen,  with  many  more,  upon  Salisbury-beach, 
^vhere  cattle  used  to  get  flesh.  In  a  few  days, 
all  the  oxen  upor)  the  beach  were  found  by 
their  tracks  to  have  run  unto  the  mouth  of 
Merrimack-river,  and  not  returned  ;  but  the  next 
day  they  were  found  come  ashore  upon  Plum- 
island.  They  that  sought  them  used  all  imagina- 
ble gentleness;  but  they  would  still  run  away 
with  a  violence  that  seemed  wholly  diabolical, 
till  they  came  near  the  mouth  of  Merrimack 
river,  when  they  ran  right  into  the  sea,  swim- 
ming as  far  as  they  could  be  seen.  One  of  them 
then  swam  back  again,  with  a  switfness  amazing 
to  the  beholders,  who  stood  ready  to  receive 
him,  and  help  up  his  tired  carcass ;  but  the  beast 


^56  MATTERS 

ran  furiously  up  into  the  island,  and  from  thence 
through  the  marshes,  up  into  Nevvbury-town,  and 
30  up  into  the  woods ;  and  after  a  while  was 
found  near  Amesbury.  So  that,  of  fourteen 
good  oxen,  there  was  only  this  saved :  the  rest 
were  all  cast  up,  some  in  one  place,  and  some  in 
another,  drowned. 

4.  John  Atkinson  testified,  that  he  exchanged 
a  cow  with  a  son  of  Susanna  Martin,  whereat 
she  muttered,  and  was  unwilling  he  should  have 
it.  Going  to  receive  this  cow,  though  he  ham- 
stringed her,  and  haltered  her,  she  of  a  tame 
creature  grew  so  mad,  that  they  could  scarce 
get  her  along.  She  broke  all  the  ropes  that 
TYere  fastened  unto  her;  and  though  she  was 
tied  fast  unto  a  tree,  yet  she  made  her  escape, 
and  ofave  them  such  further  trouble,  as  they 
could  ascribe  to  no  cause  but  witchcraft. 

5.  Bernard  Peache  testified,  that,  being  in  bed, 
on  a  Lord's-day  night,  he  heard  a  scrabbling  at 
the  window,  whereat  he  then  saw  Susanna  Mar- 
tin come  in,  and  jump  down  upon  the  floor.  She 
took  hold  of  this  deponent's  feet,  and,  drawing 
his  body  up  into  an  heap,  she  lay  upon  him  near 
two  hours;  in  all  which  time  he  could  neither 
speak  nor  stir.  At  length,  when  he  could  begin 
to  move,  he  laid  hold  on  her  hand,  and  pulling 
it  up  to  his  mouth,  he  bit  three  of  hcv  fingers, 
as  he  judged,  to  the  bone ;  whereupon  she  went 
from  the  chamber  down  the  stairs,  out  at  the 
door.  This  deponent  thereupon  called  unto  the 
people  of  the  house  to  advise  them  of  what  pas- 
sed; and  he  himself  followed  her.  The  peo- 
ple saw   her  not;  but  there  being  a  bucket  at 


OF  FACT,  kc.  2^7 

the  lei't  hand  of  the  door,  there  was  a  drop  ol 
blood  on  it,  and  several  more  drops  of  blood  up- 
on the  snow,  newly  fallen  abroad.  There  was 
hkewise  the  print  of  her  two  feet,  just  without 
the  thrcsliold;  but  no  more  sign  of  any  footing 
further  off. 

At  another  time  this  deponent  was  desired  by 
the  prisoner  to  come  to  husking  of  corn,  at  her 
house ;  and  she  said,  If  he  did  not  cotne,  it  were 
better  that  he  did.  He  went  not ;  but  the  night 
following,  Susanna  Martin,  as  he  judged,  and 
another,  came  towards  him.  One  of  them  said, 
Here  he  is  ;  but  he,  having  a  quarterstaff,  made 
a  blow  at  them :  the  roof  of  the  barn  broke  his 
blow;  but,  following  them  to  the  window,  he 
made  another  blow  at  them,  and  struck  them 
down;  yet  they  got  up,  and  got  out,  and  he  saw 
no  more  of  them. 

About  this  time,  there  was  a  rumour  about 
the  town,  that  Martin  had  a  broken  head ;  but 
the  deponent  could  say  nothing  to  that. 

The  said  Peache  also  testified,  the  bewitch- 
ing of  cattle  to  death,  upon  Martin's  discontents. 

6.  Robert  Downer  testified,  that  this  prisoner 
being  some  years  ago  prosecuted  at  court  for  a 
witch,  he  then  said  unto  her,  he  believed  she  was 
a  witch.  Whereat  she  being  dissatisfied,  said, 
that  some  she-devil  would  shortly  fetch  him  away  ; 
which  words  were  heard  by  others,  as  well  as 
himself.  The  night  following,  as  he  lay  in  his 
bed,  there  came  in  at  the  window,  the  likeness 
of  a  cat,  which  fiew  upon  him,  and  took  fast 
hold  of  his  throat,  lay  on  him  a  considerable 
while,  and  almost  killed  him;  at  length  he  re- 
22* 


255  MATTERS 

membered  what  Susanna  Martin  had  threatened 
the  day  before,  and  with  much  striving  he  cried 
out,  Avoids  thou  she-devil ;  in  the  name  of  God 
the  Father,  the  Son,  and  the  Holy  Ghost,  avoid : 
whereupon  it  leit  him,  leaped  on  the  floor,  and 
flew  out  at  the  window. 

And  there  also  came  in  several  testimonies, 
that,  be  lore  ever  Downer  spoke  a  word  of  this 
accident,  Susanna  Martin  and  her  family  had  re- 
lated how  this  Downer  had  been  iiandled. 

7.  John  Kembal  testified,  that  Susanna  Mar- 
tin, upon  a  causeless  disgust,  had  threatened 
him  about  a  certain  cow  of  his,  that  she  should 
never  do  him  any  more  good,  and  it  came  to 
pass  accordingly  ;  for  soon  after  the  cow  was 
found  stark  dead  on  the  dry  ground,  without 
any  distemper  to  be  discerned  upon  her ;  upon 
which  he  was  followed  with  a  strange  death 
upon  more  of  his  cattle  ;  w-hereol  he  lost,  in  one 
spring,  to  the  value  of  30/.  But  the  said  John 
Kembal  had  a  further  testimony  to  give  in  against 
the  prisoner,  which  was  truly  admirable.  Be- 
ing desirous  to  furnish  himself  with  a  dog,  he 
applied  himself  to  buy  one  cf  this  Martin,  who 
had  a  bitch  with  whelps  in  her  house  ;  but  she 
not  letting  him  have  his  choice,  he  said  he 
would  supply  himself  then  at  one  Biezdel's. 
Havino;  marked  a  puppy  which  he  liked  at 
Biezdel's,  he  met  George  Martin,  the  husband 
of  the  prisoner,  going  by,  who  asked  whether 
he  would  not  have  one  of  his  wife's  puppies; 
and  he  answered,  no.  The  same  day  one  Ed- 
mund Eliot,  being  at  Martin's  house,  heard 
(jeorge  Martin  relate  where  this  Kembal  had 


OK  FACT,  4-c.  259 

been,  and  what  he  had  said;  whereupon  Susan- 
na M  irtin  rephcd,  If  I  live  P II  give  him  puppies 
enough.  Within  a  lew  days  alter  this,  Kembal 
coming  out  ol'tlie  woods,  there  arose  a  httle  black 
eloud  in  the  N.  W.  and  Kcmbal  immediately 
felt  a  force  upon  him,  which  made  him  not  able 
to  avoid  running  upon  the  stumps  of  trees  that 
were  before  him,  although  he  had  a  broad, 
plain  cart-w'ay  before  him  ;  but  though  he  had 
his  axe  on  his  shoulder  to  endanger  him  in  his 
falls,  he  could  not  forbear  going  out  of  his  way 
to  tumble  over  them.  When  he  came  below 
the  meeting-house,  there  appeared  to  him  a 
little  thing  like  a  puppy,  of  a  darkish  colour, 
and  it  shot  backwards  and  forwards  between  his 
legs.  He  had  the  courage  to  use  all  possible 
endeavours  to  cut  it  with  his  axe,  but  he  could 
not  hit  it;  the  puppy  gave  a  jump  from  him, 
and  went,  as  to  him  it  seemed,  into  the  ground. 
Going  a  litUe  further,  there  appeared  unto  him 
a  black  puppy,  somewhat  bigger  than  the  first, 
but  as  black  as  a  coal.  Its  motions  were  quick- 
er than  those  of  his  axe.  It  flew  at  his  belly, 
and  at  his  throat,  so  over  his  shoulders  one 
way,  and  then  over  his  shoulders  another  way. 
His  heart  now  began  to  fail  him,  and  he  thought 
the  dog  would  have  tore  his  throat  out ;  but 
he  recovered  himself,  and  called  upon  God  in 
his  distress,  and  naming  the  name  ol'  .Tesus 
Christ,  it  vanished  away  at  once.  The  depo- 
nent spoke  not  one  word  of  tliese  accidents,  for 
fear  of  ailrighting  his  wife.  But  the  next  morn- 
ing, Edmund  Eliot  going  into  Martin's  house, 
this   woman   asked  hioi    where  Kembal    was. 


S60  .     MATTERS 

He  replied,  At  home,  a-bed,  for  ought  he  knew. 
She  returned,  They  say  he  was  frighted  last 
night.  Ehot  asked,  With  what?  She  answered, 
With  puppies.  Ehot  asked  where  she  heard 
of  it,  for  he  had  heard  nothing  of  it.  She  re- 
joined. About  the  town  ;  although  Kembal  had 
mentioned  the  matter  to  no  creature  living. 

8.  Wilham  Brown  testified,  that  Heaven 
having  blessed  him  with  a  most  pious  and  pru- 
dent wife,  this  wife  of  his  one  day  met  with 
Susanna  Martin  ;  but  when  she  approached  just 
unto  her,  Maitin  vanished  out  of  sight,  and  left 
her  extremely  atfrighted.  After  which  time 
the  said  Martin  often  appeared  unto  her,  giving 
her  no  htttle  trouble  ;  and  when  she  did  come, 
she  was  visited  with  birds,  that  sorely  pecked 
and  pricked  her  ;  and  sometimes  a  bunch  like  a 
pullet's  egg  would  rise  on  her  throat,  ready  to 
choke  her,  till  she  cried  out,  Witch^  you  shari^t 
choke  me  I  While  this  good  woman  was  in  this 
extremity,  the  church  appointed  a  day  of  prayer 
on  her  behalf;  whereupon  the  trouble  ceased; 
she  sav^^  not  Martin  as  formerly  ;  and  the  church, 
instead  of  their  fast,  gave  thanks  for  her  deliv- 
erance. But  a  considerable  while  after,  she 
being  summoned  to  give  in  some  evidence  at  the 
court  against  this  Martin,  quicklv  tliis  Martin 
came  behind  her,  while  she  was  milking  her 
cow,  and  said  unto  her.  For  thy  dcjaniing  me  at 
courts  ni  make  thee  the  miserablest  creature  in  the 
ivor/d.  Soon  after  which,  she  lell  into  a  strange 
kind  of  distemper,  and  became  horribly  frantic, 
and  uneatable  of  anv  reasonable,  action ;  the 
physicians  declaring   tnat   her   distemper    was 


Oh  FACT,  kc.  26 i 

preternatural,  and  that  some  devil  had  certainly 
bewitciied  iier  ;  and  in  that  condition  slie  now 
remained. 

9.    Sarah    Atkinson    testified,    that    Susanna 
Martin  came  from  Amesbiny,  to  their  house  at 
Newbury,  in  an  extraordinary  season,  when  it 
was  not  fit  for  any  one  to  travel.    She  came  (as 
she  said  to  Atkinson)  all  that  long  way  on  ioot. 
She  bragged  and  showed  how  dry  she  was  ;  nor 
could  it  be  perceived  that  so  much  as  the  soles 
of  her  shoes  were  w^et.     Atkinson  was  amazed 
at  it,  and  professed  that  she  should  herself  have 
been  wet  up  to  the  knees,  ii'she  had  then  come  so 
far;  but  Martin  replied,  she  scorned  to  be  drab- 
bled.     It  \va3  nofr^d  that  this    testimony,  upon 
her  trial,  cast  her  into  a  very  singular  confusion. 
10.  John  Pressy  testified,  that  being  one  even- 
ing very  unaccountably  bewildered  near  a  field 
of  Martin,  and  several   times  as  one  under  an 
enchantment,  returning  to  the  place  he  had  left, 
at  length  he  saw  a  marvellous  light,  about  the 
bigness  of  an  half  bushel,  near  two  rods  out  of 
the  way.    He  went  and  struck  at  it  with  a  stick, 
and  laid  it  on  with  all   his  might.      He  gave   it 
near  forty  blows,  and  felt  it  a  palpable  substance. 
But,  going  from  it,  his  heels    were    struck  up, 
and   he  was  laid   with  his   back  on  the  ground  ; 
sliding,  as  he  thought,  into  a  pit ;  from  wiience 
he   recovered,  by    taking  hold  on  a  bush ;     al- 
though afterwards  he  could  find  no  such  pit  in 
the  place.     Having  after  his  recovery  gone  five 
or  six  rods,  he  saw  Susanna  Martin  standing  on 
his  left  hand,  as  the  light  had  done  before  ;   but 
they  changed  no  words  with  one  another.     He 


262     *  MATTERS 

could  scarce  find  his  house  in  his  return  ;  but  at 
length  he  got  home,  extremely  affrighted.  The 
next  day  it  was  upon  inquiry  understood,  that 
Martin  was  in  a  miserable  condition,  by  pains 
and  hurts  that  were  upon  her. 

It  was  further  testified  by  this  deponent,  that 
after  he  hall  given  in  some  evidence  against  Su- 
sanna Martin  many  years  ago,  she  gave  him 
foul  words  about  it,  and  said,  he  should  never 
prosper ;  more  particularly^  that  he  should  never 
have  more  than  two  cows :  that  thou<rh  he  were 
ever  so  likely  to  have  more^  yft  he  should  never 
have  them ;  and  that,  from  that  yevy  day  to 
this,  namely  for  twenty  years  together,  he  could 
never  exceed  that  number,  bi^t  oom^  ctr-an^o 
thing  or  other  «t»ll  prevented  his  having  any 
more 

11.  Jarvis  Ring  testified,  that  about  seven 
years  ago  he  was  oftentimes  grievously  oppres- 
sed in  ihe  night,  but  saw  not  who  troubled  him, 
until  at  lengik  he,  lying  perfectly  awake,  plainly 
saw  Susanna  Martin  approach  him  :  she  came 
to  him,  and  forcibly  bit  him  by  the  finger ;  so 
that  the  print  of  the  bite  is  now,  so  long  after, 
to  be  seen  upon  him. 

12.  But,  besides  all  these  evidences,  there 
was  a  most  wonderful  account  of  one  Joseph 
Ring  produced  on  this  occasion.  This  man  has 
been  strangely  carried  about,  by  daemons,  from 
one  witch-meeting  to  another,  for  near  two 
years  together  ;  and  for  one  quarter  of  this  time 
they  made  him  and  kept  him  dumb,  though  he 
is  now  again  able  to  speak.  There  was  one 
T.  H.  whoj  having,    as  'tis  judged,  a  design  of 


OF  FACT,  &c.  263 

engaging  this  Joseph  Ring  in  a  snare  of  devil- 
isDi,  contrived  a  wile  to  bring  this  Rin^  two 
shilhngs  in  debt  unto  Kim.  Alter  wards  this 
poor  man  would  be  visited  with  unknown  sha[)es, 
and  this  T.  H.  sometimes  among  them  :  which 
would  force  him  away  with  them,  unto  unknown 
places,  where  he  saw  meetings,  feasting,  dan- 
cings;  and  alter  his  return,  wherein  they  hur- 
ried iiim  along  through  the  air,  he  gave  demon- 
strations to  the  neighbours,  that  he  had  been 
so  transported.  When  he  was  brought  unto 
these  hellish  meetings,  one  of  the  first  thmgs 
they  still  did  unto  him  was,  to  give  him  a  knock 
on  the  back,  whereupon  he  was  ever,  as  if  bound 
with  chains,  uncapable  of  stirring  out  of  the 
place,  till  they  should  release  him.  He  related, 
that  there  often  came  to  him  a  man,  who  pre- 
sented him  a  book,  whereto  he  would  have  him 
set  his  hand ;  promising  him  that  he  should  then 
have  even  what  he  would  ;  and  presenting  him 
wth  all  the  delectable  things,  persons  and  places 
that  he  could  imagine  ;  but  he  refusing  to  sub- 
scribe, the  business  would  end  with  dreadful 
shapes,  noises  and  screeches,  which  almost 
scared  him  out  of  his  wits.  Once,  with  a  book, 
there  was  a  pen  offered  him,  and  an  inkhorn, 
with  liquor  in  it,  that  seemed  like  blood ;  but  he 
never  touched  it. 

This  man  did  now  affirm,  that  he  saw  the 
prisoner  at  several  of  these  hellish  rendezvous. 

JVote.  This  woman  was  one  of  the  most  im- 
pudent, scurrilous,  wicked  creatures,  in  the 
world  :  and  she  now,  throughout  her  whole  trial, 
discovered  herself  to  be  such  an  one.  Yet  when 


264  SCATTERS 

she  was  asked  what  she  had  to  say  for  herseh"^ 
her  chief  plea  was,  that  she  had  led  a  most 
virtuous  and  holy  Hfe. 

The  Indictment  of  Elizabeth  How. 

Essex  ss.  jinno  Regni  Regis  £(  Reginai  Willielmi  Sf  Marice,  nunc 

Angliit^  8fc.  quarto.  — - 

The  jurors  for  our  sovereign  lord  and  lady  the  king 
and  queen  present,  that  Elizabi^th  How,  wife  of  James 
How,  of  Ipswich,  in  the  county  of  Essex,  the  thirty-first 
day  of  May,  in  the  fourth  year  of  the  reign  ot  our  sove- 
reign lord  and  lady  VViljiam  and  Mary,  by  the  gn\ce  of 
God,  of  England,  Scotland,  France  and  Ireland,  king  and 
queen,  defenders  of  the  faith,  &c.  and  divers  other  days 
and  times,  as  well  before  as  after,  certain  detestable  arts, 
called  witchcrafts  and  sorceries,  wickedly  and  feloniously 
hath  used,  practised  and  exercised,  at  and  within  the  town- 
ship of  Salem,  in  the  county  of  Essex,  aforesaid,  in,  upon 
and  against  one  Mary  Wolcott,  of  Salem  Village,  in  the 
county  aforesaid,  single  woman  ;  by  which  said  wicked 
arts  the  said  Mary  Wolcott,  the  said  thirty-first  day  of 
May,  in  the  fourth  year  abovesaid,  and  divers  other  days 
and  times,  as  well  before  as  after,  was  and  is  tortured, 
afflicted,  pined,  consumed,  wasted  and  tormented ;  and 
also  for  sundry  other  acts  of  witchc rails,  by  said  Elizabeth 
How  committed  and  done  before  and  since  that  time, 
ao"ainst  the  peace  of  our  sovereign  lord  and  lady,  the 
king  and  queen,  and  against  the  form  of  the  statute  in 
that  case  made  and  provided. 

Witnesses — Mary  Wolcott^  Ann  Putman^  Abigail  Wil- 
liams^ Samuel  Pearly^  and  his  wife  Rnth.,  Joseph  Andrews^ 
and  wife  Sarah^  John  Sherrin^  Joseph  Safford^  Francis  Lane, 
Lydia  Foster^  Isaac  Cummins^  junior. 

There  was  also  a  second  indictment  for  af- 
flicting JMercij  Lewis.  Witnesses— Mercy  Lew- 
is, Mary  Wolcott,  Ann  Putman,  Sarnnei  Pearly 
and  wife,  Joseph  Andrews  and  wile,  John  Sher- 
rin,  Joseph  Saifordj  Francis  Lane,  Lydia  Foster. 


OF  FACT,  &c.  266 

The  Trial  of  EuzABETH  How,  June  30,  1692; 
as  is  printed  in  Wonders  of  the  Invisible 
Worlds  from  p.  }  26  to  p.  i32,  inclusively. 

1.  Elizabeth  How,  pleading  not  guilty  to  the 
indictment  of  witchcralts  then  charged  upon 
her,  the  court,  according  to  the  usual  proceed- 
ing of  the  courts  in  England  in  such  cases,  be- 
gan with  hearing  the  deposition  of  several  af- 
flicted people,  who  were  grievously  tormented 
by  sensible  and  evident  witchcrafts,  and  all  com- 
plained of  the  prisoner  as  the  cause  of  their 
trouble.  It  was  also  found  that  the  sufferers 
were  not  able  to  bear  her  look;  as  likewise  that 
in  their  greatest  swoons  they  distinguished  her 
toucli  from  other  people's,  being  thereby  raised 
out  of  them.  And  there  was  other  testimony 
of  people,  to  whom  the  shape  of  this  How  gave 
trouble  nine  or  ten  years  ago. 

2.  It  has  been  a  most  usual  thing  for  the  be- 
witched persons,  at  the  same  time  that  the 
spectres  representing  the  witches  troubled 
them,  to  be  visited  with  apparitions  of  ghosts, 
pretending  to  have  been  murdered  by  the 
witches  then  represented.  And  sometimes  the 
confessions  of  the  witches  afterwards  acknowl- 
edged those  very  murders,  which  these  appa- 
ritions charged  upon  them,  although  they  had 
never  heard  what  information  had  been  given 
by  the  sutterers.  There  were  such  apparitions 
of  ghosts  testified  by  some  of  the  present 
sufTerers,  and  the  ghosts  affirmed  that  this  How 
had  murdered  them:  which  things  were  feared, 
but  not  proved. 

3.  This  How  had  made    some  attempts  af 

23 


266  MATTERS 

joining  to  the  church  at  Ipswich,  several  years 
ago ;  but  she  Avas  denied  an  admission  into  that 
holy  society,  partly  through  a  suspicion  of  witch- 
craft, then  urged  against  her.  And  there  now 
came  in  testimony  of  preternatural  mischiefs 
pr-esently  befalling  some  that  had  been  instru- 
mental to  debar  her  from  the  communion  where* 
upon  she  was  intruding. 

4.  There  was  a  particular  deposition  of  Jo- 
seph Safford,    that  his  wife   had  conceived  an 
extreme  aversion  to  this  How,  on  the  reports 
of  her  witchcrafts  ;  but  How  one  day  taking-  her 
by  the  hand,  and  saying,  I  believe  you  are  not  ig- 
norant of  the  great  scandal  that  I  lie  under  by  an 
£vil  report  raised  upon  me,  she  immediately,  un- 
reasonably, and  unpersuadably,    even  like  one 
enchanted,  began  to    take   this  woman's  part. 
How  being  soon  after  propounded,  as  desiring 
an  admission  to  the  table  of  the  Lord,  son'e  of 
the  pious  brethren  were  unsatisfied  about  her. 
The  elders  appointed  a  meeting,  to  hear  mat- 
ters objected  against  her ;   and  no  arguments  in 
the    world  could  hinder  this  goodwife  Safford 
from  going  to  the  lecture.    She  did  indeed  pro- 
mise, with  much  ado,  that  she  would  not  go  to 
the  church-meeting ;  yet  she  could  not  refrain 
going  thither  also.     How's  affairs  were  so  can- 
vassed, that  she  came  off  rather  guilty,  than 
cleared ;    nevertheless  goodwife   Safford  could 
not  forbear  taking  her  by  the  hand,  and  saying, 
Though  you  are  condemned  before  men,  you  are 
justified  before  God.     She  was    quickly  taken 
in  a  very  strange  manner;  frantic,  raving,  rag- 
ing, and  crying  out,  Goody  How  must  come  into 


OF  FACT,  kc.  267 

ihe  church;  she  is  a  precious  saint ;  and  tJiough 
she  be  condemned  before  nien^  she  is  justijied  bejore 
God,  So  she  continued  for  the  space  of  two  or 
thr^e  hours,  und  then  fell  Into  a  trance.  But, 
coming  to  herself,  she  cried  out,  Ha!  I  icas  mis- 
taken I  al'tervvards  again  repeated,  Ha !  I  was 
mistaken!  Being  asked  bj  a  stander-by  where- 
in, she  replied,  I  thou<fht  goody  How  had  been  a 
precious  saint  of  God,  But  now  I  see  she  is  a  witch: 
she  has  bewitched  me  and  my  child,  and  we  shall 
never  be  well  till  there  be  testimony  for  her,  that  she 
may  be  taken  into  the  church. 

And  How  said,  afterwards,  That  she  was  very 
sorry  to  see  Safford  at  the  church-meeting  mention- 
ed. Saiford,  after  this,  declared  hersefto  be  af- 
flicted by  the  shape  of  How,  and  that  from  that 
shape  she  endured  many  miseries, 

5.  John  How,  brother  to  the  husband  of  the 
prisoner,  testified,  that  he  refusing  to  accompa- 
ny the  prisoner  unto  her  examination  as  was  by 
her  desired,  immediately  some  of  his  cattle  were 
bewitched  to  death,  leaping  three  or  four  feet 
high,  turning  about,  squeaking,  faUing  and  dying 
at  once;  and  going  to  cut  off  an  ear,  for  an  use 
that  might  as  well  perhaps  have  been  omitted, 
tiie  hand  wherein  he  held  his  knife  was  taken 
very  numb;  and  so  it  remained,  and  full  of  pain, 
for  several  days,  being  not  well  at  this  very  time. 
And  he  suspected  this  prisoner  for  the  author 
of  it. 

6.  Nehemiah  Abbot  testified,  that  unusual 
and  mischievous  accidents  would  befall  his  cat- 
tle, whenever  he  had  any  difference  with  this 
prisoner.     Once  particularly  she  wished  his  ox 


268  MATTERS 

choked ;  and  within  a  Httle  while  that  ox  was^ 
choked  with  a  turnip  in  his  throat.  At  another 
time,  refusing  to  lend  his  horse  at  the  request 
of  her  daughter,  the  horse  was  in  a  preternatu- 
ral manner  abused.  '  And  several  other  odd 
things  of  that  kind  were  testified. 

7.  There  came  in  testimony,  that  one  good- 
wife  Sherwin,  upon  some  difference  with  How, 
was  bewitched,  and  that  she  died  charging  this 
How  of  having 'an  hand  in  her  death;  and  that 
other  people  had  their  barrels  of  drink  unac- 
countably mischiefed,  spoiled,  and  spilt,  upon 
their  displeasing  her. 

The  things  in  themselves  were  trivial;  but 
there  being  such  a  course  of  them,  it  made  them 
the  more  to  be  considered.  Among  others, 
Martha  Wood  gave  Jier  testimony,  that  a  little 
after  her  father  had  been  employed  in  gather- 
ing an  account  of  this  How's  conversation,  they 
once  and  again  lost  great  quantities  of  drink  out 
of  their  vessels,  in  such  a  manner  as  they  could 
ascribe  to  nothing  but  witchcraft;  as  also  that 
How  giving  her  some  apples,  when  she  had  eat- 
en of  them  she  was  taken  with  a  yery  strange 
kind  of  a  maze,  insomuch  that  she  knew  not 
what  she  said  or  did. 

8.  There  was  likewise  a  cluster  of  depositions, 
that  one  Isaac  Cummins  refusing  to  lend  his  mare 
to  the  husband  of  this  How,  the  mare  was  with- 
in a  day  or  two  taken  in  a  strange  condition. 
The  beast  seemed  much  abused,  being  bruised, 
as  if  she  had  been  running  over  the  rocks,  and 
marked  where  the  bridle  went,  as  if  burnt  with 
a  red  hot  bridle.     Moreover,  one  using  a  pipe 


OF  FACT,  Lc.  2G.d 

of  tobacco  for  the  cure  of  the  beast,  a  bhie  flame 
issued  out  of  her,  took  hold  of  her  hair,  and  not 
only  spread  and  burnt  on  her,  but  it  also  flew 
upwards  towards  the  roof  of  the  barn,  and  had 
hke  to  liave  set  the  bani  on  fire.  And  the  mare 
died  very  suddenly. 

9.  Timothy  Pearly  and  his  wife  testified,  not 
only  that  unaccountable  mischiefs  befel  their 
cattle  upon  their  having  dilFercnces  with  this 
prisoner,  but  also  that  they  had  a  daughter  de- 
stroyed by  witchcrafts ;  which  daughter  still 
charged  How  as  the  cause  of  her  affliction;  and 
it  was  noted  that  she  would  be  struck  down 
whenever  How  was  spoken  of.  She  was  often 
endeavoured  to  be  thrown  into  the  tire,  and  into 
the  water,  in  her  strange  fits ;  though  her  father 
had  corrected  her  for  charging  How  with  be- 
witching her,  yet  (as  was  testified  by  others  also) 
she  said  she  was  sure  of  it,  and  must  die  stand- 
ing to  it.  Accordingly  she  charged  How  to  the 
very  death;  and  said,  Though  How  could  afflict 
and  torment  her  body^  yet  she  could  not  hurt  her 
soul,  and  that  the  truth  of  this  matter  would  appear 
when  she  should  be  dead  and  gone, 

10.  Francis  Lane  testified,  that  being  hired 
by  the  husband  of  this  How  to  get  him  a  parcel 
of  posts  and  rails,  this  Lane  hired  John  Pearly 
to  assist  him.  This  prisoner  then  told  Lane, 
that  she  believed  the  posts  and  rails  would  not 
di),.  because  John  Pearly  helped  him;  but  that 
if  he  had  gotten  them  alone  without  John  Pear- 
ly's  help,  they  might  have  done  well  enough. 
\V  lien  James  Huw  came  to  receive  his  posts  and 
rails  of  Lane,  How  taking  them  up  by  the  ends, 

23* 


£td  MATTERS 

they,  though  good  and  sound,  yet  unaccountably 
broke  off,  so  that  Lane  was  forced  to  get  thirty 
or  forty  more.  And  this  prisoner  being  inform- 
ed of  it,  she  said,  she  told  him  so  before^  because- 
Pearly  helped  about  them, 

11.  Afterwards  there  came  in  the  confessions 
of  several  other  (penitent)  witches,  which  af- 
firmed this  How  to  be  one  of  those  who  with 
them  had  been  baptized ^by  the  devil  in  the  ri- 
ver, at  Newbury-falls ;  before  which,  he  made 
them  there  kneel  down  by  the  brink  of  the  river, 
and  worship  him. 

The  Indictment  oj*  JWartha  Carrier, 

Essex  ss.  Anno  Regni  Regis  8f  Reginas  IVillielmi  8f  Mari<£,  nunc 

Angelioei  8fc.  quarto. — 

The  jurors  for  our  sovereign  lord  and  ladj  the  king  and 
queen  present,  that  Martha  Carrier,  wife  of  Thomas  Car- 
rier, of  Andover,  in  the  county  of  Essex,  husbandnjan,  the 
thirty-first  day  of  May,  in  the  fourth  year  of  the  reign  of 
our  sovereign  lord  and  ladj  William  and  Mary,  hy  the 
grace  of  God,  of  England,  Scotland,  France  and  Ireland, 
king  and  queen,  defenders  of  the  faith,  &c.  and  divers 
other  days  and  times,  as  well  before  as  after,  certain  de- 
testable arts,  called  witchcrafts  and  sorceries,  wickedly 
*nd  feloniously  hath  used,  practised  and  exercised,  at  and 
within  the  township  of  Salem,  in  the  county  of  Essex, 
aforesaid,  in,  upon  and  against  one  Mary  VVoicott,  of  Saiem 
Village,  in  the  county  of  Essex,  single  woman  ;  by  which 
said  wicked  arts  the  said  Mary  VVoicott,  the  thirty  tirst 
day  of  May,  in  the  fourth  year  aforesaid,  and  at  divers 
other  days  and  times,  as  well  before  as  after,  was  and 
is  tortured,  afflicted,  pined,  consumed,  wasted  and  torment- 
ed ;  against  the  peace  of  our  sovereign  lord  and  lady, 
William  and  Mary,  king  and  queen  of  England,  their 
crown  and  dignity,  and  against  the  form  of  the  statute,  in 
that  case  made  and  provided. 

Witnesses— JV/ary  M'okotU  Elizabeth  Hubbard.  .^n-$ 
Pirt?nan> 


of  FACT,  Lq.  271 

There  was  also  a  second  indictment  lor  afflict- 
ing Elizabeth  Hubbard.,  bj  witclicrart.  W  itnes- 
sos — Elizabeth  Hubbard,  Mary  Wolcott,  Ann 
Putman,  Mary  Warren. 

The  Trial  o/*  Martha  Carrikr,  August  2,  1692  ; 
as  may  be  seen  in  Wonders  of  the  Invisible 
World,  from  p.  132,  to  p,  138. 

1.  Martha  Carrier  was  indicted  for  the  be- 
witching of  certain  persons,  according  to  the 
form  usual  in  such  cases.  Pleading  not  guilty  to 
her  indictment,  there  were  first  brought  in  a 
considerable  number  of  the  bewitched  persons; 
who  not  only  made  the  court  sensible  of  an  hor- 
rid witchcraft  committed  upon  them,  but  also 
deposed,  that  it  was  Martha  Carrier,  or  her 
shape,  that  grievously  tormented  them,  by  bit- 
ing, pricking,  pinching  and  choking  them.  It 
was  further  deposed,  that  while  tliis  Carrier 
was  on  her  examination  before  the  magistrates, 
the  poor  people  were  so  tortured,  that  every 
one  expected  their  death  u|>on  the  very  spot 5 
but  that  upon  the  binding  of  Carrier  they  were 
cased.  Moreover  the  looks  of  Carrier  then  laid 
the  afflicted  people  for  dead;  and  her  touch,  if 
her  eyes  at  the  same  time  were  off' them,  raised 
them  again.  Which  things  were  also  now  seen 
upon  her  trial.  And  it  was  testified,  that  upon 
the  mention  of  some  havmg  their  necks  twisted 
almost  round  by  the  shape  of  this  Carrier,  she 
replied.  Its  no  matter,  though  their  necks  had  been 
Hoisted  quite  off", 

2.  Before  the  trial  of  this  prisoner,  several  of 
her  own  children  had  frankly  and  fully  confessed, 


27«  MATTERS 

not  only  that  they  were  witches  themselves,  but 
that  their  mother  had  made  them  so.  This 
confession  they  made  with  great  shows  of  re- 
pentance, and  with  much  demonstration  of  truth. 
They  related  place,  time  and  occasion;  they 
gave  an  account  of  journeys,  meetings  and  mis- 
chiefs by  them  performed,  and  were  very  credi- 
ble in  wiiat  they  said.  Nevertheless,  this  evi- 
dence v;as  not  produced  against  the  prisoner  at 
the  bar,  in  as  much  as  there  was  other  evidence 
enough  to  proceed  upon. 

3.  Benjamin  Abbot  gave  in  his  testimony,  that, 
last  March  was  a  twelve-month,  this  Carrier  was 
very  angry  with  him,  upon  laying  out  some  land 
near  her  husband's.  Her  expressions  in  this  an- 
ger were,  that  she  would  stick  as  close  to  Abbot 
as  the  bark  stuck  to  the  tree;  and  that  he 
should  repent  of  it  before  seven  years  came  to 
an  end,  so  as  doctor  Prescot  should  never  cure 
him.  These  words  were  heard  by  others  be- 
sides Abbot  himself,  who  also  heard  her  say, 
she  w^ould  hold  his  nose  as  close  to  the  grind- 
stone as  ever  it  v*'as  held  since  his  name  was 
Abbot.  Presently  after  this  he  was  taken  with 
a  swelling  in  his  foot,  and  then  with  a  pain  in 
his  side,  and  exceedingly  tormented.  It  bred  a 
sore,  whicti  was  lanced  by  Dr.  Prescot,  and  se- 
veral gallons  of  corruption  ran  out  of  it.  For 
six  weeks  it  continued  very  bad ;  and  then  anoth- 
er sore  bred  in  his  groin,  which  was  also  lanced 
by  Dr.  Prescot.  Another  sore  bred  in  his  groin, 
which  was  likewise  cut,  and  put  him  to  very 
great  misery.  He  was  brought  to  death's  door, 
and  so  remained  until  Carrier  was  taken  and  car- 


OF  FACT,  &c.  27;i 

ried  away  by  the  constable  ;  IVoni  which  very 
day  he  began  to  mend,  and  so  grew  better  every 
day,  and  is  well  ever  since. 

Sarah  Abbot  also,  his  wife,  testified,  that  her 
husband  was  not  only  all  this  while  alflicted  in 
his  body,  but  also  that  strange,  extraordinary 
and  unaccountable  calamities  befel  his  cattle; 
their  death  being  such  as  they  could  guess  no 
natural  reason  for. 

4.  Allin  Toothaker  testified,  that  Richard, 
the  son  of  Martha  Carrier,  having  some  diffe- 
rence with  him,  pulled  him  down  by  the  hair  of 
the  head;  when  he  rose  again,  he  was  going  to 
strike  at  Richard  Carrier,  but  fell  down  flat  on 
his  back  to  the  ground,  and  had  not  power  to 
stir  hand  or  foot,  until  he  told  Carrier  he  yield- 
ed; and  then  he  saw  the  shape  of  Martha  Car- 
rier go  off  his  breast. 

This  Toothaker  had  received  a  wound  in  the 
wars;  and  he  now  testified,  that  Martha  Car- 
rier told  him,  he  should  never  be  cured.  Just 
before  llie  apprehending  of  Carrier,  he  could 
thrust  a  knitting-needle  into  his  wound  four  inch- 
es deep;  but  presently  after  her  being  seized, 
he  was  thoroughly  healed. 

He  further  testified,  that  when  Carrier  and 
he  sometimes  were  at  variance,  she  would  clap 
her  hands  at  him,  and  say,  he  should  get  nothing 
by  it.  Whereupon  he  several  times  lost  his  cat- 
tle bv  stranjre  deaths,  whereof  no  natural  causes 
could  be  given. 

5.  John  Roger  also  testified,  that,  upon  the 
threatening  words  of  this  malicious  Carrier,  his 
cattle  would  be  strangely  bewitched;  as  was 
more  particularly  then  described. 


S74  MATTERS 

6.  Samuel  Preston  testified,  that  about  tvvd 
years  ago,  having  some  difference  with  Martha 
Carrier,  he  lost  a  cow  in  a  strange,  preternatural, 
Unusual  manner;  and  about  a  month  after  this^ 
the  said  Carrier  having  again  some  difference 
with  him,  she  told  him  he  had  lately  lost  a  cow, 
and  it  should  not  be  long  before  he  lost  another; 
which  accordingly  came  to  pass;  for  he  had  a 
thriving  and  weil-kept  cow,  which  without  any 
known  cause  quickly  fell  down  and  died. 

7.  Phebe  Chandler  testified,  that  about  a 
fortnight  before  the  apprehension  of  Martha 
Carrier,  on  a  Lord's-day,  while  the  psalm  was 
singing  in  the  church,  this  Carrier  then  took  her 
by  the  shoulder,  and  shaking  her,  asked  her 
>vhere  she  lived:  she  made  her  no  answer,  al- 
though, as  Carrier  \i\ed  next  door  to  her  father's 
house,  she  could  not  in  reason  but  know  who 
she  was.  Quickly  after  this,  as  she  was  at  several 
times  crossing  the  fields,  she  heard  a  voice 
that  she  took  to  be  Martha  Carrier's,  and  it 
seemed  as  if  it  were  over  her  head.  The  voice 
told  her,  she  should  within  two  or  three  days  he 
poisoned  :  accordingly,  within  such  a  little  time, 
one  half  of  her  right  hand  became  greatly 
swollen  and  very  painful,  as  also  part  of  her  face; 
whereof  she  can  give  no  account  how  it  came. 
It  continued  very  bad  for  some  days;  and  sever- 
al times  since  she  has  had  a  great  pain  in  her 
breast ;  and  been  so  seized  on  her  legs,  that  she 
has  hardly  been  able  to  go.  She  added,  that 
lately  going  well  to  the  house  of  God,  Richard, 
'the  son  of  Martha  Carrier,  looked  very  earnest- 
ly upon  her,  and  immediately  her  hand,  whiok 


OF  FACT,  <^c.  275 

liad  formerly  been  poisoned,  as  is  abovcsaid,  be- 
gan to  pain  her  greatly,  and  she  had  a  strange 
burning  at  her  stomach  ;  but  was  then  struck 
deal',  so  that  she  could  not  hear  any  of  the 
prayer,  or  singing,  till  the  two  or  three  last 
words  of  the  psalm. 

8.  One  Foster,  who  confessed  her  own  share 
in  the  witchcraft,  for  which  the  prisoner  stood 
indicted,  afiirmed,  that  she  had  seen  the  prisoner 
at  some  of  their  witch-meetings,  and  that  it  was 
this  Carrier  who  persuaded  her  te  be  a  witch. 
She  confessed  that-the  devil  carried  them  on  a 
pole  to  a  witch-meeting;  but  the  pole  broke, 
and  she  hanging  about  Carriers  neck,  they  both 
fell  down,  and  she  then  received  an  hurt  by  the 
fall,  whereof  she  was  not  at  this  very  time 
recovered. 

9.  One  Lacy,  who  likewise  confessed  her 
share  in  this  witchcraft,  now  testified,  that  she 
and  the  prisoner  were  once  bodily  present  at  a 
witch-meeting  in  Salem  Village,  and  that  she 
knew  the  prisoner  to  be  a  witch,  and  to  have 
been  at  a  diabolical  sacrament,  and  that  the 
prisoner  w^as  the  undoing  of  her  and  her  chil- 
dren, by  enticing  them  into  the  snare  ef  the 
devil. 

10.  Another  Lacy,  who  also  confessed  her 
share  in  this  witchcraft,  now  testified,  that  the 
prisoner  was  at  the  witch-meeting  in  Salem 
Village,  where  they  had  bread  and  wine  admin- 
istered to  them. 

11.  in  the  time  of  this  prisoner's  trial,  one 
Susanna  Shelden,  in  open  court,  had  her  hands 
unaccountably  tied  together  with  a  wheel-band 


> 


276  MATTERS 

so  fast  that  without  cutting  it  could  not  be  loosen- 
ed.  It  was  done  by  a  spectre;  and  the  sufferer 
affirmed  it  was  the  prisoner's. 

Meinorandiim*  This  rampant  hag,  Martha 
Carrier,  was  the  person  of  whom  the  confessions 
of  the  WMtches,  and  of  her  own  children  among 
the  rest,  agreed  that  the  devil  had  promised  her 
she  should  be  queen  of  hell. 

Thus  far  the  account  given  in  Wonders  of  the 
Invisible  World;  in  which  (setting  aside  such 
words  as  these,  in  the  trial  of  G.  B.  viz.  "  They, 
i.  e.  the  witnesses,  were  enough  to  fix  the  char- 
acter of  a  witch  upon  him" — in  the  trial  of  Bi- 
shop, these  words,  "  But  there  was  no  need  of 
them,"  i.  e.  of  further  testimony — in  the  trial  of 
How,  where  it  is  said,  "And  there  came  in  tes- 
timony of  preternatural  mischiefs  presently  be- 
falhng  some  that  had  been  instrumental  to  debar 
her  from  the  communion,  whereupon  she  was 
intruding,")  Martin  is  called  one  of  the  most  im- 
pudent, scurrilous,  wicked  creatures  in  the  world ; 
in  his  account  of  Martha  Carrier,  he  is  pleased 
to  call  her  a  rampant  hog,  <Sz;c. 

These  expressions,  as  they  manifest  that  he 
wrote  more  like  an  advocate  than  an  historian, 
so  also  that  those  that  were  his  employers  were 
not  mistaken  in  their  choice  of  him  for  that 
work,  however  he  may  have  missed  it  in  other 
things:  as,  in  his  owning  (in  the  trial  of  G.  B.) 
that  the  testimony  of  the  beivifchedy  and  confes- 
sors, was  not  enovgh  against  the  accused  ;  for  it  is 
known  that  not  only  in  New-England  such  evi- 
dence has  been  taken  for  sufficient,  but  also  in 


OF  FACT,  &c.  177 

England,  as  himself  there  owns,  and  will  also 
hold  true  of  Scotland,  &c.  they  having  proceed- 
ed upon  such  evidence,  to  the  taking  away  of 
the  lives  of  many.  To  assert  that  this  is  not 
enough,  is  to  tell  the  world  that  such  executions 
were  but  so  many  bloody  murders;  which  sure- 
ly was  not  his  intent  to  say. 

His  telling  that  the  court  began  to  think  that 
Burroughs  stept  aside  to  put  on  invisibility,  is  a 
rendering  them  so  mean  philosophers,  and  such 
weak  christians,  as  to  be  fit  to  be  imposed  upon 
by  any  silly  pretender. 

His  calling  the  evidence  against  How  trivial, 
and  others  against  Burroughs  he  accounts  no 
part  of  his  conviction,  and  that  of  lifting  a  gun 
with  one  finger,  its  being  not  made  use  of  as  evi- 
dence, renders  the  whole  but  the  more  perplext. 
(Not  to  mention  the  many  mistakes  therein  con* 
tained.) 

Yet  all  this  (and  more  that  might  have  been 
hinted  at)  does  nbt  hinder,  but  that  his  account 
of  the  manner  of  trials  of  those  for  w^itchcraft  is 
as  faithfully  related  as  any  trials  of  that  kind, 
that  were  ever  yet  made  public;  and  it  may  al- 
so be  reasonably  thought  that  there  was  as  care- 
ful a  scrutiny,  and  as  unquestioned  evidences  im- 
proved, as  nad  been  formerly  used  in  tlie  trials 
of  others,  for  such  crimes,  in  other  places. 
Though  indeed  a  second  part  tnight  be  very  use- 
ful, to  set  forth  which  was  the  evidence  convic- 
tive  in  these  trials ;  for  it  is  not  supposed  that 
romantic  or  ridiculous  stories  should  have  any 
influence;  such  as  biting  a  spectre's  finger  so 
that  the  blood  flowed  out;  or  such  as  Shattock's 
24 


ns  MATTERS 

story  of  twelve  years  standing,  -yvhich  yet  was 
presently  eighteen  years  or  more,  and  yet  a  man 
of  so  excellent  memory  as  to  be  able  to  recall  a 
small  difference  his  wife' had  with  another  w^o- 
man  when  eighteen  years  were  past. 

As  it  is  not  to  be  supjiosed  that  such  as  these 
could  influence  any  judge  or  jury,  so  not  unkind- 
ness  to  relations,  or  God's  having  given  to  one 
man  more  strength  than  to  some  others;  the 
oversetting  of  carts,  or  the  death  of  cattle;  nor 
yet  excrescences  (called  teats)  nor  litde  bits  of 
'rags  tied  together  (called  poppets  ;)  much  less 
any  person's  illness,  or  having  their  clothes  rent> 
when  a  spectre  has  been  well  hanged;  much 
less  the  burning  the  mare's  fart,  mentioned  in 
the  trial  of  How. 

None  of  these  being  in  the  least  capable  of 
proving  the  indictment,  the  supposed  criminals 
were  indicted  for  afflicting,  &c.  such  and  such 
particular  persons  by  witchcraft,  to  which  none 
of  these  evidences  have  one  word  to  say ;  and  the 
afflicted  and  confessors  being  declared  not 
enough,  the  matter  needs  yet  further  explaining. 

But  to  proceed.  The  general  court  having 
set  and  enacted  laws,  particularly  one  against 
witchcraft,  assigning  the  penalty  of  death  to  any 
that  shall  feed,  reward  or  employ,  &c.  evil 
spirits,  though  it  has  not  yet  been  explained 
what  is  intended  thereby,  or  what  it  is  to  feed, 
reward  or  employ  devils,  (kc  yet  some  of  the 
legislators  have  given  this,  instead  of  an  explana- 
tion, that  they  had  therein  but  copied  the  law  of 
another  country. 

January  3.  By  virtue  of  an  act  of  the  general 


OF  FACT,  4-c.  279 

?ourt,  the  first  superior  court  was  held  at  Salcni, 
for  the  country  of  Essex;  the  judges  a[)pointed 
were  mr.  William  Stoughton  (the  heutenant 
Governor)  Thomas  Danlorth,  John  Richards, 
VVait  VVinthrop,  and  Samuel  Sewall,  esquires; 
^vhere  ignoramus  was  found  upon  the  several  bills 
of  indictment  against  thirty,  and  billa  vera  against 
twenty-six  more  ;  of  all  these,  three  only  were 
found  guilty  by  the  jury  upon  trial,  two  of  which 
were  (as  appears  by  their  behaviour)  the  most 
senseless  and  ignorant  creatures  that  could  be 
found;  besides  which,  it  does  not  appear  what 
came  in  aofainst  those  more  than  asfainst  the  rest 
that  were  acquitted. 

The  third  was  the  wife  of  Wardwell,  whq 
was  one  of  the  twenty  executed,  and  it  seems 
they  had  both  confessed  themselves  guilty  ;  but 
he,  retracting  his  said  confession,  was  tried  and 
executed.  It  is  supposed  that  this  woman,  fear- 
ing her  husband's  fate,  was  not  so  stiff  in  her 
denials  of  her  former  confession,  such  as  it  was. 
Taese  three  received  sentence  of  death. 

At  these  trials  some  of  the  jury  made  inquiry 
of  the  court,  what  account  they  ought  to  make 
of  the  spectre  evidence  ;  and  received  for  an- 
swer, c/^5  much  as  of  chips  in  wort. 

January  31,  1692-3.  The  superior  court  be- 
gan at  Charlestown,  for  the  county  of  Middlesex, 
mr.  Stoughton,  mr.  Danforth,  mr.  Winthrop  and 
mr.  Sewall,  judges;  where  several  had  ignora- 
mus returned  upon  their  bills  of  indictment,  and 
billa  vera  upon  others. 

In  the  time  the  court  sat,  word  was  brought 
in,  that  a  reprieve  was  sent  to  Salem,  and  had 


5«0  MATTERS 

prevented  the  execution  of  seven  of  those  thai 
were  there  condemned;  which  so  moved  the 
chief  judge,  that  he  said  to  this  etTect,  We  ivere 
in  a  tivay  to  have  cleared  the  land  of  these,  S*c. 
Who  it  is  obstructs  the  course  oj*  justice,  1  know 
not ;  the  Lord  he  merciful  to  the  coimtry  ;  and  so 
went  off  the  bench,  and  came  no  more  that  court. 
The  most  remarkable  of  the  trials,  was  of 
Sarah  Daston.  She  was  a  woman  of  about  sev- 
enty or  eightj  years  of  age.  To  usher  her  in 
to  her  trial,  a  report  went  before,  that  if  there 
were  a  witch  in  the  W'orld  she  was  one,  as  hav- 
ing been  so  accounted  of  for  twenty  or  thirty 
years;  which  drew  many  people  from  Boston, 
i&c.  to  hear  her  trial.  There  were  a  multitude 
of  witnesses  produced  against  her;  but  what 
testimony  they  gave  in  seemed  wholly  foreign, 
as  of  accidents,  illness,  &c.  befalling  them,  or 
theirs,  after  seme  cjuarrel ;  what  these  testified 
was  much  of  it  of  actions  said  to  be  done  twenty 
years  before  that  time.  The  spectre  evidence 
was  not  made  use  of  in  these  trials,  so  that  the 
jury  soon  brought  her  in  not  guilty.  Her  daugh- 
ter and  grand-daughter,  and  the  rest  that  were 
then  tried,  were  also  acquitted.  After  she  was 
cleared,  judge  Danforth  admonished  her  in  these 
words,  Woman,  woman,  repent ;  there  are  shrewd 
things  come  in  against  you*  She  was  remanded 
to  prison  for  her  fees,  and  there  in  a  short  time 
expired.  One  of  Boston,  that  had  been  at  the 
trial  of  Daston,  being  the  same  evening  in  com- 
pany Avith  one  of  the  judges  in  a  public  place, 
acquainted  him  that  some,  that  had  been  both 
at  the  trials  at  Salem  and  at  this  at  Charlestown^ 


or  FACT,  Lc.  281 

had  asserted,  That  there  was  more  evidence  against 
the  said  Dnston  than  against  any  at  Salon  ;  to 
Aviiicli  the  said  judge  conceded,  saying,  that  it 
was  so.  It  was  replied  by  that  person,  Tliat  he 
dare  give  it  under  his  hand,  that  there  was  not 
enough  come  in  against  her  to  hear  a  just  reproof. 
.fpril2C),  1693.  The  first  superior  court  was 
held  at  Boston,  lor  the  county  of  Suffolk;  the 
judges  were  the  lieutenant  Governor,  mr.  Dan- 
forth,  mr.  Richards,  and  mr.  Sewall,  esquires; 
where  (besides  the  acquitting  mr.  John  Aldin  by 
proclamation)  the  most  remarkable  was,  what 
related  to  Mary  Watkins,  who  had  been  a  ser- 
vant, and  lived  about  seven  miles  from  Boston, 
havuig  formerly  accused  her  mistress  of  witch- 
craft, and  was  supposed  to  be  distracted ;  she 
was  threatened,  it"  she  persisted  in  such  accusa- 
tions, to  be  punished.  This,  with  the  necessary 
care  to  recover  her  health,  had  that  good  effect, 
that  she  not  only  had  her  health  restored,  but 
also  wholly  acquitted  her  mistress  of  any  such 
crimes,  and  continued  in  health  till  the  return  of 
the  year,  and  then  again  falling  into  melancholy- 
humours,  she  was  found  strangling  herself;  her 
lite  being  hereby  prolonged,  she  immediately  ac- 
cused herself  of  being  a  witch;  was  carried  be- 
fore a  magistrate,  and  committed.  At  this  court 
a  bill  of  indictment  was  brought  to  the  grand 
jury  against  her,  and  her  confession  upon  her  ex- 
amination given  in  as  evidence ;  but  these,  not 
wholly  satisfied  herewith,  sent  for  hor,  who  gave 
such  account  of  herself,  that  they  (after  they 
had  returned  into  the  court  to  ask  some  ques- 
tions) twelve  of  them  agreed  to  find  ignoramus, 
24* 


282  MATTERS 

but  the  court  was  pleased  to  send  them  out 
again,  who  again  at  coming  in  returned  it  as  be- 
fore. She  was  continued  for  some  time  in  pri- 
son, &;c.  and  at  length  was  sold  to  Virginia.  About 
this  time  the  prisoners  in  all  the  prisons  were 
released. 

To  omit  here  the  mentioning  of  several  wen- 
ches inBoston,Akc.  who  pretended  to  be  afflicted, 
and  accused  several,  the  ministers  often  visiting 
them,  and  praying  with  them,  concerning  whose 
affliction  narratives  are  in  being,  in  manuscript ; 
not  only  these,  but  the  generality  of  those  accus- 
ers, may  have  since  convinced  the  ministers,  by 
their  vicious  courses,  that  they  might  err  in  ex- 
tending too  much  charity  to  them. 

The  conclusion  of  the  whole  in  the  Massachu- 
setts colony  was,  sir  William  Phips,  governor, 
being  called  home,  before  he  went  he  pardoned 
such  as  had  been  condemned,  for  which  they 
gave  about  thirty  shillings  each  to  the  king's 
attorney. 

In  August,  1697,  the  superior  court  sat  at 
Hartford,  in  the  colony  of  Connecticut,  where 
one  mistress  Benom  was  tried  for  witchcraft. 
She  had  been  accused  by  some  children  that 
pretended  to  the  spectral  sight;  they  searched 
her  several  times  for  teats;  they  tried  the  exper- 
iment of  casting  her  into  the  water,  and  after 
this  she  was  excommunicated  by  the  minister  of 
Wallinsford.  Upon  her  trial  nothing  material 
appeared  against  her,  save  spectre  evidence. 
She  was  acquitted,  as  also  her  daughter,  a  girl 
of  twelve  or  thirteen  years  old,  who  had  been 
l^ikewise  accused;  but  upon  renewed  complaints 


OF  FACT,  S:c.  28S 

against  them,    they  both  flew    into  New-York 
government. 

Bel'ore  this,  the  government  issued  forth  the 
following  proclamation : 

By  the  honourable  the  lieutenant  governor^  council 
and  assembly  of  his  majesty\s  province  of  the 
Massachusetts-bay,  in  general  court  assembled. 
Whereas  the  anger  of  God  is  not  yet  turned 
away,  but  his  hand  is  still  stretched  out  against 
his  people  in  manifold  judgments,  particularly  in 
drawing  out  to  such  a  length  the  troubles  of 
Europe,  by  a  perplexing  war ;  and  more  espe- 
cially respecting  ourselves  in  this  province,  in 
that  God  is  pleased  still  to  go  on  in  diminishing 
our  substance,  cutting  short  our  harvest,  blast- 
ing our  most  promising  undertakings  more  ways 
than  one,  unsettling  us,  and  by  his  more  imme- 
diate hand  snatching  away  many  out  of  our  em- 
braces by  sudden  and  violent  deaths,  even  at 
this  time  when  the  sword  is  devouring  so  many 
both  at  home  and  abroad,  and  that  after  many 
days  of  public  and  solemn  addressing  him  :  and 
although,  considering  the  many  sins  prevailing  in 
the  midst  of  us,  we  cannot  but  wonder  at  the 
patience  and  mercy  moderating  these  rebukes, 
yet  we  cannot  but  also  fear  that  there  is  some- 
thing still  wanting  to  accompany  our  supplica- 
tions; and  doubtless  there  are  some  particular 
sins,  which  God  is  angry  with  our  Israel  for,  that 
hive  not  been  duly  seen  and  resented  by  us, 
about  which  God  expects  to  be  sought,  if  ever 
he  turn  again  our  captivity : 

Wherefore   it  is  commanded  and  appointed, 


284  MATTERS 

that  Thursday,  the  fourteenth  of  January  next, 
be  observed  as  a  day  of  prayer,  with  fasting, 
throughout  this  province ;  strictly  forbidding  ail 
servile  labour  thereon;  that  soall'God's  people 
may  offer  up  fervent  supplications  unto  him,  for 
the  preservation  and  prosperity  of  his  majesty^s 
royal  person  and  government,  and  success  to  at- 
tend his  affairs  both  at  home  and  abroad;  that 
all  iniquity  may  be  put  away,  which  hath  stirred 
God's  holy  jealousy  against  this  land;  that  he 
would  shew  us  what  we  know  not,  and  help  us 
wherein  we  have  done  amiss  to  do  so  no  more; 
and  especially  that  whatever  mistakes  on  either 
hand  have  been  fallen  into,  either  by  the  body 
of  this  people,  or  any  orders  of  men,  referring  to 
the  late  tragedy,  raised  among  us  by  satan  and 
his  instruments,  through  the  awful  judgment  of 
God,  he  would  humble  us  therefor,  and  pardon 
all  the  errors  of  his  servants  and  people,  that 
desire  to  love  his  name ;  that  he  would  remove 
the  rod  of  the  wicked  from  off  the  lot  of  the 
righteous;  that  he  would  bring  in  the  American 
heathen,  and  cause  them  to  hear  and  obey  his 
roice. 

Given  at  Boston,  December  17,  1696,  in  the 
eighth  year  of  his  Majesty^ s  reign. 

Isaac  Addington,  Secretary. 

Upon  the  day  of  the  fast,  in  the  full  assembly 
at  the  south  meeting-house  in  Boston,  one  of  the 
honourable  judges,  who  had  sat  in  judicature  in 
Salem,  delivered  in  a  paper,  and  while  it  was  in 
reading  stood  up;  but  the  copy  being  not  to  be 
obtained  at  present,  it  can  only  be  reported  by 


OF  FACT,  &c.  286 

memory  to  this  effect,  viz.  It  was  to  desire  the 
prayers  of  God's  people  for  him  and  his  ;  and 
that  God  having  visited  his  family,  &;c.  he  was 
apprehensive  that  he  might  have  fallen  into  some 
errors  in  the  matters  at  Salem,  and  pray  that 
the  ^uilt  of  such  miscarriages  may  not  be  imput- 
ed either  to  the  country  in  general,  or  to  him  or 
his  family  in  particular. 

Some,  that  had  been  of  several  juries,  have 
given  forth  a  paper,  signed  with  their  own  hands, 
in  these  words: 

"  We,  whose  names  are  under  written,  being  in 
the  year  1692  called  to  serve  as  jurors  in  court 
at  Salem  on  trial  of  many,  who  were  by  some 
suspected  guilty  of  doing  acts  of  witchcraft 
upon  the  bodies  of  sundry  persons: 

'•We  confess  that  we  ourselves  were  not  ca- 
pable to  understand,  nor  able  to  withstand,  the 
mysterious  delusions  of  the  powers  of  darkness, 
and  prince  of  the  air;  but  were,  for  want  of 
knowledge  in  ourselves,  and  better  information 
from  others,  prevailed  with  to  take  up  with  such 
evidence  against  the  accused,  as,  on  further 
consideration  and  better  information,  we  justly 
fear  was  insufficient  for  the  touching  the  lives  of 
any,  (^Deut.  xvii.  6)  whereby  we  fear  we  have 
been  instrumental,  with  others,  though  ignorant- 
ly  and  unwittingly,  to  bring  upon  ourselves  and 
this  people  of  the  Lord  the  guilt  of  innocent 
blood;  which  sin  the  Lord  saith,  in  scripture, 
he  would  not  pardon,  (2  Kings,  xxiv.  4)  that  is, 
Ave  suppose,  in  regard  of  his  temporal  judgments. 
We  do  therefore  hereby  signify  to  all  in  general 
(and  to  the  surviving  sufferers  in  special)  oar 


286  MATTERS 

deep  sense  of,  and  sorrow  for,  our  errors,  in  act- 
ing on  such  evidence  to  the  condemning  of  any 
person;  and  do  hereby  declare,  that  we  justly 
fear  that  we  were  sadly  deluded  and  mistaken; 
for  which  we  are  much  disquieted  and  distress- 
ed in  our  minds ;  and  do  therefore  humbly  beg 
forgiveness,  first  of  God  for  Christ's  sake,  for 
this  our  error;  and  pray  that  God  would  not 
impute  the  guilt  of  it  to  ourselves,  nor  others; 
and  we  also  pray  that  we  may  be  considered 
candidly,  and  aright,  by  the  living  sufferers,  as 
being  then  under  the  power  of  a  strong  and  gene- 
ral delusion,  utterly  unacquainted  with,  and  not 
experienced  in,  matters  of  that  nature. 

"  We  do  heartily  ask  forgiveness  of  you  all, 
whom  we  have  justly  offended;  and  do  declare, 
according  to  our  present  minds,  we  would  none 
of  us  do  such  things  again  on  such  grounds  for 
the  whole  world;  praying  you  to  accept  of  this 
in  way  of  satisfaction  for  our  offence,  and  that 
you  would  bless  the  inheritance  of  the  Lord, 
that  he  may  be  entreated  for  the  land. 


Foreman,   Thomas  Fisk, 
William  Fisk, 
John  Bacheler, 
Thomas  Fisk^  jun. 
John  Dane. 
Joseph  Evelithj 


77i.  Pearly,  sen. 
John  Peabody, 
Thomas  Perkins, 
Samuel  Sayer, 
Andrew  Eliot, 
H,  Herrick,  sen.''^ 


rOSTSClIIPT. 


Since  making  the  ibregolnor  collections  oi 
letters,  to  the  rev.  mr.  Cotton  Mather,  and  oth- 
ers, (fcc.  (wliich  as  yet  remain  unanswered)  a 
hook  is  come  to  hand  intitled,  "  The  Life  of 
Sir  Wn.LiA3i  PiHPs,"  printed  in  London,  1697: 
which  book,  though  it  beais  not  the  author's 
name,  yet  the  style,  manner  and  matter  are  such, 
that,  were  there  np  other  demonstration  or  to- 
ken to  know  him  by,  it  were  no  witchcralt  to 
determine  that  the  said  mr.  Cotton  Mather  is 
the  author  of  it.  But  that  he,  who  has  cncoun- 
tered  enchantments,  and  gone  tlirough  the  IVon- 
ders  of  the  Invisible  WorUl,  and  discovered  the 
devil — that  he  sliould  step  aside  into  a  remote 
country  to  put  on  invisibility,  thougli  the  reason 
of  this  be  not  so  manifest,  yet  it  may  be  thought 
to  be  to  gratify  some  peculiar  fancies.  And 
why  may  not  this  be  one,  that  he  might  with 
the  better  grace  extol  the  actions  of  mr.  hicrease, 
Mather,  as  agent  in  England,  or  as  president  of 
Harv^ard  college,  not  forgetting  his  own? 

As  to  sir  Wilh'am,  it  will  be  generally  ac- 
knowledged, that  notwitlistanding  the  meanne.ss 
of  his  parentage  and  education,  he  attained  to 
he  master  of  a  ship,  and  that  he  had  the  good 
liap  to  find  a  Spanish  w^'eck,  not  only  sufficient 


288  POSTSCRIPT. 

to  repair  his  fortunes,  but  to  raise  hiai  to  a  con- 
siderable figure  ;  which  king  James  so  far  assist- 
ed, as  to  make  him  a  knight;  and  that  after  this, 
in  the  reign  of  his  present  majesty,  he  took  up 
with  those  of  the  agents,  that  were  for  accept- 
ing the  new  charter,  whereby  himself  became 
governor. 

It  is  not  doubted,  but  that  he  aimed  at  the 
good  of  the  people ;  and  great  pity  it  is  that  his 
government  was  so  sullied  (for  want  of  better 
information  and  advice  from  those  whose  duty 
it  was  to  have  given  it)  by  that  hobgoblin  mon- 
ster, witchcraft,  whereby  this  country  was  night- 
mared,  and  harassed,  at  such  a  rate  as  is  not 
easily  imagined. 

After  which,  some  complaints  going  to  Eng- 
land about  maladministration,  in  the  least  mat- 
ters comparatively,  yet  were  such,  that  he  was 
called  home  to  give  account  thereof,  where  he 
soon  after  expired,  so  finishing  his  life  and  gov- 
ernment together. 

Death  having  thus  drawn  the  curtain,  forbid- 
ding any  further  scene,  it  might  have  been  pru- 
dent to  let  his  dust  remain  without  disturbance. 

But  the  said  book  endeavouring  to  raise  a 
statue  to  him,  i.  e.  to  ascribe  to  him  such  achieve- 
ments as  either  were  never  performed  by  him, 
or  else  unduly  aggravated,  this  has  opened  the 
mouth,  both  of  friends  and  enemies,  to  recount 
the  mistakes  in  the  said  book  ;  as  also  those 
miscarriages  wherewith  sir  William  was  charge- 
able ;  such  as,  had  it  not  been  for  this  book^ 
would  have  been  buried  with  him. 

In  page  3,  search  is  made  over  the  world,  to 


POSTSCRIPT.      -  289 

whom  to  compare  him  in  his  advancement ;  and 
most  unhappily  Pizarro  is  pitched  upon,  as  a 
match  for  him ;  who  was  a  bastard,  dropt  in  a 
church-porch,  put  to  suck  a  sow,  and,  being 
grown,  ran  away,  and  shipt  himself  for  Ameri- 
ca ;  there  so  prospered,  as  to  command  an  ar- 
my; and  therewith  did  mighty  things,  particu- 
larly took  Atabalipa,  one  of  the  kings  of  Peru, 
prisoner ;  and,  having  received  for  his  ransom, 
m  gold  and  silver,  to  the  value  of  ten  millions, 
perfidiously  put  him  to  death;  and  was  the 
death  of  no  man  knows  how  many  thousands  of 
innocents,  and  is  certainly  one  of  the  worst  that 
could  have  been  pitched  upon  for  such  compar- 
ison. Though  this,  together  with  the  rhetori- 
cal flourishes  and  affected  strains  therein,  are  in- 
stances of  the  author's  variety  of  learning ;  for 
which  he  is  recommended  by  these  three  ven- 
erable persons  in  the  entrance  to  the  said  book ; 
yet  the  integrity,  prudence  and  veracity  thereof 
are  not  so  manifestly  to  be  seen.  Passing  over 
a  multitude  of  misrepresentations  that  are  there- 
in, relating  to  the  acts  of  sir  William,  as  not  de- 
signing to  rake  in  the  grave  of  the  dead,  who  is 
it  can  see  the  veracity  of  those  words.'*  p.  40. 
"He  lay  within  pistol-shot  of  the  enemy's  can- 
non, and  beat  them  from  thence,  and  much  bat- 
tered the  town,  having  his  ship  shot  through  in 
an  hundred  places,  with  four  and  twenty  poun- 
ders ;"  when,  in  the  judgment  of  those  present, 
they  were  not  nearer  to  the  enemy  than  about 
half  or  three  quarters  of  a  mile;  that  there 
might  be  in  all  about  seven  shot  that  struck  the 
hull  of  the  vessel,  none  of  them  known  to  be 
25 


290  POSTSCRIPT. 

bigger  than  l8  pounders,  the  enemy  having  but 
one  gun  that  would  carry  an  18  pound 'ball. 

It  were  a  folly,  after  such  assertions,  to  take 
any  notice  of  this  bedecked  statue,  when  there 
was  so  much  the  less  need  of  erecting  one  (as  is 
asserted  p.  108)  having  already  been  done  so 
well,  that  even  this  author  himself  despairs  of 
doing  it  better;  and  that  by  a  man  of  such  dif- 
fused and  embalmed  a  reputation,  as  that  his 
commendations  are  asserted  to  be  enough  to  im- 
mortalize the  reputation  of  sir  William,  or 
whomsoever  else  he  should  please  to  bestow 
them  upon,  viz.  that  reverend  person  who  was 
the  president  of  the  only  university  then  in  the 
English  America,  p.  109.  Which  by  the  way 
is  a  much  fairer  statue,  in  honour  of  the  president 
of  the  university,  than  that  erected  for  sir  Wil- 
liam. 

For,  notwithstanding  all  this  noise  of  erecting 
statues,  and  the  great  danger  in  plucking  them 
down,  (S:c.  yet,  in  p.  89,  it  is  said  that  even  sir 
William  shewed  choler  enough,  leaving  it  open 
for  others  thereby  to  understand  that  he  was 
wholly  given  over  to  passion  and  choler.  And, 
in  p.  92,  it  is  said  he  did  not  affect  any  mighty 
shew  of  devotion.  These  expressions,  w^ith 
others,  may  prevail  with  the  unbiassed  render 
to  think  that  these  builders  of  statues  had  some 
further  design  in  it,  than  to  blazon  the  achieve- 
ments of  sir'William  Phips,  viz.  to  set  forth  mr. 
1.  Mather's  negotiation  in  England,  his  procur- 
ing the  new  charter,  and  sir  W^illiam  to  be  gov- 
ernor, and  himself  established  president  of  the 
college,  are  the  things  principally  driven  at  in 
the  book. 


POSTSCRIPT.  291 

Another  principal  thino;  is,  to  set  forth  the 
supposed  witchcrafts  in  New-England,  and  how 
well  mr.  Mather  the  younger  tlierein  acquitted 
himself. 

As  to  the  new  charter,  for  the  right  under- 
standing  that   affair,   it  will  be  needful  to  say, 
that  the  people  that  afterwards  settled  in  New- 
England,  being  about  to  leave  their  native  soil, 
end  to  seek  (as  the  providence  of  God  should 
direct    thc*.n)   a  settlement  in  remote   regions, 
wherein  they  might  best  secure  their  civil  and 
religious  interests,  before  they  entered  upon  this,     ^ 
considering  it  might  be  needful  on  many  accounts  \  ■ 
lor  their  future  well-being,  they  obtained  a  char-  V 
ter  to  be  in  the  nature  of  a  prime  agreement, 
setting  forth  the  sovereign's  prerogative,  and  the 
people's  privileges;   in   the   enjoyment    whereoi 
they  long  continued,  after  having  purchased  the 
title  to  their  lands  of  the  natives  of  their  coun- 
try, and  settled  themselves  therein,  without  any 
charge  to  tlie  crown. 

That  clause  in  their  charter  for  this  country, 
viz.  "  Provided  that  no  other  christian  prince  be 
prepossessed  of  it,"  being  a  tacit  acknowledg- 
ment, that  before  settlement,  no  one  christian 
prince  had  any  right  thereto  more  than  another. 
During  this  time  of  New  England's  prosperity, 
the  government  here  were  very  sparing  of 
granting  freedoms,  except  to  such  as  were  so 
and  so  qualified:  whereby  the  number  of  non- 
freemen  being  much  increased,  they  were  very 
uneasy,  by  their  being  shut  out  from  any  share 
in  the  government,  or  having  any  votes  for  their 
representatives,  &c.     It  rendered  many  of  them 


292  POSTSCRIPT, 

ready  to  join  with  such  as  were  undermining 
the  government ;  not  duly  considering  that  it 
had  been  far  more  safe  to  have  endeavoured  to 
prevail  with  the  legislators  for  an  enlargement. 

So  that  it  will  not  be  wondered  at,  that  in  the 
latter  end  of  the  reign  of  king  Charles  II,  and 
of  king  James,  (when  most  of  the  charters  in 
England  were  vacated)  this  was  quo  icarranto^d, 
and  finally  judgment  entered  wp  against  it,  and 
the  country  was  put  into  such  a  form  of  govern- 
ment as  was  most  agreeable  to  those  times,  viz. 
a  legislative  power  was  lodged  in  the  governor 
(or  president)  and  some  few  appointed  to  be  of 
his  council,  without  any  regard  therein  either 
to  the  laws  of  England,  or  those  formerly  of  this 
colony:  thus  rendering  the  circumstances  of  this 
country  beyond  comparison  worse  than  those  of 
any  corporation  in  England  ;  the  people  of  those 
corporations  being  acknowledged  still  to  have  a 
rio-ht  to  magna  charta,  when  their  particular 
charters  were  made  void ;  but  here,  when  magna 
charta  has  been  pleaded,  the  people  have  been 
answered,  that  they  must  not  expect  that  magna 
charta  would  follow  them  to  the  end  of  the 
world;  not  only  their  estates,  but  their  lives, 
being  thereby  rendered  wholly  precarious. 
And  judge  Palmer  has  set  forth  in  print,  that  the 
king  has  power  to  grant  such  a  commission  over 
his  people. 

It  is  not  hard  to  imagine,  that  under  such  a 
commission,  not  only  the  people  were  liable  to 
be  oppressed  by  taxes,  but  also  by  confiscations, 
and  seizing  of  lands,  unless  patents  were  purchas- 
ed at  excessive  prices,  with  many  other  exorbi- 
tant innovations. 


POSTSCRIPT.  293 

The  first  that  accepted  this  commission  was 
mr.  Dudley,  a  gentleman  born  in  this  country, 
who  did  but    prepare  the  way  for  sir  Edmond    "^ 
Andros ;  in   whose  time  things  had    grown  to     I 
such  extremities,  not  only  here,  but  in  England,      ^ 
as  rendered  the  succeeding  revolution  absolutely 
necessary ;  the  revolution  here  being  no  other 
than  an  acting  according  to  the  precedent  given 
by  England. 

During  the  time  of  sir  Edmond's  government, 
mr.  Increase  Mather,  teacher  of'  the  north 
church  in  Boston,  having  undergone  some  trou- 
ble by  fobb-actions  laid  upon  him,  &;c.  (though^  ^ 
with  some  difficulty)  he  made  his  escape,  and 
got  passage  for  England,  being  therein  assisted  . 
by  some  particular  friends  ;  where  being  arri- 
ved, he  applied  himself  to  king  James  for  re- 
dress of  those  evils  the  country  then  groaned 
under;  and  meeting  Avith  a  seeming  kind  recep- 
tion, and  some  promises,  it  was  as  much  as  might 
at  that  time  be  reasonably  expected. 

Upon  the  day  of  the  revolution  here,  though 
the  greatest  part  of  the  people  were  for  reas- 
suming  their  ancient  government,  pursuant  to 
his  royal  highness's  proclamation,  yet  matters 
were  so  clogged,  that  the  people  were  dismissed 
without  it,  who  did  not  in  the  least  mistrust 
but  that  those,  who  were  put  out  of  the  gov- 
ernment by  mr.  Dudley,  would  reassume  ;  mr. 
Bradstreet,  who  had  been  then  governor,  being 
heard  to  say  that  evening,  when  returned  home, 
that  had  not  he  thought  they  would  have  reas- 
sumed,  he  would  not  have  stirred  out  of  his 
house  that  day.  But  after  this,  some  that  were 
25^ 


294  POSTSCRIPT. 

driving  at  other  matters,  had  opportunities  hy 
threats  and  other  ways  not  only  to  prevail  with 
that  good  old  gentleman,  but  with  the  rest  of 
the  government,  wholly  to  decline  it;  which 
some  few  observing,  they  took  the  opportunity 
to  call  themselves  a  committee  of  safety,  and  so 
undertook  to  govern  such  as  would  be  govefned 
by  them. 

It  has  been  an  observation  of  long  continu- 
ance, that  matters  of  state  seldom  prosper,  when 
managed  by  the  clergy.  Among  the  opposers 
of  the  reassuraing,  few  were  so  strenuous  as 
some  of  the  ministers ;  and  among  the  ministers, 
none  more  vehement  than  mr.  Cotton  Mather, 
pastor  of  the  north  church  in  Boston,  who  has 
charged  them,  as  they  would  answer  it  another 
day,  not  to  reassume.  Among  his  arguments 
against  it,  one  was,  that  it  would  be  to  put  a 
slight  upon  his  father,  who,  he  said,  was  in  Eng- 
land, labouring  for  a  complete  restoration  of 
charter  privileges,  not  doubting  but  they  would 
be  speedily  obtained.  Any  man  that  knows 
New-England  cannot  but  be  sensible,  that  such 
discourses,  from  such  men,  have  always  been 
very  prevalent.  And  hence  it  was,  that  even 
those  that  would  think  themselves  wronged,  if 
they  were  not  numbered  among  the  best  friends 
to  New-England,  and  to  its  char tei-,  would  not 
so  much  as  stoop  to  take  it  up,  when  there  was 
really  nothing  to  hinder  them  from  the  enjoy- 
ment thereof. 

After  the  committee  of  safety  had  continued 
about  seven  weeks,  or  rather  after  anarchy  had 
been  so  long  triumphant,  an  assembly    having 


POSTSCRIPT.  295 

been  called  came  to  this  resolution,  and  laid  it 
before  those  gentlemen  that  had  been  ol'  the 
government, — that  if  they  would  not  act  upon 
the  foundation  of  the  charter,  that,  pursuant  to 
it,  the  assembly  would  appoint  some  others  in 
that  station.  The  answer  to  which  was,  that 
they  would  accept,  &c.  And  when  a  declara- 
tion, signifying  such  a  reassuming,  was  prepared, 
with  the  good  liking  of  the  deputies,  in  order  to 
be  published,  some,  that  were  opposers,  so  ter- 
rified those  gentlemen,  that,  before  publishing, 
it  was  underwritten  that  they  would  not  have  it 
understood  that  they  did  reassume  charter- 
government,  to  the  no  small  amazement  of  the 
people,  and  disappointment  of  the  deputies,  who, 
if  these  had  not  promised  so  to  act,  had  taken 
other  care,  and  put  in  those  that  would. 

The  next  principal  thing  done  was,  they  chose 
two  of  their  members,  viz.  one  of  the  upper 
house,  the  other  of  the  lower,  both  of  them 
gentlemen  of  known  integrity  as  w^ell  as  ability, 
to  go  to  England,  in  order  to  obtain  their  reset- 
tlement; and  in  regard  mr.  I.  Mather  was 
already  there,  they  joined  him,  as  also  a  certain 
gentleman  in  London,  with  these  other  two. 
Those  from  hence  being  arrived  in  London, 
they  all  united  for  the  common  interest  of  the 
country,  though  without  the  desired  effect. 
They  were  in  doubt  whether  it  were  best  to 
improve  their  utmost  for  a  reversal  of  the  judg- 
ment in  a  course  of  law,  or  to  obtain  it  in  a 
parliamentary  way,  or  to  petition  his  majesty 
for  a  new  grant  of  former  privileges  ;  and,  con- 
sidering that  the  two  first  might  prove  dilatory 


i:>9G  POSTSCRIPT. 

and  expensive,  as  well  as  for  other  reasons,  they 
resolved  upon  the  latter,  and  petitioned  his  ma- 
jesty for  the  country's  resettlement,  with  form- 
er privileges,  and  what  further  additions  his  ma- 
jesty in  his  princely  wisdom  should  think  fit. 
Accordingly  it  pleased  his  majesty  to  declare  in 
council  his  determination,  viz.  That  there 
should  be  a  charter  granted  to  New-England. 
But  the  minutes  then  taken  thereof,  and  a 
draught  of  the  new  charter,  being  seen,  it  was 
the  opinion  of  the  two  gentlemen  sent  from 
hence,  that  it  were  best  to  tarry  his  majesty's 
return  from  Flanders,  in  hopes  then  to  obtain 
ease  in  such  things  as  might  be  any  ways  deem- 
ed grievous.  And  this  was  the  result  of  the  ad- 
vice of  such  as  were  best  able  to  give  it,  that 
they  could  meet  with;  and  accordingly  they 
wholly  desisted  taking  it  out  of  the  offices. 

But  mr.  Mather  and  that  other  gentleman 
had,  as  it  is  said,  other  advice  given  them,  which 
they  strenuously  pursued ;  and  his  majesty  hav- 
ing left  it  (as  is  asserted  in  the  life  of  sir  Wil- 
liam, p.  57)  to  them  to  nominate  a  governor, 
they  pitched  upon  sir  William  Phips,  Avho  Avas 
then  in  England,  as  the  most  likely  and  able  to 
serve  the  king's  interests*  among  the  people 
there,  under  the  changes,  in  some  things  unac- 
ceptable, now  brought  upon  them,  p.  62 ;  and, 
without  tarrying  for  the  concurrence  of  those 
other  agents,  the  charter  was  taken  out,  &:c, 

Bnt  mr.  Mather,  perhaps  fearing  he  should 
have  but  small  thanks  here  for  his  having  so 
far  an  hand  in  bringing  upon  them  those  unac- 
ceptable changes,  wrote,  and  caused  to  be  print- 


POSTSCRIPT.  sot 

ed,  an  account  of  his  negotiation;  but,  surelj  by 
some  error  in  the  conception,  it  proved  only  an 
embryo,  and  was  stifled  as  soon  as  born.  One 
indeed,  designed  to  be  as  it  were  a  posthumous, 
was  lel't  with  mr.  Bailey,  formerly  of  Boston, 
and  a  member  of  the  north  church,  with  a 
charge  not  to  suflfer  it  to  be  seen  till  he  were 
gone  to  New-England;  yet  it  seems  some  other 
person  got  a  sight  of  it,  which  was  the  occasion 
of  mr.  Mathers  sending  him  that  minatory  epis- 
tle, by  some  called  a  bull.  But  besides  this, 
for  fear  of  the  worst,  mr.  Mather  got  several 
non-con.  ministers  to  give  him  a  testimonial,  or 
letters  of  commendation,  for  his  great  service 
herein. 

In  the  mean  time,  mr.  Cotton  Mather,  being 
in  some  doubt  of  the  same  thing,  handed  about 
a  paper  of  fables;  wherein  his  father,  under  the 
name  of  Mercurius,  and  himself  under  the  name 
of  Orpheus,  are  extolled,  and  the  great  actions 
of  Mercurius  magnified;  the  present  charter 
exalted,  by  trampling  on  the  former,  as  bemg 
very  defective,  and  all  those  called  unreasona- 
ble that  did  not  readily  agree  with  the  new  one. 
And  indeed  the  whole  country  are  compared  to 
no  better  than  beasts,  excejjt  Mercurius  and 
Orpheus;  the  governor  himself  must  not  escape 
being  termed  an  elephant,  though  as  good  as  he 
was  great;  and  the  inferiors  told  by  Orpheus, 
that  for  the  quiet  enjoyment  of  their  land,  (fee. 
they  were  beholding  to  Mercurius.  Though 
this  paper  was  judged  not  convenient  to  be 
printed,  yet  some  copies  were  taken,  the  author 
having  shewn  variety  of  heathen  learning  in  it. 


298  POSTSCRIPT. 

This  is  in  short  that  eminent  service  for  which 
the  said  mr.  I.  M.  is  in  the  present  book  so  highly 
extolled,  in  so  many  pages,  that  to  repeat  them, 
were  to  transcribe  a  considerable  part  of  the 
said  book. 

And  no  doubt  he  deserves  as  much  thanks  as 
dr.  Sharp  did,  when  he  was  sent  by  the  pres- 
bytery of  Scotland  to  procure  the  settlement 
of  their  kirk  by  king  Charles  II  at  his  restora- 
tion. 

Not  but  that  the  present  charter  of  New- 
England  is  indeed  truly  valuable,  as  containing 
in  it  peculiar  privileges,  which  abundantly  en- 
gages this  people  to  pay  the  tribute  of  thank- 
fulness to  his  majesty,  and  all  due  subjection  to 
whom  it  shall  please  him  to  substitute  as  gov- 
ernor over  us;  and  to  pray  that  the  King  of 
kings  Avould  pour  out  his  richest  blessings  upon 
him,  giving  him  a  long  and  prosperous  reign 
over  the  nations,  under  the  benign  influences 
whereof  oppression  and  tyranny  may  flee  away. 

And  if  his  majesty  hath  put  this  people  into 
the  present  form  of  government,  that  they 
might  be  in  the  better  condition  of  defence  in  a 
time  of  war,  or  that  they  might  better  under- 
stand the  privilege  of  choosing  their  own  gov- 
ernor by  the  want  of  it,  and  should  be  gracious- 
ly pleased  (the  war  being  over)  to  restore  to 
these,  as  has  been  already  granted  to  the  rest  of 
his  majesty's  subjects,  the  full  enjoyment  of 
their  ancient  privileges,  it  would  be  such  an 
obligation  upon  them  to  thankfulness  and  duty, 
as  could  never  be  forgotten,  nor  sufficiently  ex- 
prest,  and  would  rather  abate  than  increase 
charge  to  the  crown. 


POSTSCRIPT.  29t» 

As  to  the  supposed  witchcrafts  in  New-Eng- 
land, liavlng  ah'cady  said  so  much  thereof,  there 
is  the  less  remains  to  be  added. 

In  tlie  times  of  sir  Edmond  Andres's  govern- 
ment,  goody  Glover,  a  despised,  crazy,  ill-con- 
ditioned old  woman,  an  Irish  Roman  Catholic, 
was  tried  for  afflicting  Goodwin's  children;  by 
the  account  of  which  trial,  taken  in  short  hand 
for  the  use  of  the  jury,  it  may  appear  that  the 
generality  of  her  answers  were  nonsense,  and 
her  behaviour  like  that  of  one  distracted.  Yet 
the  doctors,  finding  her  as  she  had  been  for  many- 
years,  brought  her  in  compos  mentis  ;  and  setting 
aside  her  crazy  answers  to  some  ensnaring  ques- 
tions, the  proof  against  her  w^as  wholly  deficient. 
The  jury  brought  her  in  guilty. 

Mr.  Cotton  Mather  was  the  most  active  and 
forward  of  any  minister  in  the  country  in  those 
matters,  taking  home  one  of  the  children,  and 
managing  such  intrigues  with  that  child,  and 
printing  such  an  account  of  the  whole  in  his  Me- 
morable Providences^  as  conduced  much  to  the 
kindling  of  those  flames,  that  in  sir  William's 
time  threatened  the  destruction  of  this  country. 
King  Saul  in  destroying  the  witches  out  of  Is- 
rael is  thought  by  many  to  have  exceeded,  and 
in  his  zeal  to  have  slain  the  Glbconltes  wrong- 
fully under  that  notion ;  yet  went  aiter  this  to  a 
witch  to  know  his  fortune.  For  his  wrongfully 
destroying  the  Glbeonites  (besides  the  judg- 
ments of  God  upon  the  land)  his  sons  were 
hanged  ;  and  for  his  going  to  the  witch,  himself 
was  cut  oft'.  Our  sir  William  Phips  did  not  do 
this ;  but,  as  appears  by  this  book,  had  first  his 


300  POSTSCRIPT. 

fortune  told  him,  (by  such  as  the  author  counts 
no  better)  and  though  he  put  it  off  (to  his  pas- 
tor, who  he  knew  approved  not  thereof)  as  if  it 
were  brought   to  him  in   writing,   without   his 
seeking,  &o  yet  by  his  bringing  it   so  far,  and 
safe  keeping  it   so   many   years,   it  appears  he 
made  some  account  of  it;  for  which  he  gave  the 
writer,  after  he  had  found  the   wTeck,  as  a  re- 
ward,  more    than   tw^o   hundred   pounds.     His 
tehing  his  wife,  (p.  6)  that  he  should  be  a  com- 
mander, should  have  a  brick  house  inGreenlane, 
&c.  might  be  in  confidence  of  some  such  predic- 
tion; and  that  he  could  foretel  to  him   (p.  90) 
that  he  should  be  governor    of  New-England, 
was  probably  such  an  one,  the   scriptures   not 
having    revealed  it.     Such    predictions    would 
have  been   counted,  at  Salem,   pregnant   proofs 
of  witchcraft,  and  much  better  than  what  were 
against  several    that  suffered    there.     But    sir 
William,  when  the  witchcrafts  at  Salem  began 
(in   his  esteem)    to    look    formidable,    that  he 
might  act  safely  in  this  affair,  asked  the  advice 
of  the    ministers    in    and   near    Boston.     The 
whole  of  their  advice  and   answer  is   printed  in 
Cases  of  Conscience,  the  last  pages.    But  lest  the 
world  should  be  ignorant  who  it  was  that  drew 
the  said  advice,  in  this  book  of  the  life  of  sir 
William  Phips,  p.  77,  are  these  words,  The  mi- 
nisters  made  to  his  excellency  and  the    council  a 
return,  drawn  up  at  their  desire,  by  mr.  Mather 
the  younger,  as  I  have  been  informed.     Mr.  C.  M. 
therein    intending  to   beguile    the    world,    and 
make  them  think  that  another,  and  not  himself, 
had  taken  that  notice  of   his  (supposed)  good 


POSTSCRIPT.  301 

service  done  therein,  which  otherwise  would 
have  been  ascribed  to  those  ministers  in  general ; 
though  indeed  the  advice  then  given  looks  most 
like  a  thing  of  his  composing,  as  carrying  both 
fire  to  increase,  and  water  to  quench,  the  con- 
flagration ;  particularly  after  the  devil's  testi- 
mony, by  the  supposed  afflicted,  had  so  prevail- 
ed, as  to  take  away  the  life  of  one,  and  the  liber- 
ty of  an  hundred,  and  the  whole  country  set  in- 
to a  most  dreadful  consternation,  then  this  ad- 
vice is  given,  ushered  in  with  thanks  for  what 
^vas  already  done,  and  in  conclusion  putting  the 
government  upon  a  speedy  and  vigorous  prose- 
cution, according  to  the  laws  of  God,  and  the 
wholesome  statutes  of  the  English  nation;  so 
adding  oil,  rather  than  water,  to  the  flame:  for 
who  so  little  acquainted  with  the  proceedings 
of  England,  as  not  to  know  that  they  have  ta- 
ken some  methods,  with  those  here  used,  to  dis- 
cover who  were  witches  ?  The  rest  of  the  ad- 
vice, consisting  of  cautions  and  directions,  is  in- 
serted in  this  book  of  the  life  of  sir  William  :  so 
that  if  sir  William,  looking  upon  the  thanks  for 
what  was  past,  and  exhortation  to  proceed,  went 
on  to  take  away  the  lives  of  nineteen  more,  this 
is  according  to  the  advice  said  ta  be  given  him 
by  the  ministers;  and  if  the  deyil,  after  those 
executions,  be  affronted,  by  disbelieving  his  testi- 
mony, and  by  clearing  and  pardoning  all  the  rest  of 
the  accused,  yet  this  also  is,  according  to  that  ad- 
vice, but  to  cast  the  scale.  The  same  that  drew 
this  advice  aaith,  in  Wonders  of  the  Invisible  Worlds 
Enchantments  Encountered^  that  to  have  a  hand 
in  any  thing  that  may  stifle  or  obstruct  a  regular 
26 


302  POSTSCRIPT 

detection  of  that  witchcraft,  is  what  we  may 
well  with  a  holy  fear  avoid :  their  majesties- 
good  subjects  must  not  every  day  be  torn  to  pie- 
ces by  horrid  witchcraft,  and  those  bloody  fel- 
ons be  wholly  left  unprosecuted;  the  witchcraft 
is  a  business  that  will  not  be  shammed.  The 
pastor  of  that  church,  of  which  sir  William  was 
a  member,  being  of  this  principle,  and  thus  de- 
claring it,  after  the  former  advice,  no  wonder 
though  it  cast  the  scale  against  those  cautions. 
It  is  rather  a  wonder  that  no  more  blood  was 
shed ;  for  if  that  advice  of  his  pastor  could  still 
have  prevailed  with  the  governor,  witchcraft 
had  not  been  so  shammed  off  as  it  was.  Yet 
now,  in  this  book  of  the  life  of  sir  William,  the 
pardoning  the  prisoners  when  condemned,  and 
clearing  the  gaols,  is  called  (p.  82)  a  vanquishing 
the  devil;  adding  this  conquest  to  the  rest  of 
the  noble  achievements  of  sir  William,  though 

gerformed  not  only  without,  but  directly  against, 
is  pastor's  advice.  But  this  is  not  all;  though 
this  book  pretends  to  raise  a  statue  in  honour  of 
sir  William,  yet  it  appears  it  was  the  least  part 
of  the  design  of  the  author  to  honour  him,  but 
it  was  rather  to  honour  himself,  and  the  minis- 
ters; it  being  so  unjust  to  sir  William,  as  to  give 
a  full  account  of  the  cautions  given  him,  but  de- 
signedly hiding  from  the  reader  the  encourage- 
ments and  exhortations  to  proceed,  that  were 
laid  before  him,  (under  the  name  of  the  minis- 
ters' advice ;)  in  effect  telling  the  world  that 
those  executions  at  Salem  were  without  and 
against  the  advice  of  the  ministers,  exprest  in 
those    cautions,    purposely   hiding   their   giving 


POSTSCRIPT.  303 

thanks  for  what  was  already  done,  and  exhort- 
ing to  proceed ;  thereby  rendering  sir  VViNiam 
ot" so  sanguinary  a  complexion,  that  the  ministers 
had  such  cause  to  fear  his  going  on  with  the 
tragedy,  though  against  their  advice,  that  they 
desired  the  president  to  write  his  Gases  of  Don" 
science^  (fee.  To  plead  misinformation  will  not 
salve  here,  however  it  may  seem  to  palliate 
other  things,  but  is  a  manifest,  designed  traves- 
ty, or  misrepresentation,  of  tlic  minister's  advice 
to  sir  William,  a  hiding  the  truth,  and  a  wrong- 
ing the  dead,  whom  the  author  so  much  pretends 
to  honour  i  for  which  the  acknowledgments  ought 
to  be  as  universal  as  the  offence.  But  though 
the  ministers'  advice,  or  rather  mr.  Cotton  Ma- 
ther's, was  perfectly  ambidexter,  giving  as  great 
or  greater  encouragement  to  proceed  in  those 
dark  methods,  than  cautions  against  them;  yet 
many  eminent  persons  being  accused,  there  was 
a  necessity  of  a  stop  to  be  put  to  it.  If  it  be 
true,  what  w^as  said  at  the  council-board  in  an- 
swer to  the  commendations  of  sir  William  for 
his  stopping  the  proceedings  about  witchcral't, 
viz.  that  it  was  high  time  for  him  to  stop  it,  his 
own  lady  being  accused;  if  that  assertion  were 
a  truth,  then  New-England  may  seem  to  be  more 
beholden  to  the  accusers  for  accusing  her,  and 
thereby  necessitating  a  stop,  than  to  sir  William, 
or  to  the  advice  that  was  given  him  by  his  pastor. 
Mr.  Cotton  Mather,  having  been  very  forward 
to  write  books  of  witchcraft,  has  not  been  so 
forward  either  to  explain  or  to  defend  the  doc- 
trinal part  thereof;  and  his  belief  (which  he  had 
ai  year's  time  to  compose)  he  durst  not  venture, 


304  POSTSCRIPT. 

SO  as  to  be  copied.  Yet  in  this  book  of  the  Hfe 
of  sir  WilHam  he  sufficiently  testifies  his  retain- 
ing that  heterodox  behef,  seeking  by  frightful 
stories  of  the  sutiierings  of  some,  and  the  refined 
sight  of  others,  &lc.  (p.  69)  to  obtrude  upon  the 
world,  and  confirm  it  in  such  a  belief  as  hither- 
to he  either  cannot  or  will  not  defend,  as  if  the 
blood  already  shed  thereby  were  not  sufficient. 

Mr.  1.  Mather,  in  his  Cases  of  Conscience,  p. 
25,  tells  of  a  bewitched  eye,  and  that  such  can 
see  more  than  others.  They  were  certainly 
bewitched  eyes,  that  could  see  as  well  shut  as 
open,  and  that  could  see  what  never  was  ; 
that  could  see  the  prisoners  upon  the  afflicted, 
harming  them,  when  those  whose  eyes  were 
not  bewitched  could  have  sworn  that  they 
did  not  stir  irora  the  bar.  The  accusers  are 
said  to  have  suffered  much  by  biting,  (p.  73) 
and  the  prints  of  just  such  a  set  of  teeth,  as  ' 
those  they  accused  had,  would  be  seen  on  their 
flesh;  but  such  as  had  not  such  bewitched  eyes 
have  seen  the  accusers  bite  themselves,  and  then 
complain  of  the  accused-  It  has  also  been  seen, 
when  the  accused,  instead  of  having  just  such  a» 
set  of  teeth,  has  not  had  one  in  his  head.  They 
Avere  such  bewitched  eyes,  that  could  see  the 
poisonous  powder  (brought  by  spectres,  p.  70) 
and  that  could  see  in  the  ashes  the  print  of  the 
brand,  there  invisibly  heating  to  torment  the 
pretended  suffierers  with,  <fec. 

These,  with  the  rest  of  such  legends,  have 
this  direct  tendency,  viz.  to  tell  the  world  that 
the  devil  is  more  ready  to  serve  his  votaries,  by 
his  doing  for  them  things  above  or  against  the 
course  of  nature,  shewing  himself  to  them  and 


POSTSCRIPT.  305 

inakinoj  explicit  contracts  with  them,  &c.  than 
the  Divine  Being  is  to  his  faithful  servants  ;  and 
that  as  he  is  vvilhng,  so  also  able,  to  perform  their 
desires.  The  way  whereby  these  people  are  be- 
lieved to  arrive  at  a  power  to  afflict  their  neigh- 
bours, is  by  a  compact  with  the  devil,  and  that 
they  have  a  power  to  commission  him  to  those 
evils,  p.  72.  However  irrational,  or  unscriptural, 
such  assertions  are,  yet  they  seemi  a  necessary 
part  o(  the  Jaith  of  such  as  maintain  the  belief 
of  such  a  sort  of  witches. 

As  the  scriptures  know  nothing  of  a  covenant- 
ing or  commissioning  witch,  so  reason  cannot 
conceive  how  mortals  should  by  their  wicked- 
ness arrive  at  a  power  to  commission  angels,  fall- 
en angels,  against  their  innocent  neighbours.  But 
the  scriptures  are  full  in  it,  and  the  instances  nu- 
merous, that  the  Almighty  Divine  Being  has  this 
prerogative,  to  make  use  of  what  instruments  he 
please th,  in  afflicting  any,  and  consequently  to 
commission  devils :  and  though  this  word,  com- 
missioning, in  the  author's  former  books,  might 
be  thought  to  be  by  inadvertency,  yet  now,  after 
he  hath  been  cautioned  of  it,  still  to  persist  in  it 
seems  highly  criminal;  and  therefore,  in  the 
name  of  God,  I  here  charge  such  belief  as  guil- 
ty of  sacrilege  in  the  highest  nature,  and  so  much 
worse  than  stealing  church  plate,  &c.  as  it  is  a 
higher  olFence  to  steal  any  of  the  glorious  attri- 
butes of  the  Almighty,  to  bestow  them  upon 
mortals,  than  it  is  to  steal  the  utensils  appropri- 
ated to  his  service.  And  whether  to  ascribe 
such  power  of  commissioning  devils  to  the  worst 
of  men,  be  not  direct  blasphemy,  1  leave  to  oth- 
26* 


^06  Jf-OSTSCRIPT. 

ers  better  able  to  determine.  When  the  Pha^ 
risees  were  so  wicked  as  to  ascribe  to  Beelzebub 
the  mighty  works  of  Christ  (whereby  he  did 
manifestly  shew  forth  his  power  and  godhead) 
then  it  was  that  our  Saviour  declared  the  sin 
against  the  Holy  Ghost  to  be  unpardonable. 

When  the  righteous  God  is  contending  with 
apostate  sinners  for  their  departures  from  him, 
by  his  judgments,  as  plagues,  earthquakes,  storms 
and  tempests,  sicknesses  and  diseases,  wars,  loss 
of  cattle,  &c.  then  not  only  to  ascribe  this  to  the 
devil,  but  to  charge  one  another  with  sending  or 
commissioning  those  devils  to  do  these  things,  is  so 
abominable  and  so  wicked,  that  it  requires  a  bet- 
ter judgment  than  mine  to  give  it  its  just  de- 
nomination. 

But  that  christians,  so  called,  should  not  only 
charge  their  fellow  christians  therewith,  but 
proceed  to  trials  and  executions  ;  crediting  that 
enemy  to  all  goodness,  and  accuser  of  the  breth- 
ren, rather  than  believe  their  neighbours  in  their 
own  defence;  this  is  so  diabolical  a  wickedness, 
as  cannot  proceed  but  from  a  doctrine  of  devils ; 
how  far  damnable  it  is,  let  others  discuss. 
ThouQ^h  such  things  were  acting  in  this  country 
in  sir  William's  time,  yet  (p.  65)  there  is  a  dis- 
course of  a  guardian  angel,  as  then  over-seeing 
it :  which  notion,  however  it  may  suit  the  faith  of 
Ethnicks,  or  the  fancies  of  Tritheinius,  it  is  cer- 
tain that  the  Omnipresent  Being  stands  not  in 
need,  as  earthly  potentates  do,  of  governing  the 
world  by  vicegerents.  And  if  sir  William  had 
such  an  invisible  pattern  to  imitate,  no  wonder 
though  some  of  his  actions  were  unaccountable, 


POSTSCRIPT'.  307 

especially  those  relating  to  witchcraft :  for  if 
there  was  in  those  actions  an  angel  superintending, 
there  is  little  reason  to  think  it  was  Gabriel,  or 
the  spirit  of  Mercury ;  nor  Hanael,  the  angel  or 
spirit  of  Venus ;  nor  yd  Samuel,  the  angel  or 
spirit  of  Mars;  names  feigned  by  the  said  Tri- 
themius,  &;c.  ft  may  rather  be  thought  to  be 
Apollyon,  or  Abaddon. 

Objection.  But  here  it  will  be  said,  What,  are 
there  no  witches?  Does  not  the  law  of  God 
command  that  they  should  be  extirpated  ?  Is 
the  command  vain  and  unintelligible  ? 

Sol.  For  any  to  say  that  a  witch  is  one  that 
makes  a  compact  with,  and  commissions  devils, 
&c.  is  indeed  to  render  the  law  of  God  vain  and 
unintelligible,  as  having  provided  no  way  where- 
by they  might  be  detected,  and  proved  to  be 
such ;  and  how  the  Jews  waded  through  this 
dilKculty  for  so  many  ages,  without  the  supple- 
ment of  mr.  Perkins  and  Bernard  thereto,  would 
be  very  mysterious.  But  to  him  that  can  read 
the  scriptures  without  prejudice  from  education, 
&c.  it  will  manifestly  appear  that  the  scripture  is 
full  and  intelligible,  both  as  to  the  crime,  and 
means  to  detect  the  culpable.  He  that  shall  here- 
after see  any  person,  who,  to  conhrm  people  in 
a  false  belief  about  the  power  of  witches  and 
devils,  pretending  to  a  sign  to  confirm  it ;  such 
as  knocking  oli'  of  invisible  chains  w^ith  the  hand, 
driving  away  devils  by  brushing,  striking  with  a 
sword  or  stick,  to  wound  a  person  at  a  great 
distance,  c^c.  may  (according  to  that  head  of  mr. 
Gaule's,  quoted  by  mr.C.  M.  and  so  often  herein 
before  recited,  and  so  well  proved  by  scripture) 
conclude  that  he  has  seen  witchcraft  performed. 


308  POSTSCRIPT. 

If  Balaam  became  a  sorcerer  by  sacrificing 
and  praying  to  the  true  God  against  his  visible 
people,  then  he  that  shall  praj  that  the  afflict- 
ed (by  their  spectral  sight)  maj  accuse  some 
other  persons  (whereby  their  reputations  and 
lives  may  be  endangered)  such  will  justly  deserve 
the  name  of  a  sorcerer.  If  any  person  pretends 
to  know  more  than  can  be  known  by  human 
means,  and  professeth  at  the  same  time  that 
they  have  it  from  the  black  man,  u  e.  the  devih 
and  shall  from  hence  give  testimony  against  the 
lives  of  others,  they  are  manifestly  such  as  have 
a  familiar  spirit ;  and  if  any,  knowing  them  to 
have  their  information  from  the  black  man,  shall 
be  inquisitive  of  them  for  their  testimony  against 
others,  they  therein  are  dealing  with  such  as 
have  di  familiar  spirit 

And  if  these  shall  pretend  to  see  the  dead  by 
their  spectral  sight,  and  others  shall  be  inquisitive 
of  them,  and  receive  their  answers  what  it  is 
the  dead  say,  and  who  it  is  they  accuse,  both 
the  one  and  the  other  are  by  scripture  i,'•w^7/l/  of 
7iecromancy. 

These  are  all  of  them  crimes  as  easily  proved 
as  any  whatsoever,  and  that  by  such  proof  as 
the  law  of  God  requires,  so  that  it  is  no  unin- 
ieUigible  law. 

But  if  the  iniquity  of  the  times  be  such  that 
these  criminals  not  only  escape,  being  indemni- 
fied, but  are  encouraged  in  their  wickedness,  and 
made  use  of  to  take  away  the  lives  of  others, 
this  is  worse  than  a  making  the  law  of  God  vain, 
it  being  a  rendering  of  it  dangerous,  against  the 
lives  of  innocents,  and  without  all  hopes  of  bet- 
ter, so  long  as  these  bloody  principles  remain. 


POSTSCRIPT.  309 

As  long  as  christians  do  esteeta  the  law  of 
God  to  be  imperfect^  as  not  describing  that  crime 
that  it  requires  to  be  punished  by  death  : 

As  long  as  men  suffer  themselves  to  be  poi- 
lioned  in  their  education,  and  be  grounded  in  a 
false  belief  by  the  books  of  the  heathen  : 

As  long  as  the  devil  shall  be  believed  to  have 
a  natural  power  to  act  above  and  against  the  course 
of  nature : 

As  long  as  the  ivitches  shall  be  believed  to 
have  a  power  to  commission  him: 

As  long  as  the  devil'' s  testimony,  by  the  pre-' 
tended  afflicted,  shall  be  received  as  more  valid 
to  condemn,  than  their  plea  of  not  guilty  to  acquit : 

As  long  a*  the  accused  shall  have  their  lives 
and  liberties  confirmed  and  restored  to  them  upon 
their  confessing  themselves  guilty  : 

As  long  as  the  accused  shall  be  forced  to  w«- 
dergo  hardships  and  torments  for  their  not  con- 
fessing : 

As  long  asteats  for  the  devil  to  suck  are  search- 
ed for  upon  the  bodies  of  the  accused,  as  a  to- 
ken of  guilt : 

As  long  as  the  Lord'^s  prayer  shall  be  profan- 
ed, by  being  made  a  test,  who  are  culpable: 

As  long  as  ivitchcraft,  sorcery,  familiar  spirits, 
and  necromancy,  shall  be  improved  to  discover 
who  are  witches,  &c. 

So  long  it  may  be  expected  that  innocents 
will  suffer  as  witches : 

So  long  God  will  be  daily  dishonoured,  and  so 
long  his  judgments  must  be  expected  to  be  con- 
tinued. 


GILES  CORY. 

The  files  of  qfice  contain  numerous  documents  of  the  absurd 
and  ridiculous  proceedings  and  testimonies^  by  zvhich  the 
victims  of  a  pretended  witchcraft  "zvere  driven  on  to  their 
tragical  end:  of  which  the  follozeing  will  serve  as  a  specie 
men. 

The  examination  of  Giles  Cory,  at  a  Court  at  Salem 
Village,  held  bj  John  Hathorn  and  Jona,  Curwin,  Esqrs. 
April  19,  1692. 

Giles  Cory,  you  are  brought  before  authority  upon  high 
suspicion  of  sundry  acts  of  witchcraft ;  now  tell  us  the 
truth  in  this  matter. 

I  hope  through  the  goodness  of  God  1  shall,  for  that 
matter  I  never  had  no  hand  in,  in  my  life. 

Which  of  you  have  seen  this  man  hurt  you? 

Mary  Woicott,  Mercy  Lewis,  Ann  Putman,  jr.  and  Abi- 
gail Williams  affirmed  he  had  hurt  them. 

Hath  he  hurt  you  too  ?  speaking  to  Elizabeth  Hubbard. 
She  going  to  answer  was  prevented  by  a  fit. 

Benjamin  Gold,  hath  he  hurt  you  ? 

I  have  seen  him  several  times,  and  been  hurt  after  it, 
but  cannot  affirm  that  it  was  he. 

Hath  he  brought  the  book  to  any  of  you? 

Mary  Woicott  and  Abigail  Williams  and  others  affirmed 
lie  had  brought  the  book  to  them, 

Giles  Cory,  they  accuse  you,  or  your  appearance,  of 
hurting  them,  and  bringing  the  book  to  them.  What  do 
you  say?     Why  do  you  hurt  them?     Tell  us  the  truth. 

I  never  did  hurt  them.   ■ 

It  is  your  appearance  hurts  them,  they  charge  you ;  tell 
us  what  have  you  done. 

I  have  done  nothing  to  damage  them. 

Have  you  never  entered  into  contract  with  the  devil  ? 

i  never  did. 

What  temptations  have  you  had  ? 

I  never  had  temptations  in  my  life. 

What,  have  you  done  it  without  temptations? 

What  was  the  reason  (said  goodvvife  Bibber)  that  you 
were  frighted  m  the  cow-house  ?  and  then  the  questioaist 
was  suddenly  seized  with  a  violent  fit. 


GILES  CORY.  31  i 

Samuel  Braybrook,  goodman  Bibber,  and  his  daughter, 
testliiod  that  he  had  told  them  this  morning  that  he  was 
frighted  m  the  cow-house. 

Cory  denied  it. 

This  was  not  your  appearance  but  your  person,  and  you 
(old  them  so  this  morning:   why  do  you  deny  it  ? 

What  did  you  see  in  the  cow-house  ? 

I  never  saw  nothing  but  my  cattle. 

Divers  witnessed  that  he  told  them  he  was  frighted. 

Well,  what  do  you  say  to  these  witnesses?  What  was 
it  frighted  you? 

1  do  not  know  that  ever  I  spoke  the  word  in  my  life. 

Tell  the  truth,  what  was  it  frighted  you  ? 

I  do  not  know  any  thing  that  frighted  me. 

All  the  afflicted  were  seized  now  with  tits,  and  troubled 
with  pinches.  Then  the  court  ordered  his  hands  to  be  tied. 

V\  hat,  is  it  not  enough  to  act  witchcraft  at  other  times, 
but  must  you  do  it  now  in  the  face  of  authority? 

1  am  a  poor  creature,  and  cannot  help  it. 

Upon  the  motion  ot  his  head  again,  they  had  their  heads 
and  necks  aOlicted. 

Why  do  you  tell  such  wicked  lies  against  witnesses,  that 
heard  you  speak  after  this  manner,  this  very  morning? 

I  never  saw  any  thing  but  a  black  hog. 

You  said  that  you  were  stopt  once  in  prayer ;  what 
stopt  you  ? 

1  cannot  tell;  my  wife  came  towards  me  and  iound  fault 
with  me  tor  saying  living  to  God  and  dying  to  sin. 

What  was  it  frighted  you  in  the  barn? 

I  know  nothing  frighted  me  there. 

Why  here  are  three  witnesses  that  heard  you  say  so 
io-dixy. 

1  do  not  remember  it. 

Thomas  Gold  testified  that  he  heard  him  sav,  that  he 
knew  enough  against  his  wife,  that  would  do  her  business. 

What  was  that  you  knew  against  your  wife  ? 

Why  that  of  living  to  God,  and  dying  to  sin. 

The  Marshal  and  Bibber's  daughter  confirmed  the  same, 
that  he  said  he  co\ild  say  that  that  would  do  his  wife's 
business. 

I  have  said  what  I  can  say  to  that. 

What  was  that  about  your  ox? 

I  thought  he  was  hipt. 


312  GILES  CORY. 

What  ointment  was  that  your  wife  had  when  she  was 
seized?  You  said  it  was  ointment  she  made  by  major 
Gidney's  direction. 

He  denied  it,  and  said  she  had  it  of  goody  Bibber,  or 
from  her  direction. 

Goody  Bibber  said  it  is  not  like  that  ointment. 

You  said  you  knew,  upon  your  own  knowledge,  that  she 
had  it  of  major  Gidney. 

He  denied  it. 

Did  not  you  say,  when  you  went  to  the  ferry  with  your 
wife,  you  would  not  go  over  to  Boston  now,  for  you  should 
come  yourself  the  next  week  ? 

I  would  not  go  over,  because  I  had  not  money. 

The  Marshal  testified  he  said  as  before. 

One  of  his  hands  was  let  go,  and  several  were  afflicted. 
He  held  his  head  on  one  side,  and  then  the  heads  of  seve- 
ral of  the  afflicted  were  held  on  one  side.  He  drew  in 
his  cheeks,  and  the  cheeks  of  some  of  the  afflicted  were 
suckt  in. 

John  Bibber  and  his  wife  gave  in  testimony  concerning 
seme  temptations  he  had  lo  make  away  with  himself. 

How  doth  this  agree  with  what  you  said,  that  you  had 
no  temptations  ? 

I  meant  temptations  to  witchcraft. 

If  you  can  give  way  to  self  murther,  that  will  make  way 
to  temptation  to  witchcraft. 

Note.  There  was  witness  by  several,  that  he  said  he 
would  make  away  with  himself,  and  charge  his  death  up- 
on his  son. 

Goody  Bibber  testified  that' the  said  Cory  called  said 
Bibbers  husband,  damn'd,  devilish  rogue. 

Other  vile  expressions  testified  in  open  court  by  several 
others. 

Salem  Village^  April  19,  1692. 
Mr.  Samuel  Parris  being  desired  to  take  in  tfriting  the 
examination  of  Giles  Cory^  delivered  it  in  ;  and  vpon  hcar^ 
ing  the  same.,  and  seeing  what  we  did  see  at  the  time  of  his 
examination.)  together  vnth  the  charge  of  the  afflicted  persons 
against  him^  we  committed  him  to  their  majesties''  gaol. 

JoHJf  Hathora*. 


4>